Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-015

1981-015Kanag

Testo completo

January 16, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 15
Robert J. Watson
City Attorney of Kansas City, Kansas
Ninth Floor -- Municipal Office Building
One Civic Center Plaza
Kansas City, Kansas 66101
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees--Open
Meetings--Notice and Agenda
Synopsis: A city ordinance calling for notice of regular or special
meetings only to those who request it in writing does not
comport with the mandates of the Kansas Open Meetings Act.
Although written requests for notice of government meetings
are preferred and the absence of a written request makes
prosecution under the Act nearly impossible, oral requests
for notice are to be honored. Requests for agenda also may
be made orally. Notice of special meetings cannot be
restricted to those situations where prior notice is "possible."
If a meeting is prearranged and subject to the Kansas Open
Meetings Act notice must be provided for those who request
it. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-4317, K.S.A. 1980 Supp.
75-4318, K.S.A. 75-4320.
Dear Mr. Watson:
You request the opinion of this office regarding a pair of proposed
city ordinances relating to procedures for meetings of the Kansas City,
Kansas, City Commission. You inquire whether sections 1, 2 and 3 of the
pertinent ordinance are lawful within the meaning of K.S.A. 75-4317
et seq., the Kansas Open Meetings Act.
Section 1 of the proposed ordinance (attached) provides for Regular
Formal Meetings of the Commission each Tuesday and Thursday of every
week unless otherwise specified. This section provides that an agenda
will be prepared and made available to any person requesting it. The
section makes no mention of notice to the public of such regular meetings.
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318 provides in pertinent part that "all meetings
for the conduct of the affairs of, and the transaction of business by,
all legislative and administrative bodies and agencies of the state
and political and taxing subdivisions thereof . . . shall be open to
the public."
The Act also provides th" [n]otice of the date, time and place
of any regular or special meeting of a public body designated herein-
above shall be furnished to any person requesting such information."
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318(b).
Hence, the Act requires individual notice of all regular "meetings"
of the City Commission as that term is used in the law. Section 1
of the proposed ordinance does not mention how notice of the date,
time and place of regular meetings is to be provided. Clearly, publi-
cation of the ordinance designating Tuesdays and Thursdays as the
days for regular meetings does not in itself comply with the mandates
of the Kansas Open Meetings Act. Individual notice is still required.
Currently, Kansas does not rely upon publication, posted or constructive
notice provisions and instead requires notice be provided only to those
who request it. Certainly, the City is free to publish or post notice
but such action does not abrogate the clear statutory duty to provide
actual notice to any person requesting such notice. For the convenience
of the City, notice of regular meetings may be provided in a single
notice to the requester without supplemental notices required for
meetings covered by the single notice of regular meetings. See Kansas
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-337.
In addition, the Act requires that any agenda prepared for a "meeting"
covered by the Act, must be "made available to any person" requesting
it. K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318(d). The ordinance as proposed is
consistent with this requirement.
Section 2 of the proposed ordinance concerns Special Formal Meetings.
Such meetings are those called by two or more commissioners upon
written notice. The section, however, attempts to restrict the
obligation of the City to provide notice and agenda as provided by
the Act, and is, therefore, contrary to law. The ordinance attempts
to limit the providing of notice to persons who have requested such
notice in writing. The Act makes no such limitation. A request for
notice may be made orally. If, in fact, an oral request for notice
is communicated to the governmental agency or body in a reasonable
fashion such that notice may be provided without undue burden on the
public agency, such request must be honored. Failure of the member
calling the meeting to provide notice which had been requested orally
subjects the member to prosecution for civil penalties as provided in
K.S.A. 75-4320.
We have on previous occasions cautioned the public and press to submit
requests for notice in writing because of the severe practical problems
involved with prosecution of notice violations under the Act where
the request is not recorded in black and white. Written requests for
notice are clearly preferred. However, we cannot allow requests for
notice made orally to be ignored when effectively communicated to a
governmental body or agency.
In addition, Section 2 declares that "no agenda will be prepared or
distributed." This provision is inconsistent with the Act if in
fact an agenda is prepared, and Section 2 seems to contemplate that
some form of agenda will be prepared. Section 2 states that Commissioner
are to be provided with "written notice" stating "the object of
such special meeting." In our judgment, any writing which states
the item or items to be discussed at a meeting is an agenda within
the meaning of the Kansas Open Meetings Act. Hence, if any person
requests a copy of the document which states the object of the special
meeting, the copy must be made available.
Section 3 of the propo sed ordinance provides for "reasonable" prior notice ,
more commissioners "where possible." The words "where possible" limit
the requirement of the ordinance to a standard of conduct less than
that required by the Act. The Act contains no such practical limita-
tions. Notice of all prearranged gatherings subject to the Act is
required by law.
In addition, Section 3 attempts to limit the providing of notice to
only those who have requested it in writing. As previously noted
this is an impermissible limitation, compliance with which will not
insure compliance with the Act. Oral requests for notice of public
meetings are not to be ignored.
Finally, we turn to the following clause in Section 3:
"[T]he press and the public is [sic] hereby put on notice
that such informal gatherings may occur in the offices of
the three city commissioners without prearrangement, for
which no prior notice can or will be given nor agenda pre-
pared, and the press and public are invited to attend and
be present at such informal meetings as they may occur
throughout the day in the offices of the three city
commissioners."
To the extent this provision is an attempt to provide public knowledge
of the working atmosphere of city hall and invite public access to
gatherings that are not otherwise covered by the open meetings law
(because they are not "prearranged"), the provision is unobjectionable.
However, to the extent the provision attempts to excuse members from
their responsibilities to provide notice of prearranged gatherings,
it is ineffectual.
Just what constitutes a "prearranged" gathering is a question of
fact. This office has opined that "prearranged" means the opposite
of "chance." But we have also concluded that prearrangement of a
meeting may be the result of customs which members know indicate
a meeting is to be held. We call to your attention the coffee and
roll sessions of the Emporia City Council which were a matter of
custom for that body following its regular meetings. Letter to
Jay Vander Velde (attached). Likewise, the practice of certain
governing bodies to gather prior to the regularly scheduled meeting
to establish an agenda, may itself, as a matter of habit and custom
constitute a prearranged gathering of such bodies.
In sum, the language of Section 3 of the proposed ordinance does
increase public knowledge of the possible gatherings of the City
Commission. It does not, however, alleviate the burden of notice
and access where the gathering is in fact prearranged and hence a
"meeting" under the open meetings law.
Therefore, it is our opinion that the ordinance as drafted and attached
does not comply with the requirements of the Kansas Open Meetings Act.
Behavior of members consistent with the ordinance will not insure
compliance with the Act, as the ordinance mandates a lesser standard
of conduct with regard to notice and agenda of regular and special
meetings of the City Commission.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
BradleyJ.Smoot
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BJS:phf
Enclosures

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.