Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-092

1986-092Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
June 17, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 92
Timothy J. Chambers
Reno County Attorney
Law Enforcement Center
210 West First Street
Hutchinson, Kansas 67501
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees; Open Public Meetings
-- Bodies Subject Thereto; Advisory Committees
Synopsis: The Hutchinson city manager acted as an individual,
and not as a committee subordinate to the city
commission, in recommending an applicant for the
job as engineering consultant. While three city
employees chosen by the city manager to assist in
the selection process were designated as the
"Consultant Selection Committee," it is the nature
of a group, and not its designation, which
determines whether it is subject to the KOMA. In
our opinion, this "committee" is not a body
required to have open meetings. The individuals
assisted the city manager by lending their
expertise and providing information, but they did
not, as a group, make any collective decisions.
Since the "committee" did not have any decision-
making authority, the Hutchinson city manager acted
alone and thus is not a public "body" for purposes
of the open meetings laws. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-4317; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318.
Dear Mr. Chambers:
As county attorney for Reno County, you request our opinion
regarding whether a group of employees formed to aid in the
selection of a professional engineering consultant is a public
body subject to the provisions of the Kansas Open Meetings Act
(KOMA), K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. We are informed that to
get a construction project for the city of Hutchinson
underway, the Hutchinson city manager appointed three city
employees, the city engineer, assistant city engineer, and
city director of public works, to assist him in interviewing
and recommending to the city commission an engineering
consultant for the project. We are also informed that it is
the city manager's duty to interview and recommend persons for
positions and that the city manager was not directed by the
city commission to form a selection committee. You state that
five persons applied for the engineering consultant job, all
were interviewed, and one was recommended to the city
commission for the position.
The Kansas Open Meetings Act provides that it is "the policy
of this state that meetings for the conduct of governmental
affairs and the transaction of governmental business be open
to the public." K.S.A. 75-4317. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318
defines the scope of the act:
"[A]ll meetings for the conduct of the
affairs of, and the transaction of
business by, all legislative and
administrative bodies and agencies of the
state and political and taxing
subdivisions thereof, including boards,
commissions, authorities, councils,
committees, subcommittees and other
subordinate groups thereof, receiving or
expending and supported in whole or in
part by public funds shall be open to the
public . . . ."
The above language sets forth a two-part test which must be
met for a body to be included within the act's provisions:
(1) the body is a legislative or administrative agency of the
state or one of its political or taxing subdivisions, or is
subordinate to such a body; and (2) the body receives,
expends, or is supported in whole or in part by public funds,
or, in the case of subordinate groups, has a parent or
controlling body which is so supported.
The question whether groups subordinate to public bodies are
subject to the KOMA was addressed in State ex rel. Murray v.
Palmgren, 231 Kan. 524 (1982). In that case the Kansas
Supreme Court ruled that, as long as a parent body meets the
test of being supported by public funds, all subordinate
groups of that body are automatically covered by the Act,
regardless of whether they also receive or expend public
funds. See Attorney General Opinion No. 83-38. Accordingly,
in a recent opinion by this office we stated that as long as
the parent body is administrative or legislative body, all
subordinate groups of that body are subject to the KOMA even
though the subordinate group does not perform administrative
or legislative functions. Attorney General Opinion No. 86-
84. It is clear that a city commission meets both tests of
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-4318 and is a public body subject to the
open meetings laws. Therefore, if the "consultant selection
committee" is a subordinate body to the Hutchinson city
commission, the committee must conduct its meetings in
accordance with the open meetings laws.
In your opinion the KOMA does not apply because the committee
was a group of employees that provided information to the
city's governing body. Smoot and Clothier in their article,
Open Meetings Profile: The Prosecutor's View, 20 Washburn
L.M. 241, 250 (1981), stated as follows:
"[T]o be subject to the Kansas Open
Meetings Act the person or persons in
question must constitute a body or
agency. These terms, when read in
conjunction with the definition of
'meeting,' suggest persons who exercise
their authority individually are not
within the scope of this Act.
. . [T]he Act has been applied only to
groups of persons who exercise authority
as a 'body' and not to subordinate staff
personnel who gather together but do not
take collective action."
See Tacha, The Kansas Open Meetings Act: Sunshine on the
Sunflower State?, 25 Kan. L. Rev. 169, 188 (1977). The
mere fact that the committee was composed of only city
employees , however, does not mean that the group is exempt
from the act. It is the actual functions to be performed by
the group, not the make-up of the group, that determines
whether the meetings must be open to the public. See Smoot
and Clothier, supra, at 251; Cape Publications, Inc. v.
City of Palm Bay, 473 So.2d 222, 225 (Fla.App. 1985). If
the Hutchinson city employees in question take collective
action and are a subordinate body to the city commission, the
KOMA is applicable.
