Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-153

1985-153Kanag

Testo completo

November 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85-153
The Honorable Jessie M. Branson
Representative, Forty-Fourth District
800 Broadview Drive
Lawrence, Kansas 66044-2423
The Honorable Betty Jo Charlton
Representative, Forty-Sixth District
1624 Indiana Street
Lawrence, Kansas 66044
The Honorable Henry Helgerson
Representative, Eighty-Sixth District
4009 Hammond Drive
Wichita, Kansas 67218
Re: Corporations -- Loans or Investments -- Standards
for Investment; Prudent Person Rule
Personal and Real Property -- Uniform Management of
Institutional Funds -- Standard of Conduct;
Business Care Rule
Synopsis: Kansas law contains two different standards, the
"prudent person" rule and the "business care" rule,
which are relevant to any question concerning the
divestment by a trust fund of assets linked to
investments in the Republic of South Africa. The
identity of the holder of the assets determines the
applicable standard. In administering the
investments which are subject to their control,
cities and counties are subject to the "prudent
person" rule of K.S.A. 17-5004, which requires them
to exercise the same care in the management of
trust funds that prudent persons would use in
managing their own affairs. Universities and
charitable corporations such as endowment funds are
subject to the "business care" rule found at K.S.A.
58-3606, which requires the exercise of ordinary
business care and prudence, based on the facts
available at the time. While neither standard
permits divestment decisions to be made on moral
grounds alone, the "prudent person" standard does
permit divestment upon a finding by the trustees
that economic conditions in South Africa make
continued investment in a particular asset less
than prudent. Under the "business care" standard,
notice may be taken of both the political and
economic situations existing in the country as they
affect the security of the investment. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 17-5004; 58-3606; 74-4921; L. 1983,
ch. 374; Kan. Const., Art. 2, §20.
Dear Representatives Branson, Charlton and Helgerson:
As members of the Kansas House of Representatives, you have
each submitted requests to this office asking for our opinion
concerning the "prudent person rule" as it applies to
universities, endowment funds, cities and counties.
Specifically, you ask whether the "prudent person rule"
precludes universities, endowment funds, cities and counties
from divesting of stocks and other interests in corporations
which do business in South Africa. As your separate inquiries
are similar in nature, we address your questions in one
opinion.
The central issue presented by each of your requests concerns
whether governmental entities or charitable corporations may
legally "divest" themselves of stocks and other assets in
corporations with financial ties to the Republic of South
Africa. As noted in Attorney General Opinion No. 83-135, that
country
"currently is undergoing substantial
public criticism in the United States for
its policy of apartheid. From an
Afrikaner word meaning 'separateness,'
its historical antecedents go back to the
17th century, when the area was first
settled by colonists from the
Netherlands. These settlers, or Boers,
as they called themselves, based their
domination of the native Hottentots and
the Bantu to the north on principles
they believed to be found in the Bible.
Although restrained by the British during
the period from 1815 to 1908, the Boers
gradually extended their beliefs into
government policy from that time on, with
the definitive break coming in 1948 with
the Nationalist Party's electoral victory
over the more moderate and pro-British
elements. Since that time, apartheid has
been criticized by the nations and peoples
of the world."
Our research has not disclosed any Kansas statutes or cases
which specifically address divestiture of investments in
corporations doing business in the Republic of South Africa.
1983 House Resolution No. 6056 (L. 1983, ch. 374) declares it
to be the policy of the Kansas House of Representatives that
such investment practices are against public policy. However,
such a resolution does not have the force and effect of law.
See Kansas Constitution, Article 2, Section 20.
The standard of care to be exercised by the trustees of a
university, an endowment fund, or a city or county pension
fund is generally derived from the law of trusts. The
standard is commonly referred to as the "prudent person" rule
and generally requires trustees to exercise the same care in
the management of trust funds that prudent persons of
intelligence and discretion would use in managing their own
affairs. (See K.S.A. 17-5004, cited below.) Until recently,
universities have relied on such traditional trust law to
determine the fiduciary duties of their trustees, because
little statutory or case law existed regarding the trustees or
the governing boards of charitable or non-profit
corporations. However, the emerging standard applicable to
universities and endowment funds is derived from corporate,ratherthantrust,law.Thatstandard,containedinK.S.A.
