Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-056

1987-056Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORN EY GENER AL March 25, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 56
Gerald E. Williams
Lenexa City Attorney
12350 W. 87th Parkway
P.O. Box 14888
Lenexa, Kansas 66215-0888
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Corporations--Cities' Powers of Home Rule; Issuance
of Special Obligation Bonds
Synopsis: Acquiring and constructing certain municipal
improvements, to be paid for in whole or in part by
special assessments upon property benefited by such
improvements, is a valid exercise of the City of
Lenexa's constitutional powers of home rule as
provided in Article 12, Section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution. Special assessments levied under the
home rule ordinance and payable in installments may
be paid by issuing special or limited obligation
bonds of the city payable solely from such special
assessments. K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq., which
also permits cities to acquire and construct
municipal improvements, the costs of which may be
paid (in whole or in part) by special assessments
on benefited property, and which authorizes a city
to issue bonds which are general obligations of the
the city, does not address a city's authority to
issue special obligation bonds payable solely from
special assessments. Thus, K.S.A. 12-6a01 et
seq., while it addresses a similar subject and
provides an alternative methodology, does not
preclude nor preempt the utilization of home rule
powers proposed by the City of Lenexa. Special
obligation bonds issued pursuant to the home rule
ordinance would not be subject to statutory
aggregate debt limitations applicable to the city
because such bonds are not a pledge of the city's
faith and credit nor of its general power to levy
ad valorem taxes. While the home rule amendment
states that cities shall be subject to enactments
of the legislature prescribing limits of
indebtedness this limitation does not make those
bonds issued by a city pursuant to home rule which
are otherwise exempt from statutory debt
limitations subject to such limitations. Cited
herein: Kan. Const., Art. 12, Sec. 5; K.S.A.
1986 Supp. 10-308; K.S.A. 12-6a01 to 12-6a14.
*
Dear Mr. Williams:
As attorney for the City of Lenexa you have requested an
opinion on the validity a proposed exercise of the city's home
rule powers as granted in Article 12, Section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution.
You inform us that the Lenexa city council proposes to use
home rule powers to enact an ordinance authorizing the City to
provide for internal public improvements such as streets,
sidewalks, sewer and water lines, etc., and to pay the cost of
such improvements, in whole or in part, solely from special
assessments levied against the property specially benefited by
the improvements. The ordinance would authorize funding
improvements through the use of any lawfully available funds
including federal and state grants, funds available from other
local governments, funds available from the City, and the
special assessments. The costs payable from special
assessments which will be paid in installments may be paid by
the issuance of special obligation bonds of the City payable
solely from the special assessments to be levied by the City
on the property benefited by the improvement. If the
assessments were not paid the debt would not become a general
obligation of the City. The City would have no responsibility
or authority to levy ad valorem taxes against the property in
the City to pay costs of the improvements or the principal and
interest on bonds issued to finance such improvements.
Because such special obligation bonds will be payable solely
from the special assessments and not secured by the city's
general authority to levy ad valorem taxes, such bonds would
not be subject to the statutory aggregate debt limitations
applicable to the City.
The proposed ordinance, as described in your letter, would
authorize the construction and acquisition of public
improvements which confer a special benefit upon definable
property within the City and in unincorporated areas within
three miles of the City limits. All or any part of the cost
of such improvements would be payable solely from special
assessments upon the property deemed by the governing body of
the City to have received special benefit; provided, however,
that such improvements could be made and such assessments
levied only if the governing body received a petition
requesting such improvement signed by a majority of the owners
of record and the owners of record of more than one-half of
the area liable for the assessment under the proposal,
describing the boundaries of the benefit district, and stating
the estimated cost of the improvement and proposed method of
assessment. The ordinance would provide that notice of a
public hearing by the governing body of the City on the
proposed assessments would be both published in the official
City newspaper and mailed to owners of record of property in
the benefit district prior to the hearing and that notice of
final assessments would be mailed to owners of record.
