Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-002

1985-002Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 2, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 2
Joseph W. Snell, Executive Director
Kansas State Historical Society
120 West 10th Street
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re : Labor and Industries -- Act Against Discrimination --
Commission on Civil Rights; Confidential Nature of
Investigative Files
Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Public Records
Preservation -- Records Received by State Archives;
Confidentiality Maintained
Synopsis: Information gathered in the course of an investigation
by the Kansas Commission on Civil Rights is confidential,
pursuant to K.S.A. 44-1005, as amended by L. 1984,
ch. 186, §1(e). While files of such investigations
are subject to retention under the Public Records
Preservation Act, K.S.A. 45-401 et seq., the confidential
nature of the files is required to be maintained by
the archivist. Cited herein: K.S.A. 44-1005, as amended
by L. 1984, ch. 186, §1(e); K.S.A. 45-405, as amended by
L. 1984, ch. 188, §3; K.S.A. 45-407; 45-408; L._1984,_
ch. 282, §4; K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 21-43-6.
*
Dear Mr. Snell:
As Executive Director of the Kansas State Historical Society you
have requested an opinion on the legality of opening to public
scrutiny certain records presently maintained by the Society in
its role as the official state archivist (K.S.A. 45-405, as
amended by L. 1984, L. 188, §3). The records in question are
investigative files created by the Kansas Commission on Civil
Rights (KCCR). You inform us that in 1983, pursuant to K.S.A.
45-408, the KCCR asked the State Records Board to authorize
the disposition of these investigative case files. The KCCR was
of the opinion that the records should be destroyed because of
their confidential nature. On May 23, 1983, the state records
board made the following decision regarding these records:
"These records are to be transferred to the
State Historical Society (state archives) until
the office of the Attorney General has made a
determination as to the legality of opening
them to the public scrutiny. If not determined
to be a closed public record or of possessing
enduring historical value, the records may be
destroyed on a continuing basis three calendar
years after the completion of the investigation,
unless future state law requires longer retention."
See Records Disposition Schedule No. 53-2-61.
You now seek an opinion from this office on whether such records
may be made available to public access.
K.S.A. 44-1005, as amended by L. 1984, ch. 186, §1(e), provides
that members of the KCCR and its staff "shall not disclose
what has occurred" in the course of its efforts toward conciliation
- after a probable cause finding has been made on a complaint. In
K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 21-43-6 provides:
"Non-disclosure of facts. The commission shall
not disclose what has transpired in the course
of its endeavors at conciliation and persuasion,
per K.S.A. 44-1005. However, when executed, the
final terms of a conciliation agreement may be
disclosed. No officer, agent or employee of
the commission shall make public with respect to
a particular person without his consent infor-
mation from reports obtained by the commission
except as necessary to the conduct of further
commission proceedings."
The Kansas Supreme Court has considered the provisions of K.S.A.
44-1005 and concluded that, pursuant to that section:
. . The Kansas Commission on Civil Rights is
required to treat any and all information
gathered in the course of an investigation by
the Commission as confidential." Atchison,
T. & S.F. Rly. Co. v. Lopez, 216 Kan. 108,
122, Syl. ¶4 (1975). (Emphasis added.)
Thus, it is clear that the court regards the relevant language	of
K.S.A. 44-1005 (which remains substantially unchanged by the
1984 amendments) as restricting disclosure of all material gathered
by the KCCR in the course of an investigation or effort at con-
See also, Kansas Commission on Civil Rights v. Sears,
RolYuck & Co., 216 Kan. 306, 319 (1975) and Atchison, T. & S.F. Rly.
Co v. Commission on Civil Rights, 215 Kan. 911, 919-920 (1974).
The' fore, those records maintained by the KCCR which are covered
by K.S.A. 44-1005, as amended, are to be regarded as confidential
and are not available for public inspection. The Kansas Open
Records Act (L. 1984, ch. 282, §4), provides that a public agency
shall not be required to disclose:
"(1) Records the disclosure of which is
specifically prohibited or restricted by
federal law, state statute or rule of the
Kansas supreme court or the disclosure of
which is prohibited or restricted pursuant
to specific authorization of federal law,
state statute or rule of the Kansas supreme
court to restrict or prohibit disclosure."
In our opinion, disclosure of the records in question is specifi-
cally prohibited by law and such records cannot be made avail-
able to public inspection, regardless of the effect of the open
rords act.
We note at this juncture that K.S.A. 45-407 provides that records,
access to which is restricted, shall remain subject to such re-
strictions upon deposit with the state archivist. The statute
provides in relevant part:
"(a) All government records deposited subsequent
to adoption of this act in the state archives
shall remain subject to any current state or
federal statutes, or administrative regulations
authorized by statute, which require public
access or restrict public access to the records
while retained by the state or local agency or
the branch of state government making the deposit.
The state or local agency or the branch of state
government making the deposit may require con-
tinued application to government records deposited
in the state archives of any discretionary
restrictions on public access which are authorized
by statute or by administrative regulations
authorized by statute, if such requirements are
specified at the time of the deposit. No fees
shall be charged for the examination of govern-
ment records held by the state archives.
"(d) Statutes or administrative regulations
authorized by statute restricting public access
to certain types of records shall not prohibit
the state archivist or authorized representatives
of the state archivist from examining any gov-
ernment records held by a state or local agency
in order to prepare comprehensive inventories
containing general information about the nature,
scope, contents and location of each record
or in order to assist in properly
arranging, storing and preserving government
records with enduring value. No confidential
information found in such restricted govern-
ment records shall be revealed to any person
by the state archivist or by representatives of
the state archivist. Violation of this sub-
section shall be punishable as a class B mis-
demeanor."
This statute clearly permits the archivist to maintain confidential
records as long as the archivist may deem necessary.
We conclude therefore that the investigative records of the
Kansas Commission on Civil Rights currently held by the state
archivist are not available for public inspection if they fall
under the terms of K.S.A. 44-1005, as amended.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MFC:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.