Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-013

1984-013Kanag

Testo completo

February 14, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 13
John B. Kemp
Secretary of Transportation
Seventh Floor, State Office Building
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Department of Transportation -- Expenditures From
Railroad Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund
Kansas Constitution -- Finance and Taxation --
Internal Improvements; Public Improvements; Debts
Synopsis: Expenditures made from the Railroad Rehabilitation
Loan Guarantee Fund, created pursuant to K.S.A. 1983
Supp. 75-5029, may be made only to the federal rail-
road administration following a default on any fed-
eral loan to the Mid-States Port Authority. Federal
loan moneys received by the state for transfer to
the Mid-States Port Authority shall be deposited in
the State Railroad Planning and Assistance Federal
Fund and expended as authorized by 1984 Senate Bill
No. 506, if enacted.
'Participation by the state pursuant to the Railroad
Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund in a work of
internal improvement properly authorized under Art-
icle 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution is not
subject to the conditions and restrictions of Sections
6 and 7 of Article 11 regarding the contracting of
debts for extraordinary expenses and public improve-
ments.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-3401, K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-
5029, 75-5030, L. 1981, ch. 13, L. 1983, ch. 25, 1981
House Bill 2560, 1983 House Bill 2583, 1983 Senate
Bill 506, Kansas Constitution Art. 2 §24, Art.
11, 556, 7 and 9.
Dear Secretary Kemp:
You ask three questions regarding the Railroad Rehabilitation
Loan Guarantee Fund (K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-5029, 5030) created by
the 1983 Kansas Legislature. L. 1983, Ch. 25.
By way of background we note that this is the third in a series
of formal opinions regarding this transaction. In 1982, we ad-
vised that if the State of Kansas was going to participate with
the Mid-States Port Authority (MSPA) created pursuant to K.S.A.
12-3401 et seq., and the federal government in the acquisition of
the now-defunct Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railroad Company,
the federal funds contributed to the transaction "must be made
available to the state for expenditure or distribution." Kansas
Attorney General Opinion No. 82-257.
Late in the 1983 legislative session, 1983 House Bill 2583 was
introduced to create the Railroad Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee
Fund (hereinafter, Fund), and permitting the state to become a
party to the transaction which includes a proposed $18 million
federal loan for purchase and rehabilitation of the bankrupt Rock
Island line. In substance, the proposed bill would have permitted
the state to pay "to the federal railroad administration" any
loss on the federal loan to the Mid-States Port Authority.
Immediately following its introduction, the Honorable Mike Hayden,
Speaker of the House of Representatives, urgently requested an
opinion regarding the constitutionality of this bill in light of
Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution which restricts
participation by state goVernment in works of internal improvement.
We advised Speaker Hayden that the bill as proposed was uncon-
stitutional but that the bill could be amended to be constitut-
ionally permissible if the state contribution to the project,
namely its obligation to the federal government in the event of
default on the federal loan to MSPA, was limited to "an amount not
to exceed one-half of the loss assumed by the federal government."
Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 83-61. Nearly identical
language was added to section 2 of the bill (now at K.S.A. 1983
Supp. 75-5030) and the bill was passed by the two-thirds majority
vote of both houses of the legislature as required by Article 11,
Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution.
Nearly nine months later we are asked to resolve questions of
statutory interpretation concerning use of the term "expenditures"
in sections 1 and 3 of HB 2583; constitutional questions not
raised by prior opinion requests; and procedural problems con-
cerning the authority of the state finance council during the 1984
legislative session.
First, regarding the use of the term "expenditures" in sections
1 and 3 of 1983 HB 2583, you suggest that the language of the
bill is confusing. Indeed, we so concluded in our 1983 opinion,
and we would agree that the 1983 amendments may not have totally
eliminated the confusion. However, we do not see the problem as you
do. While you suggest that the language would impair the ability
of the state to contribute in the event of default, we think the
language and intent of the act is consistent in this regard,
namely, that the state can only contribute less than or equal to
one-half of any loss suffered by the federal railroad admini-
stration on the Mid-States Port Authority Loan. On the contrary,
the confusion seems to arise from the assumption that this act,
and this fund, may be used for the pass through of federal loan
moneys. Without such assumption there is no confusion and we be-
lieve such assumption to be clearly erroneous.
