Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-004

1981-004Kanag

Testo completo

January 9, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 4
Mr. John Dekker
Director of Law and
City Attorney
City of Wichita, Kansas
455 North Main Street
Wichita, Kansas 67202
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Buildings, Structures
and Grounds--Industrial Revenue Bonds
Synopsis: The term "revenues" as is found in K.S.A. 12-1743
refers to revenues derived by a city under a lease
agreement covering facilities constructed or improved
under the Industrial Revenue Bond Law (K.S.A. 12-1740
et seq.). The term "net earnings," as used in K.S.A.
12-1744, refers to revenues received by the city by
virtue of such lease agreement.
The provisions of K.S.A. 12-1740 et seq. do not require
by implication or otherwise that, as a condition for
issuance of industrial revenue bonds, there be a
determination by the city that the tenant industry will
realize income and revenues solely from its operation
of the facilities in amounts adequate to fulfill its
obligation to pay the installments of rent and other
charges required under a lease agreement. K.S.A. 12-1743
does not require that rental payments specified in a
lease agreement bear a relationship to the fair market
rental value of the facilities acquired or constructed
from the bond proceeds.
K.S.A. 12-1743 provides that all details pertaining to
the issuance of industrial revenue bonds and the terms
and conditions thereof shall be determined by ordinance
of the city. An ordinance issued pursuant to
K.S.A. 12-1743 may be adopted by a city even
though there is no reasonable expectation that
the tenant will realize sufficient income solely
from its operation of the tenant industry sufficient
to meet its obligations under the lease.
A city may, pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1743, determine by
ordinance and authorize the issuance of term bonds
maturing in one or more installments. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 10-103, 12-1740, 12-1743, 12-1744, 12-1749a,
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 10-103.
Dear Mr. Dekker:
You have asked our opinion on several matters with respect to
the interpretation and application of certain provisions of
K.S.A. 12-1740 et seq. commonly referred to as the Kansas
Industrial Revenue Bond Law. You indicate the City of Wichita
is presently considering several requests for the issuance of
industrial revenue bonds pursuant to previously issued letters
of intent and that these proposed issues have raised several
questions.
Under the terms of the proposed issues the principal would be
payable in a single installment maturing in a relatively short time
after the date of issuance. The maturity date would typically be
from one to five years. During the term of issuance, interest on
the bonds would be payable in semi-annual installments. No
provisions would be made for the creation of a sinking fund
for the retirement of principal, and none of the principal amount
of the bonds will be paid prior to maturity. There may or may not
be a redemption provision which would call the bonds after one
year.
The lease would provide that the city will receive from a tenant
rent payments adequate to pay interest on the bonds and the
principal thereof at maturity or earlier redemption.
It is anticipated that the city may be asked to issue refunding
bonds pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1749 for the purpose of refinancing
the principal amount of the bond issue. The tenant's obligation
to pay the full principal amount of the bonds at maturity will
be absolute and unconditional. The payment of the bonds and
interest thereon will be guaranteed under the terms of a separate
unconditional guarantee agreement.
The bond ordinance and lease will contain the customary covenants
and agreements providing for issuance of the bonds and the security
therefor, including a pledge of the facility and the payments of
basic rent and other payments to be received by the city for use
of the facility, pursuant to the lease, as security for the bonds.
The bonds will be payable solely and only from the money in
revenues to be derived by the city from the lease of the facilities
required and constructed from proceeds of the bonds. The city
will not incur any obligation of any kind or character, except the
obligation to pay the principal of and interest on the bonds, which
obligation shall be payable solely and only from such revenues.
In accordance with K.S.A. 12-1747, the bond ordinance will provide,
and the bonds will recite, that the bonds and the interest thereon
are to be paid from the money and revenue received from the fees
charged and rental received for the use of the property and
facilities improved, constructed, reconstructed, repaired or other-
wise improved from the proceeds of the bonds:
It is your understanding that the terms of the proposed bonds
have been formulated in an effort to address the current economic
and financial market conditions. You further indicate in your
request that "in light of the prevailing high interest rates, and
recent history of major fluctuations in the bone markets, the
city expects to receive further requests for industrial revenue
bonds to be structured in much the same manner as described."
You have requested our opinion with respect to the proposed bonds
on the following issues.
"1. Do the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1743,
authorizing cities to issue 'bonds payable
solely and only from the revenues derived
from such facilities' [emphasis added] refer
to the revenue derived from such facilities by
the City?"
It is our opinion that the phrase "revenues derived from such
facilities" means the rent payments agreed to under the lease
agreement with the tenant. There is no indication in the statute
that only revenues resulting from the operation of the facility
are to be used to pay the bonds. To imply a statutory requirement
for any such finding would, in fact, prohibit the variety of
projects frequently financed through the issuance of industrial
revenue bonds, which projects must be conceded to be of a economic
benefit to the state and issuing city and also in the interest of
promoting the physical and mental health and general welfare of
the citizens of the State of Kansas. For example, to impose such
a requirement would effectively prohibit the issuance of industrial
revenue bonds to finance pollution control facilities and certain
health care facilities operated by not-for-profit
organizations. Such facilities clearly fall within the contemplation of the act,
but obviously may not be of the character which directly will
generate "revenues" sufficient to enable the tenant to make rental
payments under the lease in amounts calculated to provide for the
full payment of the principal of and the interest on the bonds.
In such cases some, if not all, of the necessary revenues must be
provided by the tenant from sources other than its operation of
a particular facility financed through an issue of an industrial
revenue bonds.
"2. Do the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1744, auth-
