Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-228

1982-228Kanag

Testo completo

October 21, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-228
R. Scott McQuin
Barber County Attorney
P. 0. Box 142
Medicine Lodge, Kansas 67104
Re: Roads and Bridges -- Establishment -- Authority
to Grant Easements Along Township Roads
Synopsis: The board of county commissioners is empowered by
statute to lay out all public roads in a county,
even if the road is termed a township road for
purposes of maintenance. If the land underlying
a township road was taken by eminent domain, the
county acquires only an easement for road purposes,
leaving the authority to grant additional ease-
ments vested in the owners of the land abutting
the road, i.e. the fee holders of the servient
estate. Such rights are limited, however, in
that any conveyance by the fee holders may not
interfere with public use of the road. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 12-309, 19-212, 68-106, 68-114,
68-115, 68-502, 68-518c, 68-526.
* *
Dear Mr. McQuin:
As County Attorney for Barber County, you request our opinion
on a question involving the authority of the board of county
commissioners to grant an easement along a township road.
Your question is prompted by a request from the City of Kiowa
that it be allowed to install a water pipeline along 15 to
20 miles of township roads. The pipeline, which was made
necessary by contamination of the city's water wells, is to
be placed along the right of way. As the townships involved
have refused permission, the city has requested the county's
approval.
It would be our initial conclusion that the authority to grant
such easements rests with the fee owner of the land. As the
facts you present do not indicate how or by whom the roads
in question were established, we will confine this opinion to
setting forth the potential rights of the parties, once it is
determined who holds fee title.
In Kansas, public roads may be established by purchase, con-
demnation or dedication. Kratina v. Board of Commissioners,
219 Kan. 499, 502 (1976). The authority of a governmental
body to establish public roads and the nature of the govern-
ment's resulting interest in such roads is governed by statute.
See, e.g., State, ex rel., Mitchell v. State Highway Commission,
163 Kan. 187, 196 (1947). Reading together the various pro-
visions of Chapter 68, Kansas Statutes Annotated, it appears
that only the board of county commissioners has authority to
establish roads in the county. Additionally, K.S.A. 19-212,
Ninth, empowers county commissioners to "lay out, alter or
discontinue any road running through one or more townships."
Under K.S.A. 68-106, the board is to determine whether to
establish a road and to condemn such land as is needed. If
the board establishes a road, the township board thereafter
has the duty to open and maintain it and to construct such
drains and ditches as are necessary for its safety under
K.S.A. 68-115, in compliance with specifications and regula-
tions prepared by the county engineer. K.S.A. 68-526, 68-502(4).
Townships are granted general authority over all township
roads in counties not adopting the county road unit system,
as in the present case, under K.S.A. 68-526. The township
board is to have charge and supervision over all township
roads, and is authorized to levy taxes for road purposes
under K.S.A. 68-518c, and is also responsible for opening
and maintaining township roads under K.S.A. 68-115. However,
while a county has the power of eminent domain to establish
a township road, the township has no such authority. Balliet
v. Clay County Comm'rs, 115 Kan. 99, 101 (1924).
While it is clear from the above that only the county may
grant easements along township roads, the actual power to do
so is dependent upon the method by which the land was acquired,
as less than fee ownership may have been acquired. As noted
above, a county is empowered to acquire land by eminent do-
main for road purposes. K.S.A. 68-106, 68-114. When alter-
ing or changing a road, the county also is authorized to
acquire land by purchase or donation. The distinction be-
tween eminent domain and other methods of land acquisition
determines the nature of the interest conveyed. Elder v.
Franklin County Comm., 42 Kan. 652 (1889), J. & S. Bldg. Co.
v. Columbian Title & Trust Co., 1 Kan.App.2d 228 (1977). As
fee owner, the county would have absolute ownership and could
convey or grant any easement as it wishes.
In condemnation, however, "an owner parts with his property
involuntarily and the condemnor secures no greater title or
right than that permitted by the authorizing statute."
Isley v. Bogart, 338 F.2d 33, 35 (10th Cir. 1964). As there
is no statutory authority in Chapter 68 of the statutes which
allows acquisition of a fee title, the prevailing rule per-
mits the condemning authority to acquire only an easement.
Carpenter v. Fager, 188 Kan. 234, 235 (1961), Mall v. C. & W.
Rural Cooperative Ass'n., 168 Kan. 518, 521 (1950). As the
legislature has the power to determine the nature of the
title acquired by eminent domain, the taking is limited to
an easement "sufficient for the public use intended rather
than a fee title." Carpenter v. Fager, supra at 235. See,
also, State, ex rel., Mitchell v. State Highway Commission,
supra at 196.
If, as is usually the case, the road in question was estab-
lished by eminent domain, in our opinion the county acquired
only an easement, with the underlying fee remaining in the
owners of the servient estate, the abutting landowners. In
Potter v. Northern Natural Gas Co., 201 Kan. 528, 530-31
(1968), the Kansas Supreme Court defined an easement as "an
interest which one person has in the land of another . . .
[T]he land [from which the easement issues] constitutes the
servient tenement and the easement a dominant tenement." The
owner of the servient estate remains the "owner of the fee
and holder of the ultimate title . . . [A]s owner, he may
still continue to use the property for any purpose which does
not frustrate the public use for which the property was con-
demned." Carpenter v. Fager, supra at 236. See also, Aladdin
Petroleum Corp. v. Gold Crown Properties, Inc., 221 Kan. 579
(1977). Of course, the abutting landowner's interest passes
to his grantee or other successor in interest. Carpenter v.
Fager, supra at 237-238.
Accordingly, if the county possesses only an easement, it
has only the right to maintain the road for public use. The
abutting landowners, as fee holders of the servient estate,
would have the right to use any part of the affected land in
any manner not inconsistent with the public's use of the
highway. Therefore, they, not the county, have the right to
grant, sell or convey such additional easements as they wish,
as long as the use of the road is not interfered with. How-
ever, the city does possess the authority, if necessary, to
acquire such easements by condemnation. K.S.A. 12-809.
In conclusion, the board of county commissioners is empowered
by statute to lay out all public roads in a county, even if
the road is termed a township road for purposes of maintenance.
If the land underlying a township road was taken by eminent
domain, the county acquires only an easement for road pur-
poses, leaving the authority to grant additional easements
vested in the owners of the land abutting the road, i.e.,
the fee holders of the servient estate. Such rights are
limited, however, in that any conveyance by the fee holders
may not interfere with public use of the road.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.