Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-032

1982-032Kanag

Testo completo

February 8, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 32
Ms. Susan Marshall
Lincoln County Attorney
P. 0. Box 36
Lincoln, Kansas 67455
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Hospitals -- Power
of Board of Trustees to Finance Medical Education
Synopsis: The county hospital enabling laws do not authorize
a hospital board of trustees to expend hospital
funds to pay for the education of a medical student
for the purpose of obtaining that student's promise
to practice in a certain area. However, county
home rule power pursuant to K.S.A. 19-101a may be
used to enable the county hospital board of trus-
tees to contract with a medical student for future
services. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101a, 19-1801
and 19-1804.
Dear Ms. Marshall:
You request our opinion regarding the authority of the Lincoln
County Hospital Board of Trustees to expend hospital funds to
give or loan money to a medical student, in order to obtain a
promise from that student to practice in your area upon gradua-
tion and completion of internship and residency requirements.
In addition, you ask about several alternative methods for
accomplishing this objective. Because your questions all per-
tain to the ability of the board of trustees to expend hospi-
tal funds for the contemplated purpose, we will determine
whether Kansas law authorizes this action before entering into
any discussion of your specific questions.
A county hospital board of trustees is a governmental agency
and, as such, has only those powers expressly conferred by law
and those necessary to make effective the powers expressly
conferred. See Murray v. State Board of Regents, 194 Kan.
686 (1965), and Kansas Power Co. v. Fairbanks, Morse, & Co.,
142 Kan. 109 (1935). Express authority for undertaking the
action in question does not exist, but, as you note, K.S.A.
19-1804 does allow the board to "expend funds deemed neces-
sary in the recruitment of professional staff." This lan-
guage was added to K.S.A. 19-1804 and to the enabling statutes
for city, township and district hospitals by L. 1972, ch. 44.
An examination of the legislative history of this enactment
shows no intent to allow hospital boards to finance the edu-
cation of medical students, in return for a promise to prac-
tice in a certain geographical area. The minutes of the
Senate Public Health and Welfare Committee on February 2,
1972 show the following:
"Chairman Thomas advised that the committee
would break from the hearings on Substitute
for Senate Bill No. 291 to hear from Senator
Smith on S.B. 584 - AN ACT CONCERNING CITY,
TOWNSHIP, COUNTY AND DISTRICT HOSPITALS.
Senator Smith advised that even though this
bill is lengthy, it basically only makes one
change in the law and that is to allow hospi-
tals to spend funds for recruitment of hospi-
tal personnel. Senator Janssen asked if this
could open the way for hospitals to pay a por-
tion or all of a student's expenses during
medical school as an enticement to come back
to the hospital. Senator Smith does not invi-
sion [sic] this."
Additionally, we note that the arrangement contemplated here
is not the normal method for recruitment of professional staff.
Attorney General Schneider notes in Attorney General Opinion
No. 77-315, that recruiting expenses normally include "such
items as travel for interviews, lodging and other subsistence,
and perhaps moving expenses and like costs which the prospec-
tive employer agrees to defray in order to encourage and
facilitate the recruitment of professional staff." Because
these other methods of effectively exercising the express
power granted by K.S.A. 19-1804 are available, we cannot
say as a matter of law that the expenditure of county hospital
funds to finance a medical student's education, in return for
the student's promise to practice in a certain area, is a pow-
er clearly necessary to the effective exercise of the power
expressly granted. This determination makes it unnecessary
to discuss whether medical students fit within the term
"professional staff."
Since we have concluded that the hospital board of trustees
does not have by statute the authority to perform the action
in question, it is necessary to point out that such power
may reside in the county through use of its home rule power.
We determined in Attorney General Opinion 81-37 that a board
of county commissioners may empower the hospital board of
trustees to do certain acts, when those acts are within the
county's home rule power granted by K.S.A. 19-101a. Because
the action contemplated here does not appear to be contrary to
any uniformly applicable act of the legislature, it would be
within the authority of the board of county commissioners
to authorize the expenditure of county hospital funds for
the purpose of giving or loaning sufficient funds to a medi-
cal student to obtain that student's promise to practice in
a certain area.
Since the above analysis seems to answer the substance of
your questions, they will not be addressed individually. To
summarize, it is our opinion that the county hospital enabling
laws do not authorize a county hospital board of trustees to
expend hospital funds to pay for the education of a medical
student for the purpose of obtaining that student's promise
to practice in a certain area. However, county home rule
power pursuant to K.S.A. 19-101a may be used to enable the
county hospital board of trustees to contract with a medical
student for future services.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
BradleyJ.Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.