Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-050

1984-050Kanag

Testo completo

June 7, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 50
Donald R. Hoffman
Humpage, Berger and Hoffman
314 West 7th Street
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: State Department; Public Officers and Employees --
Open Public Meetings -- Procedures for Bodies Ex-
ercising Quasi-Judicial Functions
Synopsis: -In making recommendations as to the zoning of an
individual parcel of land, a planning commission acts
in a quasi-judicial, rather than a legislative,
function. As such, its deliberations may be held
in closed session, as a specific exception to the Kan-
sas Open Meetings Law, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. For
purposes of the Open Meetings Law, "binding action"
would occur when the commission votes to approve or
deny a particular request, and would have to be done
in an open meeting. Further, In that K.S.A. 12-708 re-
quires the commission to adopt its recommendations by
affirmative vote at the conclusion of the hearing, it
is not possible to have a binding vote before such rec-
ommendations, in the form of specific findings, are
prepared. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-708, K.S.A. 1983
Supp. 75-4318, 75-4319.
Dear Mr. Hoffman:
As attorney for the Topeka-Shawnee County Planning Commission,
you request our opinion concerning the procedures which the com-
mission should follow to comply with both the provisions of the
statutes dealing with zoning (K.S.A. 12-707 et seq.) and open
public meetings (K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq.). You advise us of a
number of recommendations which you have made to the commission
as its counsel, and seek our opinion as to whether the pro-
cedures you outline would comply with the Open. Meetings Law.
Additionally, you inquire whether, in the interest of avoiding
a one month delay between the initial hearing and the final
vote, a vote could be taken on the merits of the proposed change,
with the commissioners signing off on the formal findings of
facts and conclusions of law at a later time, but before the
next meeting.
There can be no question but that planning commissions are public
bodies or agencies which are subject to the provisions of the
Open Meetings Act. K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-4318(a). Following
the case of Golden v. City of Overland Park, 224 Kan. 591, 597
(1978), there is also little dispute that a planning commission
does at some points exercise quasi-judicial functions in weighing
evidence, balancing equities, and applying rules and ordinances
to a specific set of facts. Accordingly, the following language
found at the end of K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-4318(a) would apply:
"[A]ny administrative body that is authorized
by law to exercise quasi-judicial functions shall
not be required to have open meetings when such
body is deliberating matters relating to a
decision involving quasi-judicial functions."
In light of the above, you have made the following recommendations
to the commission:
(1) The agenda for each meeting be divided into three
parts; (a) quasi-judicial matters; (b) legis-
lative matters; and (c) administrative matters.
(2) Public hearings be held for quasi-judicial mat-
t ters such as zoning changes.
(3) Thereafter, private deliberations be held with
the staff and written findings of fact and con-
clusions of law be prepared for public vote at
the next meeting.
(4) In some cases a public vote could be held at the
first hearing, if the staff report is adopted by
the commission as its findings.
(5) The commission will have to determine in advance
whether a particular matter is legislative or
quasi-judicial, so that closed deliberations do
not occur for the former.
(6) An announcement will be made at the beginning of
each meeting as to the procedure which will be
followed.
In our opinion, each of these recommendations is consistent with
the intent and substance of the Open Meetings Act. While deliber-
ations made be held in private session for quasi-judicial matters,
no other business may be so discussed [absent one of the six ex-
ceptions found in K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-4319(b)], and even in
the case of these matters, any vote or other binding action must
be taken in public. See, e.g. Attorney General Opinion No. 79-
225. Adoption of a comprehensive plan, as well as any amendments
thereto, is a legislative action the entirety of which is subject
to the Act, as are numerous other acts of the commission. The
commission must bear the responsibility to determine when a
quasi-judicial matter arises which may be properly deliberated
in closed session. For a detailed discussion of what actions
constitute quasi-judicial functions, see Attorney General Op-
inion No. 82-266. Copies of both the above-cited opinions are
enclosed.
Your second concern deals with the time delay which the above
procedures will produce in many cases. At present, the Topeka-
Shawnee County Planning Commission meets once a month, at which
time public hearings are conducted on proposed zoning changes.
Except in those cases where the commission can, following its
closed deliberations, adopt the staff recommendations in a public
vote, the need to draw up specific findings of fact and con-
clusions of law will necessitate delaying final action until the
next month's meeting. Such findings and conclusions are required
to be made in order to comply with cases such as Golden, supra,
and subsequent decisions. Taco Bell v. City of Mission, 234
Kan. 879 (1984). As a means of expediting the process, you in-
quire whether such findings and conclusions could be prepared
in written form between meetings, with each commissioner then
signing-off, either in concurrence with the decision or in dis-
sent before the next meeting.
In our opinion, such a procedure would be open to challenge on
two grounds. First, the Open Meetings Law only exempts delib-
erations made in quasi-judicial matters, not binding action in
the form of votes, which must be . taken in public, open session.
The procedure of circulating proposed findings and conclusions
would contravene this, for either the decision would be made at
other than a scheduled meeting, or they would have been decided
during the closed session, both of which are improper. Second,
assuming that a decision was made during the public portion of
the initial meeting (following the hearing and closed deliber-
ations), a problem would still exist with K.S.A. 12-708. That
statute, which deals with the procedure for considering changes
in zoning, provides that the public hearing
"may be adjourned from time to time and at the
conclusion of the same, the planning commission
shall prepare its recommendations and shall by
an affirmative vote of a majority of all of the
members of the commission adopt the same in the
form of a proposed zoning ordinance and shall
submit the same, together with the accurate
written summary of the hearing thereon, to the
governing body of the city." (Emphasis added.)
In that the statute requires a vote of the commission to adopt
its recommendations for a change in zoning, in our opinion the
recommendations, in the form of findings of fact and conclusions
of law in the form mandated by Golden, must precede the vote,
rather than follow them.
In conclusion, in making recommendations as to the zoning of an
individual parcel of land, a planning commission acts in a quasi-
judicial, rather than a legislative, function. As such, its
deliberations may be held in closed session, as a specific exception
to the Kansas Open Meetings Law, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. For pur-
poses of the Open Meetings Law, "binding action" would occur when
the commission votes to approve or deny a particular request, and
would have to be done in an open meeting. Further, In that K.S.A.
12-708 requires the commission to adopt its recommendations by
affirmative vote at the conclusion of the hearing, it is not pos-
sible to have a binding vote before such recommendations, in the
form of specific findings, are prepared.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTOREY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.