Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-037

1981-037Kanag

Testo completo

February 9, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 37
Mr. J. Ronald Vignery
Hospital Board Attorney
Northwest Kansas Medical Center
P.O. Box 629
Goodland, Kansas 67735
Re: Counties and County Officers--Hospitals--Medical Clinics
Synopsis: (1) County hospital boards do not have power to purchase
medical clinics.
(2) Assuming the use of statutorily authorized funding
hospital boards do have the power to add to existing
medical clinics once they have been lawfully acquired.
(3) The hospital board does not have the power to use
private financing to acquire a medical clinic.
(4) That the method of purchase to be used in acquiring
a medical clinic is purchase of the corporation holding
the building does not by itself make such purchase
unlawful.
(5) The hospital board may lease a facility to be used
as a medical clinic to medical doctors, dentists, optome-
trists and pharmacists.
(6) The hospital board may not use a lease-purchase agree-
ment to acquire that which it could not acquire by normal
purchase.
(7) The county commission may purchase a medical clinic
for the hospital board using methods provided in K.S.A.
19-1801 et seq. or through use of county home rule power,
but private financing may not be used.
(8) The county commission may use county home rule power
to enable the hospital board to purchase a medical clinic,
but such power may not be used to allow private financing.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 10-1101, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1675,
K.S.A. 19-101, second, fourth, K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-101a,
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-1801, 19-1804, 19-1815e, 19-1869,
19-1878 and K.S.A. 19-18,117, 19-18,118.
Dear Mr. Vignery:
You inquire regarding the authority of the Sherman County Commission
or the Board of Trustees of the Northwest Kansas Medical Center, a
county hospital created under the authority of K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq.,
to purchase an existing structure to be used as a medical clinic. You
state that the structure in question is currently the sole asset of a
corporation whose only owner is a physician.
Specifically, you posed eight separate questions; hence, consideration
of your questions will be in the order that they were presented. We
will endeavor to include some discussion of options available to the
hospital board and county commission.
"1. May the hospital board purchase an existing facility
owned privately for use as a medical clinic? (Page
14 of your Opinion No. 79-47 at paragraph 1 at the
bottom thereof, seems to indicate that this is possible
although other language of the opinion is conflicting.)"
As you noted in your question, this office has discussed the subject of
medical clinics and county hospitals in Attorney General Opinion No.
79-47. In that opinion we determined, inter alia, that the board
of trustees of a county hospital could not purchase or construct a medical
clinic using funds derived from a bond issue or tax levy. We also
determined that funds derived from other unrestricted sources could
be used to construct a medical clinic. The power of a hospital board
to purchase a medical clinic with funds derived from unrestricted sources
was not analyzed in that opinion, but references to the question were
made in two conclusory statements. The first of these statements was
made as a summation of part one of the opinion, where we stated:
"In sum, the hospital board may not purchase or construct
a medical clinic unless the funds to be used for such
construction (not purchase) are derived from business
receipts, grants, donations or other unrestricted source."
Attorney General Opinion No. 79-47, p. 9. (Emphasis in
original.)
The second statement appears in the conclusion of the opinion as
follows:
"(1) The hospital board may not purchase or construct
a medical clinic using funds derived from a bond
issue or tax levy; however, funds derived from
other sources, not otherwise restricted, may be
used to purchase or construct a medical clinic
without an election." Id. at page 14. (Emphasis
added.)
The portions of these statements which deal with the question at issue
here are not in accord; but since that question really was not dealt
with in the above opinion the conflicting language need not be given
undue weight.
The problem with determining whether a hospital board may purchase
a medical clinic using otherwise unrestricted funds arises because
hospital boards are given authority in K.S.A. 19-18,117 to "construct
or reconstruct, maintain, operate, improve, equip, lease, rent or
enlarge medical, dental and optometric clinics." This statute is
the only authority enabling hospital boards, established pursuant to
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-1801 et seq., to acquire medical clinics, and
it does not contain language in re ference to any power to purchase
a medical clinic. Although it may seem logically consistent that a
hospital board with the power to construct, maintain, operate, improve,
equip, lease, rent or enlarge a medical clinic would also be able to
purchase a medical clinic, the language of the statute does not grant
that power. K.S.A. 19-18,117 with regard to this issue, is not, on
its face, ambiguous and thus does not invite interpretation other than
the plain meaning. Had the legislature intended to grant the power
to purchase a medical clinic the word "purchase" could have very easily
been included. In 73 Am.Jur.2d Statutes §203, it is stated:
"In this respect, it has been declared that it is not
the office of the court to insert in a statute that which
has been omitted, and that what the legislature omits,
the courts cannot supply. These rules have been regarded
as applicable to an unintentional omission." (Footnotes
omitted.)
