Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-153

1982-153Kanag

Testo completo

July 9, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 153
The Honorable Elwaine F. Pomeroy
State Senator, Eighteenth District
1415 Topeka Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Consumer Credit Code -- Consumer Loans -- Finance
Charge; Effect of Amendments Passed in Same
Legislative Session
Synopsis: During the 1982 session of the Legislature, both
Senate Bill Nos. 559 and 595 were enacted into
law. As each of the two measures contains a section
amending K.S.A. 16a-2-401, they should, if possible,
be considered together in order to give effect to
both. In that they alter different subsections
of the statute, the two measures are not in con-
flict. Even though the changes made by S.B. No.
595 are not reflected in S.B. No. 559, K.S.A.
16a-2-401 may be read to include the changes made
by both acts. Cited herein: K.S.A. 16a-2-201,
16a-2-401, 1982 Senate Bill No. 559, 1982 Senate
Bill No. 595.
*
Dear Senator Pomeroy:
You request the opinion of this office on a question which
concerns the effect to be given to two measures which were
enacted by the 1982 Legislature. Both of the bills originated
in the Senate, and were designated as Nos. 559 and 595, respec-
tively. In that the two bills were both approved by the
legislature and signed by the governor, you inquire concern-
ing the effect of an inconsistency between the two regarding
K.S.A. 16a-2-401.
Found in the Kansas Consumer Credit Code, K.S.A. 16a-2-401
contains a number of provisions regarding consumer loans made
by supervised lenders. Of relevance here are the following
subsections (as they read prior to the 1982 Legislative
Session):
"(1) With respect to a consumer loan, includ-
ing a loan pursuant to open end credit, a len-
der may contract for and receive a finance
charge, calculated according to the actuarial
method, not exceeding 18% per year on the un-
paid balance of the amount financed not exceed-
ing $1,000 and 14.45% per year on that portion
of the unpaid balance in excess of $1,000.
"(2) As an alternative to the rates set forth
in subsection (1), with respect to a supervised
loan made under a license issued by the admin-
istrator, including a loan pursuant to open
end credit, a supervised lender may contract
for and receive a finance charge, calculated
according to the actuarial method, not exceed-
ing the equivalent of the greater of either of
the following:
"The total of (a) 36% per year on that part of
the unpaid balance of the amount financed
which is $300 or less; and
"(b) twenty-one percent per year on that part
of the unpaid balance of the amount financed
which is more than $300, but does not exceed
$1,000; and
"(c) fourteen and forty-five hundredths per-
cent per year on that portion of the unpaid
balance of the amount financed which is more
than $1,000; or
"(d) eighteen percent per year on the unpaid
balance of the amount financed.
• • •
"(8) As an alternative to the rates set forth
in subsection (1) and subsection (2)(d), dur-
ing the period beginning on the effective date
of this act and ending July 1, 1982, a super-
vised financial organization may contract for
and receive a finance charge not exceeding 18%
per year on the unpaid balance of the amount
financed."
We note that the last subsection quoted hereinabove was added
to the statute in 1980 (Ch. 77, §3), and originally contained
an expiration date of July 1, 1981. During the 1981 session,
the subsection was further amended to extend the date to
July 1, 1982. (Ch. 94, §3).
During the most recent session, K.S.A. 16a-2-401 was amended
by two different senate bills. The first, No. 559, enrolled
and presented to Governor Carlin on April 1, 1982, was to
become effective upon publication in the statute book. In its
final form, it bore no resemblance to the measure originally
introduced by the Senate Commercial and Financial Institutions
Committee. Although initially dealing solely with K.S.A.
16a-2-202, which relates to consumer sales, the bill was al-
tered in the House to amend only K.S.A. 16a-2-401, relating to
consumer loans. The "over-ride" provision contained in sub-
section (8) was not affected in any way by the language which
was eventually approved. Rather, a new subsection was inserted
which authorized adjustable rate loans, an area upon which the
Code had hitherto been silent.
The other bill which amended K.S.A. 16a-2-401, S.B. No. 595, was
also introduced by the Senate Commercial and Financial Insti-
tutions Committee, was enrolled and presented to the governor
on April 30, 1982, and was to become effective upon publication
in the statute book. This measure contains no reference to the
additional language of Senate Bill No. 559, which had been
signed into law by the date of enrollment of the former bill.
However, it does contain changes to the over-ride language of
subsection (8), in that the date upon which the subsection
lapses is changed from July 1, 1982 to July 1, 1983. Addi-
tionally, a supervised lender is allowed to charge 21%, rather
than 18%, as an alternative to the rates set forth earlier in
the statute.
In determining the effect to be given to these two bills, we
are guided by a frequently-stated rule of statutory construc-
tion, namely that
"[l]aws enacted by the same legislature about
the same time and concerning the same subject-
matter, being in pari materia, are to be taken
and considered together in order to determine
the legislative purpose and arrive at the true
result." In re Hall, Petitioner, 38 Kan. 670,
Syl. 1, (1888).
See also State ex rel. v. McCombs, 125 Kan. 92 (1928), Millhaubt
v. McKee, 141 Kan. 181 (1935). In the Hall case, it was es-
tablished that two measures enacted at the same time which are
apparently in conflict must be read together and, whenever
possible, reconciled to form a consistent whole. Insofar as
repeals by implication are not favored by the law, only when
this is impossible should other rules of statutory construction
be employed to determine which act takes precedence. Millhaubt,
supra, at 183, 184.
In the McCombs case, the court was faced with a situation
where two acts of the legislative session of 1907 were in
apparent conflict. Although the court did determine that por-
tions of one act were superseded by the other, it reached
this conclusion reluctantly, and only after first quoting
from an earlier decision:
"Where a conflict , exists between a later and
an earlier act of the legislature, and where
the later act does not attempt to cover all
the provisions of the earlier act, both acts
ordinarily remain in force except on the point
where the acts are in conflict, in which re-
spect the later act supersedes, repeals or mo-
difies the inconsistent terms of the earlier
enactment. (Bank v. Reilly, 97 Kan. 817 [Opin-
ion on Rehearing, p. 827, syl. ¶3], 157 Pac.
391.)"
In our opinion, in the present situation it is unnecessary to
find that one of the two measures must be superseded by the
other. We base this conclusion on the above-quoted rules of
statutory construction, as well as the particular-facts here.
While both Senate Bill Nos. 559 and 595 amend the same sta-
tute, they do not alter identical provisions, as the former
adds a totally new subsection and the latter alters an exist-
ing subsection left unchanged by No. 559. There is no point
upon which the acts are directly in opposition, as would be
the case if both set new, but different, interest rates in
subsection (8). Therefore, as the two measures are not "in
conflict" as to any particular "point," both may be given
force and effect.
In conclusion, during the 1982 session of the Legislature,
both Senate Bill Nos. 559 and 595 were enacted into law. As
each of the two measures contains a section amending K.S.A.
16a-2-401, they should, if possible, be considered together
in order to give effect to both. In that they alter differ-
ent subsections of the statute, the two measures are not in
conflict. Even though the changes made by S.B. No. 595 are
not reflected in S.B. No. 559, K.S.A. 16a-2-401 may be read
to include the changes made by both acts.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.