It is the opinion of the City and the City's bond counsel that
the proposed ordinance may be enacted utilizing the city's
constitutional powers of home rule. You seek our concurrence
in this opinion.
The home rule amendment provides in significant part:
"Cities are hereby empowered to determine
their local affairs and government . . .
by ordinance passed by the governing body
. . . subject only to enactments of the
legislature of statewide concern
applicable uniformly to all cities, to
other enactments of the legislature
applicable uniformly to all cities, to
enactments of the legislature applicable
uniformly to all cities of the same class
limiting or prohibiting the levying of any
tax, excise, fee, charge or other exaction
and to enactments of the legislature
prescribing limits of indebtedness." Art.
12, §5(b).
As the Kansas Supreme Court has stated, the home rule
amendment gives cities the power to determine their local
affairs and government without legislative authorization in
the form of an enabling statute. Home rule powers are subject
to limitation by the legislature in certain cases but the
powers are to be liberally construed for the purpose of
granting cities the largest measure of self-government.
Claflin v. Walsh, 212 Kan. 1 (1971); City cf Junction
City v. Lee, 216 Kan. 495, 498 (1975). In our opinion, the
ordinance proposed by the City of Lenexa fits well within
the City's constitutional home rule powers and is not
precluded by any of the optional limitations stated in
Articlel2, §5.
The home rule amendment makes cities subject to uniformly
applicable enactments of statewide concern and to other
uniformly applicable enactments of the legislature. As you
note, K.S.A. 12-6a01 et sec. is a uniformly applicable
legislative enactment which authorizes Kansas cities to
acquire and construct municipal improvements and to finance
such improvements by levying special assessments against the
benefited property. K.S.A. 12-6a14 provides that such special
assessments which will be paid in installments shall be paid
by the issuance of bonds of the city. The bonds so issued are
general obligations of the city secured by the special
assessments and the city's obligation to levy ad valorem taxes
against all taxable property in the city should such special
assessments be insufficient to pay the principal and interest
on the bonds. Such bonds must be issued within the city's
aggregate debt limitations (unless otherwise excluded).
It is apparent that K.S.A. 12-6a01 et Lt a. is not a
matter of statewide concern. It addresses local concerns in
providing a methodology for acquiring, constructing and
financing local municipal improvements. The statutes
apparently are uniformly applicable to Kansas cities, however,
we do not believe that this precludes the exercise of local
home rule powers in the case you have described.
As the Kansas Supreme Court has often noted, the home rule
amendment requires a liberal construction of the powers and
authority granted to cities for the purpose of granting the
largest measure of self-government. Art. 12, §5(d). Where
the legislature has acted in some area, the city's power to
act in the same area should be upheld unless the legislature
has clearly preempted the field to preclude city action.
"Unless there is actual conflict between a municipal ordinance
and a statute, the city ordinance should be permitted to
stand." Claflin v. Walsh, 212 Kan. 1, 7 (1973).
The subject matter addressed by K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq.
and also by the proposed ordinance is the provision of certain
municipal improvements financed by the levy of special
assessments on specially benefited property. K.S.A. 12-6a01
et seq., on its face, is uniformly applicable to all
cities and provides a specific methodology for Kansas cities
to accomplish certain municipal improvements. It does not,
however, provide the exclusive methodology for providing and
financing such improvements and, in fact, states that it is
intended as "a complete alternative to all other methods
provided by law." K.S.A. 12-6a02. We do not find in K.S.A.
12-6a01 any evidence of a legislative intent to preempt all
local authority on the subject of providing for municipal
improvements to be financed by special assessments upon
benefited property. Nothing in the statutes indicates that
the legislature intended to occupy the field nor retain
exclusive jurisdiction to legislate on this subject matter.
See Anderson Construction Co. v. City of Topeka, 228
Kan. 73, 79 (1980). If a city proposed to do exactly that
which K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq. authorized, i.e., issue
general obligation bonds to finance the costs of
improvements to be paid by special assessments paid in
installments, then the uniformly applicable provisions of
K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq. might arguably preclude the
exercise of home rule authority on the subject.
