Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-003

1985-003Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 2, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 3
Vic Miller
Director of Property Valuation
Fifth Floor, State Office Building
Topeka, Kansas 66625
Re: Real and Personal Property -- Conveyances of
Land -- Recording of Instruments
Synopsis: In the absence of a statute to the contrary, a
register of deeds lacks authority to allow
changes to be made in the real estate records of
the county in order to correct errors made in
original instruments that were properly recorded
by the register of deeds. If the parties to a
recorded instrument discover an error in the original
instrument, a document containing the correct infor-
mation should be prepared and recorded.
The register of deeds is an elected county officer
whose duties are prescribed by law. No other officer
or entity is charged with the responsibility of
supervising the activities of the register of deeds.
However, like the actions of any other public officer,
the actions of a register of deeds are subject to
review by the courts and the electors of the county.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-1204, 58-2221.
*
Dear Mr. Miller:
You explain that your office has received complaints from county
appraisers that the registers of deeds in their counties have been
allowing errors to be corrected in deeds recorded in their office
without notifying other county officials of such changes. This
action has resulted in problems in the preparation of the real
estate assessment rolls and in the proper appraisal of real
property in these counties. Due to these problems, you seek our
opinion on whether the register of deeds possesses the authority
to glow changes to be made in the real estate records of the
county, and if the appraiser has any authority to require the
register of deeds to notify the appraiser of any changes that
ar emade. You also inquire whether some officer or entity is
charged with the duty of supervising the activities of the
register of deeds.
4
We have reviewed the provisions of chapter 19 of the Kansas
Statutes Annotated, relating to registers of deeds, and the
pr visions of chapter 58, concerning the recording of instruments
conveying or affecting real property, and find no authority therein
for a register of deeds to allow changes to be made in the records
maintained in his or her office. In addition, we find no Kansas
case which has either approved or disapproved of such activity.
However, in 76 C.J.S. Records §25, it is stated:
"[A] record cannot be altered so as to show
anything not in the instrument recorded at the
time of the original record; and, if at the time
of the original record the instrument was cor-
rectly copied, the officer cannot subsequently
alter the record, even though there was a mistake
in the original instrument and the alteration of
the record is made by consent and on the written
request of the parties." (Footnotes omitted.)
Also, we note the case of Nelson, Curtis & Nelson v. Bridgeman,
152 La. 190, 92 So. 855 (1922), in which the court was required
to determine whether a clerk had the authority to alter a
recorded deed, due to an alleged mistake in the discription of
the property that was to be conveyed. The court concluded that
no such authority existed and stated: "If parties desire to make
a correction, a correction deed should be prepared and, after
its execution, should be recorded in the conveyance records.. ------
The correction then would. be properly made." 92 So. at 857.
We believe the rule announced in Bridgeman is consistent with
the current Kansas statutes which concern the recording of deeds
and the duties of the register of deeds. Under K.S.A. 58-2221,
only those instruments in writing, which are proved or acknowledged
and certified as prescribed in article 22 of chapter 58, and which
convey or affect real property or concern an interest in an oil
or gas lease may be recorded in the real estate records of the
register of deeds' office. Instruments that are not proved or
acknowledged and certified in accordance with the requirements
of law are not entitled to be recorded. See Horney v. Buffenbarger,
169 Kan. 342 (1950), Fisher v. Cowles, 41 Kan. 418 (1889), and
Meskimen v. Day, 35 Kan. 46 (1886). It is required that ac-
knowledgements be made before some proper officer. (See
ch. 58, art. 22.) Where an instrument is changed and is not
re-executed and re-acknowledged, the original certificate of
acknowledgement is rendered incorrect. The altered instrument
would not be the instrument acknowledged or proved before the
officer who issued the certificate of acknowledgement on the
original, unaltered instrument.
It is clear, then, that the law places a duty upon registers of
deeds to record those instruments which the law authorizes to be
recorded. Further, under K.S.A. 19-1204, the register of
deeds is required to "safely keep and preserve all the books,
records, deeds, maps, papers and microphotographs deposited or
kept in his office." (Emphasis added.) To allow deeds in his
or her office to be changed is inconsistent with a register's
duty to "safely keep and preserve" those deeds. Accordingly,
based upon the considerations stated above and in the absence
of a statute authorizing such activity, we are of the opinion
that a register of deeds has no authority to allow changes to
be made in the real estate records of the county. If parties
to a recorded instrument discover an error in the original
instrument, a document containing the correct information should
be prepared and recorded. If the procedure prescribed above is
followed, those county officials who utilize the real estate
records of the county to prepare the real estate assessment rolls
and appraise the real estate of the county for property tax
purposes could note any corrections made in the information pro-
vided in the real estate records and compile the correct information
needed to perform their duties.
Finally, in regard to your inquiry concerning supervision of a
register of deeds in the performance of his or her duties, we
note the register of deeds is an elected county officer whose
duties are prescribed by various laws. See K.S.A. 19-1201 et seq.
and 58-2221 et seq. The responsibility of performing the duties
of this office are ,imposed solely upon the officer. No other
officer or entity is charged with the responsibility of supervising
the register's activities as far as the recording of instruments
is concerned. As a result, in the absence of a statute to the
contrary, a county appraiser could not require a register of
deeds to notify the former's office of any corrections made.
Of course, like the actions of any other public officer, the
actions of a register of deeds are subject to review by the courts
[See, e.g., State ex rel. Stephan v. Board of Lyon County Comm'rs,
234 Kan. 732 (1984) and State ex rel. v. Mowry, 119 Kan. 74 (1925)]
and the electors of the county.
In summary, it is our opinion that, in the absence of a statute
authorizing such activity, a register of deeds lacks authority
to allow changes to be made in the real estate records of the
county. If the parties to a recorded instrument discover an
err r in the original instrument, a document containing the
correct information should be prepared and recorded.
s further our opinion that the register of deeds is an elected
county officer whose duties are prescribed by law. No other
officer or entity is charged with the duty of supervising the
activities of the register of deeds. However, like the actions
of any other public officer, the actions of a register of deeds
9e subject to review by the courts and the electors of the county.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:RJB:sc

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.