Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-043

1987-043Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
March 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 43
The Honorable Paul Feliciano, Jr.
State Senator, Twenty-Eighth District
State Capitol, Room 126-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Public Health--Central Interstate Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Compact--Definitions; Options;
Consequences of Compact Membership
Synopsis: Low-level radioactive waste is specifically
exempted from the definition of "hazardous waste"
found in K.S.A. 65-3430(f) and, as such, is not
precluded from underground burial pursuant to
K.S.A. 65-3458. It is likely a ban on the disposal
of low-level radioactive waste in Kansas would be
found inconsistent with the terms of the Central
Interstate Low-Level Radioactive Waste Compact
(Compact), K.S.A. 65-34a01 et seq. Such a
finding could expose Kansas to the membership
revocation penalties of the Compact. Withdrawing
from the Compact this year may cost the state as
much as $25 million. Should Kansas delay beyond
this year and then withdraw, these costs may
increase. If Kansas remains in the Compact, costs
have been estimated to be $5 million. A decision
to pull Kansas out of the Compact guarantees a
waste management facility in the state. Any
attempt to limit disposal in such a facility to
Kansas generated waste must be in conformity with
federal law, which requires "emergency access" by
out-of-state generators, and waste from certain
federal generators.
This opinion is intended to aid the Legislature in
making an informed decision regarding the Compact.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 48-1622; K.S.A.
65-3430; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-3458; 65-34a01 et
seq.; 42 U.S.C. § 2011 et sea.; 42 U.S.C. §
2014; P.L. 99-240; 40 C.F.R. § 261.4 (7-1-86
Edition); U.S. Const., Art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 3;
Art. VI; 126 Congr. Reg. 33, 966 (1980).
Dear Senator Feliciano:
As Senator for the Twenty-Eighth District, you request our
opinion on a variety of topics concerning low-level
radioactive waste (LLRW). Specifically, you have asked:
first, whether LLRW is considered hazardous waste under
Kansas law and, if so, whether a ban on below-ground
disposal of hazardous waste would preclude the below-ground
disposal of LLRW in Kansas. Second, you inquire if Kansas
can prohibit the "disposal" of LLRW in Kansas, but allow the
"storage" of LLRW without violating the Central Interstate
Low-Level Radioactive Waste Compact (Compact), K.S.A.
65-34a01 et seq. Third, you inquire as to the fiscal
impact, long and short term, of Kansas' withdrawal from the
Compact. Finally, you inquire as to the options available to
Kansas at this time and the consequences of these options.
I. LOW-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE v. HAZARDOUS WASTE LAWS
As to your first inquiry, K.S.A. 65-3430(f) states in part:
"'Hazardous waste' . . . shall not
. . . (7) materials listed in 40
CFR 261.4, as in effect on July 1, 1983.
40 C.F.R. § 261.4 (7-1-86 Edition) lists in relevant part:
"(4) Source, special nuclear or by-product material as defined
by the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 2011
et se This material includes low-level radioactive
waste. 42 U.S.C. §2014. Thus, low-level radioactive waste
is specifically exempted from the definition of "hazardous
waste" by Kansas law. As such, its underground burial would
not be precluded under K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-3458.
II. PROHIBITING DISPOSAL
As to your second inquiry, the rights and obligations of each
party state under the Central Interstate Low-Level
Radioactive Waste Compact (K.S.A. 65-34a01 et seq.) are
set forth in Article I of the Compact. The intentions of the
members of the Compact are stated as follows:
"It is the purpose of this compact to
provide the framework for such a
cooperative effort; to promote the health,
safety and welfare of the citizens and the
environment of the region; to limit the
number of facilities needed to effectively
and efficiently manage low-level
radioactive wastes and to encourage the
reduction of the generation thereof; and
to distribute the costs, benefits and
obligations among the party states."
K.S.A. 65-34a01, Article I. (Emphasis
added.)
Among the obligations outlined in the Compact is the selection
of a host state for the site of a regional disposal facility.