58-3606, directs trustees to make their investment decisions
subject to "ordinary business care and prudence under the
facts and circumstances prevailing at the time of action or
decision." While similar, these standards are not identical.
Accordingly, the standard of care for universities and
endowment associations will be discussed under the traditional
"prudent person" standard (which is applicable to the state
and its political subdivisions), and also under the emerging
"business care" standard.
The "prudent person" rule is codified at K.S.A. 17-5004 and
states in part as follows:
"In acquiring, investing, reinvesting,
exchanging, retaining, selling and
managing property for the benefit of
another, a fiduciary shall exercise the
judgment and care under the circumstances
then prevailing, which men of prudence,
discretion and intelligence exercise in
the management of their own affairs, not
in regard to speculation but in regard to
the permanent disposition of their funds,
considering the probable income as well
as the probable safety of their capital.
Within the limitations of the foregoing
standard, a fiduciary is authorized to
acquire and retain every kind of
property, real, personal or mixed, and
every kind of investment, specifically but
not by way of limitation, bonds,
debentures and other corporate
obligations, and stocks, preferred or
common, and securities of any open-end or
closed-end management type investment
company or investment trust registered
under the federal investment company act
of 1940, as from time to time amended,
which men of prudence, discretion and
intelligence acquire or retain for their
own account, and within the limitations
of the foregoing standard, a fiduciary may
retain property properly acquired, without
limitation as to time and without regard
to its suitability for original
purchase." (Emphasis added.)
"Prudent person" is defined in K.S.A. 58-1201(c) as follows:
"'prudent person' means a trustee whose
exercise of trust powers is reasonable and
equitable in view of the interests of
income or principal beneficiaries, or
both, and in view of the manner in which
persons of prudence, discretion and
intelligence would act in the management
of their own affairs." (Emphasis added.)
The "prudent person" rule establishes a high fiduciary
standard of care in managing trust assets. In re Estate of
Rothko, 43 N.Y.2d 305, 372 N.E.2d 291 (1977); In re Bank
of New York, 35 N.Y.2d 512, 323 N.E.2d 700 (1974). Hence,
traditional notions of prudent investment would not enable
trustees to make a decision to divest based solely on moral
beliefs without violating their fiduciary responsibilities.
However, K.S.A. 17-5004 allows a trustee to consider the
"probable income" of the investment as well as the "probable
safety" of the capital. Pursuant to such language, in our
opinion a trustee could legitimately consider the present
economic climate of South Africa in making a divestment
decision, i.e., investments which are in danger of being
expropriated or destroyed may be imprudent. A decision by
trustees to divest could be based on the theory that any
immediate loss from selling stock of corporations doing
business in the Republic of South Africa would be less than
the potential loss if the growing political crisis leads to
nationalization or even destruction of the corporation's
property, with a decline in the value of the particular
stock. Therefore, the prevailing fiduciary standard of care
does not prohibit trustees from divesting on the grounds of
potential economic loss if the trustees believe divestiture
is in the best interests of all trust beneficiaries, both
present and future.
A case which illustrates the merging of economic factors with
political ones is Chase National Bank of New York City v.
Runicke, 10 N.Y.S.2d 420 (1938). There, a trustee was
requested by the settlor of a trust to loan the settler 80% of
the corpus, as provided for in the trust instrument.
Repayment was to be made by the settlor (a resident of
Germany) subject to existing laws of the Third Reich which
limited such repayment of interest to a fraction of what was
actually owed. The court found that the trustee properly
refused to make a loan under such conditions, where there was
little hope of repayment.
In noting that this economic fact was related to prevailing
political conditions in Germany, the court found as follows:
"Judicial notice of the condition now
existing under the presently controlled
government of Germany, is inescapable.