The proposed exercise of city home rule by Lenexa, however,
addresses a similar but different subject, i.e., the
issuance of special obligation bonds to finance the type of
improvements often accomplished and financed under the
provisions of K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq. We find no
conflict between the proposed ordinance as described in your
letter and the provisions of K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq. The
fact that the legislature has provided an alternative method
of accomplishing the improvements does not preclude the
exercise of city home rule authority as long as there is no
conflict in terms with state legislation and the state
legislature has not preempted the field. See City of
Junction City v. Lee, 216 Kan. 495, 499 (1975). There is
no statutory enactment which permits the issuance of special
obligation bonds to finance the improvements the City hopes to
authorize pursuant to the proposed ordinance. K.S.A. 12-6a01
et seq. provides a mechanism whereby the improvements
may be accomplished and financed but only through the issuance
of bonds to be paid by special assessments and which are also
general obligations of the city.
In our opinion K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq. does not provide
the exclusive method of accomplishing the kinds of
improvements which the city hopes to provide. It exists as an
alternative which the city may utilize but does not, in our
opinion, preclude the exercise of home rule described in your
letter. The legislature has not spoken to the specific matter
of issuing special obligation bonds backed solely by special
assessments to finance municipal improvements and the
existence of statutes which provide different methods of
financing similar improvements do not preclude the use of home
rule powers in the area. In our opinion, both the statutes
and the constitution provide the city with a method to
accomplish and finance certain municipal improvements. The
fact that two alternatives exist does not make one bad or one
exclusive of the other. Cf., Clark v. City of Overland
Park, 226 Kan. 609, 617 (1979). Moreover, the proposed
local ordinance does not conflict with the provisions of the
state law on the same subject since the ordinance does not
address the exact same subject but provides an alternative
method of financing not addressed by the state statute. Thus,
the city need not enact a charter ordinance exempting from any
state enactment which addresses the same subject because no
such enactment exists.
The final limitation on city home rule which might be at issue
here is the constitutional provision that cities shall be
subject to "enactments of the legislature prescribing limits
of indebtedness." It is the city's opinion that special
obligation bonds issued pursuant to the proposed home rule
ordinance would not be included in the city's aggregate debt
limitation. In our opinion, the special obligation bonds
issued pursuant to the home rule ordinance are not the type of
bonds which traditionally are included within the "enactments
of the legislature prescribing limits of indebtedness"
described in the home rule amendment.
The language of the home rule amendment relevant here was
interpreted in Attorney General Opinion No. 80-229 which
concluded that "enactments prescribing limits of indebtedness"
only referred to limitations on total or aggregate
indebtedness. Thus, a city may not utilize home rule power to
exempt from the stattutory limits on total indebtedness found
in K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 10-308. (See also Attorney General
Opinions No. 82-186, 77-368). It does not appear that this is
what the City of Lenexa proposes to do. The City will be
subject to enactments prescribing limits of indebtedness while
operating under its home rule ordinance. The special
obligation bonds proposed to be issued by the City, however,
are not the type of bonds which, in our opinion, are limited
by the aggregate debt limitations applicable to the City.
Thus, the City is not attempting to use home rule to exempt
from aggregate debt limitations; it is using home rule to
issue a type of bond which is not included in the City's
aggregate debt limitation.
The bonds authorized by the proposed ordinance are special
obligations secured solely by a pledge of the special
assessments to be levied on the property benefited by the
improvement. You inform us that the City will not pledge it's
faith and credit and the bonds will not be general
obligations. Thus, the City will have no obligation or
authority to levy general ad valorem taxes on the property in
the City to pay principal and interest on the bonds. Unlike
bonds issued pursuant to K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq., the
bonds issued under the proposed ordinance will not obligate
the City for repayment of principal and interest except to the
extent of the revenues pledged, i.e., the special
assessments. In this respect the bonds issued pursuant to the
ordinance are equivalent to revenue bonds. The credit of the
city is not pledged as security for the bonds and to that
extent the relevant aggregate debt limitations do not apply.
