Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-229

1982-229Kanag

Testo completo

October 26, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 229
Ms. Trudy Jacobsen, Chairman
Seward County Economic Development
Advisory Committee
2033 Windsor
Liberal, Kansas 67901
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Economic Develop-
ment Programs -- Use of Funds
Synopsis: K.S.A. 19-4103 authorizes expenditure of county
moneys for programs related to economic develop-
ment. The only constraints in this regard are
that such expenditures have a demonstrable and
rational relation to programs of economic develop-
ment and that they satisfy the public purpose
doctrine. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-4101, 19-4102,
19-4103.
Dear Ms. Jacobsen:
As chairman of the Seward County Economic Development Committee
you have requested an opinion from this office regarding
whether county moneys raised pursuant to a tax levy authorized
by K.S.A. 19-4102 may be used for various purposes specified
in your opinion request. Your opinion request states, in
relevant part, as follows:
"[W]e seek your opinion as to whether we can
use these funds [raised pursuant to K.S.A.
19-4102] for the following purposes:
"1. Payment to architect for preparing pre-
liminary plans for proposed multi-purpose/
convention center facility.
"2. Cost to prepare a first class presenta-
tion selling Seward County/Liberal to prospec-
tive industrial developers (Booklet, film pre-
sentation).
"3. Advertisements in Site Locaters Magazines
and other publications - promoting Liberal
through greater circulative means.
"4. Dues for memberships to Economic/Indus-
trial Development Organizations - encouraging
on-going exchange of information and ideas.
"5. Travel expenses, including transportation,
dining, and accomodations, for potential indus-
trial development prospects.
"6. Educational expenses for member/members
of Economic Development Committee to attend
Industrial Development seminars, schools,
workshops. Expenses would include travel,
room and board, tuitions, registration fees.
"7. Contributions to county-wide promotional
campaign billboard signs, license plates,
placemats, radio spots, t-shirts - with the
intent of promoting Liberal to the people of
Liberal, as well as attracting others to
Liberal to live, work, and shop.
"8. Allocation of funds for tokens and ges-
tures of appreciation to existing industries
to demonstrate appreciation for their exist-
ence in the community: gifts, periodic lun-
cheons represented by individuals from local
companies and Committee members.
"9. Funds to be used for hiring of individual/
individuals for part-time administration duties,
as well as supplies to be used for administer-
ing Economic Development program (stationery,
postage, copying, etc.)."
K.S.A. 19-4103 outlines how moneys raised pursuant to the
tax levy authorized by K.S.A. 19-4102 may be utilized. K.S.A.
19-4103 states:
"Any such county establishing an economic de-
velopment program under this act may utilize
the funds herein authorized to conduct studies
and prepare comprehensive plans for its future
economic growth and development; to inventory
the services, facilities and resources of the
entire county; to promote, stimulate and en-
courage the growth and development of the ag-
riculture, commerce and industry of the county
as a whole, in order to achieve maximum utili-
zation of its human, economic and natural re-
sources and tourist attractions; and to other-
wise promote the general economic welfare and
prosperity of the area."
The language utilized in K.S.A. 19-4103 grants very broad
discretion to counties vis a vis utilization of moneys raised
pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4102. We believe that the only con-
straints on such expenditure of moneys is that there be a
rational and demonstrable relationship to the uses specified
in K.S.A. 19-4103 and that such expenditures satisfy the
public purpose doctrine.
It is well-settled that a unit of local government, in exer-
cising powers conferred on it by a state legislature, may
expend funds only for public purposes. Loan Association v.
Topeka, 20 Wall. 655 (1875), Green v. Frazier, 235 U.S. 233
(1920), State ex rel., Ferguson v. City of Pittsburg, 188
Kan. 612 (1961), Kan. Att'y Gen. Op. No. 82-191. In 64 C.J.S.
