Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-028

1986-028Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 28, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 28
Curtis E. Campbell
Gray County Attorney
222 South Main
Cimarron, Kansas 67835
Re: Taxation -- Listing Property for Taxation --
Listing of Cattle Held in Feedlots; Payment of
Collection Fee
Synopsis: A personal property tax is imposed by K.S.A.
79-307b upon cattle which are held in feedlots.
The statute permits the operator of the feedlot
to collect the tax, which is calculated on a daily
basis for each head of livestock present in the
lot, and remit the same to the county along with
the monthly report which is required by the same
statute. Such taxes may not be released,
discharged, remitted or commuted by the board of
county commissioners or any other county officer.
Accordingly, a resolution by a county commission
which rebates part or all of the tax to the owner
of the cattle either directly or indirectly through
a collection fee to the feedlot operator is
invalid. However, a collection fee which is not
based on the amount of tax collected and which is
reasonable in size is permissible. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 79-307b; 79-1703.
Dear Mr. Campbell:
As Gray County Attorney, you have requested our opinion
regarding the legality of a proposed resolution by the Gray
County board of commissioners. The resolution allows payment
of a collection fee to feedlot operators based on the
amounts of tax they "collect." It is our opinion that a
collection fee which is in fact a rebate is unlawful, as it is
in effect a release, discharge, remission or commutation of a
portion of the taxes assessed. On the other hand, a fee which
is not linked to the amount of the tax, but instead reflects
compensation for services performed, would be permissible.
K.S.A. 79-307b imposes a duty on feedlot operators to report
the number of cattle in the feedlot on a monthly basis to
the county appraiser, listing the cattle owner's name and
address, and the number, sex and approximate weight of the
cattle. The filing of the report is required for compliance
with the statutes regarding listing of property for taxation.
In addition to filing the report, the feedlot operator may
include with the report the tax due on the cattle, but there
is no obligation for him to do so. The statute is silent as
to payment of a collection fee to the operator.
Gray County Board of Commissioners Resolution No. 16-85
authorizes payment of four-tenths of one cent per head per
day as a collection fee, out of a total due per day of $1.15
per head. This amount, which represents only three-tenths
of one percent of the tax due, is de minimis and can be
viewed as reasonably related as compensation for the
collection of the tax.
However, it has been suggested that a much higher fee (i.e.
25 cents per day) be paid by the county to each feedlot.
The impetus for such a change is apparently a recent increase
in the amount of tax due per head from 75 cents to $1.15 each
day, with the "fee" intended to cushion the increase to the
owner of the cattle, who would pay 90 cents, with the extra 25
cents returned by the county to the feedlot owner. In this
respect, such a resolution would be repugnant to K.S.A. 79-
1703, which states in part:
"(a) Except as . . . otherwise provided by
law, no board of county commissioners or any
officer of any county shall have power to
release, discharge, remit or commute any
portion of the taxes assessed or levied
against any person or property within their
respective jurisdictions for any reason
whatever . . . ."
Further, it has long been the law in this state that revenues
produced from taxation must be used for a public, and not
merely a private benefit. Leavenworth County Comm's v.
Miller, 7 Kan. 479, 518 (1871), State ex rel. Griffith v.
Davis, 113 Kan. 4, 8 (1923). A typical example of such a
"private purpose" is found in the case of In re Page, 60
Kan. 842 (1899), where 40% of the revenue generated by a tax
was to be used for the benefit of paid or volunteer fire
departments. It was the inclusion of these latter, private
individuals which the court found rendered the statute
defective, stating that:
"The taxing power of the state, however,
can hardly be exercised in order to bestow
public money on a department made up of
volunteers who are not employed by the
municipality, and for whose services no
expense is assumed or incurred by it.
However commendable the object of such an
organization may be, it is clear that
public money can only be used to discharge
a public liability. As will be observed,
the money when collected is to be applied
to the benefit of such a department and
not for the benefit of the municipality,
but taxes cannot be imposed nor public
money expended for the benefit of private
individuals or enterprises, nor'can it be
given away for such purposes." 60 Kan.
at 848. (Emphasis added.)
Therefore, we perceive both statutory barriers and strong
policy reasons which preclude the payment of a collection fee
which is intended to be a rebate of a portion of the taxes
collected.
In conclusion, a personal property tax is imposed by K.S.A.
79-307b upon cattle which are held in feedlots. The statute
permits the operator of the feedlot to collect the tax,
which is calculated on a daily basis for each head of
livestock present in the lot, and remit the same to the county
along with the monthly report which is required by the same
statute. Such taxes may not be released, discharged, remitted
or commuted by the board of county commissioners or any other
county officer. Accordingly, a resolution by a county
commission which rebates part or all of the tax to the owner
of the cattle either directly or indirectly through a
collection fee to the feedlot operator is invalid. However,
a collection fee which is not based on the amount of tax
collected and which is reasonable in size is permissible.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
"Jeffrey S. Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.