Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-070

1981-070Kanag

Testo completo

March 13, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81-70
Mr. Ward P. Ferguson
P. 0. Box 429
Sixth and Main Streets
McPherson, Kansas 67460
Re: Crimes and Punishments -- Crimes Against Property --
Giving A Worthless Check
Synopsis: Under various programs established by credit unions
for their respective members, whereby certain
written instruments, payable either on or through a
bank, are used by such members for the withdrawal of
money from their credit union accounts, the making,
drawing, issuing or delivering of any such instru-
ment is embraced by K.S.A. 21-3707, the worthless
check statute, in the event there are insufficient
funds on deposit to cover such instrument. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 21-3707, 84-3-102, 84-3-104, 84-3-120,
R.S. 21-554.
*
Dear Mr. Ferguson:
You request our opinion on the applicability of K.S.A. 21-3707
("worthless check statute") to instruments written in accordance
with credit union "share draft" or "expandachek" programs.
More specifically, you inquire whether there is a need to amend
the existing statute to cover these instruments.
Before examining the pertinent statutory provisions, it is
appropriate to determine the nature of the instruments prompting
your inquiry. The credit unions' programs involved here were
established so that credit union members could write "checks"
which would be covered by the members' credit union funds.
While these "checks" are eventually covered by the members'
funds in the credit union, they are not made directly payable
on the credit union, but are made payable on or through a bank
specified on the instrument. This arrangement is made possible
through an agreement between the credit union, the bank and
the credit union member. Pursuant to the agreement, the bank
accepts a member's "check" and then collects sufficient funds
to cover such "check" from the credit union, which transfers
the funds out of the member's credit union account.
Generally speaking, these instruments are very much like ordin-
ary bank checks. They contain blanks for the signature of the
drawer, for the name of the payee (along with a direction to
pay thereto), the amount in both words and figures, the date
and a number for the drawer's convenience. They usually contain
the name of the credit union where the drawer has an account and
the name of the bank on or through which the instrument is pay-
able, and they also contain the normal transit numbers and
encoded symbols along the bottom.
It is with this brief description of these instruments in mind
that we have considered the scope and coverage of K.S.A. 21-3707
and its applicability to instruments written under the various
credit union programs and accounts. That statute, in describing
the offense of giving a worthless check, states in pertinent part:
"(1) Giving a worthless check is the making,
drawing, issuing or delivering or causing or
directing the making, drawing, issuing or de-
livering of any check, order or draft on any
bank or depository for the payment of money or
its equivalent with intent to defraud and know-
ing, at the time of the making, drawing, issuing
or delivering of such check, order or draft as
aforesaid, that the maker or drawer has no de-
posit in or credits with such bank or depository
or has not sufficient funds in, or credits with,
such bank or depository for the payment of such
check, order or draft in full upon its presenta-
tion." (Emphasis added.)
The scope of this statute and its applicability to the instru-
ments in question are controlled by the above-emphasized phrase,
"any check, order or draft on any bank or depository." This
phrase was originally used when the statute was first enacted
in 1969 (L. 1969, ch. 180, §21-3707) and was retained unchanged
when the statute was amended in 1972. L. 1972, ch. 117, §1.
To gain an understanding of this phrase, however, we must
resort to rules of statutory construction.
The primary rule of construction is disclosed by the following
statement in Southeast Kansas Landowners Ass'n. v. Kansas
Turnpike Auth., 224 Kan. 357 (1978):
"The fundamental rule of statutory construction,
to which all others are subordinate, is that the
purpose and intent of the legislature governs
when that intent can be ascertained from the
statutes. Easom v. Farmers Insurance Co., 221
Kan. 415, Syl. 2, 560 P.2d 117 (1977); Thomas
County Taxpayers Ass'n. v. Finney, 223 Kan.
434, 573 P.2d 1073 (1978); Brinkmeyer v. City
of Wichita, 223 Kan. 393, 573 P.2d 1044 (1978)."
224 Kan. at 367.
The Court also has provided guidance in ascertaining the legis-
lature's intent, and we believe the following statement of the
Court to be of relevance here:
"A primary rule for the construction of a sta-
tute is to find the legislative intent from its
language, and where the language used is plain
and unambiguous and also appropriate to the
obvious purpose the court should follow the
intent as expressed by the words used and is
not warranted in looking beyond them in search
of some other legislative purpose or extending
the meaning beyond the plain terms of the Act.
(Alter v. Johnson, 127 Kan. 443, 273 Pac. 474;
Hand v. Board of Education, 198 Kan. 460, 426
P.2d 124; City of Overland Park v. Nikias, 209
Kan. 643, 498 P.2d 56; Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan.
11, 499 P.2d 1087.)" City of Kiowa v. Central
Telephone & Utilities Corporation, 213 Kan.
169, 176 (1973).