In Eidson v. Palmquist, 188 Kan. 373, 376 (1961), the Kansas Supreme
Court stated that: "The mandate of the legislature cannot be enlarged
by supplied language or by strained interpretation." A study of the
legislative history of this act does not provide any clear indication
that it was part of the legislative intent to enable hospital boards
to purchase a medical clinic. A further indication of the propriety of
this determination is the fact that the legislature has provided alter-
native methods of acquiring (by purchase) a medical clinic through the
enumerated powers of the county commission. Alternative methods
for the purchase of a medical clinic are contained in K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
19-1869 and 19-1878.
"2. May the hospital board purchase an existing
structure for use as a medical clinic and add
to that existing structure an addition also
to be used as a medical clinic to house
physicians, dentists, optometrists, and a
pharmacy."
Although we have determined that the hospital board may not purchase
a medical clinic we will discuss the second part of this question
because of the likelihood that it may also arise when an alternative
method of purchase is used. The use to which a medical clinic is to
be put is no where delineated in the statutes. However, in K.S.A.
19-18,117 the hospital board is expressly granted the authority to
enlarge medical, dental and optometric clinics. The use of a medical
clinic to house a pharmacy is not mentioned. In addition, what is
meant by medical clinic is nowhere defined in the county hospital
laws. Generally speaking, medical clinics are common in Kansas as
facilities for the providing of out-patient medical services. Offices,
examining rooms and laboratories are essential to the delivery of
such services. Pharmacies are frequently included in office complexes
housing physicians for the conveniences of doctors and patients alike.
Common to all such uses of medical clinic space is the character of its
use, namely, delivery of out-patient medical services. K.S.A. 1980
Supp. 19-1804 grants the hospital board various powers and duties, among
them a general custodial power: "The board shall be charged with
the business-like supervision, care and custody of all hospital
property." In the absence of further clarification we must assume
that decisions regarding the space utilization of medical clinics
are matters to be determined within the sound discretion of the
hospital board of trustees.
"3. Again mindful of your Opinion No. 79-47, and
language therein indicating that the hospital board
is not subject to the Cash Basis Law, may the hospital
board finance the purchase of the existing structure
and a new addition thereto through means of private
financing as well as the use of unrestricted funds and
business receipts of this hospital?"
Here, again, we note our previous conclusion that the hospital board
does not have the authority to purchase a medical clinic. However,
we will proceed to discuss the rest of this question under the assumption
that a permissible alternative method of purchase is found which might
necessitate an answer to the question. As you have noted, we reiterated
in Attorney General Opinion No. 79-47 that county hospital boards are
not subject to the Cash Basis Law (K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq.). Hospital
boards neither have the power to create an indebtedness against the
municipality nor are they a mere administrative arm of the county. See
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-352. However, it is a commonly accepted
rule of statutory interpretation that the powers of administrative
bodies are limited to those powers expressly given or necessarily implied
from the laws creating the body and enabling its activities. 1 Am.Jur.2d
Administrative Law §70 (1962), citing Bennett v. Corp. Comm'n., 157 Kan.
539 (1943). Cf. Wichita Pub. Schools Employees Union v. Smith, 194 Kan.
2 (1964) (school boards) and Murray v. State Board of Regents, 194 Kan.
686 (1965). In light of this rule we must conclude that county
hospital boards may not borrow money from private sources, as such
financing is not expressly authorized anywhere in K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq.,
nor is it necessarily implied since the legislature has specifically
provided for alternate methods for financing, i.e., a tax levy or bond
issue by the county. We call your attention to Attorney General Opinion
No. 79-90, wherein this office concluded that a community mental health
center lacked authority to borrow from a private financial institution
to purchase or construct a building because the enabling legislation
provided other funding sources.
"4. May the hospital board purchase only stock of the
existing corporation now owning the medical clinic through
means of private financing and unrestricted funds and
business receipts of the hospital, and then dissolve the
corporation so that the purchase of the stock would not
be for investment purposes as such."
Once again, our response to this question is predicated on our
conclusion that it must be the county and not the hospital board
which funds and purchases the medical clinic. Likewise, since the
hospital board has no authority to borrow money from a private lending
institution, we can respond to your question only if we assume that
the county is to acquire the property through a purchase financed by
some statutorily authorized means. If we make this assumption, the
question becomes whether the county may purchase the corporate stock
of the corporation holding title to the real estate in question.
One of the most basic of the powers of a county is "[t]o purchase
and hold real and personal estate for the use of the county." K.S.A.
19-101, second. The county is also empowered "[t]o make all contracts
and do all other acts in relation to the property and concerns of the
county necessary to the exercise of its corporate or administrative
powers." K.S.A. 19-101, fourth. However, counties are restricted in
the use of "moneys which are not immediately required for the purposes
for which the moneys were collected or received," to those investment
vehicles contained in K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1675. In the present situation
we believe the county may use these broad powers to purchase real property
for a legitimate county concern (acquiring a medical clinic) by purchasing
the stock of a corporation. (We note, however, that if the corporation
was created pursuant to the Professional Corporation Law, K.S.A.
