Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-097

1987-097Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL June 25, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 97
Robert A. Gottschalk
Executive Secretary
The Kansas State Fair
2000 North Poplar
Hutchinson, Kansas 67502
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Kansas Tort Claims Act -- Personal Liability of
Board of State Fair Managers
Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages -- Cereal Malt
Beverages -- Prohibited Acts; Sunday Sales on
Fairgrounds
Synopsis: Members of the Board of State Fair Managers are
state employees for purposes of the Kansas Tort
Claims Act. As such, except as provided in K.S.A.
75-6104, they are subject to suit for claims
arising out of their wrongful acts. Members who
have been held liable for damages occurring within
the scope of their employment shall be indemnified
by the state, though in the event the employee has
acted with actual fraud or malice or has failed to
cooperate in the defense, the state is entitled to
repayment of any amounts paid out.
The board is given authority to regulate and
control fairground use. While the sale and
consumption of intoxicating liquors are generally
prohibited on public property, the prohibition does
not extend to cereal malt beverages. Therefore, as
long as the statutory and regulatory requirements
are met, the board may authorize Sunday sales of
cereal malt beverages on the fairgrounds. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 2-139; 2-202, as amended by 1987
Senate Bill No. 3, Sec. 7; 2-205, as amended by
1987 Senate Bill No. 3, Sec. 10; 41-102(b), as
amended by 1987 House Substitute for Substitute for
Senate Bill No. 141, Sec.54; 41-2704(a), as
amended by 1987 House Substitute for Substitute for
Senate Bill No. 141, Sec. 4; 74-520, as amended
by 1987 Senate Bill No. 3, Sec. 3; 74-521, as
amended by 1987 Senate Bill No. 3, Sec. 20;
75-6101, 75-6102(d); 75-6104, amended by 1987 House
Bill No. 2023, Sec. 3; 75-6105(c); 75-6109; 1987
House Bill No. 2615, Sec. 4(b)(2).
Dear Mr. Gottschalk:
As Executive Secretary of the Board of State Fair Managers,
you have requested our opinion concerning two unrelated
issues. First, you have questioned the extent of the personal
liability of board members for claims which may arise out of
the operation of the fair grounds. Your second inquiry
involves the Sunday sales of cereal malt beverages on the fair
grounds.
Membership of the Board of State Fair Managers is established
by K.S.A. 74-520, as amended, and is comprised of the state
board of agriculture, its secretary and three appointed
individuals. The function of the board is to perform duties
in connection with the holding of a state fair. K.S.A.
74-521, as amended. The lands held by the State of Kansas for
fair purposes are directed and controlled by the board.
K.S.A. 2-202, as amended. Inclusive in such direction and
control is the authority to regulate the use of the
fairgrounds in conducting and operating a state fair, and to
lease the buildings and grounds when they are not necessary
for use for fair purposes. K.S.A. 2-202; 2-205, as amended.
As the board members act on behalf of the State of Kansas when
performing the duties stated above, we believe they are
employees of the state for purposes of the Kansas Tort Claims
Act, K.S.A. 75-6101 et seq. C.F., Attorney General
Opinions No. 86-155; 84-88.
An employee is defined by the tort claims act as:
"any . . . member of a board of a
governmental entity, including elected or
appointed officials and persons acting on
behalf or in service of a governmental
entity in any official capacity, whether
with or without compensation." K.S.A.
75-6102(d).
Employees who act within the scope of their employment are not
immune from liability arising out of their wrongful acts,
unless their actions fall within the exceptions to liability
listed in K.S.A. 75-6104, as amended. However, pursuant to
K.S.A. 75-6109, the governmental entity must indemnify an
employee against damages caused by the employee's act if the
act was within the scope of employment. The governmental
liability for indemnification does not extend to an award of
punitive or exemplary damages, but K.S.A. 75-6105(c) precludes
such an award against employees absent actual fraud or
malice. If the employee fails to cooperate in good faith in
the defense of the claim or action, or if the trier of fact
finds that the act or omission of the employee was because of
such employee's actual fraud or actual malice, the
governmental entity has the right to recover any payments made
by it for any judgment or fees and costs associated with the
defense of the employee.
In summary, we believe that members of the Board of State Fair
Managers are employees for purposes of the Kansas Tort Claims
Act. As such, they may be subject to suit for damages
proximately caused by their wrongful acts. Members who have
been held liable for damages occurring within the scope of
their employment shall be indemnified by the state, though in
the event there is actual fraud or malice or a failure to
cooperate in the defense by the employee, the governmental
entity is entitled to repayment of any amounts it indemnifies.
You next inquire whether the Fair Board may allow the Sunday
sale of cereal malt beverages on the fairgrounds. The sale of
cereal malt beverages on Sunday is allowed by 1987 House Bill
No. 2615, Sec. 4(b)(2) when three conditions are met.
First, the place of business must be licensed to sell cereal
malt beverages for consumption on the premises. The second
condition is that at least 30% of the business' gross sales
must be derived from the sale of food consumed on the
premises. Finally, the business must be located in a city or
county which authorizes Sunday sales. We will assume that
these conditions are met.
There is little doubt that the Board may allow the sale of
cereal malt beverages on Sunday if the requirements of 1987
House Bill No. 2615 are met. The board is empowered to
regulate and control the use of the fairgrounds in operating
the state fair. K.S.A. 2-202, as amended. While the
consumption of alcoholic liquor upon property owned by the
state is generally prohibited (with exceptions not here
relevant) by K.S.A. 41-719, as amended by 1987 House
Substitute for Substitute for Senate Bill No. 141, Sec. 54
(hereinafter 1987 Senate Bill No. 141), there is no general
prohibition against the sale or consumption of cereal malt
beverages on state property. A similar prohibition regarding
the sale of intoxicating liquor, applicable to county fair
associations, appears in K.S.A. 2-139. These prohibitions
refer only to alcoholic liquor, which by definition does not
include cereal malt beverages. K.S.A. 41-102(b), as amended
by 1987 Senate Bill No. 141, Sec. 2. There being no general
prohibition, we believe that specific legislative authority
enabling the Board to allow the Sunday sale of cereal malt
beverages is not required. It is our opinion that the Board
may allow such sales under its authority to regulate and
control fairground use.
Licensing of cereal malt beverage retailers has lawfully been
delegated to local units of government. City of Baxter
Springs v. Bryant, 226 Kan. 383, 387 (1979). The
appropriate local unit of government is empowered with
authority to prescribe, within reason, hours of operation,
standards of conduct, and rules regarding moral, sanitary and
health conditions of licensed vendors. K.S.A. 41-2704(a), as
amended by 1987 House Bill No. 2615, Sec. 4. Vendors who
sell cereal malt beverages must therefore conform to the
requirements of the licensing authority, and the terms of the
license itself, for regulation beyond the cereal malt beverage
act.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that members of the Board of
State Fair Managers are state employees for purposes of the
Kansas Tort Claims Act. As such, except as provided in K.S.A.
75-6104, they are subject to suit for claims of damages
proximately caused by their wrongful acts. Members who have
been held liable for damages shall be indemnified by the
state, though in the event the employee has acted with actual
fraud or malice or has failed to cooperate in the defense, the
state is entitled to repayment of any amounts paid. In
addition, the board is given authority to regulate and control
fairground use. While the sale and consumption of
intoxicating liquors are generally prohibited on public
property, no such prohibition is placed on the sale and
consumption of cereal malt beverages. Therefore, as long as
the statutory and regulatory requirements are met, the board
may authorize the Sunday sale of cereal malt beverages on the
fairgrounds.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.