Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-041

1987-041Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL March 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 41
The Honorable Ben E. Vidricksen
State Senator, Twenty-Fourth District
State Capitol, 143-N
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Plumbing and Electrical
Wiring; Plumbing and Plumbers in Cities and
Counties; Electricians and Electrical
Wiring--Competency and Licensure of Plumbers and
Electricians
Synopsis: In implementing the competency and licensure
statutes for plumbers and electricians found in
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1508 et seq. and
12-1525 et se a ., the board of county
commissioners of a county or the governing body of
a city: (1) may refuse to issue a license because
a city or county has a higher passing grade than
the city or county that issued the certificate of
competency because it is our opinion that the
statutory scheme established by subsections (b) and
(c) of K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1509 for plumbers and
12-1526 for electricians is unconstitutional based
on unauthorized delegation of legislative
authority; (2) has the discretion to prescribe
requirements for passage of examinations; (3) may
require passage of the standard Block and
Associates exam in order to practice outside of the
jurisdiction that has granted a license based on an
alternative exam; (4) has no statutory authority to
require a contractor to buy an additional license
unless the contractor was granted a license based
upon the passage of an alternative exam; and (5)
may impose their bonding and insurance requirements
on a contractor from another city, provided the
bonding and insurance requirements are part of the
county's or city's plumbing codes, standards and
regulations. The plumbing and electrician
competency and licensing statutes are parallel and
the above apply to both. Cited herein: K.S.A.
1986 Supp. 12-1508; 12-1509; 12-1510; 12-1525;
12-1526; 12-1527.
Dear Senator Vidricksen:
As Senator for the Twenty-Fourth District, you request our
opinion on a series of questions dealing with the
implementation of competency and licensure statutes by local
units of government. Specifically, you ask five questions
that concern the competency and licensure statutes for
plumbers and electricians. You indicate that the laws are
parallel and that your questions apply to both plumbers and
electricians.
The statutes dealing with competency and licensure are found
in K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1508 through 12-1510, inclusive for
plumbers and K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1525 through 12-1527,
inclusive, for electricians. Your first two questions are as
follows:
"When a person has passed the Block and Associates Exam
and has been issued a certificate of competency, can
another city refuse to issue a license because they have
a different passing grade than the city issuing the
certificate of competency?"
"Since Block and Associates has been designated as the
standard examination, and they recommend a 75% passing
grade, is that the minimum score required for the
passage of examinations?"
These two questions are interdependent and must be answered
together. For purposes of clarity, the second question will
be addressed first. K.S.A. 1986 Supp 12-1509(a) states:
"Any county or city requiring the
licensure of plumbers practicing within
the county or city may conduct
examinations designated by K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 12-1508 for the purpose of
determining the competency of applicants
for such licensure. The board of county
commissioners of such county or the
governing body of such city shall adopt
rules and regulations: (1) Governing the
conduct and grading of such examinations;
(2) prescribing requirements for passage
of examinations; and (3) fixing a uniform
fee to be charged all applicants taking
each such examination." (Emphasis
added.) (The provisions of K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 12-1526(a) are identical for
electricians.)
It is our opinion that the statutes allow the board or
governing body to prescribe their own requirements for passage
of examinations and that there is nothing in the statute to
preclude the board or governing body from adopting the Block
recommended 75% passage as a minimum score.
Addressing now your first question, it clearly indicates a
concern about applying different passage requirements in
conjunction with the mandates of subsections (b) and (c) of
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1509 requiring a county or city to issue
a license to any applicant who presents a certificate of
competency based on passage of the standard Block exam and
requiring that all licenses issued upon this basis be honored
in all cities or counties. This situation creates a problem
based on unlawful delegation of legislative authority. While
the power to make laws cannot be delegated, the power to
apply them can be delegated provided clear standards are
established to regulate and control the delegated power.
State, ex rel., Schneider v. Bennett, 222 Kan. 12, 19
(1977). (Emphasis added.) Great leeway is allowed the
legislature in setting forth standards, and the use of general
standards rather than minute standards is permissible.
State, ex rel., Tomasic v. Kansas City, Kansas Port
Authority, 230 Kan. 404, 417 (1981), citing Bennett
supra; Welsey Medical Center v. McCain, 226 Kan.
263, 269 (1979). The delegation of authority by the
legislature to the boards of county commissioners of counties
or the governing bodies of cities to prescribe the
requirements for passage of examinations is within the
legislature's power, especially in light of the Kansas Supreme
Court's reasoning in Tomasic.
In Tomasic , 230 Kan. 404, the Kansas Supreme Court
looked to whether a general determination of need (that it was
necessary for a port authority to transact business or
exercise their power) was a sufficiently clear standard. The
court held that such a determination of need was
constitutionally adequate when coupled with the assumption
that it would be made "fairly, honestly and reasonably." 230
Kan. at 417. Likewise in our instance, the power to
prescribe a passing score can be coupled with the assumption
that the score will be set fairly, honestly and within
reason. The delegated power to prescribe a passing score
appears to be constitutionally adequate as a clear standard.
