Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-052

1984-052Kanag

Testo completo

June 11, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84 - 52
Wayne M. Stallard
307 Leonard Street
Onaga, Kansas 66521
Re: Townships and Township Officers -- Hospitals --
Attachment of Territory; Effective Date
Synopsis: Territory may be added to a hospital district created
under K.S.A. 80-21,101 et seq., by means of the pro-
cedures set forth in K.S.A. 80-21,120. The statute,
which was enacted in 1955, makes the attachment ef-
fective on March 1 following the entry of the county
commission's order, with this date intended to re-
flect the day property was assessed for tax purposes.
However, such date was changed in all taxation statutes
in 1959 to January 1, with the general statute govern-
ing attachment of territory (K.S.A. 79-1807) amended
at the same time to make attachments of territory ef-
fective as of December 31. In view of these subse-
quent amendments,' that portion of K.S.A. 80-21,120
which refers to March 1 as the effective date of any
attachment of territory has been repealed by impli-
cation, and the effective date is now that provided
in K.S.A. 79-1807. Cited herein: K.S.A. 79-309, 79-
1807, 80-21,120, 1984 House Bill No. 2003.
Dear Mr. Stallard:
As attorney for Hospital District No. 1 in Pottawatomie County,
Kansas, you request our opinion on a question concerning the an-
nexation of territory by the district. You inform us that on
October 10, 1983, the Board of County Commissioners of Potta-
watomie County approved the attachment of certain territory lo-
cated in Nemaha County to the district. The process followed
was prescribed by K.S.A. 80-21,120, which is contained in the
act which governs districts of this type. No questions have been
raised in your letter concerning the validity of the attachment,
which involved territory which was not previously contained in
any other hospital district. Rather, you inquire concerning the
effective date of the attachment of territory for purposes of
taxation.
Specifically, you point to language in K.S.A. 80-21,120 which
states that, following the entry by the commissioners of their
order, the annexation will "take effect on the first day of
March next following the entry of said order." In that other
statutes contained in Chapter 79 require property to be assessed
as of January 1 in order to be included in the tax base for that
year (K.S.A. 79-301, 79-309), the use of a March 1 date would
have the effect of precluding taxation of the territory for
district purposes until the following January 1. In this case,
the result would be a fifteen month period (October, 1983 to
January, 1985), during which the area involved would be receiving
services without being subject to taxation therefor.
At the time the statute was enacted (1955), the use of a March
1 date was compatible with the general statutes concerning the
assessment of property for taxation purposes. K.S.A. 79-309,
for example, stated that "[a]ll property shall be listed and
valued on the first day of March in the year in which the same
is assessed." However, by means of Chapter 365 of the 1959
Session Laws, K.S.A. 79-309 and thirty other statutes were amended
to change March 1 to January 1, a date which remains in effect
today. K.S.A. 80-21,120 was not included in this act, and re-
mained unamended until the 1984 session, when it was repealed,
effective July 1, 1984. 1984 House Bill No. 2003. However, in
that the action taken by the county commission occurred in October
of last year, the act of the 1984 legislature does not dispose
of your inquiry.
Also of interest to this problem is K.S.A. 79-1807, which pro-
vides in pertinent part:
"(a) Except as provided in subsection (b) of
this section, whenever any of the territory of
a municipality or other taxing district is
annexed, attached, or transferred to another
municipality or other taxing district on or be-
fore April 1 of any year, or whenever an entire
municipality or other taxing district is merged
or consolidated with another municipality or
taxing district on or before April 1 of any year,
such annexation, attachment, transfer, merger, or
consolidation shall take effect for tax pur-
poses as of the last day of December preceding
such annexation, attachment, transfer, merger
or consolidation: Provided, That the taxes due
on November 1 next preceding the date said
organization, incorporation, or change takes
effect for taxation purposes shall be collected
and distributed as before assessed and levied.
[sic]"
Like K.S.A. 79-309, 79-1807 was amended in 1959 to reflect the
change from March 1 to January 1. Whereas before the amendment
the effective date for tax purposes of any annexation was the
last day in February, in 1959 it was changed to read in its pre-
sent form, i.e. the last day of December. The effect of the
statute is clear, namely to provide that any territory added
to a municipality or taxing district would be in place by Jan-
uary 1, and so be included for the purposes of that year's
assessments.
It is not possible to harmonize the requirements of K.S.A. 80-
21,120 with those of K.S.A. 79-1807 and the other statutes amended
in 1959 to reflect a January 1 assessment date. In our opinion,
therefore, resort must be had to the concept of repeal by im-
plication. While the law does not favor the repeal of part or
all of a statute in this manner, a former statute can be so
treated when a latter enactment is so repugnant to it that
both cannot be given force and effect. Matter of Suesz' Estate,
228 Kan. 275 (1980). Furthermore, it is also a well-recognized
rule of statutory construction that older statutes must be read
in light of later legislative enactments. Thomas v. Board of
Trustees of Salem Township, 224 Kan. 539 (1978). While an earlier,
more specific statute is not automatically repealed by impli-
cation upon the enactment of a later, more general statute dealing
with the same subject [Howard v. Hulbert, 63 Kan. 793 (1901)],
when it appears that the general act was intended to be of uni-
versal application or where the two acts are irreconcilable with
each other, the more general will prevail.
In this particular situation, there appears to be no public
policy which is served by treating the annexation of territory by
a hospital district organized pursuant to K.S.A. 80-21,101 in a
different fashion than such action by any other unit of govern-
ment. Indeed, it would be contrary to public policy to apply
the March 1 date in such cases as here, where the annexed ter-
ritory would obtain a free year of services (1984) without hav-
ing to bear any share of the taxation responsibility. To con-
tinue to use the March 1 date now, in light of all the changes
which have occurred in other statutes regarding the date of
assessment of property, would foster inequity, without achieving
any benefits. We are not prepared to conclude that March 1 re-
mains the effective date, and are of the opinion that the annex-
ation of territory to Hospital District No. 1 was effective on
December 31, 1983, for purposes of taxation. In that the statute
in question (K.S.A. 80-21,120) will be repealed as of July 1,
1984, this problem should not arise again, especially since the
statute which will now govern attachment of territory (1984
House Bill No. 2003, Section 22) states that for tax purposes
the attachment shall be effective as provided by K.S.A. 79-1807.
In conclusion, territory may be added to a hospital district
created under K.S.A. 80-21,101 et seq., by means of the pro-
cedures set forth in K.S.A. 80-21,120. The statute, which was
enacted in 1955, makes the attachment effective on March 1
following the entry of the county commission's order, with this
date intended to reflect the day property was assessed for tax
purposes. However, such date was changed in all taxation statutes
in 1959 to January 1, with the general statute governing attach-
ment of territory (K.S.A. 79-1807) amended at the same time to
make attachments of territory effective as of December 31. In
view of these subsequent amendments, that portion of K.S.A. 80-
21,120 which refers to March 1 as the effective date of any
attachment of territory has been repealed by implication, and
the effective date is now that provided in K.S.A. 79-1807.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.