In Coggins v. Public Employee Relations Board, 2
Kan.App.2d 416, 423 (1979), the court found that the "term
[meeting) includes all gatherings at all stages of the
decision-making process." In accordance with the broad
definition of "meeting" and the liberal interpretation to be
given to the act, this office has opined that an advisory
board to a rural fire district and an advisory committee to a
board of education were public bodies required to have open
meetings. Attorney General Opinion Nos. 86-84, 84-81.
"As [advisory) committees participate in
the decision-making process by gathering
information, evaluating options, and
making recommendations to the governing
body, they participate in 'the conduct of
the affairs of' the governing body, and so
are covered by the scope of K.S.A. 1983
Supp. 75-4318(a)." Attorney General
Opinion No. 84-81.
The present situation can be distinguished in that the
committees in the above-referenced opinions were appointed by
the parent body while the Hutchinson city employees were not
appointed by the city commission. The means by which the
consultant selection committee was formed, however, is of no
consequence if the committee as a whole is responsible to the
city commission.
While Kansas has no applicable case law, the fact situations
of two decisions from other jurisdictions are similar to the
situation submitted for our opinion. In Krause v. Reno,
366 So.2d 1244 (Fla.App. 2979), the city manager appointed
four private citizens to assist him in selecting a police
chief. The committee of four screened all the applications,
interviewed fifteen they decided were the best qualified, and
selected four applicants from which the city manager appointed
the police chief. The court ruled that the selection
committee was subject to the provisions of the open meetings
law. The key to the court's decision was that the committee
in its process of elimination and reducing the number of
applicants to a recommended few from which the police chief
was chosen, was an integral part of the decision-making
process. Because the committee was involved in this manner,
the city manager and the persons he selected to assist him
became a body subject to the Florida Sunshine Laws.
A similar situation yielded a different result in Cape
Publications, Inc. v. City of Palm Bay, 473 So.2d 222
(Fla.App. 1985). In that case the city manager, whose duty
it was to select the new police chief, reviewed the
applications and selected three for interviews. The city
manager then asked certain people to sit in with him during
the interviews. Those persons included the city personnel
director, the city attorney, a member of the Florida
Department of Law Enforcement, and a deputy police chief. The
court found the role of the "selection committee" to be as
follows:
"The sole function of the group was to sit
in when the city manager interviewed the
applicants he had selected, to ask
questions of a technical nature such as
would help the city manager better
understand the qualifications of the
applicant, and to offer such comments to
the manager as they deemed pertinent on
the qualifications of the applicants. The
record supports the City's position that
the city manager screened all applicants,
determined who would be interviewed,
established the procedures for the
interviews, was present during each
interview, would decide which applicant to
further interview, and would ultimately
select the new police chief. The group
was delegated no authority; they did not
select or screen applicants, and they were
not authorized or delegated the
responsibility of making recommendations.
Their sole function was to assist the city
manager in acquiring information by asking
questions during the interviews and then
discussing with the city manager the
qualifications of each candidate after the
interview . . . ." 473 S.2d at 222.
The court distinguished this case from Krause v. Reno,
supra, and held that the group assisting the city manager
was not a body required to be open to the public. In
Krause a portion of the decision-making authority was
delegated to the committee; the committee screened and
interviewed the applicants and selected a few from which the
city manager made the selection. In City of Palm Bay, the
advisory group assisted in the interviews and discussed the
candidates with the city manager, but did not have any
decision-making authority.
In the situation submitted to us it was the city manager's
duty to recommend a person as an engineering consultant. The
city manager chose the head of the department in charge of the
construction project, the city engineer, and the assistant
city engineer to assist him in the selection process.
Obviously, these individuals were selected for their expertise
and the technical advice they could offer as to the
qualification of the applicants. While the group in City of
Palm Bay assisted only in interviewing, we are informed that
the "consultant selection committee" participated in all steps
of the process. The committee's participation in this case,
however, is different than in Krause where the committee
members, and not the city manager, did the screening and
interviewing and narrowed the applicants down to four. In the
present case, decision-making authority was not delegated to
the committee. The city manager sought and received
assistance and input from the group during the process, but
the committee did not make any collective decisions and the
decision as to which applicant to recommend rested with the
city manger.
In summary, the Hutchinson city manager acted as an
individual, and not as a committee subordinate to the city
commission, in recommending an applicant for the job as
engineering consultant. While three city employees chosen by
the city manager to assist in the selection process were
designated as the "Consultant Selection Committee," it is the
nature of a group, and not its designation, which determines
whether it is subject to the KOMA. Smoot and Clothier,
supra, at 251. In our opinion, this "committee" is not a
body required to have open meetings. The individuals assisted
the city manager by lending their expertise and providing
information, but they did not, as a group, make any collective
decisions. Since the "committee" did not have any decision-
making authority, the Hutchinson city manager acted alone and
thus is not a public "body" for purposes of the open meetings
laws.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.