Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-176

1986-176Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. December 29, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 176
Kenneth M. Wilke, Chief Counsel
State of Kansas State Board of Agriculture
109 SW 9th
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1280
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Open Public Meetings
-- Secret Ballots; Voting Procedure to Elect
Members of the State Board of Agriculture
State Boards, Commissions and Authorities -- State
Board of Agriculture; Election and Duties of Board
-- Annual Meeting; Election of Board Members
Synopsis: The annual meeting of the State Board of
Agriculture (Board) and the caucus meetings held by
the agricultural districts are public bodies
subject to the provisions of the Kansas Open
Meetings Act (KOMA). Under the open meetings law,
no binding action can be taken by secret ballot.
The purpose of this provision is to make public
every official's vote on the public's business. A
"secret ballot," then, is one in which the voter's
choice or decision is not known. The procedure
which has been followed in electing members of the
Board violates the KOMA as the public has noway to
determine how each delegate voted. Delegates may,
however, vote by paper ballot if each delegate
signs his or her name to the ballot and the ballots
are open for public inspection. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 25-2422; 25-2901; 25-3008; 74-502; 74-503;
75-4317; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318.
Dear Mr. Wilke:
As chief counsel for the State of Kansas State Board of
Agriculture, you ask our opinion concerning the applicability
of the Kansas Open Meetings Act (KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317 et
seq., to the selection of members of the Board of
Agriculture.
The annual meeting of the State Board of Agriculture (Board)
is held in Topeka the second Wednesday of January each year.
K.S.A. 74-503. At this meeting members of the Board are
elected by delegates chosen by farm organizations across the
state. K.S.A. 74-502. This system of selection is unique to
Kansas. The Board is composed of two members from each of the
six agricultural districts. K.S.A. 74-503. In January 1987
five positions on the Board are up for election.
You describe the procedure followed in electing Board members
as follows:
"[E]lection of the board members occurs
at the business portion of the annual
meeting of the State Board of
Agriculture. This portion of the annual
meeting is analogous to a congress of
delegates. Each delegate in attendance at
the business session may vote on the
election of each board member regardless
of whether or not that prospective board
member resides in the delegate's
district. Usually, there are 170 or more
voting delegates.
"Prior to the business meeting, the
delegates from each of the six separate
districts meet and caucus for the purpose
of selecting a candidate for that
particular district, should a board
position in that district be vacant, for
submission to the delegate body as a
whole. Past practice has involved the use
of ballots in the following manner: Each
delegate is given a slip of paper upon
which the delegate may write the name of
the nominee which the delegate favors and
the ballots are then counted in public
view and the person having a plurality
from the number of delegates in that
particular district is proposed to the
delegate body at the business session as a
candidate for that district's board
position. Run off elections are use, if
needed. Note that this action in the
caucus is not binding upon the delegate
body as a whole.
"During the business session, the person
proposed for nomination from a district is
placed before the whole assembly of
delegates and the chairperson asks if
there are other nominations. If other
nominations are forthcoming, then an
election from the delegate body of the
whole determines who shall fill the vacant
board position. In the absence of other
nominations, the delegate body will elect
the district's caucus nominee in [sic] by
unanimous ballot upon proper motion being
made." (Emphasis in original.)
The KOMA provides that all meetings of public bodies must be
open to the public. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318(a). The
purpose of the law is stated in K.S.A. 75-4317(a):
"In recognition of the fact that a
representative government is dependent
upon an informed electorate, it is
declared to be the policy of this state
that meetings for the conduct of
governmental affairs and the transaction
of governmental business be open to the
public."
The Act also provides that "no binding action by [public]
bodies shall be by secret ballot." K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
75-4318(a). The question presented is whether the election
procedure at the annual meeting violates the prohibition in
the open meetings law against secret ballots.
An organization is not a "public body" subject to the KOMA
unless a two-part test is met: (1) the body is either a
legislative or administrative agency of the state or-one of
its political or taxing subdivisions or is subordinate to such
a body; and (2) the body receives or expends and is funded in
whole or in part by public funds, or, in the case of
subordinate groups, has a parent or controlling body which is
so supported. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318(a). Clearly, the
Board of Agriculture is subject to the KOMA. In order to
answer the question whether the election procedure violates
the open meetings law, it must first be determined whether the
gatherings of delegates at the annual meeting and district
caucuses are public bodies.
Agriculture districts are created by statute. K.S.A. 74-503.
District meetings are not groups "subordinate" to the Board
because they in effect implement the Board by selecting its
members through the caucuses and annual meeting. However,
notwithstanding the relationship between the districts and the
Board, the annual meeting and the district caucus meetings
meet the two-part test and thus are in themselves public
bodies which must abide by the KOMA's prohibition against
secret ballots. The "public funds" requirement is met as
certain expenses of the annual meeting, not to exceed $10,000
annually, are paid out of the state treasury. K.S.A. 74-503.
The second part of the test is also met. This office has used
several factors to aid in determining whether an organization
is a legislative or administrative agency of the state:
"'1) If the agency has the authority to
make governmental decisions and act for
the state, it is covered by an open
meetings law. If it only collects
information, makes recommendations or
renders advice, it is not. McLarty v.
