Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-101

1982-101Kanag

Testo completo

May 4, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 101
The Honorable David L. Webb
State Representative, Twenty-Seventh District
Box 163
Stilwell, Kansas 66085
Re: Taxation--Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax--
Constitutionality of Tax Imposed Upon Gross
Receipts Received from the Sale of Newspapers
Synopsis: The Kansas retailers' sales tax imposed upon the
gross receipts received from the sale of newspapers
at retail does not abridge the freedom of the press
guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth Amendments
to the Federal Constitution. Cited herein:
U. S. Const., Amends. I and XIV, §1.
* *
Dear Representative Webb:
You request our opinion as to the constitutionality of the
Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act. Specifically, you ask whether
the tax imposed upon the gross receipts received from the sale
of newspapers at retail abridges the freedom of the press
guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the Federal
Constitution.
The constitutionality of a state sales tax which included within
its scope sales from the publication of newspapers was considered
in Giragi v. Moore, 64 P.2d 819, appeal dismissed, 301 U.S. 670
(1936). In that case, it was contended that the imposition of
a sales tax at the rate of 1% upon the gross proceeds received
from the publication of newspapers constituted "a previous
restraint upon the business of publishing a newspaper." In
rejecting said contention, the Arizona Supreme Court stated
as follows:
"It is obvious the tax will reduce to
its extent the net income of all persons
required to pay it, including newspaper
publishers. Every business taxed faces
the same problem. If security of life and
property were possible without expense,
taxes could be forgotten, but, since that
is not possible, all who share the protection
given by the government should also share the
expense of that protection in proportion to
their ability, regardless of the business
they are engaged in, if it is for profit.
The mere fact that a tax reduces a person's
net income is no legal restraint on him or
his business. If the taxpayer is a newspaper
publisher, it must appear that the law not
only 'takes money from the pockets,' but
also that the law was adopted by the state
as a 'form of previous restraint upon print-
ed publications, or their circulation.' If
it is so adopted, then, however small the
tax may be, it is bad and in violation of
due process. It is not the amount of the
tax, but the use of it as a means to abridge
the freedom of the press, that is forbidden.
The adoption of chapter 77, supra, was for
the sole purpose of raising revenue and is,
therefore, not within the spirit of the
prohibition of the Fourteenth Amendment
against depriving one of the fundamental
right of due process." (Emphasis added.)
64 P.2d at 822.
In our opinion, the Kansas retailers' sales tax, like the
Arizona sales tax considered in Giragi, was imposed for the
sole purpose of raising revenue, and was not enacted as a means
of abridging the freedom of the press. Therefore, in our judgment,
the Kansas retailers' sales tax imposed upon the gross receipts
received from the sale of newspapers at retail does not abridge
the freedom of the press guaranteed by the First and Fourteenth
Amendments to the Federal Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.