Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-162

1986-162Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL November 20, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 162
Thomas A. Krueger
P.O. Box 728
Emporia, Kansas 66801
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Open Public Meetings
-- Executive Sessions; Consultation with an
Attorney
Synopsis: K.S.A. 75-4319(b)(2) authorizes public bodies
subject to the Kansas Open Meetings Act (KOMA) to
recess into an executive session for the purpose of
"consultation with an attorney for the body or
agency which would be deemed privileged in the
attorney-client relationship . . . ." The term
"'consultation" as used in the KOMA necessarily
implies the presence of an attorney. Even though a
letter from an attorney to his client containing
advice is a privileged communication, we must
conclude that members of a public body cannot
recess into an executive session to review and
discuss among themselves a letter from their
attorney. Therefore, it is our opinion that the
"consultation with an attorney" exception to the
open meetings law cannot be invoked unless the
attorney for the body is present. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 60-426; 75-4317; K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
75-4318(a); K.S.A. 75-4319.
Dear Mr. Krueger:
As legal counsel for Unified School District (U.S.D.) No. 252
(Hartford), you request our opinion concerning the Kansas Open
Meetings Act (KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317 et sec-. Many boards
of education across the state employ legal counsel located in
a city other than the city where the board's office is
located. The board office for U.S.D. No. 252 is not located
in Emporia, where you practice. You state that, because of
the distance involved, it becomes necessary at times for you
to communicate with the board by correspondence. Therefore,
you ask whether a letter you have written to the board in
response to an inquiry would constitute a "consultation with
an attorney" to allow the board to recess into an executive
session to discuss such written advice or opinions regardless
that you are not actually present.
The KOMA provides that meetings of public bodies must be open
to the public. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318(a). A public body
may, however, recess into a closed meeting for the purpose of
discussing one of the six subjects listed in the act. K.S.A.
75-4319(b)(2) states that an executive session may be called
for "consultation with an attorney for the body or agency
which would be deemed privileged in the attorney-client
relationship . . . ."
In Attorney General Opinion No. 82-247, we were asked to give
some general guidelines for the use of the "consultation with
an attorney" exception to the open meetings law. Relying in
part on Attorney General Opinion No. 78-303, we stated that
this exception is inapplicable unless the attorney is present
for the consultation:
"Members of boards or agencies subject to
the Act are simply not allowed to discuss
legal issues concerning the body among
themselves under the guise of this
privilege, unless the attorney is a party
to the consultation."
In Attorney General Opinion No. 78-303 we were informed that a
board of education recessed into executive session to discuss
a pending lawsuit. The board's attorney was not present.
However, the superintendent of the district was present and
relayed to the board information about the litigation which
the attorney had furnished to him. It was concluded that
since the board's attorney was not present, the attorney-
client privilege could not be relied upon to justify the
closed session as the discussion by the board members among
themselves was not a privileged communication.
The situation now presented for our review is distinguished
from that of the above opinion in that board members would
have a written document furnished by their attorney. K.S.A.
60-426 provides that "communications . . . between [a] lawyer
and his or her client in the course of that relationship and
in professional confidence, are privileged . . . ." A
"communication" is defined as follows:
"'[C]ommunication' includes advice given
by the lawyer in the course of
representing the client and includes
disclosures of the client to a
representative, associate or employee of
the lawyer incidental to the professional
relationship . . . ." K.S.A. 60-426(c)(2).
In referring to the above statute, the court in State v.
Newman, 235 Kan. 29, 40 (1984), stated that "a
communication here means a transmission of information between
the attorney and the client." Clearly, a letter from an
attorney containing advice to his client is a privileged
communication within the meaning of the statute. It is your
contention that such a letter would allow the board to recess
into an executive session for purposes of having a
"consultation with an attorney" to discuss the written
communication even without the actual presence of the board's
attorney.
To give effect to the policy of openness in government, the
KOMA is interpreted liberally and its exceptions narrowly
construed. K.S.A. 75-4319(b)(2) provides that an executive
session may be held for consultation with an attorney which
would be deemed privileged. The word "consultation" is
defined generally as "the act of consulting or conferring;
deliberation of two or more persons on some matter."
Webster's Third New International Dictionary 490. Black's
Law Dictionary 286 (rev. 5th ed. 1979) defines the term
as the "[a]ct of consulting or conferring . . . .
Deliberation of persons on .some subject." Consultation, then,
necessarily implies the presence of an attorney. In
discussing among themselves the contents of a letter from
their attorney, board members would not be conferring with
an attorney. While an attorney's letter giving advice to his
client is a privileged communication, it is not a
"consultation" within the meaning of the KOMA. It is
important to note that not all consultations with an attorney
will justify a closed meeting; such consultation must also be
privileged.
In summary, K.S.A. 75-4319(b)(2) authorizes public bodies
subject to the Kansas Open Meetings Act to recess into an
executive session for the purpose of "consultation with an
attorney for the body or agency which would be deemed
privileged in the attorney-client relationship . . . ." The
term "consultation" as used in the KOMA necessarily implies
the presence of an attorney. Even though a letter from an
attorney to his client containing advice is a privileged
communication, we must conclude that members of a public body
cannot recess into an executive session to review and discuss
among themselves a letter from their attorney. Therefore, it
is our opinion that the "consultation with an attorney"
exception to the open meetings law cannot be invoked unless
the attorney for the body is present.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.