Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-085

1986-085Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
June 3, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-85
Larry E. Wolgast, Ed.D.
Secretary of Human Resources
401 S.W. Topeka Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Labor and Industries--Minimum Wage and Maximum
Hours--Overtime and Compensation; Exceptions
Synopsis: The Kansas minimum wage and maximum hours law
(MWMHL) supplements the Fair Labor Standards Act
(FLSA), covering those occupations the FLSA
does not reach and those which the FLSA excludes
from coverage. It is therefore our opinion that
the provisions of the MWMHL apply to law
enforcement agencies with less than five employees
as these occupations have been exempted from
coverage under the FLSA. Cited herein: K.S.A.
44-1201 et seq.; 29 U.S.C. §§207, 213; 29
C.F.R. §553.4.
*
Dear Secretary Wolgast:
As the Secretary of the Department of Human Resources, you
have requested our opinion as to the applicability of the Fair
Labor Standards Act (FLSA) to law enforcement agencies.
Specifically, you inquire whether deputy sheriffs, who are
employed by a county covered by the FLSA, but who are
exempted because the sheriff's department employs five or
fewer deputies, are then subject to the provisions of K.S.A.
44--1201 et seq., the Kansas minimum wage and maximum
hours law (MWMHL).
Under the FLSA, minimum wage and maximum hours are
prescribed. 29 U.S.C. 201 et seq. The Act applies to
all employers and employees engaged in commerce or the
production of goods for commerce, and if applicable,
_supersedes any state law in the area. The basic hours rule is
that no employer shall require employees to work for more than
40 hours a week unless compensation equal to 1 1/2 times the
-normal rate is paid for those extra hours. 29 U.S.C. §207(a).
Recognizing that certain occupations were not amenable to a
standard maximum hours law, Congress adopted alternative rules
to cover those areas. For our purposes, Congress provided
that:
"No public agency shall be deemed to have
violated subsection (a) with respect to
the employment of . . . any employee in
law enforcement activities (including
security personnel in correctional
institutions) if--
"(1) in a work period of 28 consecutive
days the employee receives for tours of
duty which in the aggregate exceed the
lesser of (A) 216 hours, or (B) the
average number of hours (as determined by
the Secretary pursuant to section 6(c)(3)
of the Fair Labor Standards Amendments of
1974) [29 USCS §213 note] in tours of
duty of employees engaged in such
activities in work periods of 28
consecutive days in calendar year 1975; or
(2) in the case of such an employee to
whom a work period of at least 7 but less
than 28 days applies, in his work period
the employee receives for tours of duty
which in the aggregate exceed a number of
hours which bears the same ratio to the
number of consecutive days in his work
period as 216 hours (or if lower, the
number of hours referred to in clause (B)
of paragraph (1)) bears to 28 days,
compensation at a rate not less than one
and one-half times the regular rate
which he is employed." 29 U.S. §207(k).
This provision allows law enforcement officers to work longer
hours before requiring public agencies to pay overtime rates.
In 1974, Congress altered the effect of the above section with
29 U.S.C. §213. This relevant section reads as follows:
"The provisions of section 7 [29 USCS
§207] shall not apply with respect to --
"20) any employee of a public agency who
in any workweek is employed in fire
protection activities or any employee of a
public agency who in any workweek is
employed in law enforcement activities
(including security personnel in
correctional institutions), if the public
agency employs during the workweek less
than 5 employees in fire protection or law
enforcement activities, as the case may
be;"
"Any employee in law enforcement activities" refers to any
employee:
"(1) who is a uniformed or plainclothed
member of a body of officers and
subordinates who are empowered by statute
or local ordinance to enforce laws
designed to maintain public peace and
order and to protect both life and
property from accidental or willful
injury, and to prevent and detect crimes,
(2) who has the power of arrest, and (3)
who is presently undergoing or has
undergone or will undergo on-the-job
training and/or a course of instruction
and study which typically includes
physical training, self-defense, firearm
proficiency, criminal and civil law
principles, investigative and law
enforcement technique, community
relations, medical aid and ethics." 29
CFR §553.4.
Before 1985, the applicability of these statutes to local law
enforcement agencies was in doubt. In National League of
Cities v. Usery, 426 U.S. 833, 96 S.Ct. 2465, 49 L.Ed.2d
245 (U.S.D.C. 1976) a sharply divided Supreme Court ruled that
the overtime provisions of the FLSA are not enforceable
against the states "in areas of traditional governmental
_functions." 426 U.S. at 852. However, the Court did not
provide guidelines as to how traditional functions were to be
distinguished from nontraditional ones. Presumedly, police
-protection would be considered a traditional governmental
function exempted from FLSA coverage under the Usery
rule.
