Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-065

1987-065Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 9, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87 - 65
Lewis S. Carter, Clerk
Kansas Supreme Court
Kansas Judicial Center
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1507
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Judicial--Selection of Justices of the Supreme Court
Synopsis: Under the provisions of Article 3, §5 of the Kansas
Constitution, no member of the Supreme Court
Nominating Commission shall, while he or she is a
member, hold any other "public office" by
appointment. The term "public office" refers to
the common-law concept of a public office, and
except where the office of city attorney has been
stripped of all prosecutorial and other sovereign
power (through the exercise of home rule powers), a
city attorney holds a public office. Cited
herein: Kan. Const., Article 3, §5.
Dear Mr. Carter:
You request our interpretation of subsection (g) of Article 3,
§5 of the Kansas Constitution. Specifically, you ask whether
a person who has been appointed to the position of city
attorney by a city manager, and presently holds that office,
qualifies to be an attorney member of the Supreme Court
Nominating Commission.
Article 3, .55 of the Kansas Constitution provides for
establishment of the Supreme Court Nominating Commission, with
subsection (g) providing as follows:
"No member of the supreme court nominating
commission shall, while he is a member,
hold any other public office by
appointment or any official position in a
political party or for six months
thereafter be eligible for nomination for
the office of justice of the supreme
court. The commission may act only by the
concurrence of a majority of its
members." (Emphasis added.)
The term "public office," as used in the above-quoted
constitutional provision, apparently refers to the common-law
concept of a public office. That concept was discussed at
length in Durflinger v. Artiles, 234 Kan. 502 (1983),
where the court noted that it universally has been held that
the right to exercise some definite portion of sovereign power
constitutes an indispensable attribute of a public office.
Id. at 502. Other characteristics of a public office
include the following: powers defined by the legislature or
through legislative authority; duties performed independently
without control of superior power other than law; and some
permanency and continuity. Id. at 503.
Application of the above criteria would generally appear to
confirm that a city attorney holds a public office.
Specifically, a city attorney, as part of the duties of that
position, is often called upon to advise the city governing
body concerning legal affairs of the city, draft proposed
ordinances and resolutions for the governing body, draft and
review contracts proposed for the city, and act otherwise as
an adviser and counselor. In this capacity, the city attorney
does not exercise any independent sovereign power of the city,
but merely serves as its counselor or adviser. As a
prosecutor, however, the city attorney does exercise, in the
name of the city, independent power (prosecutorial
discretion), prosecuting (in the name of the city) offenses
against its ordinances and codes. While it would be possible,
through the exercise of home rule powers, to strip the city
attorney of all prosecutorial power and vest such power in a
municipal prosecutor (see Attorney General Opinion No.
83-134), we doubt that such action has been taken in many
Kansas cities.
In summary, under the provisions of Article 3, §5 of the
Kansas Constitution, no member of the Supreme Court Nominating
Commission shall, while he or she is a member, hold any other
"public office" by appointment. The term "public office"
refers to the common-law concept of a public office, and
except where the office of city attorney has been stripped of
all prosecutorial and other sovereign power (through the
exercise of home rule powers), a city attorney holds a public
office.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.