Municipal Corporations, 51835 (1950), the general law govern-
ing judicial scrutiny in the application of the "public pur-
pose" doctrine is stated thus:
"Each case must be decided in the light of the
existing conditions, with respect to the ob-
jects sought to be accomplished, the degree
and manner in which that object affects the
public welfare, and the nature and character
of the thing to be done; but the court will
give weight to a legislative determination of
what is a municipal purpose, as well as wide-
spread opinion and general practice which re-
gard as city purposes some things which may
not be such by absolute necessity, or on a
narrow interpretation of constitutional pro-
visions. Where an appropriation of public
funds is primarily for public purposes, it is
not necessarily rendered violative of consti-
tutional provisions against gifts and loans
of public credit by an incidental result which
may be of private benefit. On the other hand,
if the result is chiefly that of private bene-
fit, an incidental or even ostensible public
purpose will not save its constitutionality.
A purpose may be a public one so as to be
within a municipal power to appropriate funds
therefor, even though it is not a necessary
purpose. It has been laid down as a general
rule that the question whether the performance
of an act or the accomplishment of a specific
purpose constitutes a 'public purpose' for
which municipal funds may be lawfully dis-
bursed rests in the judgment of the municipal
authorities, and the courts will not assume
to substitute their judgment for that of the
authorities unless the latter's exercise of
judgment or discretion is shown to have been
unquestionably abused." (Footnotes omitted.)
Id. at 334-335. [Excerpt relied upon by the
Supreme Court of Ohio in State ex rel., McClure
v. Hagerman, 155 Ohio St. 320, 98 N.E.2d 835
(1951).]
We are constrained to defer to the legislature's policy deter-
mination that government financed programs of economic develop-
ment serve a valid public purpose. However, this deference
does not necessarily validate every expenditure by a public
body under the Economic Development Programs Act. Therefore,
it is necessary to analyze each of the proposed expenditures
to determine whether any prohibition exists which would pre-
clude same.
1. "Payment to architect for preparing preliminary plans for
proposed multi-purpose convention center facility."
K.S.A. 19-4103 specifically authorizes expenditures by a
county to "prepare comprehensive plans for its future econ-
omic growth and development . . . and to promote the general
economic welfare and prosperity of the area." We cannot say,
as a matter of law, that an architect's fee for plans for a
proposed "multi-purpose convention center facility" does not,
in some way, fall within the allowable uses specified in
K.S.A. 19-4103. Furthermore, it has been held that a valid
public purpose is served by the building of a public audi-
torium or convention center. See: Wilkerson v. Lexington,
222 S.W. 74 (Ky. 1920), Bernstein v. Pittsburgh, 77 A.2d 452
(Pa., 1951), State v. Tampa, 146 So. 2d 100 (Fla. 1962)%
2. "Cost to prepare a first class presentation selling Seward
County/Liberal to prospective industrial developers (Booklet,
film presentation)."
3. "Advertisements in Site Locaters Magazines and other
publications - promoting Liberal through greater circulative
means."
K.S.A. 19-4103 specifically authorizes the expenditure of
moneys raised pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4102 "to promote, stimu-
late and encourage the development of the agriculture, com-
merce and industry of the county as a whole." It is well-
recognized that where the statutory power exists, courts have
permitted local units of government to advertise their advan-
tages in order to attract commercial enterprises to the
community. See: Sacramento Chamber of Commerce v. Stephens,
2998.728 (Cal. 1931); Fernandina v. State, 197 So. 454 (Fla.
1940); Dennis v. Raleigh, 116 S.E.2d 923 (N.C. 1960). We
believe that the proposed "presentation" and "advertisements"
are within the scope of the uses specified in K.S.A. 19-4103.
4. "Dues for memberships to Economic/Industrial Development
organizations - encouraging ongoing exchange of information
and ideas."
According to Rhyne, The Law of Local Government Organizations,
§31.6, p. 1027, "[i]t is the unanimous rule, that payment by
a municipality . . . for the cost of membership in associations
of municipal officials is for a public purpose." To the ex-
tent that such membership will serve to "encourage growth and
development" of the Seward County economy such would be an
expenditure authorized by K.S.A. 19-4103. See also: Louisville
and Jefferson Co. Bd. of Health v. Steinfeld, 215 S.W. 2d 1011
(Ky. 1943) and Cf, Beauchamp v. Snider, 185 S.W. 868 (Ky.