After the lower federal courts struggled to apply the
principles of Usery, the Supreme Court reversed itself
in Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan Transit Authority,
469 U.S. , 105 S.Ct. 1005, 83 L.Ed.2d 1016 (U.S. Tex.
1985). The majority held the traditional functions test was
unworkable in practice and unsound in principle and led to
inconsistent results. The court rejected the
traditional/nontraditional test and opened the doors to
federal regulation of local government employees.
Consequently, the overtime and wage provisions of the FLSA
could be applied to mass transit authorities since they were
not destructive of state sovereignty or violative of the
Constitution.
This landmark decision has left state and local governments
scrambling to bring their employment policies within the
guidelines of the FLSA. In Kansas, Garcia has resulted
in state and local governments being elevated from the Kansas
minimum wage and maximum hours law (MWMHL) K.S.A. 44-1201
et seq., to the FLSA.
Once a county is subjected to the FLSA, can a FLSA
exemption remove the county's law enforcement agency into the
provisions of the previously applied state labor act? The
answer is yes and can be supported on two grounds.
First, the MWMHL applies to employers and employees as
defined by Kansas statute.
"(d) 'Employer' means any individual,
partnership, association, corporation,
business trust or any person or group of
persons acting directly or indirectly in
the interest of an employer in relation to
an employee, but shall not include any
employer who is subject to the provisions
of the fair labor standards act of 1938
(29 U.S.C.A. §201 et seq.) and any other
acts amendatory thereof or supplemental
thereto.
"(e) 'Employee' means any individual
employed by an employer, but shall not
include: (1) Any individual employed in
agriculture; (2) any individual employed
in domestic service in or about a private
home; (3) any individual employed in a
bona fide executive, administrative or
professional capacity or in the capacity
of an outside commission paid salesman, as
such terms are defined and delimited by
regulations of the secretary; (4) any
individual employed by the United States;
(5) any individual who renders service
gratuitously for a nonprofit organization
as such terms are defined by regulations
of the secretary; (6) persons eighteen
years of age or less or sixty years of age
or older employed for any purpose on an
occasional or part-time basis; or (7) any
individual employed by a unified school
district in an executive, administrative
or professional capacity, if the
individual is engaged in such capacity
fifty percent (50%) or more of the hours
during which the individual is so
employed." K.S.A. 44-1201(d) & (e).
(Emphasis added.)
The MWMHL was passed in 1977 to supplement those gaps in
coverage of the FLSA after the Supreme Court's decision in
Usery. Kansas intended to put its employees on par with
those covered 1.y the FLSA. Thus, when Garcia elevated
some state and local employees to FLSA protection, it
removed them from MWMHL coverage. However, not all state
employees were removed, and some were removed and then
subsequently exempted. It seems likely that the original
intent of the MWMHL would apply today to place those not
subjected to the FLSA's provisions under the supplementary
Kansas act. Thus, law enforcement employees in departments
with less than five employees should be covered by the
MWMHL. We believe, in this case, that the FLSA "exempt"
law enforcement officers are not subject to the FLSA but are
covered by the Kansas act.
A second rationale for this interpretation is that the FLSA
would otherwise set up a dilemma as now stated. It includes
a county under its definition of "employer" but would exempt
the same county's law enforcement officers from being covered
_--by the FLSA's definition of "employee." 29 U.S.C. §207 and
29 U.S.C. §213(20) must be read in pari materia to
afford a proper interpretation of the FLSA. In general,
-4213 must be read as removing §207 coverage from the stated
occupations. More clearly, the occupations exempted under
§213(b) are "not covered" by the FLSA.
It is clear under certain circumstances the state may enact
supplements to federal legislation since only an actual
conflict of legislation will operate to suspend inconsistent
state laws.
"Unless Congress has clearly manifested
otherwise or a clear repugnance exists
between federal and state legislation, a
state will not be barred, as a consequence
of federal legislation, from legislating
within a particular area.
"The test of whether both federal and
state regulations may operate, or the
state regulation must give way, is whether
both regulations can be enforced without
impairing the federal superintendence of
the field, not whether they are aimed at
similar or different objectives." 16
Am.Jur.2d Constitutional Law §292 (1985).
The MWMHL is not inconsistent with federal regulations. It
was enacted to supplement existing federal law and involves no
actual conflict, with the FLSA. As support for this
argument, Kansas recognized federal preeminence in the field
by specifically excluding MWMHL application from areas
covered by the FLSA. As a corollary, an occupation not
covered by the FLSA is implicitly covered by the MWMHL.
Thus, the law enforcement agencies with less than 5 officers
exempted by 29 U.S.C. 5213(b)(20) are covered by the
supplementary Kansas MWMHL.
In conclusion, the Kansas minimum wage and maximum hours law
supplements the Fair Labor Standards Act, covering those
occupations the FLSA does not reach and those which the
FLSA excludes from coverage. It is therefore our opinion
that the provisions of the MWMHL apply to law enforcement
agencies with less than five employees as these occupations
have been exempted from coverage under the FLSA.
Very truly yours
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.