As the title to the act and the fund itself suggest, this is a
loan guarantee fund. Nothing in the language of the act mentions
the receipt or expenditure of federal funds by the state, except
that expenditures from this fund shall not exceed federal "partici-
pation." The language of section 2 specifically authorizes the
expenditures from the fund only to the federal railroad admini-
stration. There is no authorization to pay moneys from the
fund to the Mid-States Port Authority or any other person or
agency.
If the legislature desires to authorize the pass through of fed-
eral funds as required by Article 11, Section 9, and noted in
Attorney General Opinion No. 82-257, a "specific" appropriation
is required by law. See Kan. Const., Art. 2, §24. We believe
the legislature has provided for the receipt and expenditure of
federal railroad moneys since 1981 by the enactment of 1981 House
Bill 2560. That appropriations bill created the State Railroad
Planning and Assistance Federal Fund and authorized the expenditure
of all federal grants and Pother federal receipts" for the purposes
set forth in such grants or other receipts. See L. 1981, ch. 13,
§4. Unlike, the Railroad Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund, this
appropriation clearly authorizes the receipt and disbursement of
federal funds. See bill title. Although that year's appropriation
to this fund was passed by a more than two-thirds majority vote of
the legislature [see 1983 House Journal 443 (125 yeas - o nays),
1983 Senate Journal 460 (35 yeas - 3 nays)], such is not required
for internal improvement activities involving the expenditure of
federal funds only. See Kan. Const., Art. 11, §9(4). The fund
is to be continued pursuant to the governor's 1985 budget and
contains a "no limit" appropriation. See 1984 Senate Bill No.
506.
In sum, it is our opinion that federal loan moneys for the Mid-
States Port Authority will be deposited in the State Railroad
Planning and Assistance Federal Fund and expended pursuant 1984
Senate Bill No. 506, if passed. Expenditures from the Railroad
Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund will be limited to payments
to the federal railroad administration in the event of default
by MSPA on the federal loan.
Our answer to your first question makes your third question moot.
You had inquired as to how the procedural requirements for finance
council approval of expenditures from the Railroad Rehabilitation
Loan Guarantee Fund could be met while the legislature is in ses-
sion, i.e. until April 24, 1984. As expenditures from this Fund
can only be made to the federal government in the event of default
on the MSPA loan there is no conceivable way that such expenditures
can be necessitated in the next ninety days. Indeed, the loan
itself has not yet been approved by the federal government, re-
ceived by the state or transferred to MSPA. Until MSPA defaults
on the federal loan and suffers a loss (after sale of MSPA assets,
etc.) the state obligation to expend money under the Guarantee
Fund does not arise. Naturally, the Railroad Rehabilitation Loan
Guarantee Fund should continue to receive the annual "no limit"
appropriation, although we understand that such an appropriation
has not yet been introduced in the 1984 Legislature. In order that
the loan would be guaranteed for the 1985 fiscal year, such an
appropriation needs to be made.
We turn now to your second question. You inquire as to whether
Article 11, Sections 6 and 7 of the Kansas Constitution, concern-
ing state "debts," are applicable to this situation. Those
sections provide respectively:
"S6. For the purpose of defraying extraordinary ex-
penses and making public improvements, the state
may contract public debts; but such debts shall
never, in the aggregate, exceed one million dol-
lars, except as hereinafter provided. Every such
debt shall be authorized by law for some purpose
specified therein, and the vote of a majority of
all the members elected to each house, to be taken
by the yeas and nays, shall be necessary to the
passage of such law; and every such law shall
provide for levying an annual tax sufficient to
pay the annual interest of such debt, and the
principal thereof, when it shall become due; and
shall specifically appropriate the proceeds of
such taxes to the payment of such principal and
interest; and such appropriation shall not be
repealed nor the taxes postponed or diminished,
until the interest and principal of such debt
shall have been wholly paid.
