Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-119

1986-119Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
August 22, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 119
The Honorable Edward F. Reilly, Jr.
State Senator, Third District
430 Delaware, Box 9
Leavenworth, Kansas 66048
Re: Taxation--Property Exempt from Taxation--Church
Parsonages; Application for Exemption
Synopsis: It is well-settled that parsonages are not
tax-exempt under the Kansas Constitution. Thus,
parsonages have been taxable property since the
1969 legislature dropped the specific provision
granting parsonages an exemption. By passing
Senate Bill No. 400, the 1986 legislature once
again granted parsonages an exemption. However,
churches must affirmatively reapply to the Board of
Tax Appeals to be granted such an exemption. In
addition to this application being mandated by
statute, it is necessary in light of the fact that,
through 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, the legislature
changed the test to be applied in determining a
parsonage's tax exempt status from its pre-1969
test. Because of this, it is imperative that the
Board of Tax Appeals have the applications in order
to make an informed decision. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 79-201, as amended by L. 1986,
ch. 368, §1 Seventh, and L. 1986, ch. 369, §1
Seventh; K.S.A. 79-213; Kan. Const., Art. 11,
§1; Gen. Stat. of 1909, Sec. 9216; L. 1929,
ch. 283, §1; K.S.A. 1968 Supp. 79-201 First;
L. 1969, ch. 429, §1.
Dear Senator Reilly:
As Senator for the Third District, you request our opinion
regarding the application of 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, which
provides a tax exemption for church parsonages. See L.
1986, Ch. 368, §1 Seventh, as amended by L. 1986, ch.
369, §1 Seventh. More specifically, you ask whether all
churches owning property used as parsonages must make
affirmative reapplication to the Board of Tax Appeals to be
eligible for this exemption from the state and local property
tax.
The Kansas Constitution has, since its inception, exempted
from property tax ". . . all property used exclusively for
state, county, municipal, literary, educational, scientific,
religious, benevolent and charitable purposes. . . ."
(Emphasis added.) Kan. Const., Art. 11, §1. However, in
1872 the Kansas Supreme Court held that this constitutional
provision did not exempt a church parsonage from taxation.
Vail v. Beach, 10 Kan. 166 (1872). The property in
question in that case was a house in Lawrence that was owned
by the Protestant Episcopal Diocese of Kansas and used by its
Bishop as a residence. Id. The Court stated that, "the
property is used as any other dwelling, and the use is not
distinguishable from that of the residence of any other
Christian pastor or Christian gentleman. It is clear that it
is not the purpose of the section referred to to relieve such
property from the burden of taxation. . . ." Id. at 166-167.
The holding in Vail, supra, was the law of Kansas until
1909 when the Kansas Legislature enacted the following
specific exemptions for proper ties owned and used by religious
organizations:
"First, all buildings used exclusively
as places of public worship, as public
schoolhouses, or both, with the furniture
and books therein contained and used
exclusively for the accommodation of
schools and religious meetings, together
with the grounds owned thereby not
exceeding in any one case 10 acres, if not
leased or otherwise used with view to
profit; and also any parsonage or
dwelling owned by any church society and
occupied by its pastor as a residence,
together with the ground on which it is
situated, not exceeding in any one case
1/2 acre." Gen. Stat. of 1909, Sec.
9216 (Emphasis added.)
In 1916, the Kansas Supreme Court construed this statute to
deny an exemption for a church-owned residence of a Bishop
who was not a pastor of the church. Griswald v. Quinn,
97 Kan. 611 (1916). Then, in 1929, the Kansas Legislature
amended section 79-201 First of the Revised Statutes of
Kansas 1923 to extend the parsonage exemption to include the
residences of district church officials. L. 1929, ch. 283,
§1. The effect of this amendment was to vitiate the Court's
decision in Griswald, supra.
