Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-011

1986-011Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL	
February 3, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-11
Richard E. LaMunyon
Chief of Police
City Hall, 4th Floor
455 North Main -
Wichita, Kansas 67202
Re: Public Health -- Controlled Substances --
Forfeitures
Synopsis: No conflict exists between Kansas and
federal statutes regarding the
distribution of money obtained from
forfeiture of property in cases involving
controlled substances. The state
forfeiture statute is not applicable to
cases brought in federal court; rather, the
federal provisions apply. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 65-4135, 21 U.S.C. §881.
Dear Chief LaMunyon:
You have proceeds from sale ofinion concerning the disposition
of proceedstatutes . Specificallyroperty seized under the
forfeiture statutesUnitedly, you ask whether federal
law and the Unforfeiture States Attorney General's guidelines
regarding fo inconsistent with the laws of
Kansas.
§III(d)(3)(eThe pertinent section of the federal regulations is
SIII(d)(3)(e) of the United States Attorney General's
Guidelines on Seized and Forfeited Property (authorized by
21 U.S.C. §881), which states:
"(e) Property will be transferred only
in cases where the tangible property or
cash will be credited to the budget of
the state or local agency that directly
participated in the seizure or
forfeiture, resulting in an increase of
law enforcement resources for that
specific state or local agency."
(Emphasis added.)
Forfeiture of property seized for violations of Kansas
controlled substances laws is authorized by K.S.A. 65-
4135(e). That statute provides in part:
"(e) When property is forfeited under
this act the law enforcement agency
having custody of it may: (1) Retain it
for official use;
"(2) sell that which is not required to
be destroyed by law and which is not
harmful to the public;
"(3) transfer it for medical or
scientific use to any state agency in
accordance with the rules and regulations
of the board;
"(4) require the sheriff of the county in
which the property is located to take
custody of the property and remove it to
an appropriate location for disposition
in accordance with law; or
"(5) forward it to the bureau for
disposition.
"The proceeds from the sale under
paragraph (2) and any moneys forfeited
under this section shall be used to pay
all proper expenses of the proceedings
for forfeiture and sale including
expenses of seizure, maintenance of
custody, advertising and court costs.
The proceeds from such sale and any
moneys forfeited under this section
remaining after payment of such expenses
shall be transferred to the general fund
of the unit of government having custody
of the forfeited property or money."
(Emphasis added.)
In our opinion, it is evident that forfeitures which occur
in those cases which are prosecuted by the federal
government will be governed by the federal guidelines.
Only in cases prosecuted by the state will the state
forfeiture statute be utilized.
The jurisdiction to prosecute controlled substance charges,
and thus invoke the forfeiture statutes, is concurrent
between the federal and state governments. When
jurisdiction is concurrent, the principle of priority
governs. This principle states that, where two courts have
jurisdiction, the first one to exercise that jurisdiction
holds it to the exclusion of the other. The United States
Supreme Court recognized this principle in Taylor v.
Taintor, 16 Wall 366, 21 L.Ed. 287, 290 (1873).
"Where a state court and a court of the
United States may each take jurisdiction,
the tribunal which first gets it holds it
to the exclusion of the other, until its
duty is fully performed and the
jurisdiction invoked is exhausted; and
this rule applies alike in both civil and
criminal cases. It is indeed a principle
of universal jurisprudence that where
jurisdiction has attached to person or
thing, it is (unless there is some
provision to the contrary) exclusive in
effect until it has wrought its
function." (Citations omitted.)
The question then becomes whether the federal and state
laws are in such conflict that the state law is rendered
invalid by the supremacy clause. In the case of Jones v .
Rath Packing Co., 430 U.S. 519, 51 L.Ed.2d 604, 614
(1977), the Supreme Court held:
"The criterion for determining whether
state and federal laws are so inconsistent
that the state law must give way is firmly
established in our decisions. Our task is
'to determine whether, under the
circumstances of this particular case,
[the State's] law stands as an obstacle to
the accomplishment and execution of the
full purposes and objectives of Congress."
We do not believe the state law is an obstacle to the
purposes of the federal act. Both the state forfeiture
statute and the federal regulations are penal in nature.
They are aimed at punishing criminals by taking away
property used during the violation. Nothing in the Kansas
law appears to be in conflict with the "full purposes and
objectives of Congress." Therefore, it is our opinion that
the Kansas law is not inconsistent with the federal
guideline's purpose of punishing individuals who break drug
laws by seizing the property used in committing the crime.
In our opinion, funds which result from a sale under the
federal forfeiture regulation may be treated as any other
federal aid. As previously noted, federal regulations
dictate that money from items seized under 21 U.S.C. §881
must go directly to the budget of the law enforcement
agency assisting in the seizure. Nothing in state law
would prevent that from happening, in that K.S.A. 65-
4135(e) concerns property forfeited under that act.
Accordingly, as federal forfeitures are not in any way
connected with the state forfeiture statute, proceeds from
such forfeitures do not have to be disposed of in the same
way as state proceeds.
In conclusion, no conflict exists between the federal
regulation and the state statute on disposition of proceeds
from forfeitures. If charges are filed in federal court
pursuant to federal law, the federal regulation would
control, with the money going directly to the local law
enforcement agency. If the charge is filed in state court
pursuant to state law, then the Kansas forfeiture statute
would control.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:may

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.