Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-240

1982-240Kanag

Testo completo

November 8, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 240
Terry R. Fuller
Edwards County Attorney
P. 0. Box 394
Kinsley, Kansas 67547
Re: Roads and Bridges -- Minimum Maintenance Roads --
River Crossing; Title of Land Held by State
Synopsis: Title to the bed and channel of any navigable
river is held by the State of Kansas. In that
the Arkansas River is legally declared to be a
navigable river, title to the bed, even if dry,
remains with the state, and its use by a county
for road purposes would be subject to the approval
of the state. In the absence of such approval,
county equipment should not be used to maintain
the crossing. Additionally, while a county may
designate the county road leading to the cross-
ing as a minimum . maintenance road, pursuant to
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 68-5,102, an easement from the
state would be required before the crossing it-
self could be so posted. Cited herein: K.S.A.
68-119, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 68-5,102.
Dear Mr. Fuller:
As County Attorney for Edwards County, Kansas, you request
our opinion on a question concerning potential liability for
a crossing over the Arkansas River. Specifically, you inform
us that a county bridge over the river at that point was
closed several years ago as being unsafe, and local residents
have taken to driving across the bed of the river. You wish
to know what the liability of the county, as well as the town-
ship, would be for this situation, and whether county equip-
ment should be used for maintaining access to the river
bottom, as well as the bed itself.
From your letter, it is our understanding that neither the
township nor the county has taken any action to encourage
the use of this crossing across the Arkansas River. Rather,
due to the county's closing of the bridge at a point near
there, and the inconvenience of driving to another bridge,
local landowners began driving on the bed of the river, which
is usually either completely dry or at most two feet deep in
a few places. The county road leading up to the closed bridge
is still open, but the county has not assisted in clearing
any access route from the road down to the river bed.
You first inquire whether the provisions of the minimum main-
tenance road statute, K.S.A. 1931 Supp. 68-5,102, could be of
assistance here. That statute provides that if the county
commission determines that a road is used only occasionally
or by a few persons, it may declare the road to be a minimum
maintenance road. Pursuant to subsection (d), signs are to
be posted on the affected stretches of road which state
"Minimum maintenance, travel at your own risk." Once such
signs have been posted, the county, as well as any township
through which the road passes, are exempt from liability under
the Kansas Tort Claims Act, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6101 et seq.
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 68-5,102(f). While this office has expressed
reservations about certain aspects of the statute (Attorney
General Opinion No. 81-125), to the best of our knowledge it
has not been challenged in the courts as of this time. A
copy of our prior opinion is enclosed-for your reference.
In our opinion, the provisions of this statute would not be
capable of application here, where the trafficway in question
is across the bed of the river, and not on a road which has
been officially opened and maintained by the county. „ Indeed,
any traffic across the river bed is unauthorized, in that it
is occurring on land owned by the State of Kansas. Since the
early case of Wood v. Fowler, 26 Kan. 682 (1881), it has been
established in Kansas that a riparian owner holds title only
down to the high-water mark, with title to the river bed held
by the state. Since the Arkansas River has been declared to
be legally navigable, regardless of the actual state of the
river [Dana v. Hurst, 86 Kan. 947 (1912)], any private use
of the river bed must be approved by the state. See, e.g.,
Siler v. Dreyer, 183 Kan. 419 (1958). Accordingly, while
the county could obtain an easement from the riparian owner
for the access road down to the high-water mark, permission
for anything beyond that would need to be obtained from the
state, through action of the legislature. K.S.A. 82a-201 et
seq.
Assuming, however, that such an easement were granted, the
county could go through the steps of laying out a road across
the river bed, applying, if desired, K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
68-5,102 after having done so. This would alert motorists
using the road that caution should be observed, as well as
relieving the county and township of liability for negligent
acts. K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-6104(g). If the crossing is
thereby given an official status, K.S.A. 68-119 imposes an
additional duty on the township, to-wit:
"Each township trustee within his township
shall erect and maintain, at the expense of
the township, posts or boards at the fords of
every river or creek that in high water be-
comes impassable, which posts shall be set at
or near low watermark, on which shall be in-
scribed in legible letters, or plain figures,
the depth or water at low water, together with
a scale of feet showing the number of feet
above low watermark to the height to which
said stream is known to have ever risen."
In conclusion, title to the bed and channel of any navigable
river is held by the State of Kansas. In that the Arkansas
River is legally declared to be a navigable river, title to
the bed, even if dry, remains with the state, and its use
by a county for road purposes would be subject to the approval
of the state. In the absence of such approval, county equip-
ment should not be used to maintain the crossing. Addition-
ally, while a county may designate the county road leading
to the crossing as a minimum maintenance road, pursuant to
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 68-5,102, an easement from the state would
be required before the crossing itself could be so posted.
Very truly yours,
3 ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle
Enc.

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.