Of similar import is the Court's pronouncement in Lakeview
Gardens, Inc. v. State, ex rel. Schneider, 221 Kan. 211 (1976):
"[T]his court must ascertain and give effect
to the intent of the legislature. In so doing
we must consider the language of the statute;
its words are to be understood in their plain
and ordinary sense. (Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan.
11, 13, 499 P.2d 1087; Roda v. Williams, 195
Kan. 507, 511, 407 P.2d 471.) When a statute
is plain and unambiguous this court must give
effect to the intention of the legislature as
expressed rather than determine what the law
should or should not be. (Amoco Production
Co. v. Armold, Director of Taxation, 213 Kan.
636, 647, 518 P.2d 453; Jolly v. Kansas Public
Employees Retirement System, 214 Kan. 200, 204,
519 P.2d 1391.)" 221 Kan. at 214.
Also of pertinence to our consideration is the fact that K.S.A.
21-3707 is a penal statute. In this context, the rule of con-
struction reiterated in State v. Howard, 221 Kan. 51 (1976), is
relevant:
"We are not unaware or unmindful of the rule
requiring strict construction of penal statutes
in favor of the persons sought to be subjected
to their operation. State, ex rel., v. American
Savings Stamp Co., 194 Kan. 297, 398 P.2d 1011;
State v. Bishop, 215 Kan. 481, 483, 524 P.2d 712.
The rule simply means that ordinary words are to
be given their ordinary meaning. It does not
permit or justify a disregard of manifest leg-
islative intention appearing from plain and
unambiguous language. State v. Walden, 208 Kan.
163, 166, 167, 490 P.2d 370." 221 Kan. at 54.
In accord is State v. Logan, 198 Kan. 211 (1967), wherein the
Court states: "A penal statute should not be read so as to
add that which is not readily found therein, or to read out
what, as a matter of ordinary language, is in it." Id. at 213.
All of the foregoing authority suggests that, where a statute
is plain and unambiguous, its meaning is to be derived from
the language of the statute itself, and that the words used
are to be understood by their plain and ordinary meanings,
particularly where the statute is penal in character. Although
we have discerned no ambiguity in the provisions of 21-3707,
the statute does not specifically define the terms used therein,
nor are they defined elsewhere for specific application to
this statute. However, we note that certain of the key terms
are defined elsewhere in the statutes (see K.S.A. 84-3-102,
84-3-104) and that these definitions were in existence at the
time 21-3707 was enacted as part of the Kansas Criminal Code.
We think it appropriate to utilize these statutory definitions
in discerning the plain and ordinary meanings of terms used
in 21-3707, because of the contextual similarity of their
respective usage. The statutory definitions in question have
application in the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) with respect
to the issuance of commercial paper, and this is the same
context in which these terms are used in 21-3707.
We note that support for this conclusion is found in other
well-established rules of construction. Citing Motor Equipment
Co. v. Winters, 146 Kan. 127 (1937), the Court in State, ex rel,
v. Shawnee County Commissioners, 159 Kan. 87 (1944), found that
it is essential to a determination of legislative intent "to
consider statutes in existence when the statutes involved were
enacted." Id. at 90. Furthermore, "[t]he words of a statute
must be taken in the sense in which they were understood at the
time the statute was enacted." State ex rel., v. Moore, 154
Kan. 193, 201 (1941).
The sections of the UCC referenced above (84-3-102 and 84-3-104)
were enacted in 1965 (L. 1965, ch. 564, §§123, 125) and, thus,
were in existence at the time 21-3707 was enacted in 1969. The
UCC, of course, contains a vast body of statutory law designed
to govern the significant majority of all commercial transac-
tions. Similarly, 21-3707 is concerned with fraudulent commer-
cial transactions. As was said by the Kansas Supreme Court
with respect to the statute which preceded 21-3707, the object
of such statutes is "to discourage overdrafts and bad banking
and to stop the practice of check-kiting and avert the mischief
to trade and commerce which the circulation of worthless checks
inflicts." State v. Williams, 141 Kan. 732, 733 (1935).
For these reasons, and based on the authorities cited herein,
we believe it necessary and appropriate not only to attribute
to the legislature that enacted 21-3707 in 1969 a knowledge
and understanding of the terms used in the UCC, but to ascribe
to that legislature a further intent that the terms "check,"
"order" and "draft" used in the criminal statute be understood
within the context of the UCC.
K.S.A. 84-3-102(1)(b) defines "order" as follows:
"An 'order' is a direction to pay and must be
more than an authorization or request. It
must identify the person to pay with reasonable
certainty. It may be addressed to one or more
such persons jointly or in the alternative but
not in succession."
K.S.A. 84-3-104 prescribes the requirements for a writing to
be considered a negotiable instrument, requiring that such
writing must
"(a) be signed by the maker or drawer; and
"(b) contain an unconditional promise or order
to pay a sum certain in money and no other
promise, order, obligation or power given by
the maker or drawer except as authorized by
this article; and
"(c) be payable on demand or at a definite
time; and
"(d) be payable to order or bearer." (Emphasis
added.)
