Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-143

1982-143Kanag

Testo completo

June 30, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 143
Donald 0. Phelps
Consumer Credit Commissioner
535 Kansas Avenue, Suite 1114
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Consumer Credit Code -- Limitations on Consumer's
Liability -- Balloon Payments; Denial of Right to
Refinance
Synopsis: K.S.A. 16a-3-308 of the Consumer Credit Code gives
a consumer certain protections against the use of
a balloon payment, i.e., a scheduled payment that
is more than twice as large as the average of ear-
lier scheduled payments. The consumer has the
right to refinance the balloon payment at the time
it is due without penalty and at terms that are no
less favorable to him or her than those of the
original transaction. In that this section is
clearly designed for the protection of consumers,
a consumer is not obligated to affirmatively ex-
ercise this right, and a seller, lender or lessor
may not, merely by the failure of a consumer to
request the same terms, proceed to extend more
onerous terms than those in the original agreement.
Such conduct would result in an impermissible
waiver by the consumer of rights given by the
Code (K.S.A. 16a-1-107) and additionally could be
found unconscionable (K.S.A. 16a-5-108). Cited
herein: K.S.A. 16a-1-101, 16a-1-102, 16a-1-107,
16a-3-308, 16a-5-108, 16a-6-111.
Dear Commissioner Phelps:
As Consumer Credit Commissioner for Kansas, you request our
opinion on the interpretation to be given to a section of
the Consumer Credit Code ("Code"), K.S.A. 16a-1-101 et seq.
Specifically, you inquire concerning K.S.A. 16a-3-308, which
relates to the rights of a consumer in the refinancing of a
so-called balloon payment.
As amended by the 1981 Legislature, K.S.A. 16a-3-308 states:
"With respect to a consumer credit transac-
tion, other than one pursuant to open end
credit, if any scheduled payment is more than
twice as large as the average of earlier sche-
duled payments, the consumer has the right to
refinance the amount of that payment at the
time it is due without penalty. The terms of
the refinancing shall be no less favorable to
the consumer than the terms of the original
transaction. These provisions do not apply to
the extent that the payment schedule is ad-
justed to the seasonal or irregular income of
the consumer."
While fairly plain on its face, the statute has been inter-
preted by some so as to have a different result than that
taken by your office. While you read the statute to leave
a seller, lender or lessor no option but to refinance a
balloon payment at terms that are as favorable as those
initially agreed to by the consumer, this alternate reading
would require a consumer to affirmatively exercise this
right. In the absence of such action, a seller, lender or
lessor would be free to offer refinancing terms different
than in the original agreement.
Initially, we would note that nowhere in K.S.A. 16a-3-308 is
an express notice requirement set out, as is the case in at
least one other state which has also adopted the _Code. See,
e.g. Colorado Revised Statutes §5-3-402. However, in our
opinion the absence of such a clause in the Kansas statute
does not require the adoption of the latter interpretation
noted above. Rather, it would be our conclusion that, if
the purpose of the statute is considered, as well as that
of other sections of the Code, the controlling legislative
intent behind K.S.A. 16a-3-308 gives support to the interpre-
tation reached by your office.
A useful background to the purpose of the statute is provided
by the 1973 Kansas Comment written by Professor Barkley Clark.
Therein, Professor Clark notes:
"Balloon payments can be used to induce a buyer
or borrower to enter into a burdensome contract
by offering him invitingly small installment
payments until the end of the contract when
the buyer or borrower is confronted with a
ballon payment too large to pay. This section
meets that threat by giving the buyer or bor-
rower the right to have the amount of the bal-
loon payment refinanced under terms no less
favorable than those of the original sale or
loan. Under the refinancing, the size of the
installment payments may not exceed the aver-
age scheduled payments excluding the balloon
payment and the rate of finance charge may not
exceed that under the original agreement. If
the balloon payment was agreed to by the par-
ties to accommodate the buyer or borrower be-
cause of his seasonal or irregular income ex-
pectations, the abuse at which the section is
aimed is not present and the section does not
apply. Agricultural notes and contracts are
also excluded. Prior Kansas law contained no
limits on balloon notes."
Additional help is provided by the Official Comment to this
section adopted by the National Conference of Comm ssioners
on Uniform Laws, which notes that the section's p pose "is
to protect consumers against deceptive or unfair se of irreg-
ular payments." These comments indicate an interpretation of
the section by the authors, as well as of the statute itself
by a well-known commentator, that looks to a broad, and not
a narrow, protection for consumers. Such a reading would be
inconsistent with an implied requirement that a consumer must
affirmatively ask for the same terms before a seller, lender
or lessor would have to supply them.
Such a narrow interpretation would also conflict with other
sections of the Code. At K.S.A. 16a-1-102(1), it- is stated
that the Code should be liberally construed to promote its
underlying purposes and policies. One such purpose, set out
at subsection (2)(d) of the same statute, is "to protect con-
sumer buyers, lessees and borrowers against unfair practices
by some suppliers of consumer credit." Additionally, as pro-
vided by K.S.A. 16a-1-107(1), a consumer may not waive rights
or benefits under the Code. By declining to inform a consumer
of her or his rights under K.S.A. 16a-3-308, a seller, lender
or lessor would be permitting just such a waiver.
Finally, although the facts of such situations could vary
widely, we should also note that K.S.A. 16a-5-108, which pro-
hibits unconscionable agreements, might also apply. The un-
conscionable agreement would not be the initial transaction,
but would instead be the new agreement by which the balloon
is refinanced at, for example, a higher rate of interest.
The latter agreement could be found to have been induced by
unconscionable conduct where it is made possible, for example,
through the silence of the seller, lender or lessor as to
K.S.A. 16a-3-308's existence. Such a finding by your office
could trigger action under K.S.A. 16a-6-111 to restrain a
creditor from so acting.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 16a-3-308 of the Consumer Credit Code
gives a consumer certain protections against the use of a
balloon payment, i.e., a scheduled payment that is more than
twice as large as the average of earlier scheduled payments.
The consumer has the right to refinance the balloon payment
at the time it is due without penalty and at terms that are
no less favorable to him or her than those of the original
transaction. In that this section is clearly designed for
the protection of consumers, a consumer is not obligated to
affirmatively exercise this right, and a seller, lender or
lessor may not, merely by the failure of a consumer to re-
quest the same terms, proceed to extend more onerous terms
than those in the original agreement. Such conduct would
result in an impermissible waiver by the consumer of rights
given by the Code (K.S.A. 16a-1-107) and additionally could
be found unconscionable (K.S.A. 16a-5-108).
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:JSS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.