Some of its citizens are deprived of their
homes, of the right of free speech, of
their liberties, or of any privileges
usually accorded to citizens and
inhabitants of a civilized country, and
this without even a pretext of law, order,
or of justice. Rigid, abnormal and cruel
restrictions affecting their human and
property rights are enacted and enforced
without reason and without warning. Power
and Force has supplanted Right and
Justice. All of it is revolting to the
mind and sickening to the heart.
"Phrases, impregnated with a wealth of
meaning in our Courts, such as 'Justice
under the Law', 'Due regard for human
rights or property rights', 'Due process
of Law' and many others, too numerous to
mention, are preciously regarded, and
safeguarded by us. These are foreign
terms in the Third Reich, and for the
present, there seems to be neither the
ability nor the willingness to understand
them." 10 N.Y.S.2d at 430.
As earlier noted, the standard of care governing the trustees
of a university or an endowment fund was initially derived
from corporation law and the law of trusts, as is K.S.A.
17-5004. However, the Uniform Management of Institutional
funds Act (UMIFA), codified in Kansas at K.S.A. 58-3601 et
seq., was adopted in 1973 as an attempt to respond to the
needs of trustees of universities and charitable corporations
in carrying out their responsibilities. In part, the
"business care" standard was adopted in order to alleviate the
debilitating effect that fear of liability may have upon
members of a governing board. K.S.A. 58-3606 describes the
standard of conduct required of trustees when making
investment decisions:
"In the administration of the powers to
appropriate appreciation, to make and
retain investments, and to delegate
investment management of institutional
funds, members of a governing board shall
exercise ordinary business care and
prudence under the facts and circumstances
prevailing at the time of the action or
decision, and in so doing they shall
consider long and short term needs of the
institution in carrying out its
educational, religious, charitable, or
other eleemosynary purposes, its present
and anticipated financial requirements,
expected total return on its investments,
price level trends, and general economic
conditions." (Emphasis added.)
A number of commentators have observed that the "business
care" standard is somewhat more flexible than is the "prudent
person" standard, for the "business care" standard requires
proof of bad faith or gross or willful neglect before personal
liability for an investment (or divestment) decision can be
imposed on trustees or directors. Comment, Divestiture
Resolutions: University Director Liability Under the Emerging
Corporate Standard, 15 U.S.F.L.Rev. 261 (1981); Comment,
University Investments in South Africa, 11 Journal of Law
and Politics 543 (1979). See also Stern v. Lucy Webb Hayes
National Training School, 381 F.Supp. 1003 (Dist. of Col.
1974), which is in accord with the UMIFA, of which K.S.A.
58-3606 is a part.
Further, the more liberal investment discretion allowed
charitable corporations under the "business care" standard
enables trust administrators to exercise greater discretion in
their investment decisions than is enforced by the traditional
trust standards of the "prudent person" rule. As a result, if
held to the "business care" standard, directors or trustees
may legitimately consider both the political and the economic
climate of the Republic of South Africa, especially if the
present unrest there constitutes a change in circumstances
threatening to defeat or substantially impair the
accomplishment of the trust purpose. If such a showing could
be made, under UMIFA the trustees of a university or the
directors of an endowment association could defend themselves
from a legal challenge arising out of their decision to
divest, even if some economic loss resulted from the decision.
In conclusion, Kansas law contains two different standards,
the "prudent person" rule and the "business care" rule, which
are relevant to any question concerning the divestment by a
trust fund of assets linked to investments in the Republic of
South Africa. The identity of the holder of the assets
determines the applicable standard. In administering the
investments which are subject to their control, cities and
counties are subject to the "prudent person" rule of K.S.A.
17-5004, which requires them to exercise the same care in the
management of trust funds that prudent persons would use in
managing their own affairs. Universities and charitable
corporations such as endowment funds are subject to the
"business care" rule found at K.S.A. 58-3606, which requires
the exercise of ordinary business care and prudence, based on
the facts available at the time. While neither standard
permits divestment decisions to be made on moral grounds
alone, the "prudent person" standard does permit divestment
upon a finding by the trustees that economic conditions in
South Africa make continued investment in a particular asset
less than prudent. Under the "business care" standard, notice
may be taken of both the political and economic situations
existing in the country as they affect the security of the
investment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:BGH:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.