The function of such a facility can be gleaned from the
following definitions appearing in Article II of the Compact:
"b. '[D]isposal' means the isolation
and final disposition of waste.
• • •
"d. '[F]acility' means any site,
location, structure or property used or to
be used for the management of waste;
"h. '[M]anagement of waste' means the
storage, treatment or disposal of
waste;
"p. '[S]torage' means the holding of
waste for treatment or disposal;
"q. '[T]reatment' means any methods,
technique or process, including storage
for radioactive decay, designed to change
the physical, chemical or biological
characteristics or composition of any
waste in order to render such waste safer
for transport or management, amenable for
recovery, convertible to another usable
material or reduced in volume." K.S.A.
65-34a01, Article II. (Emphasis added.)
The state could not ban the operation and development of a
regional facility for the management of LLRW without being
in direct conflict with the purpose of the Compact. K.S.A.
65-34a01, Article I. Since management of LLRW includes the
storage, treatment and disposal of LLRW (K.S.A. 65-34a01,
Article II § h), it is our opinion that the state cannot ban
any of these functions without subjecting itself to a finding
of noncompliance by the Compact Commission. This opinion is
buttressed by a reading of the Compact in toto, in that the
fundamental intent and duties of the member states and the
intent of the federal law which mandated the Compact are the
complete disposition of LLRW. See, e.g. Atchison v.
City of Englewood, Colo., 568 P.2d 13, 18 (Colo,
1977).
The Compact, at Article VI, states in relevant part: "b. No
party state shall pass or enforce any law or regulation which
is inconsistent with this compact." However, this would not
appear to preclude the State from enacting strict regulations
concerning the methods by which LLRW should be stored,
treated and disposed of should Kansas be chosen as the site
for a regional facility.
III. FISCAL IMPACT
A finding of noncompliance by the Commission pursuant to
K.S.A. 64-34a01, Article VI, § b, could be cause for
revocation of Kansas' membership in the Compact. This leads
to your third and fourth inquiries, regarding long and short
term fiscal impact, options and consequences. Article VII,
states in part:
"e. Any party state which fails to comply
with the terms of this compact or fulfill
its obligations hereunder may, after
notice and hearing, have its privileges
suspended or its membership in the compact
revoked by the Commission. Revocation
shall take effect one year from the date
such party state receives written notice
from the Commission of its action. The
Commission may require such party state to
pay to the Commission, for a period not
to exceed five years from the date of
notice of revocation, an amount
determined by the Commission based on the
anticipated fees which the generators of
such party state would have paid to each
regional facility and an amount equal to
that which such party state would have
contributed in accordance with section d
of Article III, in the event of
insufficient revenues. The Commission
shall use such funds to ensure the
continued availability of safe and
economical waste management facilities for
all remaining party states. Such state
shall also pay an amount equal to that
which such party state would have
contributed to the annual budget of the
Commission if such party state would have
remained a member of the compact. All
legal rights established under this
compact of any party state which has its
membership revoked shall cease upon the
effective date of revocation; however, any
legal obligations of such party state
arising prior to the effective date of
revocation shall not cease until they have
been fulfilled. Written notice of
revocation of any state's membership in
the compact shall be transmitted
immediately following the vote of the
Commission, by the chairman, to the
governor of the affected party state, all
other governors of the party states and
the Congress of the United States."
K.S.A. 65-34a01, Article VII. (Emphasis
added.)
Since it is our opinion that a ban on the disposal of
low-level radioactive waste in Kansas could be found
inconsistent with the terms of the Compact, the passage of a
law banning disposal, and the ensuing finding would expose
Kansas to the revocation penalties thereunder. The fees paid
for LLRW facility use, Kansas' annual contribution to the
Commission, and Kansas' share of the LLRW facility cost is
estimated to be at least $5 million. This presumes a $25
million cost for the regional facility, $5 million being
Kansas' share, in addition to other fees and contributions.
