Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-001

1986-001Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 3, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86-1
JohnDekker
City Attorney
City Hall - Thirteenth Floor
455 North Main Street
Wichita, Kansas 67202
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Exceptions to Disclosure
Crimes and Punishments -- Criminal Code; Crimes
Affecting Public Trusts -- Unlawful Use of Names
Derived from Public Records
Synopsis: The Kansas Open Records Act, K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
45-215 et seq., does not require that a city
employee disclose names and addresses derived from
city records to a person who the employee knows
intends to use such names and addresses for a
commercial purpose. Such disclosure is
specifically prohibited by K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
21-3914. Any person who receives a list of such
names and addresses for the purpose of selling or
offering to sell any property or service to listed
persons may be found guilty of a misdemeanor.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 21-3914; 45-221.
Dear Mr. Dekker:
As City Attorney for the City of Wichita, Kansas, you request
our opinion concerning the Kansas Open Records Act, K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 45-215 et seq. (KORA), and K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
2 1-3914. You first inquire about the legality of the city's
practice of disclosing to local newspapers of general
circulation the names and addresses of persons who have hooked
up to the city water department, while refusing to provide
that same information to a "newsletter service" which would
convey those names to its subscribers as sales prospects.
The KORA establishes as a general rule in Kansas that
records maintained by public agencies in this state are to be
open for public inspection and, if desired, copying. K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 45-221 contains exceptions to this general
"openness" policy by providing that a public agency shall not
be required to disclose records which fall into one of
thirty-five enumerated categories. The statute does not
prohibit disclosure of records which fall within an exception,
but leaves the decision to disclose to the agency's discretion.
One provision of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 45-221(a) would serve as a
basis for the exercise of such discretion by the City of
Wichita. It states that a public agency shall not be required
to disclose the following:
"Records of a utility or other public
service pertaining to individually
identifiable residential customers of the
utility of service, except that
information concerning billings for
specific individual customers named by the
requester shall be subject to disclosure
as provided by this act."
Under the KORA, the City of Wichita may disclose the names
and addresses of persons hooking up to the city water
department unless that disclosure is specifically prohibited
or restricted by state statute or other law. K.S.A. 1984
Supp. 45-221(a)(1). Conversely, the City of Wichita may
decline to disclose those names and addresses unless
disclosure of that information is required by a law other
than the KORA. K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 45-221(a).
Our research has revealed no law other than the KORA which
would compel the disclosure of records maintained by the
city's water department. Rather, Kansas statutes contain a
specific prohibition against the disclosure of names and
addresses derived from public records under certain
circumstances. With exceptions not relevant to this
discussion, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 21-3914 provides:
"No person shall knowingly sell, give
or receive, for the purpose of selling
or offering for sale any property or
service to persons listed therein, any
list of names and addresses contained in
or derived from public records . . . ."
(Emphasis added.)
Violation of this statute is a class C misdemeanor [K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 21-3914(b)], and this office has previously stated
that it prohibits a public body from knowingly providing a
list derived from public records to a person who intends to
use it for the purpose of ,selling or offering to sell to the
listed persons any property or services. See Atty. Gen.
Opin. Nos. 84-16 and 85-34.
In our opinion, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 21-3914 prohibits the City
of Wichita from providing a list of names and addresses
derived from the city water department's hook-up records to
a person whom the city knows intends to use the list for any
commercial purpose. The "newsletter service," although it
does not directly solicit customers from that list, compiles
and sells the names and addresses to its subscribers so those
subscribers may solicit customers from that list. In light of
the language in K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 45-220(c)(2)(B), we believe
even such an "indirect" commercial purpose is within the type
of activity the statute was intended to prohibit.
Accordingly, the City may decline to provide the list in
question to the "newsletter service" but may, in its
discretion, provide the same list to local newspapers of
general circulation which routinely include the list as a
matter of public interest and in no way derive any financial
benefit from that inclusion.
Your second question concerns the legality of the City's
practice of allowing any person to come into the Central
Inspection Division (C.I.D.) office of the City's Department
of Housing and Economic Development to view completed
,applications for building permits. You advise that C.I.D.
personnel make no attempt to limit access to the list or to
inquire about the purpose for which the information is
sought. You are aware that some persons copying names and
addresses from the list use the list for commercial purposes.
In our judgment, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 21-3914(a) is violated when
a city employee gives a list of names and addresses contained
in or derived from public records of building permits to a
person whom the employee knows intends to use that list for
any commercial purpose. The statute is not violated where an
employee gives the list to a person without knowing the
purpose for which the list is being sought. In that instance,
the primary impact of the statute falls upon the person
receiving the list. Where the person receiving the list
obtains it for any commercial purpose, he or she may be found
guilty of a violation of criminal law. In order to make the
impact of the law clear to such recipients, the city may wish
to employ a certification form of the type set forth at K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 45-220(c). A requester's refusal to provide the
certification provides a basis for the city to refuse to
release the information, even in the absence of any specific
knowledge about the requester's purpose.
Very truly yours,
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Kathryn Gardner
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:KG:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.