Bd. of regents, 231 Ga. 22, 220
S.E.2d 117, 119 (1973).
"'2) Does the agency have independent
authority in the exercise of its
functions? Soucie v. David, 440 F.2d
1967 (D.C. Cir. 1971).
"'3) Is the agency subject to government
audits or otherwise have its business
procedures supervised? Rocap v.
Indiek, 539 F.2d 174 (D.C. Cir. 1976).
"'4) Finally, one court has defined
"governmental agency" to include corporate
instrumentalities that accomplish public
ends, both government and proprietary.
Ratan Public Service Co. v. Hobes,
76 N.M. 536, 417 P.2d 32 (1966).'"
Attorney General Opinion Nos. 84-10;
79-284.
Candidates chosen at district caucuses are virtually
guaranteed election at the annual meeting of all the delegates
to represent the district that nominated him or her. Members
of the Board are not chosen by popular election. Decisions
made by delegates at the annual meeting and district caucuses
are made for the public. The selection of persons to serve on
the State Board of Agriculture, then, is a governmental
function. Therefore, the annual meeting of delegates and
agricultural districts caucus meetings are public bodies
subject to the open meeting laws.
The KOMA provides that no binding action can be taken by
secret ballot. K.S.A. 75-4318(a). It is argued that the
caucus elections do not constitute binding action because the
delegate body as a whole may elect some other persons placed
in nomination during the annual meeting. Historically,
however, the person who wins the district caucus is the only
person nominated for that position at the annual meeting. In
addition, one commentary on the KOMA has suggested that
"binding action" is the equivalent of "final action:"
"In other states the phase 'final action'
is often used and has been broadly
construed 'to connote finality within the
scope of the powers delegated' to the
bodies subject to those statutes."
Smoot and Clothier, Open Meetings
Profile: The Prosecutor's View, 20
Washburn L.J. 241, 270 (1981).
Even if other persons are nominated at the annual meeting in
addition to the persons elected at the district caucus, the
caucus elections constitute binding action as such elections
are the final actions that caucus meetings can take within the
scope of their powers.
The argument is made that the balloting procedure used by the
caucuses is not "secret" because the pieces of paper used for
the election are opened and made available for public
inspection. This does not, however, make the casting of such
ballots "not secret." The Kansas Supreme Court has said that
the purpose of the secret ballot prohibition "is to make
public every official's vote on the public's business."
Olathe Hospital Foundation, Inc. v. Extendicare, 217
Kan. 546, 562 (1975). We must conclude that the voting
procedure currently employed by the district caucuses violates
the open meetings law as the public has no way to determine
how each delegate voted.
You also ask whether the secret ballot provision of the KOMA
would be violated if delegates voted by paper ballot to which
each delegate would sign his or her name. As proposed, the
ballots would be counted in public view and open for
inspection by any person. You also suggest that the ballots
could be retained as part of the record.
In 1893 Kansas adopted the Australian-ballot system for
voting in popular elections. This method was designed to
protect voters in maintaining secrecy of their ballot.
Lambeth v. Levens, 237 Kan. 614, 619 (1985). "Every
person has a privilege to refuse to disclose the tenor of his
or her vote at a political election . . . ." K.S.A. 60-431.
See K.S.A. 25-2422; 25-2901; 25-3008. In Taylor v.
Bleakley, 55 Kan. 1, 14 (1895), the Kansas Supreme Court
defined "ballot" and stated as follows:
"It is conceded that the word 'ballot'
means 'a bit of paper having printed or
written thereon the designation of an
office, and the name of a person to fill
it, and that the person casting it has a
right to do so in absolute secrecy.' The
cardinal features of chapter 78 [L. 1893,
Ch. 78; enacting election laws] are
two: First, an arrangement for polling by
which compulsory secrecy of voting is
secured; second, an official ballot
containing the names of all candidates,
printed and distributed under official
authority. The act compels a vote by
ballot, and absolute secrecy."
The KOMA mandates that every official's vote on the public's
business be made public. As previously noted, members of the
Board of Agriculture are elected by a public body, not by
popular election. Secret ballots, therefore, cannot be used
in selecting Board members as their election is subject to
public scrutiny. Ballots are secret when a voter's choice is
not disclosed. The fact that a piece of paper is used in
voting does not necessarily make an election by "secret
ballot." If a delegate's choice is made known, the ballot is
not secret. Signing one's name to his or her ballot which is
open for public inspection precludes secrecy in voting. It is
our opinion that the open meetings law is not violated if
delegates to the annual meeting of the State Board of
Agriculture vote for board members by writing their choice on
a piece of paper and sign their names thereto.
In summary, the annual meeting of delegates and district
caucuses are public bodies subject to the open meetings laws.
It is our opinion that the voting procedure that has been used
to elect members to the state Board violates the provision in
the KOMA which prohibits binding action by secret ballot.
Under the Act, a "secret ballot" is one in which each member's
vote or decision is not known. The KOMA would not be
violated, then, if delegates voted for board members by
writing their choice on a paper ballot and signed their names
thereto.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.