Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-012

1983-012Kanag

Testo completo

January 31, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 12
David K. Clark
Buffalo City Attorney
609 Monroe
Fredonia, Kansas 66736
Re: Taxation--Limitations on Tax Levies--Limitation
on Certain Tax Levies in Cities of the Third Class
Synopsis: The maximum tax levy which a city of the third class
may be compelled to certify, in any one year, to
satisfy a judgment entered against it, is limited
to an amount which a court determines to be reasonable
and not oppressive. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-151,
79-1953, 79-5011.
Dear Mr. Clark:
You request our interpretation of K.S.A. 12-151. Specifically,
you advise that a judgment in the amount of $350,000 has been
rendered against the city of Buffalo, and you request information
as to the maximum tax levy, if any, which the city of Buffalo
must certify (for the purpose of satisfying said judgment) in
any one year in order to comply with the provisions of the
aforesaid statute.
K.S.A. 12-151 provides as follows:
"Except for judicial tax foreclosure, all
lands, buildings, monies, debts due the
city, and all other property and other
assets of every description belonging to
any city shall be exempt from levy,
execution and sale, and no judgment against
a city shall be a charge or lien on such
property: Provided, That nothing herein
shall relieve a city from the obligation
of levying taxes or otherwise providing
funds to pay judgments, and any such taxes
levied or funds provided for such purpose
shall not be exempt from any appropriate
judicial process to enforce a judgment."
(Emphasis added.)
As is readily apparent, the above-quoted statute does not set
forth any mathematical formula whereby one may calculate, in
quantitative terms, the obligation of a city to levy a tax to
satisfy a judgment. As you point out, K.S.A. 79-1953, which
establishes levy limitations for certain prescribed city purposes
for cities of the third class, does not set forth such a limitation
in relation to taxes levied to satisfy judgments. Additionally,
the tax lid law (K.S.A. 79-5001 et seq.) does not apply to or
limit the levy of taxes for the payment of judgments rendered
against a city. See K.S.A. 79-5011(d).
Although we are unaware of any statutory provision which places
a limitation upon the amount of taxes which must be levied by
a city of the third class to satisfy a judgment, the Kansas
Supreme Court has indicated that courts will not compel a levy,
for such purposes, which is unreasonable or oppressive. Phelps v.
Lodge, 60 Kan. 122, 125 (1899). In the Phelps case, the court
held that the governing body of a city of the third class may be
compelled by mandamus to levy taxes to pay a judgment rendered
against the city, and also noted the court's discretion in
compelling a tax levy:
"The court has some measure of discretion
in awarding writs of mandamus, and in
requiring levies of taxes they will not
be so employed as to impose an unneces-
sarily oppressive burden at one time. In
providing for the payment of a large judg-
ment the whole amount may be apportioned
and collected part at a time by successive
levies." (Emphasis added.) Phelps v. Lodge,
supra, Syllabus ¶3.
Similarly, a recognized authority on the law of municipal
corporations has noted the discretion which a court may exercise
in compelling a municipal corporation to exercise its taxing power
to pay judgments against it, to wit:
"The court may exercise a reasonable dis-
cretion in determining whether the amount
of a judgment shall be raised by a single
tax or by two or more levies spread over a
reasonable number of years." McQuillin,
Mun. Corp. (3rd Ed.) §51.46.
In accordance with the above quoted authorities, it is our
opinion that the maximum tax levy which the city of Buffalo
may be compelled to certify, in any one year, to satisfy a
judgment, is limited to an amount which a court determines to
be reasonable and not oppressive.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.