TOMAS LUIS COLLAZO HEREDIA and ARILYN COTTO CORDERO

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

€ase:10-06495-BKT13 Doc#:49 Filed:06/09/11 Entered:06/09/11 12:38:37 Desc: Main
Document Page 1 of 3

IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR
THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO

IN RE:
TOMAS LUIS COLLAZO HEREDIA CASE NO. 10-06495 BRT
ARILYN COTTO CORDERO Chapter 13

XXX-XX-8788
XXX-XX-5272
FILED & ENTERED ON 06/09/2011

Debtor(s)

OPINION AND ORDER
This proceeding is before the Court upon the United States Trustee's
Position and Answer to Order at Docket #27 [Dkt. No. 28]; the Debtors’ Reply to
United States Trustee’s Answer to Order at Docket #27 [(Dkt. No. 32]; and the
Debtors’ Motion for Voluntary Dismissal [Dkt. No. 42].
I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The Debtors have made only one of eight payments currently due under the
plan. Since August 2002, Debtors have filed four bankruptcy cases (including the
present case) in the District of Puerto Rico, all of which have been dismissed
for failure to make plan payments. The United States Trustee requests that the
granting of the Debtors’ voluntary dismissal be conditioned upon a bar to re-file

to prevent abuse of the bankruptcy process. This Court agrees.

II. LEGAL ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
Bankruptcy courts have authority to dismiss bankruptcy cases and bar al
debtor from re-filing. 11 U.S.C.A. § 349(a). In an effort to prevent abuse of

the bankruptcy system, several bankruptcy courts have barred debtors who have

AUTHENTIFATED
US. GOVERNIMENT
INFORMA ION

GPO

Pase:10-06495-BKT13 Doc#:49 Filed:06/09/11 Entered:06/09/11 12:38:37 Desc: Main
Document Page 2 of 3

filed multiple cases in bad faith from re-filing. See In re Price, 304 B.R. 769,
774 (Bankr. N.D. Ohio 2004) (imposing a 360-day bar on a debtor who filed six
petitions in six years, in conjunction with non-debtor spouse, to prevent

mortgage holder from foreclosing on property); In re Craighead, 377 B.R. 648,

657 (Bankr. N.D. Cal. 2007) (imposing a three-year bar on debtor after finding
that the six filings by debtor and the sixteen filings by family members of

debtor were filed in a bad-faith attempt to avoid foreclosure); In re Gonzalez-

Ruiz, 341 B.R. 371, 386 (B.A.P. 1st Cir. 2006) (upholding bankruptcy court’s
authority both to dismiss debtors' fourth successive Chapter 13 case, and to bay
debtor from re-filing for 180 days for lack of good faith).

The majority of bankruptcy courts use a “totality of the circumstances”
test to determine whether a Chapter 13 petition has been filed in bad faith,
evaluating six factors: (1) the debtor's accuracy in stating his debts and
expenses, (2) the debtor's honesty in the bankruptcy process, including whether
he or she has made any misrepresentations to the court, (3) whether the
Bankruptcy Code is being unfairly manipulated, (4) the type of debt sought to be
discharged, (5) whether the debt would be dischargeable in a Chapter 7, and (6)
the debtor's motivation and sincerity in seeking Chapter 13 relief. Gonzalez-
Ruiz at 383. The final factor is particularly relevant to this case, as the
Debtors have a history of failing to make plan payments, raising concern as to
their motivation and sincerity in seeking Chapter 13 relief. To prevent furthey
abuse of the bankruptcy process, this Court adopts the United States Trustee's
position in Dkt. No. 28 conditions its dismissal of the Debtors’ current case on
a bar to re-file a bankruptcy petition in any jurisdiction for two (2) years.

In accordance with the abovementioned, this Court GRANTS the Debtors’
motion for voluntary dismissal [Dkt. No. 42], and adopts the United States
Trustee's position and therefore impose a bar to re-file another bankruptcy
petition in any jurisdiction for two (2) years.

SO ORDERED.

San Juan, this 09 day of June, 2011.

q
N

Document

Pase:10-06495-BKT13 Doc#:49 Filed:06/09/11 Entered:06/09/11 12:38:37 Desc: Ma

Page 3 of 3

/s/Brian K. Tester
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge

n