Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-161

1985-161Kanag

Testo completo

November 21, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 161
Van Smith
Smith Law Office
Hilton Plaza
1135 College Drive, Suite #L2
Garden City, Kansas 67846
Re: Drainage and Levies -- Watershed Districts --
Meetings of Directors
State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Public Officers and Employees -- Meetings Open to
Public
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 24-1212, a watershed district
board is required to have regular meetings once
each quarter during the year. While this statute
establishes minimum standards which must be met by
the board, more frequent regular meetings may be
held in that the statute is directory, rather than
mandatory, on this point. K.S.A. 24-1212 also
requires that all meetings of the board be open,
and that no executive sessions be held. In that
this language conflicts with the more recent and
comprehensive language of the Open Meetings Act,
K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq., it has been repealed by
implication, as was concluded in Attorney General
Opinion No. 82-130. Cited herein: K.S.A. 24-1212;
75-4319.
Dear Mr. Smith:
As attorney for Pawnee Joint Watershed District No. 81, you
request our opinion on two questions involving the operation
of K.S.A. 24-1212. Specifically, you inquire whether that
statute requires the district's board of directors to have
regular meetings on only a quarterly basis, or whether regular
meetings may be held monthly. Second, you ask if language in
the statute which prohibits executive sessions can be
reconciled with language in the Open Meetings Act (at K.S.A.
75-4319) which permits such closed discussions in certain
circumstances.
The statute in question, K.S.A. 24-1212, states as follows:
"Regular meeting of the board of
directors shall be held quarterly at the
office of the corporation on such day as
is selected by the board of directors.
Notice of such meeting shall be mailed to
each director at least five (5) days prior
to the date thereof, and special meetings
may be held at any time upon waiver of
notice of such meeting by all directors or
may be called by the president or any two
directors at any time: Provided, That
notice in writing, signed by the persons
calling any special meeting, shall be
mailed to each director at least two (2)
days prior to the time fixed for such
special meeting. A majority of the
directors shall constitute a quorum for
the transaction of business and in the
absence of any of the duly elected
officers of the district a quorum at any
meeting may select a director to act as
such officer pro tem. Each meeting of
the board, whether regular or special,
shall be open to the public and the board
shall at no time go into executive
session." (Emphasis added.)
We will first address your question concerning the holding of
meetings. You inform us that the board wishes to hold regular
meetings on a monthly basis, rather than merely once every
three months. While authority exists for the calling and
holding of special meetings, the monthly meetings are in fact
not special in the sense of being unscheduled or in response
to an emergency or unforeseen situation. Additionally, the
holding of special meetings imposes additional notice
requirements that regular meetings do not have.
At the outset, it would be noted that the mere use of the word
"shall" in the statute ("Regular meeting[s] of the board of
directors shall be held quarterly . . .") is not dispositive
of the question. Numerous Kansas decisions have construed
statutes containing "shall" as being directory, rather than
mandatory, when the context requires it. City of Kansas City
v. Wyandotte County Commissioners, 213 Kan. 777 (1974),
Spalding v. Price, 210 Kan. 337 (1972), Paul v. City of
Manhattan, 212 Kan. 381 (1973). In Paul, the court stated:
"In determining whether a legislative
provision is mandatory or directory, it is
a general rule that where strict
compliance with the provision is essential
to the preservation of the rights of
parties affected and to the validity of
the proceeding, the provision is
mandatory, but where the provision fixes a
mode of proceeding and a time within which
an official act is to be done, and is
intended to secure order, system and
dispatch of the public business, the
provision is directory." Syl. §1.
"Factors which would indicate that a
statute or ordinance is mandatory are:
(1) the presence of negative words
requiring that an act shall be done in no
other manner or at no other time than that
designated, or (2) a provision for a
penalty or other consequence of
noncompliance." Syl. §2. (Emphasis
added.)
In the present situation, there exist no "negative words"
which would preclude the use of a lesser time span before
holding regular meetings of the district. In our opinion, if
the statute required weekly meetings, a different result would
be presented. However, the holding of monthly meetings does
comply with the standard established by the legislature, for
meetings will in fact be held once every quarter, the minimum
prescribed.
Your second question has previously been answered by an
opinion of this office. Attorney General Opinion No. 82-130
(copy enclosed) was issued in response to an inquiry from Wet
Walnut Creek Joint Watershed District No. 58, and concerned
the ability of a board to conduct an executive session for the
purpose of discussing certain matters with their counsel. We
concluded that the prohibition in K.S.A. 24-1212 against
closed sessions was repealed by implication, and stated:
"While the law does not favor the repeal
of a statute in this manner, a former
stature can be so eliminated when a latter
enactment is so repugnant to it that both
cannot be given force and effect. Matter
of Suesz' Estate, 228 Kan. 275 (1980).
Furthermore, it is also a
well-recognized rule of statutory
construction that older statutes must be
read in light of later legislative
enactments. Thomas v. Board of Trustees
of Salem Township, 224 Kan. 539 (1978).
While an earlier, more specific statute is
not automatically repealed by implication
upon the enactment of a later, more
general stature dealing with the same
subject [Howard v. Hulbert, 63 Kan.
793 (1901)], when it appears that the
general act was intended to be of
universal application or where the two
acts are irreconcilable with each other,
the more general will prevail.
"In this particular situation, there
appears to be no public policy which is
served by treating the meetings of a
watershed district in a different fashion
than the meetings of any other unit of
government covered by the Open Meetings
Act. Indeed, it would be contrary to
public policy for a watershed district
board to hold all consultations with its
attorney concerning a pending lawsuit in
public session, as this would give
opposing parties a decided advantage.
Where, as here, the subject matter of the
suit concerns the expenditure of district
funds in a condemnation proceeding, the
damage to the district could well be
measured in dollars if the higher price
were asked or a larger award given. In
short, to read K.S.A. 24-1212 without
reference to the exceptions contained in
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319(b) would
conflict with another publicly stated
policy (i.e., private communications
with one's attorney are privileged to the
extent necessary for him or her to possess
the information necessary to do the job
professionally), and ignores established
rules of statutory construction."
In conclusion, pursuant to K.S.A. 24-1212, a watershed
district board is required to have regular meetings once each
quarter during the year. While this statute establishes
minimum standards which must be met by the board, more
frequent regular meetings may be held in that the statute is
directory, rather than mandatory, on this point. K.S.A.
24-1212 also requires that all meetings of the board be open,
and that no executive sessions be held. In that this language
conflicts with the more recent and comprehensive language of
the Open Meetings Act, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq., it has been
repealed by implication, as was concluded in Attorney General
Opinion No. 82-130.
Very truly yours,,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.