In 1968, the Kansas Legislature created a Joint Committee on
State Tax Structure to study the property tax in Kansas. The
committee's interim report, which was filed for consideration
by the 1969 legislature, specifically addressed the exemption
of church-owned parsonages. See Journal of The Senate,
January 30, 1969, page 104, et seg. It was the
committee's conclusion that, whenever possible, tax exemptions
should be based on the State Constitution. Id. at 132-13.3.
Thus, the committee recommended to the legislature that K.S.A.
1968 Supp. 79-201 First be amended to strike the 10 acre
limitation and all references to parsonages and residences of
chaplains. Id. at 133. This recommendation was adopted by
the legislature at that time. L. 1969, ch. 429, §1.
Despite this 1969 revision, counties did not add parsonages to
their tax rolls, and the State Board of Tax Appeals continued
to exempt parsonages in its rulings. These rulings were not
challenged until 1984, when Johnson County appealed an
exemption decision granted by the Board of Tax Appeals. In
Matter of the Application of First Assembly of God Church,
84 CV 965 (Shawnee Co. 1984), Judge Buchele held that,
absent a specific statutory exemption, parsonages were not tax
exempt. Id. at 9. In his decision, Judge Buchele noted
that, "when the legislature revises an existing statute it is
presumed that the legislature intends to make some change in
the existing laws." Id. at 6. Furthermore, it is the
accepted rule of statutory construction that, when a statute
is revised, some part being omitted, the omitted parts are
ordinarily to be considered annulled. See Hauserman v.
Clay County, 89 Kan. 555 (1913), Schmeling v. F.W.
Woolworth Co., 137 Kan. 573 (1933); State, ex rel., v.
Richardson, 174 Kan. 382 (1953). "These rules of statutory
construction and the published Committee Report make it
obvious that the legislature intended to eliminate the
statutory exemption for parsonages". First Assembly of-God
Church, supra at 6. Additionally, Judge Buchele
reaffirmed the holding in Vail v. Beach, supra and held
that a church-owned parsonage is not entitled to an
exemption under Section 1, Article 11 of the Kansas
Constitution. First Assembly of God Church, supra at 8.
Following the district court ruling, the Director of the
Division of Property Valuation, Kansas Department of Revenue,
issued a memorandum, which directed all counties to restore
parsonages to their tax roles effective January 1, 1986.
See Attachment 1. The Legislature responded to the 1984
ruling by passing 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, which
re-established church-owned parsonages as tax-exempt,
effective December 31, 1985. L. 1986, Ch. 368, §1
Seventh. The division of property valuation is now
requiring all churches to make affirmative reapplication to
the Board of Tax Appeals for exemption from the state and
local. property tax pursuant to K.S.A. 79-213.
You contend that such affirmative reapplication is
unnecessary, and that it creates an undue financial burden
upon all churches that seek to exempt their parsonages from
taxation. Clearly, complying with this directive will cost
the churches monies for costly surveys and title work.
However, it is our opinion that, despite this burden, such
reapplication is indeed a necessity.
It is clear that when the legislature removed the parsonage
exemption from K.S.A. 79-201 First in 1969, parsonages were
no longer exempt from state and local taxes under either the
Kansas statutes or Constitution; See First Assembly of 'God
Church, supra at 6; Vail v. Beach, supra. Thus,
while it has been argued that 1986 Senate Bill No. 400 was
passed in order to "maintain the longstanding policy in this
state," [see Attachment 2, p. 2], 1986 Senate Bill No. 400,
in effect, created a new tax exemption. As such, churches are
required to file an initial application with the Board of Tax
Appeals in order to be granted a parsonage exemption. K.S.A.
79-213.
The provisions of K.S.A. 79-213 notwithstanding, it could be
argued that churches should not have to reapply if such
reapplication was duplicitous in nature. However, in
drafting 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, the legislature changed the
"test" that must be used when determining whether a parsonage
should be tax exempt. Compare L. 1986, ch. 369, §1 with
L. 1929, ch. 283, §1. Thus, parsonages that had been
considered tax exempt in the past might no longer be entitled
to such status. This determination can be made only by the
Board of Tax Appeals, and they must have the applications in
order to make an informed determination.
