Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-177

1983-177Kanag

Testo completo

December 1, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 177
The Honorable Jack H. Brier
Secretary of State
Second Floor, Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Cities -- Home Rule -- Authority to Hold Non-
Binding Advisory Elections
Elections -- City Elections -- Non-Binding Advi-
sory Elections; Supervision by County Election
Officer
Synopsis: The governing body of a city may, pursuant to
the home rule authority granted by Article 12,
Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution, call and
hold an advisory election, provided that such
election is for a public purpose and is not an
unauthorized delegation of legislative authority.
Because of its non-binding nature, an advisory
election is not included within the term "question
submitted election" or any other category of city
election under K.S.A. 25-2101 et seq. Accordingly,
advisory elections may not be supervised bey county
election officials. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-184,
12-682, 12-809, 12-811, 12-1220, 12-2001, 12-2104,
13-1024a, 25-605a, 25-2104, 25-2110, 25-2810, Kan.
Const. Art. 12,§5.
Dear Secretary Brier:
In your role a! the chief election officer of the State of
Kansas, you request our opinion on two questions concerning
advisory elections held by cities. First, you inquire
whether such advisory elections may in fact be held by means
of a city ordinance and the subsequent submission of the
question to the voters. Second, you wish to know whether
the administration of such an election is within the duties
of the county election officer.
A response to your first question must begin with the pro-
visions of the Kansas Constitution which give cities home rule
authority over numerous local matters. Article 12, Section
5 of the state constitution states in pertinent part:
"(b) Cities are hereby empowered to determine
their local affairs and government including
the levying of taxes, excises, fees, charges
and other exactions except when and as the
levying of any tax, excise, fee, charge or
other exaction is limited or prohibited by
enactment of the legislature applicable uni-
formly to all cities of the same class:
Provided, That the legislature may establish
not to exceed four classes of cities for the
purpose of imposing all such limitations or
prohibitions. Cities shall exercise such de-
termination by ordinance passed by the govern-
ing body with referendums only in such cases
as prescribed by the legislature, subject
only to enactments of the legislature of
statewide concern applicable uniformly to all
cities, to other enactments of the legisla-
ture applicable uniformly to all cities, to
enactments of the legislature applicable uni-
formly to all cities of the same class limit-
ing or prohibiting the levying of any tax,
excise, fee, charge or other exaction and to
enactments of the legislature prescribing
limits of indebtedness." (Emphasis added.)
In the context of advisory elections, at least one prior
opinion of this office has determined that a city's home
rule power is sufficient to authorize the holding of a non-
binding election, even in the absence of specific statutory
authority. Attorney General Opinion No. 74-351. The opin-
ion noted that the city commission could not
delegate legislative authority which it possessed to the voters through
such an election, but instead could "authorize the holding
of an election, purely advisory in nature, at which a ques-
tion of public concern is submitted for the expression of
the wishes of the people." We concur with the opinion's
reasoning and the result reached therein, but note that the
question of how such an election should be conducted was
not raised or discussed.
It should also be noted that the language of subsection (b)
quoted above makes reference to the holding of "referendums
only in such cases as prescribed by the legislature." The
referendum is a device whereby a measure which has been
approved by a legislative governing body does not go into
effect until it is also approved by a specified proportion
of the voters in an election. A. Ranney, Referendums:
A Comparative Study of Practice and Theory, p. 67 (1978).
Charter ordinances, for example, must be submitted to the
voters if, within 60 days after their passage by the city
commission, a petition containing the requisite number of
signatures is filed. Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5(c)(3). The
decision of the voters is binding, and if the resolution is
not approved, it is of no effect. One commentator has ex-
plained the limitation in subsection (b) of Article 12, §5
regarding referendums in general as an attempt to prevent
city commissions from delegating legislative authority which
they possess to the voters, and so "pass the buck." A. Martin,
"Home Rule for Kansas Cities," 10 Kan. L. Rev., 501, 504 (1962).
Although the term "referendum" is not used in the statutes
which concern elections, a similar concept appears in the con-
cept of a "question submitted election." K.S.A. 25-2104(a).
That statute provides that such an election involves the
submission to the voters of a special question dealing with
a particular issue. As a matter of law, such questions are
phrased in such a way as to present the voter with a choice,
either for or against, a specific proposition. See K.S.A.
25-605a and Kimsey v. Board of Education, Unified School Dist.
No. 273, 211 Kan. 618 (1973). A number of statutes require
the holding of a question submitted election before a measure
approved by a governmental body may go into effect. See,
e.g., K.S.A. 12-184 (change in form of city government),
K.S.A. 12-811 (purchase of utility plants), and various
statutes authorizing issuance of bonds, such as K.S.A.
13-1024a (public improvements), K.S.A. 12-809 (waterworks),
and K.S.A. 12-682 (street improvements). Others require
such elections upon the filing of valid protest petitions
following certain actions by the governing body of the city.
K.S.A. 12-1220 (establishment of library), K.S.A. 12-2001
(grant of franchise), and K.S.A. 12-2104 (trash collection
expenses). These are the types of questions in which a city
may legitimately hold a "referendum" of the kind referred
to in the home rule section of the constitution.
When compared to a question submitted election, an advisory
election is different in two important respects. First, it
is held only at the discretion of the city commission or
council, and not in response to the commands of any statute.
Second, the results of such an election are no more binding
upon the governing body than would be the outcome of a pub-
lic opinion poll which was conducted on a particular issue.
-n our opinion, these differences go to the very heart of
what constitutes an "election" within the meaning of K.S.A.
25-2101 et seq. When a voter casts his or her ballot on a
question submitted in a special election, they are partici-
pating in a legislative activity by which an ordinance will
stand or fall. The choice they face is a real one, as are
the consequences of the electorate's decision. 25 Am.Jur.2d
Elections, §1, citing Nelson v. Robinson, 301 A.2d 508 (Fla.
App. 1974). In contrast, an advisory election is the result
of an administrative decision by the city council or commis-
sion (i.e., to seek public input through a more elaborate
method than through public comment or an opinion poll), and
the choice presented to the voters is an illusory one. Un-
like a general, primary or question submitted election,
where each person's vote can be decisive, no one's vote in
an advisory election carries any legal import whatsoever.
In view of these essential differences, in our opinion advi-
sory elections are not included by implication within the
categories of elections set forth in K.S.A. 25-2101 et seq.
The only statute which they could conceivably fall under
[K.S.A. 25-2104(a)] concerns question submitted elections,
and, as demonstrated above, advisory election resemble them
only superficially. While the county election officer is
empowered to conduct city elections [K.S.A. 25-2104(b),
25-2110, 25-2810], such officer's authority is limited to
the supervision of only those elections authorized by sta-
tute, and no others. 25 Am.Jur.2d Elections, §44, 29 C.J.S.
Elections, §67, p. 158. Accordingly, if a city desires to
hold an advisory election, it cannot rely upon the county
election officer to supervise the proceedings, for such ac-
tion would be in excess of that officer's authority. Our
reasoning and conclusions herein are consistent with Kansas
Attorney General Opinion No. 79-44 regarding the home rule
powers of counties to conduct advisory elections.
In conclusion, the governing body of a city may, pursuant to
the home rule authority granted by Article 12, Section 5 of
the Kansas Constitution, call and hold an advisory election,
provided that such election is for a public purpose and is not
an unauthorized delegation of legislative authority. Because
of its non-binding nature, an advisory election is not in-
cluded within the term "question submitted election" or any
other category of city election under K.S.A. 25-2101 get seq.
Accordingly, advisory elections may not be supervised by
county election officials.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.