Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-076

1982-076Kanag

Testo completo

April 1, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-76
Honorable Kenneth W. Green
Representative, Seventy-Fifth District
Room 157 East, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas
Re: Automobiles and Other Vehicles--Registration of
Vehicles--Collection and Use of Registration Fees
Synopsis: The county treasurer has control over the means by
which the duties imposed under the state motor
vehicle registration laws are to be fulfilled. Thus,
the county treasurer, and not the board of county
commissioners, has the authority to fix the salaries
of the necessary help needed to fulfill those duties.
However, the county has no responsibility or authority
to give financial assistance to the county treasurer
in regard to the administration of the state motor
vehicle registration laws. The financial resources
available to the county treasurer to administer these
laws are confined, by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145, to the
amount deposited in the special fund provided for in
that statute. (Attorney General Opinion No. 77-39 is
withdrawn.) Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145.
*
Dear Representative Green:
On behalf of the Butler County Treasurer, you seek an opinion
in regard to the provisions of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145. Specifically,
you pose the following questions:
"Does the treasurer have complete control
to set the salaries of the necessary help
needed to perform the duties required under
the statutes pertaining to the motor vehicle
registration?
"Should the fees received for the operation
of that office by the county treasurer be
insufficient to meet all the .salaries including
the salary of the county treasurer and incidentals,
would the county general fund be required to
supplement the difference?
"To what extent does the Board of County Com-
missioners have control over the operations of
that department?"
K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145 specifies that all registration and
certificate of title fees shall be paid to the county treasurer
and that
"[t]he county treasurer shall deposit seventy-
five cents (750) of each license application,
seventy-five cents (750) out of each application
for transfer of license number plates and . . .
two dollars ($2) out of each application for a
certificate of title, collected by such treasurer
under this act, in a special fund, which fund
is hereby appropriated for the use of the county
treasurer in paying for necessary help and expenses
incidental to the administration of duties in ac-
cordance with the provisions of this law and extra
compensation to the county treasurer for the services
performed in administering the provisions of this
act . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
The statute also provides that the extra compensation to be paid
the county treasurer "shall be in addition to any other compensa-
tion provided by any other law." A method for computing the extra
compensation, and a maximum amount thereof, are prescribed in the
statute.
The law then provides:
"The total amount of compensation paid said
treasurer together with the amounts expended
in paying for other necessary help and expenses
incidental to the administration of the duties
of the county treasurer in accordance with the
provisions of this act, shall not exceed the
amount deposited in such special fund. Any
balance remaining in such fund at the close
of any calendar year shall be withdrawn and
credited to the general fund of the said county."
(Emphasis added.)
Section 8-145 is a part of the statutes relating to the registration
of motor vehicles. The section originally was enacted shortly
after the turn of this century. It has been amended a number
of times since its original enactment, but, since 1937, the section
has required that the county treasurer deposit certain prescribed
amounts of the fees collected in a special fund, which fund is
appropriated, by the legislature, for the use of the county
treasurer in paying for "necessary help and expenses incidental
to the administration of the duties" required under the motor
vehicle registration laws. See Wyandotte County Comm'rs v.
Ferguson, 159 Kan. 80, 85-86 (1944).
There has long existed confusion over the powers and responsibilities
of the county treasurer and those of the board of county commissioners
in light of the provisions of this section. The confusion was dis-
sipated somewhat by Wyandotte County Comm'rs v. Ferguson, supra,
where the Court said: "It is . . . perfectly clear . . . that the
county treasurers are used by the state for state purposes . . .
[and] that the treasurer and not the board [of county commissioners]
is charged with administrative responsibilities under the act."
159 Kan. at 85. The Court also concluded that the money in the
special fund did not constitute part of the county general fund
and the county treasurer was free to expend moneys from this fund
without interference by the board of county commissioners.
Given these statements of the Court, we are of the opinion that,
subject to the direction of the legislature and the constraints
of the financial resources available, the county treasurer has the
exclusive authority to establish the salaries to be paid from the
special fund created under the provisions of K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
8-145 to those persons who provide the "necessary help" incidental
to the administration of the state motor vehicle registration laws.
However, under the express direction of the legislature in K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 8-145, the total amount expended for such necessary help,
together with the expenses of the treasurer incidental to the
administration of those laws and the extra compensation paid the
treasurer, cannot "exceed the amount deposited" in the special fund
provided for in the statute. In this regard, it must be noted
that no provision is made in the statute for supplementation of
the amount deposited in the special fund. Thus, we are constrained
to conclude that no moneys in the county general fund may be used
to augment the special fund created by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145.
It appears the legislature has limited the funds available to
the county treasurer in administering the state motor vehicle
registration laws to that deposited in the special fund. If
that amount is insufficient, we believe the request for additional
funds should be made to the legislature, not to the board of
county commissioners.
In reaching the foregoing conclusion, we have not overlooked
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-39, in which an opposite conclusion
was reached. In that opinion, however, neither the Ferguson
decision, nor the last-quoted provisions of K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
8-145, were mentioned, although both were in existence at the time
the opinion was issued. We believe that failure to consider these
provisions produced an erroneous conclusion. Therefore, Attorney
General Opinion No. 77-39 is hereby withdrawn.
Finally, in regard to your inquiry concerning the degree of
control the board of county commissioners has over the operations
of the county treasurer's motor vehicle registration department,
we can only reiterate the Court's statement in Ferguson, supra,
that it is the county treasurer and not the board of county
commissioners who is charged with administrative responsibilities
under the state motor vehicle registration laws. Given this
statement, we must conclude that no authority is vested in the
board, under this statute, to "control" the operations of the
county treasurer in fulfilling the duties imposed under the state
motor vehicle registration laws.
However, this conclusion is limited to the operations of the
county treasurer in fulfilling those specific duties. We are
not suggesting that the board of county commissioners, in pre-
scribing the annual county budget, lacks the authority to pre-
scribe the total amount of moneys from the county general fund
which shall be available to the county treasurer in the next
ensuing fiscal year. Clearly, the Board has this authority.
K.S.A. 19-235, 19-241, 28-167, 28-824, 79-1802, and 79-2925 et seq.
Therefore, while the board of county commissioners is not charged
with administrative responsibilities under the state motor vehicle
registration laws, and thus lacks the authority to prescribe
limits upon expenditures made by the county treasurer from the
special fund created under 8-145, the board of county commissioners
does retain the right and the responsibility to establish, through
the adoption of the county budget, the total amount of county
general fund moneys that are available to the county treasurer
in performing those duties of the treasurer, other than those
imposed under the state motor vehicle registration laws. To
this extent, the board of county commissioners does have "control"
over the office of the county treasurer.
In summary, it is our opinion that the county treasurer has control
over the means by which the duties imposed under the state motor
vehicle registration laws are to be fulfilled. Thus, the county
treasurer, and not the board of county commissioners, has the
authority to fix the salaries of the necessary help needed to
fulfill those duties. However, the county has no responsibility
or authority to give financial assistance to the county treasurer
in regard to the administration of the state motor vehicle regis-
tration laws. The financial resources available to the county
treasurer to administer these laws are confined, by the provision
of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 8-145, to the amount deposited in the special
fund provided for in that statute.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.