In conclusion, it is well-settled that parsonages are not
tax-exempt under the Kansas Constitution. Thus, parsonages
have been taxable property since the 1969 legislature dropped
the specific provision granting parsonages an exemption. By
passing 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, the legislature once again
granted parsonages an exemption. However, churches must
affirmatively reapply to the Board of Tax Appeals to be
granted such an exemption. In addition to this application
being mandated by statute, it is necessary in light of the
fact that, by passing 1986 Senate Bill No. 400, the
legislature changed the test to be applied in determining a
parsonage's tax exempt status from its pre-1969 test.
Because of this, it is imperative that the Board of Tax
Appeals have the applications in order to make an informed
decision.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm
MEMORANDUM
TO: All County Appraisers
And County Commissioners
FROM: Victor W. Miller, Director
Division of Property Valuation
DATE: September 19, 1985
SUBJECT: Parsonages
Our office has received a number of inquiries concerning the tax exempt
status of church parsonages. We have reviewed existing statutes as well
as case law and can find no basis for exempting parsonages from ad valorem
taxation.
The exempt status this property once enjoyed was repealed by the 1969
legislature. We have attached a copy of the Shawnee County District Court
decision which is most explicit on controlling Kansas law.
By way of this memorandum, you are asked to review your exempt property
rolls and be-prepared to restore to the rolls on January 1, 1986 (with
1986 property tax liability) any church parsonage not already on the rolls.
Attachment
VWM:bkh
We are following this memorandum and District Court decision
and placing your parsonage back on the tax rolls effective
January 1, 1986.
Don Gordon C.K.A.
Douglas County Appraiser
441-acArYtt-1-1- I
MICHAEL L. JOHNSTON
SENATE MINORITY LEADER
SENATOR. FOURTEENTH DISTRICT
LABETTE COUNTY AND PARTS OF
CRAWFORD. MONTGOMERY AND
NEOSHO COUNTIES
P 0 BOX A
PARSONS. KANSAS 67357-0040
Joint Committee on Assessment and Taxation
Senate Bill 399, Tax Exemption of Church Parsonages
January 30, 1986
Statement by Senator Michael Johnston
The tax exemption of parsonages is nothing new in
this state. The issue of whether a church parsonage was
exempt from taxation was considered by the Kansas Supreme
Court in 1872. The Court held that the Kansas Constitution
did not exempt parsonages because they did not meet the
exclusive religious use test of the Constitution.
In 1909, the Kansas Legislature created a statutory
exemption for properties including parsonages which were
owned and used by religious organizations. In 1969, the
Kansas Legislature revised the 1909 exemption law and removed
the Parsonage exemption from that law. In spite of the 1969
revision, counties did not add parsonages to their tax rolls
and the State Board of Tax Appeals continued to exempt
Page 2
parsonages in their rulings. These rulings were not challenged
until 1984 when Johnson County appealed an exemption decision
granted by the Board of Tax Appeals. The District Court, on
appeal, reversed the decision and held that, absent a specific
statutory exemption, parsonages were not tax exempt.
Since the 1984 district court ruling, a few counties
have added parsonages to their tax rolls and all counties
have been directed by the State Division of Property Valuation
to place parsonages on their 1986 tax rolls.
A bill specifically exempting parsonages must be
passed this session in order to maintain the longstanding
policy in this state. I am not proposing a new exemption.
There will be no negative financial impact on the state
since we .are currently not receiving tax revenue from parsonages.
I realize that there will be some problems in
interpreting which residences should be exempted under this
bill. Most of the bills we !pass are subject to various
interpretations. My intent in introducing this bill is to
assure the continuance of the current practice of exempting
church parsonages from taxation. This bill is necessary to
clear up the confusion and restore what has been the practice
in Kansas for many years. I urge your support of Senate
Bill 399.

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.