Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-182

1983-182Kanag

Testo completo

December 19, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 182
The Honorable Arthur Douville
State Representative, 20th District
9600 Woodson
Overland Park, Kansas 66207
Re: Corporations -- Agricultural Corporations --
Limitations on Ownership of Land; Exceptions for
Security Interests
Synopsis: K.S.A. 17-5904 prohibits corporations from owning,
acquiring or otherwise obtaining or leasing any
agricultural land in Kansas, except as provided
therein. While subsection (1) allows bona fide
encumbrances to be taken by corporations for the
purpose of security, such language refers to
mortgages or other equitable interests, and does
not include legal title retained by a vendor in a
contract for deed and thereafter sold to a cor-
poration. By contrast, a corporation could
acquire agricultural land which is subject to a
contract for deed under the provisions of subsec-
tion (4), through foreclosure on a vendor's in-
terest which had been pledged as security for a
separate loan. Accordingly, a corporation could
not acquire legal title in agricultural land
through a program of purchasing vendors' inter-
ests in contracts for deed. Cited herein: K.S.A.
17-5904.
Dear Representative Douville:
You have requested our opinion on a question concerning K.S.A.
17-5904, which regulates the ownership by corporations of
agricultural land in Kansas. Specifically, you inform us
that a corporation wishes to establish a secondary market for
installment sales contracts, by purchasing vendors' interests
in contracts for deed (thereby acquiring legal title in the
property). Equitable title would remain with the purchaser,
who would thereafter make his payments to the corporation,
rather than the original landowner, who would assign his
right to receive the proceeds to the corporation. The deed
would be transferred upon completion of the contract, at
which time both legal and equitable title would merge in the
purchaser. In view of the numerous provisions which exist
governing corporate ownership of agricultural land, you in-
quire whether such activity by a corporation is permitted.
K.S.A. 17-5904 was enacted in 1981 (ch. 106, §2) as part of
an overhaul of statutes dealing with corporate farming and
corporate ownership of agricultural land. In pertinent part,
the statute states as follows:
"(a) No corporation, trust, limited corporate
partnership or corporate partnership, other
than a family farm corporation, authorized
farm corporation, family trust, authorized
trust or testamentary trust shall, either
directly or indirectly, own, acquire or other-
wise obtain or lease any agricultural land
in this state. The restrictions provided in
this section do not apply to the following:
"(1) A bona fide encumbrance taken for pur-
poses of security.
• • •
"(4) Agricultural land acquired by a corpora-
tion by process of law in the collection of
debts, or pursuant to a contract for deed exe-
cuted prior to the effective date of this act,
or by any procedure for the enforcement of a
lien or claim thereon, whether created by mort-
gage or otherwise, if such corporation divests
itself of any such agricultural land within 10
years after such process of law, contract or
procedure.
"(b) Any corporation, trust, limited corporate
partnership or corporate partnership, other
than a family farm corporation, authorized
farm corporation, family trust, authorized
trust or testamentary trust, violating the
provisions of this section shall be subject
to a civil penalty of not more than $50,000
and shall divest itself of any land acquired
in violation of this section within one year
after judgment is entered in the action. The
district courts of this state may prevent and
restrain violations of this section through
the issuance of an injunction. The attorney
general or district or county attorney shall
institute suits on behalf of the state to en-
force the provisions of this section." (Em-
phasis added.)
As noted above, the situation which you posit involves the
purchase by a corporation of the seller's interest in a
contract for deed. Under such a contract, the seller retains
legal title until the buyer completes his payments, with
the buyer having an equitable interest which increases as
he performs. This arrangement may be contrasted with the
taking of a mortgage on realty, in which the buyer has legal
title while the seller or lender retains an equitable inter-
est (in the form of the mortgage) which decreases as payments
are made. While in many respects these situations are two
sides of the same coin, only in the case of a contract for
deed is legal title retained by the seller, or, as here, the
corporation.
This distinction becomes important when the provisions of the
statute are examined. Subsection (1) exempts bona fide encum-
brances taken for purposes of security, which would clearly
apply to mortgages held by a corporation. We are informed
that the Iowa Attorney General's office recently concluded
that this exemption (which also appears in their statutes
at §172C.4(1), 1983 Code of Iowa) also extends to the re-
tention of bare legal title in a contract for deed situation
and that as a result possession of such title by a corpora-
tion would be permitted. Given the commonly understood
meaning of the term "encumbrance", however, we cannot concur
with this conclusion. According to Black's Law Dictionary,
4th ed. (1968), the term is defined (at page 908) as a charge
or liability to which land is subject, such as a mortgage,
lien, judgment, lease, covenant, easement or right of redemption.
In each of these cases, legal title remains with the owner,
with the encumbrances imposed by action of another. In this
sense, land sold under a contract for deed is encumbered by the
presence of the equitable interest of the purchaser, which
would transfer with any sale of the legal title. Therefore,
the vendor's interest, which a corporation would acquire,
cannot be said to be an encumbrance, in that it constitutes
the legal title itself, and not-a charge or liability on the
title.
This is not to say, however, that there exist no circumstances
under which a corporation could obtain title to land by ac-
quiring rights under a contract for deed. For example, if a
corporation loaned money to an individual who had sold agri-
cultural land under a contract for deed to another, the
contract could be taken as security by the corporation for
repayment of the loan. Should default occur, the corporation
would acquire legal title under the contract for deed as well
as the right to receive payments from the buyer. This would
be a situation of the type posited by subsection (4) of
K.S.A. 17-5904, since the interest would have been obtained
through process of law in the collection of a debt or the
enforcement of a lien. Should the buyer then default, the
corporation would have full title, legal and equiable. In
either event, it would thereafter have 10 yeas to dispose
of its interest. [Note: We read the language of subsection
(4) concerning contracts for deed as referring to situations
where the corporation is the buyer, not the vendor, and thus
inapplicable here.]
In conclusion, K.S.A. 17-5904 prohibits corporations from
owning, acquiring or otherwise obtaining or leasing any
agricultural land in Kansas, except as provided therein.
While subsection (1) allows bona fide encumbrances to be
taken by corporations for the purpose of security, such
language refers to mortgages or other equitable interests,
and does not include legal title retained by a vendor in a
contract for deed and thereafter sold to a corporation. By
contrast, a corporation could acquire agricultural land
which is subject to a contract for deed under the provisions
of subsection (4), through foreclosure on a vendor's inter-
est which had been pledged as security for a separate loan.
Accordingly, a corporation could not acquire legal title in
agricultural land through a program of purchasing vendors'
interests in contracts for deed.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.