See Gelfand et al., State & Local Government Debt
Financing, §2:07 (1985); 15 McQuillin, Municipal
Corporations §41.31 (3d Ed. 1985).
The general aggregate bonded debt limitation applicable to
Kansas cities is expressed as a percentage of the city's
assessed valuation. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 10-308. Thus, the type
of bonded debt which the statute is designed to limit is that
bonded indebtedness which pledges the faith and credit of the
city through its general powers to levy ad valorem taxes.
(Cf. 15 McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §41.17 (3d
Ed., 1985). Bonds issued for local improvements and payable
solely from special assessments on the property benefited
are generally held not to create a municipal indebtedness
within the context of debt limitation laws. See 14
McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §§41.31; 41.32 (3d Ed.
1985) and Gelfand, supra at §12:11. Like revenue bonds,
such special obligations cannot be regarded as municipal
indebtedness for the purposes of debt limitations as long as
payment of the special obligations is limited to the special
assessments. The holders of the bonds will not be entitled to
look to the general credit of the city for payment of the
bonds but only to the funds to be derived from the special
assessments. We find nothing in your description of the
proposed ordinance to indicate that if the revenues produced
by the special assessments are insufficient to meet principal
and interest the bond holders would have any claim on the
faith and credit of the city. Cf., State, ex rel. v.
Kansas City, 148 Kan. 623, 625 (1938) and 149 Kan. 252,
257 (Same Case, Supplemental Opinion 1939.) Of course, to the
extent that such bonds would obligate the city's general
credit they would be included within general debt limitation
laws. We repeat, however, that the proposed home rule
ordinance appears to authorize the issuance of special
obligation bonds payable solely from the special assessments
on benefited property. In such a circumstance the city does
not violate the provisions of the home rule amendment making
city's "subject to" enactments of the legislature prescribing
limits of indebtedness. The city is certainly still subject
to such limits; it is simply issuing bonds which are not
subject to such limits. In our opinion the constitutional
provision making cities subject to enactments of the
legislature prescribing limits of indebtedness means that
cities may neither use home rule to exempt from such
enactments nor issue types of bonds which are subject to such
limitations and provide that such bonds are exempt. It does
not mean that any type of bond which might be issued by a city
utilizing home rule powers (e.g. revenue bonds, special
obligation bonds) becomes subject to general statutory
aggregate debt limitations.
We conclude, therefore, that acquiring and constructing
certain municipal improvements to be paid for in whole or in
part by special assessments upon property benefited by such
improvements is a valid exercise of the City of Lenexa's
constitutional powers of home rule as provided in Article 12,
Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution. Special assessments
levied under the home rule ordinance and payable in
installments may be paid by the city issuing special or
limited obligation bonds payable solely from such special
assessments. K.S.A. 12-6a01 et seq., which also permits
cities to acquire and construct municipal improvements, the
costs of which may be paid (in whole or in part) by special
assessments on benefited property, and which authorizes a
city, to issue bonds which are general obligations of the the
city does not address a city's authority to issue special
obligation bonds payable solely from special assessments.
Thus, K.S.A. 12-6a01 et !fa ., while it addresses a
similar subject and provides an alternative methodology, does
not preclude nor preempt the utilization of home rule powers
proposed by the City of Lenexa. Special obligation bonds
issued pursuant to the home rule ordinance would not be
subject to statutory aggregate debt limitations applicable to
the city because such bonds are not a pledge of the city's
faith and credit nor of its general power to levy ad valorem
taxes. While the home rule amendment states that cities shall
be subject to enactments of the legislature prescribing limits
of indebtedness this limitation does not make those bonds
issued by a city pursuant to home rule which are otherwise
exempt from statutory debt limitations subject to such
limitations.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mary F Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MFC:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.