The withdrawal provision of the Compact appears in Article
VII, which states in part:
"d. Any party state may withdraw from
this compact by enacting a statute
repealing the same. Unless permitted
earlier by unanimous approval of the
Commission, such withdrawal shall take
effect five years after the governor of
the withdrawing state has given notice
in writing of such withdrawal to each
governor of the party states. No
withdrawal shall affect any liability
already incurred by or chargeable to a
party state prior to the time of such
withdrawal." K.S.A. 65-34a01, Article
VII. (Emphasis added.)
A full 5-year liability is possible, assuming the other
Compact states would advocate such liability. Liability could
include contribution expenses to the Commission budget as well
as regional facility construction costs. The current Kansas
commitment to the Commission is $25,000 per year. This figure
will undoubtedly increase as the Commission moves from
planning to actual construction. This could be increased by
whatever damages are ascertained, based upon the $25 million
facility cost and additional penalties.
There are penalties that Kansas generators could incur upon
the state's withdrawal from the Compact at this time if tardy
in implementing a solo project. These penalties are based
upon surcharges set forth in the Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Policy Amendments Act of 1985, P.L. 99-240, Section 5(d)(1) as
follows:
"The disposal of any low-level
radioactive waste under this section
(other than low-level radioactive waste
generated in a sited compact region) may
be charged a surcharge by the State in
which the applicable regional disposal
facility is located, in addition to the
fees and surcharges generally applicable
for disposal of low-level radioactive
waste in the regional disposal facility
involved. Except as provided in
subsection (e)(2), such surcharges shall
not exceed--
"(A) in 1986 and 1987, $10 per cubic
foot of low-level radioactive waste:
"(B) in 1988 and 1989, $20 per cubic
foot of low-level radioactive waste; and
"(C) in 1990, 1991, and 1992, $40 per
cubic foot of low-level radioactive
waste." (Emphasis added.)
The Act goes on to impose certain deadlines for states and/or
compact regions in the establishment of waste management
facilities. The failure to meet these deadlines will result
in surcharges increased by penalties. In addition, access to
the three operating regional disposal facilities would be
restricted.
These surcharges would apply regardless of whether Kansas
withdraws from the Compact. Kansas generators are responsible
for these surcharges until a regional facility is established
under the Compact, or until Kansas establishes its own waste
management facility.
The deadline requirements are stated in relevant part at
section 5(e)(1) of the Act:
"(1) REQUIREMENTS FOR NON-SITED COMPACT
REGIONS AND NON-MEMBER STATES.--Each
non-sited compact region, or State that
is not a member of a compact region that
does not have an operating disposal
facility, shall comply with the following
requirements:
"(A) By July 1, 1986, each such
non-member State shall ratify compact
legislation, or, by the enactment of
legislation or the certification of the
Governor, indicate its intent to develop a
site for the location of a low-level
radioactive waste disposal facility within
such State.
"(B) By JANUARY 1, 1988.--
. . . .
"(ii) each non-member State shall
develop a siting plan providing detailed
procedures and a schedule for establishing
a facility location and preparing a
facility license application for a
low-level radioactive waste disposal
facility and shall delegate authority to
implement such plan; and
"(iii) The siting plan required pursuant
to this paragraph shall include a
description of the optimum way to attain
operation of the low-level radioactive
waste disposal facility involved, within
the time period specified in this Act.
Such plan shall include a description of
the objectives and a sequence of deadlines
for all entities required to take action
to implement such plan, including, to the
extent practicable, an identification of
the activities in which a delay in the
start, or completion, of such activities
will cause a delay in beginning facility
operation. Such plan shall also identify,
to the extent practicable, the process for
(1) screening for broad siting areas; (2)
identifying and evaluating specific
candidate sites; and (3) characterizing
the preferred site(s), completing all
necessary environmental assessments, and
preparing a license application for
submission to the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission or an Agreement State.
