Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-078

1981-078Kanag

Testo completo

April 7, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81-78
Mr. David E. Retter
Peoples Savings and Loan Bldg., Suite A
P. 0. Box 676
Concordia, Kansas 66901
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Buildings, Structures
and Grounds -- Unsafe and Immediately Hazardous
Structures
Synopsis: K.S.A. 12-1750 et seq. do not authorize cities
to repair unsafe structures except where such
structures are immediate hazards. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 12-1750, 12-1752, 12-1753, 12-1755, 12-1756
Dear Mr. Retter:
As counsel for the City Council of the City of Tipton, Kansas
you request our opinion regarding the power of the city to
repair unsafe structures pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1750 et seq.
You state that apparent inconsistencies within these statutes
present the question of whether a city has authority to repair
a dangerous or unsafe structure rather than razing or removing
the same.
K.S.A. 12-1751 et seq., are the statutes which generally grant
cities power to act in this area. K.S.A. 12-1751 states thus:
"The governing body of any city shall have
power to cause the repair or removal of, or to
remove any structure located within the city,
which may have become unsafe or dangerous."
(Emphasis added.)
This general authority allows the city to either cause repair
or removal, or to actually carry out removal. This critical
difference is consistently reflected by language in the remain-
ing provisions of these statutes. K.S.A. 12-1753 grants cities
the power to make a resolution directing the owner to repair
or remove the structure in question. Normally, the city's
authority to take action beyond this resolution is limited to
the two situations described in K.S.A. 12-1755 and 12-1756.
The former section grants the city power to take direct action
only in the event that the owner has failed to commence repair
or removal as required by the notice and resolution. That
section states in pertinent part thus:
"If the owner of any structure has failed to
commence the repair or removal of such struc-
ture within the time stated in the resolution
or has failed to diligently prosecute the same
thereafter, the city may proceed to raze and
remove such structure, make the premises safe
and secure, or let the same to contract . . . ."
(Emphasis added.)
Notably absent is any reference to the repair of the danger-
ous structure. Thus, in the usual instances when resolution
and notice to the owner ordering repair or removal of a struc-
ture are utilized, the city may proceed to remove, but not
repair, the dangerous structure from the premises after the
owner has failed to act.
The only time the city has power to take action to repair is
in the event that the structure creates an immediate hazard.
K.S.A. 12-1756 governs this situation as follows:
"When in the opinion of the enforcing officer,
any structure is in such condition as to con-
stitute an immediate hazard requiring immedi-
ate action to protect the public, such officer
may erect barricades or cause the property to
be vacated, taken down, repaired, shored or
otherwise made safe without delay and such
action may, under such circumstances, be taken
without prior notice to or hearing of the
owners, agents, lienholders and occupants.
The cost of any such action shall be assessed
against the property and paid in the manner
provided by K.S.A. 12-1755." (Emphasis added.)
The ability of a city to repair in this situation is granted
only in the event that immediate action is required to
"protect the public." Elsewhere in this act, the powers of
the city are limited to removal or the causing of others to
repair or remove their own structures.
You suggest that the power of cities to repair unsafe, but
not immediately hazardous, structures is supported by lan-
guage in K.S.A. 12-1752, the statute providing notice and
hearing requirements. The statute states in pertinent part
thus:
"Whenever the enforcing officer shall file with
the governing body of the city, a statement in
writing that any structure, describing the same
and where located, is unsafe or dangerous, said
governing body shall by resolution fix a time
and place at which the owner, his or her agent,
and lienholders of record and any occupant of
such structure may appear and show cause why
such structure should not be condemned and
ordered repaired or demolished." (Emphasis
added.)
In our opinion this language does not expand any power of
the city to repair. The statute does not grant power to the
city, it merely provides some designated persons with a forum
to show why the structure should not be ordered repaired or
demolished. We note that even if this language worked to
grant power, such power, by its terms, would be only to order
structures repaired or demolished. In our opinion the act
is not inconsistent or confusing so as to require application
of the traditional rules of statutory construction. Simply
stated, private property may be ordered removed or repaired
when such property is determined to be dangerous. Such may
only take place following notice and hearing. Failure of
the owner of dangerous property to comply with an order of
the city to repair or remove, may result in removal of the
structure by the city. On the other hand, where the struc-
ture is deemed to be an immediate hazard, notice and hearing
procedures may be dispensed with, and the city is authorized
to either remove or repair the hazardous structure.
Therefore, it is our opinion that K.S.A. 12-1750 et seq. do
not authorize cities to repair unsafe structures unless said
structures constitute immediate hazards.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT	STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Bradley	J.Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.