17-2706 et seq., the transfer of stock may be subject to the restrictions
contained in K.S.A. 17-2712.) This type of purchase is to be contrasted
with the investment of idle funds in certain securities under the provi-
sions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 12-1675 and 19-1804, which are for the
purpose of causing a return on unneeded funds, while the purchase of
a medical clinic is a specifically authorized concern of the county
and county hospital board. This contrast is possible only if the
corporation is dissolved upon purchase by the county. In 56 Am.Jur.2d
Municipal Corporations, it is stated that municipal corporations normally
may not subscribe to or purchase stock in private corporations, but:
"[A] purchase of all of the stock of a corporation
by a municipality or other governmental unit, for the
purpose of enabling it to acquire the property of the
corporation for public purposes, has been held not
to violate a constitutional prohibition against the purchase
of stock, particularly where the intention was to
dissolve the corporation upon acquiring all its
stock." (Footnotes omitted.)
Thus, the contemplated purchase is within the power of the county when
such purchase is for a public purpose and is followed by dissolution
of the private corporation.
"5. If the facility is able to be purchased by the
hospital board, may the same be leased to medical
doctors, dentists, optometrists, and pharmicists?"
Again, your question is predicated upon the purchase of a medical clinic
by the hospital board, a premise which has been rejected. Assuming,
however, that a suitable medical clinic can be obtained by the county,
your question might be whether the hospital board may lease the clinic
to doctors, dentists, optometrists and pharmicists. We call your
attention to our answer to question 3 above and conclude that such
leases would be permissible.
"6. May the hospital board lease the medical clinic from
the regular corporation and then sublease the same to medical
doctors, dentists, optometrists and pharmicists under a
twenty year lease purchase agreement? Said agreement to
establish monthly lease terms and at the end of the twenty
year period, the building would be deeded to the hospital."
Pursuant to K.S.A. 19-18,117, the hospital board is given authority
to lease or rent (as tenant) a medical clinic. In addition, as
previously noted in answers to questions 2 and 4, the board may enter into
leases (as lessor) to permit dentists, doctors, optometrists, etc. to
practice in a medical clinic managed by the hospital board. However,
your question proposes that the lease agreement will provide for the
purchase of the medical facility by the hospital board after the
twenty-year lease. Presumably the installment payments to be made by
the board are designed to cover the lease costs and purchase price. As
stated in our response to question number 1, the hospital board has no
authority to purchase a medical clinic. This is true, whether the
manner of payment is by lump sum at the time of contracting or by
installment payments over a period of years.
In addition, we call your attention once again to the language of
Attorney General Opinion No. 79-47, which concluded that tax funds
raised for operation and maintenance of a county hospital may not
be used to lease a medical clinic. Id. at 10.
"7. It appears from your Opinion No. 79-47, that Home
Rule by the County Commission would be applicable in this
instance. Assuming that the County Commission would adopt
a Home Rule provision relating to hospitals and medical
clinics in Sherman County, may the County Commission
purchase the existing medical clinic through unrestricted
funds of the hospital and private financing. If not, must
an election be held before a bond issue may be issued for
the purchase of the existing structure and the new addition."
The applicability of county home rule power in this area was recognized
by the Kansas Supreme Court in Thomas County Taxpayers Ass'n. v. Finney,
223 Kan. 434 (1978). Home rule power is available to the county under
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-101a; however, this power may not be exercised when
it conflicts with uniformly applicable legislation. The Cash Basis Law,
K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq., is uniform in application and controlling on
the creation of indebtedness by county government. Because the use of
private financing by the county must be in compliance with the Cash
Basis Law, any such creation of indebtedness will be so limited. Home
rule power may be used to enable the county to use a method of purchase
not provided in K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq., where there is no conflict with
uniformly applicable legislation.
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-1869 enables the county to issue bonds for the
purchase or construction of a medical clinic. This statute calls for
approval by the electorate before issuance of the bonds. Thus, an
election must be held before bonds issued pursuant to this statute
may be issued for the purchase of the structure in question under these
statutes. The above question was answered by Attorney General Curt
Schneider in Attorney General Opinion No. 77-342. Attorney General
Schneider determined that county home rule power could be used to exempt
the county hospital from the provisions of 19-1801 et seq. by charter
resolution. Thus, an election must be held before bonds may be issued
under K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq., unless pursuant to the exercise of county
home rule, the county exempts itself from these provisions.
