Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-095

1982-095Kanag

Testo completo

April 26, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-95
The Honorable Fred W. Rosenau
State Representative, 39th District
3050 South 65th Street
Kansas City, Kansas 66106
The Honorable David L. Webb
State Representative, 27th District
Box 163
Stilwell, Kansas 66085
Re: Counties and County Officers--Public Improvements--
Sewer Districts; Collection of Special Assessments
and Enforcement of Delinquencies
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 19-2731 et seq., a board of county
commissioners is empowered to raise money for the
construction of both main and lateral sewers through
the issuance of general obligation bonds. Said
bonds shall be paid for through the making of special
assessments on the land in the district, and, at
the option of the board of county commissioners,
on the improvements thereto (K.S.A. 19-27,153). These
assessments are to be collected in the same manner
as other property taxes. Accordingly, the failure by
a property owner to pay such an assessment subjects
the property to sale by the county. In the event of
a dispute over the amount or validity of such an
assessment, a property owner must follow procedures
established by statute for challenging the assessment,
and cannot as an alternative withhold the disputed
portion from the total taxes and assessments due on
the property. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-2735, 19-2737,
60-907, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 60-2301, 79-2004, 79-2005,
K.S.A. 79-2302.
Dear Representatives Rosenau and Webb:
As state representatives from districts located in whole or in
part in Johnson County, you request our opinion on two questions
which relate to special assessments. Specifically, you inquire
whether the owner of property which is subject to such an assess-
ment may withhold payment of the amount due if he contests the
manner in which the assessment has been levied. Further, you
ask whether, in the event of non-payment, a property owner's
residence may be subject to sale by the county for such assessments.
Briefly, you inform us that a sewer district was organized at
some time in the past by Johnson County in the area near Stanley,
Kansas. Designated as Blue River District No. 5, you state that
the district was originally designed to provide service for a
number of new residences and other buildings. Due to various
factors, only a few of these anticipated structures have actually
been built. As a result, you state that the lots which have
been developed, together with existing residences, face large
special assessments, so large in fact some property owners are
faced with the possibility of nonpayment.
Your first inquiry concerns whether the affected property owners
may elect to withhold payment of the assessments in question,
while at the same time continuing to pay all other assessments
and ad valorem levies. We presume that under such a scenario
such withholding would continue until an adjustment in the amount
of the assessment could be made, or another solution reached.
In our opinion, under present law such an option is not avail-
able to property owners in the district. The controlling statutes
in this area, K.S.A. 19-2731 et seq., empower the board of county
commissioners to establish and develop both main and lateral
sewer districts, which developments may be financed through the
issuance of general obligation bonds. The principal and interest
payments on such bonds are paid through the levying of special
assessments. In speaking to the manner of collecting such assess-
ments, K.S.A. 19-2735 (concerning main sewer districts) and 19-2737
(lateral sewer districts) contain virtually identical wording. For
example, K.S.A. 19-2735 states that:
"The amount to raise such fund shall be
levied and collected annually as one tax
in addition to other taxes and assessments
and shall be by the county clerk, and when
so ordered by the board of county commis-
sioners, placed upon the tax roll for col-
lection, subject to the same penalties,
entitled to the same rebate, and collected
in the same manner as other taxes." (Emphasis
added.)
From the above, it is clear that special assessments for such
sewer districts should be treated for collection purposes in
the same manner as ad valorem taxes levied by governmental units
pursuant to general taxing authority. This principle has been
established in Kansas since at least 1890, when the Supreme
Court decided Sanger v. Rice, 43 Kan. 580. At issue there was
an assessment made by the city of Fort Scott for the surfacing
of streets, which assessment was to be "levied and collected as
one tax, in addition to the taxes for general revenue purposes."
43 Kan. at 588. The court viewed the assessment as identical
to a tax for purposes of collection, a conclusion which we
reach here as well. General authorities, it may also be noted,
also recognize the similar nature of the two types of levies.
See 14 McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §§38.255, 38.311 (1970).
As this is the case, one may look to those statutes which govern
the collection of ad valorem taxes. Specifically, K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 79-2001 et seq. provide the manner in which a county
treasurer collects taxes on real property. Pursuant to this
procedure, a tax statement is sent to each ta xpayer by December 15,
with the latter given two options (by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-2004)
as to payment, namely payment in full by December 20 or one-half
on that date and one-half on the following June 20. No discretion
is given a taxpayer to tender, nor the county treasurer to accept,
any payments other than the above. Rather, if a taxpayer feels
that all or a part of the taxes are based on illegal or void
assessments, he is limited to paying the amounts due, and then
initiating protest procedures. K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 79-2005.
[Alternatively, injunctive relief may be available under K.S.A.
60-907(a).] In our opinion, the same would be true here, i.e.,
a property owner could not withhold payment of the disputed amount
pending some type of future resolution.
Your second question concerns the possible result if the special
assessment imposed for the sewer district is not paid. As the
statutes authorizing such assessments state that they are to be
subject to the same penalties as other taxes, we may again look
to general law on the subject. Such statutes are found at K.S.A.
79-2301 et seq., wherein are set out the procedures to be followed
if taxes on real estate are not paid. K.S.A. 79-2302 provides
that affected parcels may be sold for the amount of the delinquent
taxes and legal charges which are due thereon. In light of the
wording of K.S.A. 19-2735 and 19-2737 concerning the collection
of sewer district assessments, there can be no question that the
county is empowered to proceed with the sale of properties on
which such assessments are not paid, pursuant to K.S.A. 79-2301
et seq. See, e.g. Challiss v. Parker, 11 Kan. 384, 393 (1873).
Nor in our opinion is the protection of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 60-2301
available. That statute, creating an exemption from forced sales
for a homestead, states that "no property shall be exempt from
sale for taxes." (Emphasis added.) Given all of the above
authorities, special assessments would again clearly be considered
as "taxes," and so be excluded from the general homestead exemption.
In conclusion, a board of county commissioners is empowered
to raise money for the construction of both main and lateral
sewers through the issuance of general obligation bonds. Said
bonds shall be paid for through the making of special assess-
ments on the land in the district, and, at the option of the
board of county commissioners, on the improvements thereto
(K.S.A. 19-27,153). These assessments are to be collected in
the same manner as other property taxes. Accordingly, the fail-
ure by a property owner to pay such an assessment subjects the
property to sale by the county. In the event of a dispute over
the amount or validity of such an assessment, a property owner
must follow procedures established by statute for challenging the
assessment, and cannot as an alternative withhold the disputed
portion from the total taxes and assessments due on the property.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
(/Jeffrey S. Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:WRA:JSS:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.