§7. No debt shall be contracted by the state except
as herein provided, unless the proposed law for
creating such debt shall first be submitted to a
direct vote of the electors of the state at some
general election; and if such proposed laws shall
be ratified by a majority of all the votes cast
at such general election, then it shall be the
duty of the legislature next after such election
to enact such law and create such debt, subject
to all the provisions and restrictions provided
in the preceding section of this article."
In our judgement, debts contracted by the state pursuant to par-
ticipation in works of internal improvement authorized by Article
11, Section 9 of the Kansas Constitution are not subject to the
restrictions imposed by Sections 6 and 7 of Article 11. This issue
was resolved by the Kansas Supreme Court in State ex rel v. State
Highway Commission, 138 Kan. 913, 920, 921 (1934) and reaffirmed
in State ex rel. v. State Highway Commission, 139 Kan. 391, 395
(1934)
In these cases, the state proposed to accept a loan from the
federal government for highway purposes without specifying the
source of repayment. There, the Court limited the effect of
Article 11, Sections 6 and 7 (then Sections 5 and 6) on two basis
relevant here.
First, the loan for highway purposes arose under the authority
and within the bounds of the internal improvements section
(Article 11, §9, then §8) which (then and now) permits state par-
ticipation in a state system of highways so long as no general
obligation bonds or property taxes are used to finance the
activity. Article 11, Sections 6 and 7 were limited to "debts to
be paid by a general property tax." 138 Kan. at 918. Thus, the
internal improvements involving highways, which could not be
funded by general obligation bonds or a property tax (per Art. 11
§9) were not within the scope of Sections 6 and 7.
Second, Sections 6 and 7 of Article 11 refer to "public improve-
ments" not "internal improvements" governed by the terms of
Section 9. Referring to the 1919 amendment by the voters of
Article 11, Section 9 to permit state participation in highway
construction, the court noted
"that the state could not carry on the work of
constructing and maintaining state highways, even
to the limited extent then provided, if the re-
strictions and limitations of Article 11, section
5 and 6 [now 6 and 7], of the constitution should
apply to its operations, and it was specifically
provided that such sections should not apply."
138 Kan. 919, 920.
As in the case of highway projects considered in these earlier
cases, the state participation in the internal improvement project
regarding railroads is restricted by the terms of Article 11,
Section 9 to funding from sources other than the issuance of gen-
eral obligation bonds or a general property tax. Hence, based on
prior Kansas Supreme Court decisions, we readily conclude that the
limitations contained in Article 11, Sections 6 and 7 are inappli-
cable to a project of internal improvement permitted by Article
11, Section 9. The creation and administration of the Railroad
Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund constitutes state participation
in a work of internal improvement and has been properly authorized
pursuant to 1983 House Bill 2583 and the requirements of Article
11, Section 9.
Therefore, it is our opinion that expenditures made from the
Railroad Rehabilitation Loan Guarantee Fund, created pursuant to
K.S.A. 1983 Supp 75-5029, may be made only to the federal rail-
road administration following a default on any federal loan to
the Mid-States Port Authority. Federal loan moneys received
by the state for transfer to the Mid-States Port Authority shall
be deposited in the State Railroad Planning and Assistance Fed-
eral Fund and expended as authorized by 1984 Senate Bill 506,
if enacted.
Participation by the state pursuant to the Railroad Rehabilita-
tion Loan Guarantee Fund in a work of internal improvement prop-
erly authorized under Article 11, Section 9 of the Kansas Con-
stitution is not subject to the conditions and restrictions of
Sections 6 and 7 of Article 11 regarding the contracting of
debts for extraordinary expenses and public improvements.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Br	adle	y	J.Smoot
De y Attorney General
RTS:BJS:crw

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.