"(C) By JANUARY 1, 1990.--
"(i) a complete application (as determined
by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission or
the appropriate agency of an agreement
State) shall be filed for a license to
operate a low-level radioactive waste
disposal facility within each non-sited
compact region or within each non-member
State; or
"(ii) the Governor (or, for any State
without a Governor, the chief executive
officer) of any State that is not a member
of a compact region in compliance with
clause (i), or has not complied with such
clause by its own actions, shall provide a
written certification to the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission, that such State
will be capable of providing for, and will
provide for, the storage, disposal, or
management of any low-level radioactive
waste generated within such State and
requiring disposal after December 31,
1992, and include a description of the
actions that will be taken to ensure that
such capacity exists.
"(D) By January 1, 1992, a complete
application (as determined by the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission or the appropriate
agency of an agreement State) shall be
filed for a license to operate a
low-level radioactive waste disposal
facility within each non-sited compact
region or within each non-member State.
"(F) Any State may, subject to all
applicable provisions, if any, of any
applicable compact, enter into an
agreement with the compact commission of a
region in which a regional disposal
facility is located to provide for the
disposal of all low-level radioactive
waste generated within such State, and, by
virtue of such agreement, may, with the
approval of the State in which the
regional disposal facility is located, be
deemed to be in compliance with
subparagraphs (A), (B), (C), and (D)."
P.L. 99-240.
The penalties for failure to meet these deadlines follow in
section 5(e)(2) of the Act:
"(2) PENALTIES FOR FAILURE TO COMPLY.--
"(A) BY July 1, 1986. --If any State fails
to comply with subparagraphs (1)(A)--
"(i) any generator of low-level
radioactive waste within such region or
non-member State shall, for the period
beginning July 1, 1986, and ending
December 31, 1986, be charged 2 times
the surcharge otherwise applicable under
subsection (d); and
"(ii) on or after January 1, 1987, any
low-level radioactive waste generated
within such region or non-member State
may be denied access to the regional
disposal facilities referred to in
paragraphs (1) through (3) of subsection
(b).
"(B) BY JANUARY 1, 1988. --If any
non-sited compact region or non-member
State fails to comply with paragraph
(1)(B)--
"(i) any generator of low-level
radioactive waste within such region or
non-member State shall--
"(I) for the period beginning January 1,
1988, and ending June 30, 1988, be
charged 2 times the surcharge otherwise
applicable under subsection (d); and
"(II) for the period beginning July 1,
1988, and ending December 31, 1988, be
charged 4 times the surcharge otherwise
applicable under subsection (d); and
"(ii) on or after January 1, 1989, any
low-level radioactive waste generated
within such region or non-member State
may be denied access to the regional
disposal facilities referred to in
paragraphs (1) through (3) of subsection
(b).
"(C) BY JANUARY 1, 1990. -- If any
non-sited compact region or non-member
State fails to comply with paragraph
(1)(C), any low-level radioactive waste
generated within such region or
non-member State may be denied access to
the regional disposal facilities referred
to in paragraphs (1) through (3) of
subsection (b).
"(D) BY JANUARY 1, 1992. --If any
non-sited compact region or non-member
State fails to comply with paragraph
(1)(D), any generator of low-level
radioactive waste within such region or
non-member State shall, for the period
beginning January 1, 1992 and ending upon
the filing of the application described in
paragraph (1)(D), be charged 3 times the
surcharge otherwise applicable under
subsection (d)." P.L. 99-240 (Emphasis
added.)
The most immediate deadline that Kansas faces is the January
1, 1988 deadline imposed by P.L. 99-240, § 5(e)(1)(B). The
cost for preparing a siting plan has been estimated by the
Kansas Department of Health and Environment to be from
$500,000 to $1 million. ("Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Management," pp. 30-31 KDHE, February, 1987).
In summary, Kansas as a Compact member could be liable for its
share of the cost of the Compact site ($5 million estimate),
minus license revenues, plus penalties should the Region miss
deadlines. Kansas as a solo operator may be liable for its
own $10-20 million facility, plus its share of the surcharges,
penalties and costs under the Compact for building a facility
in one of the other four states (withdrawal penalties), plus
any federal deadline penalties, less any license revenues
should Kansas be forced to accept out-of-state LLRW.
