Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-106

1987-106Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 16, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87-106
Mr. Stan Teasley
Executive Director
Kansas Commission on Veterans' Affairs
Jayhawk Tower, Suite 701
700 SW Jackson
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Soldiers, Sailors and Patriotic Emblems -- Kansas
Commission on Veterans' Affairs -- Retroactive
Reimbursement for Dependents
Synopsis: K.S.A. 73-1218 provides that every state-supported
institution of post-high school education "shall"
provide enrollment, without charge of tuition or
fees, to any eligible dependent of a person who
died as a result of a service-connected disability
suffered during the Vietnam conflict. The
legislature's intent and purpose for drafting this
statute was to allow all eligible dependents to
attend state postsecondary institutions free of
charge. Neither K.S.A. 73-1218, nor K.A.R. 97-5-1,
the regulation which addresses the procedure to be
followed in applying for benefits under K.S.A.
73-1218, contains language setting a date by which
an application for benefits must be submitted.
Accordingly, an eligible dependent who applies for
retroactive educational benefits under K.S.A.
73-1218 must be reimbursed for fees and tuition,
subject only to continued appropriations by the
legislature. Cited herein: K.S.A. 73-1217;
73-1218; K.A.R. 97-5-1.
Dear Mr. Teasley:
As Executive Director of the Kansas Commission on Veterans'
Affairs (K.C.V.A.), you request our opinion regarding K.S.A.
73-1218. Specifically, you inquire about the legality of
retroactively reimbursing an eligible dependent under K.S.A.
73-1218 for fees and tuition incurred during six semesters of
postsecondary education in Kansas institutions.
You inform us that the individual is presently enrolled at a
state university for the 1987 summer session. The university
has been notified that the individual is eligible to receive
educational benefits under K.S.A. 73-1218 for this summer and
subsequent semesters, not to exceed twelve semesters.
However, no determination has been made on the individual's
eligibility to receive retroactive benefits under the
statute. K.S.A. 73-1218 provides:
. . [T]he governing body of every . .
institution of post-high school
education which is supported by any state
moneys shall provide for enrollment
without charge of tuition or fees for any
dependent of a person who died as the
result of a service-connected disability
suffered during the Vietnam conflict as a
result of such conflict, so long as such
dependent is eligible, but not to exceed
twelve (12) semesters of instruction or
the equivalent thereof at all such
institutions for any person. . .
(Emphasis added).
The statute provides that every state-supported institution
of post-high school education "shall" provide enrollment
without charge of tuition or fees to any eligible dependent.
We believe use of the word "shall", rather than "may",
reflects legislative intent that all eligible dependents of
deceased Vietnam veterans be allowed to attend postsecondary
institutions free of charge. This conclusion is
supported by the supplemental information the Senate Committee
on Education provided with the bill, which states:
"S.B. 764 provides that dependents of
persons who were residents of Kansas at
the time of entry into the armed services
and who were killed in action during the
Vietnam conflict, as a result of that
conflict, are to be admitted to publicly
supported Kansas postsecondary
institutions without having to pay
tuition or fees. . . ." (Emphasis added).
The supplemental information gives no indication that the
committee intended to limit educational benefits to those
persons who apply for them prospectively. Nor does K.S.A.
73-1218 contain any date by which an application for benefits
must be submitted.
In addition to K.S.A. 73-1218, a Kansas Administrative
Regulation exists which addresses the procedure to be followed
in applying for benefits under K.S.A. 73-1218. K.A.R. 97-5-1
provides in part:
"Persons interested in applying for
benefits provided by this chapter shall
initiate a formal application to the
executive director, Kansas veterans'
commission. . . . The application must be
complete and documented to establish legal
relationship between applicant and
parent. . . ."
We note that, like its authorizing statute, this regulation
makes no reference to a date by which dependents must make
application for benefits to the K.C.V.A.
After considering the language in K.S.A. 73-1218, the
supplemental information to 1976 Senate Bill No. 764, and
K.A.R. 97-5-1, we conclude that any qualified individual who
applies for benefits under K.S.A. 73-1218 is entitled to
reimbursement for tuition and fees, not to exceed 12 semesters
of instruction, even if said payment must be made
retroactively. In our opinion, allowing an individual to be
retroactively reimbursed under K.S.A. 73-1218 is consistent
with legislative intent.
While there have been no cases in Kansas or in the 10th
Circuit addressing this issue, the legislature has granted
retroactive reimbursement upon request to several eligible
individuals. 1976 House Bill No. 3077 of the Joint Committee
on Special Claims Against the State appropriated funds for
retroactive reimbursement of fees and tuition for two
dependents attending Butler County Community College.
The retroactive nature of the payments, though not mentioned
in the bill, is indicated by correspondence between Leonard
McKinney, registrar of the college, and Wayne Garret, former
director of the K.C.V.A. The letter dated November 7, 1975
states:
"We have met with the Claims and Accounts
Committee of the Legislature regarding the
retroactive claims for these two former
students. I am happy to tell you that the
Committee unanimously approved payments of
these claims."
A similar retroactive claim was honored through an
appropriation in 1976 Senate Bill No. 1009 for a dependent
attending Wichita State University.
We are aware that these claims were made under K.S.A. 73-1217,
rather than under K.S.A. 73-1218. However, in our opinion the
reasoning used by the legislature in making retroactive
payments under K.S.A. 73-1217 applies to the case at hand,
since the statutes differ only with respect to whether the
applicant is a dependent of a prisoner of war or a person
missing in action, or alternatively, a dependent of a Vietnam
veteran.
1976 House Bill No. 2920 amended K.S.A. 73-1217 by providing
that the governing body of an institution which grants tuition
or fees without charge to a dependent under this act may file
a claim with the Kansas veterans' commission, rather than with
the Kansas legislature. Subsequent to that amendment, a line
item appropriation from the legislature to the K.C.V.A. was
made, and continues to be made on an annual basis, to the
commission's educational grant fund.
The K.C.V.A. allowed retroactive payments out of this fund for
a claim made under K.S.A. 73-1218 in 1977. In a letter to a
Mr. Beardsley at Fort Hays University, dated November 1,
1977, Wayne Garret stated his basis for approving the payments:
"I recognize that it is unusual for the
state to be involved in retroactive
payments of this nature, but this has
happened on 2 or 3 prior occasions and we
have a firm mandate from the Legislature
that the student will not be punished due
to a lack of information on applying for
benefits under the bill and that
retroactive payments should be made."
(Emphasis added).
Mr. Garret's use of the phrase "firm mandate" plainly
indicates his belief that retroactive payments under K.S.A.
73-1218 are not only permissible, but are mandatory. We note
also that in every instance in which retroactive reimbursement
has been requested, it has been granted.
As this opinion previously indicated, we believe that the
legislature's intent and purpose for drafting K.S.A. 73-1218
was to allow all eligible dependents to attend state
postsecondary institutions free of charge. Neither K.S.A.
73-1218 nor K.A.R. 97-5-1 contains language setting a date by
which an application for benefits must be submitted. Further,
the legislature and the K.C.V.A. have previously appropriated
funds for the purpose of retroactively reimbursing dependents
of veterans who were residents of Kansas. Based on this
information, it is our opinion that an eligible dependent who
applies for retroactive educational benefits under K.S.A.
73-1218 must be reimbursed by the Kansas Commission on
Veterans' Affairs for fees and tuition, subject only to
continued appropriations by the legislature.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.