1916).
5. "Travel expenses, including transportation, dining, and
accomodations for potential industrial development prospects."
The legislative intent embodied in K.S.A. 19-4101 et seq. is
to allow local units of government to expend public moneys
to facilitate economic growth. To the extent that the pay-
ment of travel expenses for "potential industrial development
prospects" will serve such purpose, then same would be autho-
rized by K.S.A. 19-4103. See also: State ex rel., v. City
of Pittsburg, 188 Kan. 612 (1961), and Attorney General Opin-
ion No. 82-191 and authorities cited therein.
6. "Educational expenses for member/members of Economic
Development Committee to attend Industrial Development semin-
ars, schools, workshops. Expenses would include travel, room
and board, tuitions, registration fees."
According to Rhyne, supra, the recent cases have held that
the traveling expenses of government officials on official
business are for a valid public purpose. Again, to the ex-
tent that such expenses bear a reasonable relationship to
the economic development of Seward County, same would be an
authorized use of moneys pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4103. See
also: Frohmiller v. Bd. of Regents; 171 P.2d 356 (1946),
Gardner v. Industrial Comm'n., 233 P.2d 833 (1951); and
Louisville and Jefferson County Bd. of Health v. Steinfeld,
supra.
7. "Contributions to county-wide promotional campaign bill-
board signs, license plates, placemats, radio spots, t-shirts,
with the intent of promoting Liberal to the people of Liberal,
as well as attracting others to Liberal to live, work, and
shop."
Rhyne, supra, at p. 1026 states:
"Besides procuring the materials, supplies and
direct labor it requires, municipalities, like
businesses, must expend moneys for purposes
that only indirectly affect their daily opera-
tions. These purposes include advertising,
promotion, publicity, and the support of muni-
cipally related organizations and conventions."
We believe that such promotional activities as listed in your
inquiry are within the scope of the uses specified in K.S.A.
19-4103. However, the above-listed activities are aimed at
promoting the city of Liberal. We believe that the moneys
raised pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4102 must be expended to promote
the county's economic development as - distinguished from any
particular city within the county. We realize that Liberal
is the major population center in Seward County. However,
the tax levied pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4102 is intended to pro-
mote the county as a whole. Therefore, any promotional acti-
vities conducted pursuant to K.S.A. 19-4101 et seq. must be
intended to promote and benefit the county as a whole.
8. "Allocation of funds for tokens and gestures of apprecia-
tion to existing industries to demonstrate appreciation for
their existence in the community: gifts, periodic luncheons
represented by individuals from local companies and Committee
members."
Unless specific statutory authority exists, the general' rule
is that a municipality has no power to make a gift or dona-
tion to any person. See: Rhyne, §31.7, p. 1027, McQuillin,
Municipal Corporations, 539.30, 539.25, §28.43 and authori-
ties cited therein. We find no authority either in K.S.A.
19-4101 et seq. or in the statutory or case law governing
local units of government in Kansas that would permit the
moneys raised by the tax levy authorized by K.S.A. 19-4102
to be used for gifts or other "tokens and gestures of appre-
ciation." See, also, Attorney General Opinion No. 80-19.
9. "Funds to be used for hiring of individual/individuals
for part time administration duties, as well as supplies to
be used for administering Economic Development program (sta-
tionery, postage, copying, etc.)."
We believe that such necessary and proper administrative
overhead expenses are within the scope of the uses specified
in K.S.A. 19-4103.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 19-4103 permits expenditure of county
moneys for programs related to economic development. The
only constraints in this regard are that such expenditures
have a demonstrable and rational relation to programs of
economic development and that they satisfy the public pur-
pose doctrine.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Robert Vinson Eye
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RVE:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.