Analysis reveals a potential $5 million or less cost to Kansas
as a member of the Compact, and a possible $25 million cost to
Kansas as a non-member. As a non-member, costs to Kansas
could, at a minimum, include the $10-20 million costs of a
solo facility.
IV. COMMERCE AND SUPREMACY CLAUSES
The question has arisen as to the ability of the state to
prohibit disposal of out-of-state generated LLRW in light of
the Commerce. A federal case dealing directly with an
attempted ban on the importation of LLRW is Washington
State Building and Construction Trades Council v. Spellman,
684 F.2d 627 (9th Cir. 1982), cert. denied, 461 U.S.
913, 103 S.Ct. 1891, 77 L.Ed. 2d 282 (1983). In Spellman,
the Ninth Circuit invalidated a Washington law imposing such a
ban using a commerce clause analysis. The state of Washington
was one of only three states that had an operating facility at
that time. In addition, Spellman was argued and decided
prior to the passage of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste
Policy Amendments Act of 1985, P.L. 99-240, which provides
that each state is responsible for disposal of LLRW
generated within its borders, either in a facility of its own
or pursuant to a compact. Thus, it is our understanding that
the Act, as a general rule, would allow states to restrict
out-of-state disposal, though there are exceptions to this
general rule. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission could require
a state to accept other states' LLRW in situations deemed by
that agency to warrant emergency access. Additionally, waste
generated by certain federal generators could be disposed of
in any state facility. Thus, if Kansas should withdraw from
the Compact and construct its own facility, the state could
not prevent the disposal of all out-of-state generated
waste. It is our opinion that any state restrictions on the
disposal of LLRW generated out-of-state would have to
conform with the 1985 Act due to application of the Supremacy
Clause to the United States Constitution. U.S. Const., Art.
VI.
V. OTHER CONCERNS
As mentioned previously in this opinion, we find no
restrictions in the Act on the state's ability to determine
the methods of disposal if the site is within its borders, as
long as those methods are not inconsistent with the purpose of
the Act. Thus, if the state is a member of a compact, it may
design a state-of-the-art facility, perhaps even surpassing
NRC safety regulations, using contributions from other
members of the Compact. If not a member of the Compact, the
state must fund such a facility on its own.
We should note that if all states selected as sites for
regional facilities decide to withdraw from their various
compacts, Congress may be forced to amend or repeal the
current provisions of the Low-Level Radioactive Waste Policy
Amendments Act of 1985 dealing with compact facilities, and
may dispose of that option.
Finally, Kansas law requires state ownership of the land upon
which a LLRW facility is located. K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
48-1622(e). It is our opinion that this requirement is merely
a first step in the right direction. Public ownership and
control of a LLRW site and facility should be the
cornerstone of an active state policy protecting the citizens
of this state from the dangers of improper disposal, storage
and treatment of radioactive waste.
In conclusion, low-level radioactive waste is specifically
exempted from the definition of "hazardous waste" found in
K.S.A. 65-3430(f) and, as such, is not precluded from
underground burial pursuant to K.S.A. 65-3458. It is likely a
ban on the disposal of low-level radioactive waste in Kansas
would be found inconsistent with the terms of the Central
Interstate Low-Level Radioactive Waste Compact (Compact),
K.S.A. 65-34a01 et seq. Such a finding could expose
Kansas to the membership revocation penalties of the Compact.
Withdrawing from the Compact this year may cost the state as
much as $25 million. Should Kansas delay beyond this year and
then withdraw, these costs may increase. If Kansas remains in
the Compact, costs have been estimated to be $5 million. A
decision to pull Kansas out of the Compact guarantees a waste
management facility in the state. Any attempt to limit
disposal in such a facility to Kansas generated waste must be
in conformity with federal law, which requires "emergency
access" by out-of-state generators, and waste from certain
federal generators.
This opinion is intended to aid the Legislature in making an
informed decision in deliberations regarding withdrawal from,
or remaining in, the Compact.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TL:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.