orizing the City to 'pledge the facility purchased
or constructed and the net earnings therefrom
[emphasis added] to the payment' of the Bonds,
refer to the net earnings received by the City
by virtue of the lease?"
The term "net earnings" is not defined in K.S.A. 12-1744 or
elsewhere in the Industrial Revenue Bond Law, and your question
emphasizes the fact that the meaning of this term is not clear
on its face, being susceptible of more than one interpretation.
Because of such ambiguity it is appropriate to employ established
rules of statutory construction to resolve your inquiry. Of
particular relevance are the rules reiterated in Brown v. Keill,
224 Kan. 195 (1978), to wit:
"The fundamental rule of statutory construction,
to which all others are subordinate, is that the
purpose and intent of the legislature governs
when that intent can be ascertained from the
statute, even though words, phrases or clauses
at some place in the statute must be omitted or
inserted. (Farm & City Ins. Co. v. American
Standard Inc. Co., 220 Kan. 325, Syl. ¶3, 552
P.2d 1363 [1976].) In determining legislative
intent, courts are not limited to a mere con-
sideration of the language used, but look to the
historical background of the enactment, the
circumstances attending its passage, the purpose
to be accomplished and the effect the statute may
have under the various constructions suggested.
(State, ex rel., v. City of Overland Park, 215
Kan. 700, Syl. ¶10, 527 P.2d 1340 [1974].) In
order to ascertain the legislative intent, courts
are not permitted to consider only a certain
isolated part or parts of an act but are required
to consider and construe together all parts thereof
in pari materia. When the interpretation of some
one section of an act according to the exact and
literal import of its words would contravene the
manifest purpose of the legislature, the entire
act should be construed according to its spirit
and reason, disregarding so far as may be necessary
the literal import of words or phrases which conflict
with the manifest purpose of the legislature (Kansas
Commission on Civil Rights v. Howard, 218 Kan. 248,
Syl. ¶2, 544 P.2d 791 [1975].)" Id. at 199, 200.
Without unduly burdening this opinion by a recitation of the
various considerations generated by application of the foregoing
rules to 12-1744 and the other provisions of the Industrial Revenue
Bond Law, suffice it to state that, in our opinion, these rules
compel the conclusion that the legislature intended that the
terms "rentals," "revenues" and "net earnings," as used in these
statutes, be treated as synonymous.
Therefore, it is our opinion that the "net earnings therefrom"
as is found in K.S.A. 12-1744 refers to revenues or rents
received by the city under the lease agreement.
"3. Do the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1740 to
12-1749a, inclusive, as amended, require, by
implication or otherwise, that as a condition
for issuance of the Bonds there be a determination
by the City that the tenant industry will realize
income and revenues solely from its operation of
the facilities in amounts adequate to fulfill its
obligations to pay the installments of basic
rent and other charges required under the lease?"
We find no provision either explicitly or by implication re-
quiring a determination that the tenant industry will realize
income and revenues solely from its operation of a facility in
amounts adequate to fulfill its obligations to pay the installments
of rents under the lease and, therefore, it is our opinion that
no such determination need be made by the governing body.
"4. Does K.S.A. 12-1743 require that the rental
payments specified in the lease bear any relation-
ship to the fair market rental value of the
facilities acquired or constructed from proceeds
of the Bonds?"
As discussed above, an industrial revenue bond lease purchase
agreement is primarily a financing device and not a true lease.
The lease rentals are not rentals in the ordinary sense of the
word, but rather, payments intended to retire the bonds and pay,
expenses relating to the issue. It follows that there is no
requirement that the rental payments specified in the lease
bear any relationship to the fair market rental value of the
facility. The act requires only that such rental payments be
sufficient to provide for payment of the principal of and interest
on the bonds. The act does not require that there be any reasonable
expectation that the tenant will realize sufficient income solely
from its operation of the facility to meet its obligations under
the lease.
"5. Under K.S.A. 12-1743, which provides that,
'All details pertaining to the issuance of such
bonds and the terms and conditions thereof shall
be determined by ordinance of the-City,' may the
City adopt an ordinance authorizing the issuance
of Bonds which reasonably may be expected to be
paid, in whole or in part, from payments received
by the City from the tenant industry pursuant to
the lease when there is no reasonable expectation
that the tenant will realize sufficient income
solely from its operation of the facility to meet
its obligations under the lease?"
As stated in the answer to question four, it is our opinion that
no such determination need be made by the governing body.
"6. Is the maturity schedule a detail pertaining
to the issuance of such Bonds which may be determined
by ordinance of the City pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1743,
and if so, may the City authorize the issuance of
term bonds maturing in one or more installments?"
All details pertaining to the issuance of such industrial revenue
bonds and the terms and conditions thereof shall be determined by
ordinance of the city pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1743. Such legislation
must be contrasted with the provisions of numerous statutes relating
to specific requirements imposed by the legislature in connection
with the issuance of bonds by municipalities for certain specified
purposes, as well as the provisions of K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 10-103.
Unlike K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 10-103, which imposes specific requirements
with respect to the maturity schedule and maximum interest rates
with respect to municipal bonds subject to the general bond law,
K.S.A. 12-1743 contains no such specific requirement. As previously
stated in Attorney General Opinion Nos. 76-336 and 80-58, the
Kansas General Bond Law (K.S.A. 10-103 et seq., as amended)
does not apply to bonds issued under K.S.A. 12-1740 et seq.
Given the specific language of K.S.A. 12-1743, taken in the
context of the act, it is our opinion, that the schedule of bond
maturities is a detail which may be determined by the governing
body. Accordingly, the city, in its discretion, may authorize
the issuance of term bonds maturing in one or more installments
as may be necessary to carry out and give effect to the financing
plan in connection with such industrial revenue bonds.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas,
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:DEJ:jm
Donald E. Jensen

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.