However, by making all licenses (issued upon the basis of
successful passage of the standard Block exam) valid in all
cities or counties, [subsection (c) of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1509 and 12-1526], the legislature is allowing the city or
county with the lowest passage requirement to impose that
standard on all counties and cities. Illustrative of this is
the scenario where an applicant for licensure fails the
standard exam in one county, goes to another county and makes
the same score but because of a lower passage requirement
obtains a certificate of competency and is issued a license.
This license in turn must be honored by the county where the
applicant originally did not pass the exam. It is readily
apparent that subsections (b) and (c) of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1509 and 12-1526 allow the city or county with the lowest
passage requirement to set the passing score for all other
cities or counties. Allowing one city or county to set the
standard for all other cities or counties results in the
unauthorized delegation of legislative authority and
contravenes the power to make laws that is vested in the House
of Representatives and the Senate. Kan. Const., Art. 2,
§1.
Accordingly, it is our opinion that the statutory scheme
established by subsections (b) and (c) of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1509 for plumbers and 12-1526 for electricians is
unconstitutional based on unauthorized delegation of
legislative authority. It is therefore our opinion that a
city can refuse to issue a license because the city has a
different higher passing grade than the city which issued the
certificate of competency. See 16 C.J.S. Constitutional
Law §144 (1984).
The rest of the questions will be answered in the order
asked. Your third question is:
"Do contractors need to be Block certified to do
business in another jurisdiction?"
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1510 states in pertinent part:
"Within their respective jurisdictions and
subject to the provisions of K.S.A.
12-1509, any county or city may:
"(a) Utilize examinations other than those
designated by K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1508
for the examination of plumbers for
licensure to practice only within the
jurisdiction of such city or county;
"Except when authorized by reciprocal
agreement between the political
subdivisions involved, licenses granted
upon the basis of examinations other than
those designated by K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1508 [Block and Associates exam] shall
not authorize a plumber to practice
outside of the jurisdiction of the city or
county granting such license." (The
provisions of K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1527
are identical for electricians.)
In accordance with these statutes, it is our opinion that
contractors who have not taken the standard Block and
Associates exam cannot practice outside of the jurisdiction
that has granted a license based on an alternative examination
unless authorized by reciprocal agreement.
Your fourth question poses the following scenario:
"Section (c) [K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1526(c)] states, 'All
licenses issued by a county or city [per this Act] . . .
shall be valid in any county or city which requires
examination and licensure of electricians for practice
in such county or city.' Contractor 'X' successfully
passed the standard examination, received a Certificate
of Competency, and was subsequently issued a license by
City 'A'. Must City 'B' accept the license issued by
City 'A' and allow Contractor 'X' to work within its
jurisdiction; or may City 'B' merely accept the City 'A'
license as recognition that its examination requirements
have been met and still require Contractor 'X' to buy an
additional license?"
In accordance with our answer to your first and second
questions, subsections (b) and (c) of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1509 and 12-1526 may be subject to constitutional
challenge. Notwithstanding, it is our opinion that until such
constitutional challenge is made, City B must accept the
license issued by City A and allow Contractor X to work within
its jurisdiction. Further, there is no statutory authority
for requiring Contractor X to buy an additional license
unless Contractor X was granted a license upon the basis of
passage of an exam other than the standard Block exam in
accordance with K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1510(c) for plumbers or
12-1527(c) for electricians which limits the validity of a
license issued upon an alternative exam to the jurisdiction of
the city or county granting such license.
Your fifth and last question concerns bonding and insurance.
You ask:
"May City 'B' impose the same requirements on a
contractor from City 'A' that they impose on City 'B'
contractors in regards to bonding and insurance? Would
this come under Section 3(b) [K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1510(b) and 12-1527(b)]?"
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1510(b) provides that a city or county
may, within their respective jurisdiction and subject to
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1509, adopt and enforce plumbing codes,
standards and regulations promulgated by the board of county
commissioners or governing body of the city. Accordingly, it
is our opinion that K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1510(b) authorizes a
city to impose their bonding and insurance requirements on a
contractor from another city, provided the bonding and
insurance requirements are part of the city's plumbing codes,
standards and regulations. The same would be true for
electricians pursuant to K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1527(b).
In conclusion, our opinion is as follows. The plumbing and
electrician competency and licensure statutes do not set any
minimum score for passage of the standard Block exam, and
further they allow the passage requirements to be prescribed
by the governing bodies of cities or the boards of county
commissioners of counties. Contingent upon a successful
constitutional challenge against subsections (b) and (c) of
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1509 and 12-1526, a city may refuse to
issue a license because they have a different passing grade
than the city issuing the certificate or competency.
Contractors that have not taken the standard Block exam cannot
practice outside of the jurisdiction that has granted a
license based on an alternative exam unless authorized by
reciprocal agreement. There is no statutory authority for
requiring a contractor to buy an additional license unless the
contractor was granted a license upon the basis of an
alternative exam. Finally, a city may impose their bonding
and insurance requirements on a contractor from another city,
provided the requirements are part of the city's plumbing
codes, standards and regulations.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:GE:jm
en Easley

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.