Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-041

1985-041Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
April 26, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 41
The Honorable Marvin A. Harder
Secretary of Administration
Room 263-E, State Capitol Building
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County Counselor --
Duties; Social Security Benefits
Synopsis: A county counselor appointed by a board of county
commissioners and whose responsibilities require some
exercise of the soverign authority of the county is a
county officer. As such an officer, the county
counselor is a county "employee" as defined in K.S.A.
40-2302(c), and the remuneration he receives for
holding the office is "wages" as defined in K.S.A.
40-2302(a). Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101; K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 19-101a; 19-247; K.S.A. 40-2301; 40-2302;
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 40-2305; K.S.A. 79-2101; 79-3419;
79-34,102.
*
Dear Secretary Harder:
You have requested our opinion on various questions concerning
the Reno County counselor. You inform us that the Reno County
Commissioners have entered into an agreement with a local law
firm for the purpose of obtaining the services of a member of
the firm as Reno County counselor.
The agreement recites that the county commissioners have
"established a position of County Counselor" and that they wish
to obtain the services of Joseph P. O'Sullivan "to serve as
County Counselor for Reno County and to perform the duties
specified . . . ." The agreement then provides:
"1. That Joseph P. O'Sullivan will serve as
County Counselor for Reno County, and in this
capacity will attend meetings of the County
Commission when requested; give legal advice
to said commissioners and other county
officials; represent the county in civil suits
and all other matters of civil law; prepare or
review for legality county resolutions,
contracts, agreements, and other written
documents requiring legal review; and
generally perform duties for Reno County as
set out in K.S.A. 19-247."
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-247, which the agreement incorporates,
establishes the duties of a county counselor as follows:
"The county counselor shall: (a) When
requested by the board of county commissioners
or when necessary, attend the meetings of such
board:
"(b) give advice upon all legal questions that
arise and assist the board on all legal
matters-referred to the county counselor;
"(c) commence, prosecute or defend, as the case
requires, all civil suits or actions in which
the county is interested and represent the
county generally in matters of civil law;
"(d) draw all contracts and other papers
required by the board of county commissioners
and furnish to the board, when requested by
it, opinions in writing upon legal matters
pending before the board;
"(e) if applicable, perform the duties provided
by K.S.A. 19-716 and amendments thereto; and
"(f) perform all the duties in civil matters
that have previously been required by law of
the county attorney of the county. (Emphasis
added.)
Compensation for the services of county counselor is provided in
the form of a monthly retainer with provisions for prorating the
fee if fewer than 18 hours of legal services are provided in a
month. In addition, services requiring more than 18 hours per
calendar month are to be paid at an hourly rate on a case by case
basis. The agreement also provides that the county counselor
shall not be considered an employee of Reno County nor be
entitled to any rights or privileges associated with county
employment "including insurance or retirement benefits and
compensation or indemnity for injury or sickness arising out of
the performance of legal services for the county."
You raise several questions concerning this arrangement, the most
important of which is whether the Reno County counselor is a
county officer covered by the agreement between the county and
your office pursuant to K.S.A. 40-2301 et seq. This agreement
provides coverage for county employees under the Old Age and
Survivors Insurance program contained in the social security act.
You also ask whether the county's agreement with Mr. O'Sullivan's
law firm is "valid."
As you are aware, K.S.A. 40-2301 declares the policy of this
state to be as follows:
"In order to extend to certain employees of
the state and its political subdivisions and
to the dependents and survivors of such
employees, the basic protection accorded to
others by the old-age and survivors insurance
system embodied in the social security act, it
is hereby declared to be the policy of the
legislature, subject to the limitations of
this act, that such steps be taken as to
provide such protection to employees of the
state and its political subdivisions on as
broad a basis as is permitted under the social
security act."
Since 1951, Reno County has participated in an agreement with
your agency to extend the benefits of Old Age and Survivors
Insurance to county employees. K.S.A. 40-2302(a) defines
"wages" as all remuneration for employment or service of the
state or a political subdivision of the state. K.S.A.