"8. If the County Commission were to pass a Resolution
providing for Home Rule for the hospital, may the hospital
board by itself be given the authority to purchase the
existing medical clinic and build an addition thereon using
unrestricted funds of the hospital and its business receipts
as well as private financing for its source of funding and
thereafter lease said facility to physicians, dentists,
optometrists, and pharmacists."
The question posed here presents an interesting problem. County
home rule power is made available by K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-101a, which
states in pertinent part thus:
"Counties are hereby empowered to transact all county
business and perform such powers of local legislation
and administration as they deem appropriate, subject
only to the following limitations, restrictions, or
prohibitions: First, counties shall be subject to all
acts of the legislature which apply uniformly to all
counties." (Emphasis added.)
This broad grant of power may only be used for county business and
local legislation or administration. Because authority analyzing
the connections between the county and the hospital board is lacking
it is difficult to determine whether hospital board business is to be
included. Examination of K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq. shows that the
county hospital is created by the county to provide health care
for its inhabitants, it is initially funded by county funds, title to
hospital property is held by the county, hospital board trustees are
initially appointed by the county, and the county commission determines
the number of trustees to sit on the hospital board. K.S.A. 19-101c
requires that county home rule powers be liberally construed for the
purpose of giving counties the largest measure of self-government. The
substantial ties mentioned above, coupled with the requirement that
home rule be liberally construed leads to the conclusion that county
hospital districts are within county home rule power. In accord:
Opinions of the Attorney General, Nos. 76-255, 77-79, 77-208 and 79-66.
However, the use of county home rule power in this situation is not
without limitation. K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-101a first requires that
"[c]ounties shall be subject to all acts of the legislature which apply
uniformly to all counties." As concluded in answer to question 7
above, K.S.A. 19-1801 et seq. is not uniformly applicable and thus
county home rule power may be used. However, the Cash Basis Law,
K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq., is a uniform act applicable to all counties.
Because the hospital board must gain the ability to use private
financing through county home rule it is exercising the power of
the county, and such power is subject to the Cash Basis Law. Stated
another way, the county does not have the power to use private financ-
ing contrary to the Cash Basis Law; because the county does not have
the power to enter into private financing agreements, it may not
grant such power to an agency which it may affect with its home rule
power. In Murray v. State Board of Regents, 194 Kan. 686 (1965),
similar reasoning was used to determine that a lease entered into by
the Kansas State University Endowment Association was not enforceable:
"The legislature has not seen fit to authorize the State
Board of Regents to acquire land by negotiation and purchase,
neither has the legislature seen fit to authorize the Board
to negotiate options to purchase, and it had no authority
to do so. No doubt the Endowment Association entered into
the lease and option agreement for the purpose of assisting
the Kansas State University in obtaining government grants
for the purpose of conducting nuclear research programs, but
its assistance could not go beyond the power of the University
and the State Board of Regents to act. The Endowment Associa-
tion could not by agreement, or under the claim of agency,
extend the power of the State Board of Regents beyond that
granted by the legislature." Id. at 690, 691.
Thus, county home rule power may be used to give the hospital board
power to purchase a medical clinic, but this power will not work to
allow the use of private financing in contravention of the Cash Basis
Law.
Although we have endeavored to respond to your specific questions,
the questions themselves suggest the need to analyze generally the
power of the county hospital board vis-a-vis county government and
the methods of financing contemplated by the legislature for the
acquisition of medical clinics.
Generally speaking, although the county hospital law grants authority
to the hospital board of trustees to manage the financial affairs
of the county hospital (see K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-1804), it leaves
the generation of funds for capital expenditures to the county (see
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 19-1801, 19-1809, 19-1815e, 19-1869, 19-1878).
Throughout the Act, no mention is made of private funding. The
Legislature seems to have contemplated funding of county hospital
improvements through those traditional sources of public financing,
namely, municipal bonds and taxes. There is no grant of authority to
borrow funds and obligate either county real estate or hospital funds
(public funds) for the repayment of such loans. Probably most signif-
icant in the statutory scheme, consistent throughout the Act, is
the requirement for public elections where capital expenditures are
anticipated. Action by a county hospital board which circumvents
the public funding mechanisms provided by statute also destroys oppor-
tunity for direct voter participation in the process of acquiring real
property. The acquisition by the county of real property is significantly
different from the purchase of bedding and supplies for operation of
the hospital. Real property is both a benefit and a liability. In
addition, it involves the removal of private property from the county
tax roles when such property is transferred to a public entity. In
short, the Legislature was not to be presumed to lack justification
for distinct methods of acquisition and funding for the purchase or
construction of real property and personal property. Under the county
hospital law, the county commission has a significant role in the
funding and acquisition of real property and little or no authority
over the decision-making process for actual management of the hospital
facilities. Management is entrusted to the board of trustees. Funding
is entrusted to the county.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
BradleyJ.SmootDeputyAttorneyGeneral
RTS:BJS:phf

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.