Subsequently, this same section classifies the various nego-
tiable instruments, providing in part that:
"(2) A writing which complies with the require-
ments of this section is
"(a) a 'draft' ('bill of exchange') if it is
an order;
"(b) a 'check' if it is a draft drawn on a
bank and payable on demand; . . ."
From the foregoing, it is apparent that all of the instruments
used in connection with the various credit union programs
discussed herein satisfy the definitional requirements of an
"order" contained in 84-3-102(1)(b), since such instruments
contain a direction to pay money to a specified person. How-
ever, to fit the definition of "draft" in 84-3-104, such instru-
ment additionally must either be payable on demand or at a
specified time, and to qualify as a "check" pursuant to its
definition in 84-3-104, the instrument must be a draft that
is drawn on a bank and payable only on demand.
In this regard, we have noted that certain of the instruments
about which you have inquired are "payable through" a bank,
rather than being payable by such bank on demand. Such instru-
ments are defined in K.S.A. 84-3-120, as follows: "An instru-
ment which states that is is 'payable through' a bank or the
like designates that bank as a collecting bank to make present-
ment but does not of itself authorize the bank to pay the
instrument." The Official UCC Comment following this section
in Volume 7 of Kansas Statutes Annotated explains the scope
and authority of a "payable through" bank, in part, as follows:
"The bank is not named as drawee, and it is
not ordered or even authorized to pay the in-
strument out of the drawer's account or any
other funds of the drawer in its hands:. Neither
is it required to take the instrument for col-
lection in the absence of special agreement to
that effect. It is merely designated as a col-
lecting bank through which presentment is
properly made to the drawee." (Emphasis added.)
Thus, the foregoing would suggest that an instrument devised
by agreement of a bank, credit union and members of such credit
union that draws upon such members' accounts by being "payable
through" such bank do not qualify as either a "draft" or "check."
However, there is some authority that where the draft closely
resembles an ordinary check and is generally treated by the
bank as such and where the "through" is printed inconspicuously,
the instrument will be treated as a check. Berman v. United
States Nat. Bank, 197 Neb. 268, 249 N.W.2d 187 (1976).
Notwithstanding the negotiability or non-negotiability of such
"payable through" instruments, it is apparent that these instru-
ments are, at the least, "orders" within the meaning of the
UCC. Moreover, even though such instruments are not drawn on
a bank, we believe such instruments fit within the contempla-
tion of 21-3707, since they are ultimately drawn upon the
credit union where the drawer maintains an account. It is to
be noted that 21-3707 requires that the check, order or draft
be drawn "on any bank or depository." (Emphasis added.) In
our judgment, a credit union is a depository, since it is in
the business of accepting deposits and maintaining accounts
for its members. Had the legislature intended to limit the
payors of such instruments to banks, it would not have included
the additional language, "or depository." In State v. Williams,
supra, the Court considered whether a draft drawn on a packing
house fell within the purview of R.S. 21-554, a predecessor
of 21-3707. In concluding that such draft was not covered by
the then existing worthless check statute, which applied to
a check or draft drawn on "any bank or depository," the Court
stated:
"The statute provides that it shall be a bank
or place like it, where money is deposited
subject to be drawn out on a check or draft.
There may be some other institutions, like
trust companies or treasuries, where money is
deposited subject to be drawn out at the
option of the drawer, but it is insisted that
a packing house where animals are sold and
slaughtered is not one of these. . . . The
statute is plain that the place must be one
where money is deposited to be drawn out on
the option of the depositor . . . ." (Emphasis
added.) 141 Kan. at 733.
It is clear, therefore, that the Court also recognizes that
financial institutions other than banks are included under
the worthless check statute.
Thus, it is our opinion that the instruments used to implement
the various credit union programs that are payable on demand
by a bank are either "drafts" or "checks" within the context
of the UCC and, accordingly, must be considered as such for
the purposes of K.S.A. 21-3707. Also, while it is possible
that those instruments that are "payable through" a bank may,
under certain circumstances, be viewed as "checks" or "drafts,"
these instruments are in any event "orders" and, for the
reasons just stated, must be considered as such for the pur-
poses of 21-3707.
In summary, it is our opinion that, under, programs estab-
lished by credit unions for their respective members, whereby
certain written instruments, payable either on or through a
bank, are used by such members for the withdrawal of money
from their credit union accounts, the making, drawing, issuing
or delivering of any such instrument is embraced by K.S.A.
21-3707, the worthless check statute, in the event there are
insufficient funds on deposit to cover such instrument.
In concluding, we wish to acknowledge the assistance provided
us by the Kansas Banker's Association and the Kansas Credit
Union League, through the submission of briefs by their respec-
tive counsel. We note that both briefs addressed the issue
of whether the various credit union programs discussed herein
are authorized by law. That issue was not addressed herein,
since it was unnecessary to do so in providing a response to
your specific inquiries. However, the absence of commentary
on that proposition in this opinion should not be construed
as indicating our support for either side of the issue.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.