40-2302(c) defines the term "employee" to include an officer of
the state or a political subdivision of the state. In our
opinion, the Reno county counselor is such an officer and
therefore, is an "employee" for the purposes of K.S.A. 40-2301
et
While there is no express statutory authorization for a county to
hire a county counselor, previous Attorney General Opinions have
concluded that a board of county commissioners may appoint a
county counselor in the exercise of the home rule power provided
by K.S.A. 19-101 and K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-101a. See Attorney
General Opinions Nos. 78-127; 77-31. A board of county
commissioners may then prescribe the duties of a county
counselor, either by reference to K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-247 or
independently of that statute.
As noted above, the agreement entered into by the Reno County
commissioners defines the county counselor's responsibilities by
incorporating K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-247. That statute defines
the duties of the counselor to include performance of all the
duties in civil matters that previously have been required by law
of the county attorney. Some of these responsibilities involve
the exercise of authority which, in our opinion, makes the county
counselor a county officer.
In Opinion No. 83-133, the Attorney General noted that one of
the attributes of public office is the right to exercise some
definite portion of the sovereign power. Sowers v. Wells, 150
Kan. 630 (1939). In distinguishing an office from mere
employment, it has been said:
"Although an office is an employment, it does
not follow that every employment is an office.
An individual may be employed under a
contract, express or implied, to do an act or
perform a service without becoming an officer.
But where the duties are continuing ones which
are defined by government-prescribed rule and
not by contract, and the government-appointed
individual performs these duties without any
contract defining them, if the duties continue
even though the person performing them changes
it is difficult to distinguish such employment
from an office, or the person performing the
duties from an officer." (Emphasis added.)
3 McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §12.30.
Attorney General Opinion No. 83-133 was concerned with an
attempt by a city to authorize "independent contractors" to
exercise some of the sovereign power of the city. The opinion
concluded that such an attempt was contrary to public policy and
void. The individuals in question, however, were found to be
de facto officers because they exercised some of the sovereign
authority under an apparently legitimate appointment. As such
officers, they were also city employes for the purposes of social
security contributions. The Reno County agreement pertaining to
the services of a county counselor does not purport to establish
an "independent contractor" relationship. Instead the
commissioners have appointed an attorney to fill the recently
established position of county counselor. The counselor is
required to perform duties for the county as prescribed by state
law. K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-247. Thus, the county counselor is
performing duties defined by government prescribed rule. His
responsibilities are not specifically defined by the contract and
presumably the duties of office will continue regardless of who
performs them. In establishing and filling the county counselor
position, in our opinion, the county commissioners have
established a county office.
Much of the county counselor's role as legal advisor to the
county does not involve the exercise of sovereign authority.
However, a county counselor is required by law to perform various
acts necessary to and inherent in the county's power of taxation.
For example, K.S.A. 79-2801 requires the county attorney or
county counselor, as ordered by the county commissioners, to
institute civil actions to enforce liens for delinquent taxes on
unredeemed real estate in the county. The statute further
provides that:
"Any member of the board of county
commissioners, county attorney or county
counselor who fails to perform the duties
required by this section shall forfeit
the office held by such officer." (Emphasis
added.)
According to the agreement in question, the Reno County counselor
performs all duties in civil matters which are required of the
county attorney. K.S.A. 79-2101 makes it the duty of the county
attorney to begin proceedings which are necessary to collect a
judgment for delinquent personal property taxes. A county
attorney (or, as here, a county counselor) is also required to
pursue all civil proceedings necessary for the recovery of tax,
penalties and interest due under the Liquified Motor Fuel Tax.
K.S.A. 79-34,102. Similar responsibilities regarding
enforcement of the Motor Vehicle Fuel Tax belong to the county
attorney. See K.S.A. 79-3419. In performing such functions,
the county counselor exercises a portion of the sovereign power
of taxation and thus acts as an officer of the county. As such
an officer, the counselor is also a county employee pursuant to
K.S.A. 40-2302(c). The renumeration the counselor receives for
holding the office is therefore "wages" as defined in K.S.A.
40-2302(a). Presumably, the agreement between Reno County and
the State of Kansas regarding social security benefits is
applicable to all county employees. (K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
40-2305). Therefore, in our opinion, the county counselor's
position is covered by the agreement between the county and the
state regardless of the provision in the local agreement between
the county and the counselor, which provides that the counselor
is not entitled to any other benefits of county employment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MFC:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.