Velazquez v. Wagner Industries, Inc. et al

3:25-cv-00913Pamd20 mar 2026

Testo completo

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
EDGARDO VELAZQUEZ,
Plaintiff
V.
WAGNER INDUSTRIES, INC.,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION NO. 3:25-913
(JUDGE MANNION)
MEMORANDUM
Pending before the court is a motion to dismiss the plaintiff's complaint
filed 	pursuant 	to 	Fed.R.Civ.P.12(b)(6) 	on 	behalf 	of 	defendant 	Wagner
Industries, 	Inc. 	("Wagner"). (Doc. 	30). 	Upon review of the motion and all
related materials, Wagner's motion to dismiss will be DENIED.
Fed.R.Civ.P. 	12(b)(6) provides for the dismissal of a complaint, 	in
whole or in part, if the plaintiff fails to state a claim upon which relief can be
granted. The moving party bears the burden of showing that no claim has
been stated, Hedges v. U.S., 404 F.3d 744, 750 (3d Cir. 2005), and dismissal
is appropriate only if, accepting all of the facts alleged in the complaint as
true, the plaintiff has failed to plead "enough facts to state a claim to relief
that is plausible on its face." Bell Atlantic Corp. v. 	Twombly, 550 U.S. 544,
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 1 of 17
570 (2007) (abrogating "no set of facts" language found in Conley v. Gibson,
355 U.S. 41 , 45-46 (1957)). The facts alleged must be sufficient to "raise a
right to relief above the speculative level." Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555. This
requirement "calls for enough fact[s] to raise a reasonable expectation that
discovery will reveal evidence of' necessary elements of the plaintiff's cause
of action. Id. Moreover, in order to satisfy federal pleading requirements, the
plaintiff must "provide the grounds of his entitlement to relief," which "requires
more than labels and conclusions, and a formulaic recitation of the elements
of a cause of action will not do. " Phillips v. 	County of Allegheny, 515 F.3d
224, 231 	(3d Cir. 2008) (brackets and quotations marks omitted) (quoting
Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 at 555).
In 	ruling 	on 	a motion to dismiss, the court generally considers the
complaint, exhibits attached to the complaint, and matters of public record.
In re Lengyel, 2014 WL 2003099 (M.D .Pa . May 15, 2014) (citing Mayer v.
Belichick, 605 F.3d 223, 230 (3d Cir. 2010)).
Generally, the court should grant leave to amend a complaint before
dismissing it as merely deficient. 	See, 	e.g ., Fletcher-Harlee Corp. 	v. 	Pote
Concrete Contractors, Inc., 482 F.3d 247, 252 (3d Cir. 2007); 	Grayson v.
Mayview State Hosp., 293 F.3d 103, 108 (3d Cir. 2002); Shane v. Fauver,
213 F. 3d 113, 116-17 (3d Cir. 2000). "Dismissal without leave to amend is
- 2 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 2 of 17
justified only on the grounds of bad faith , undue delay, prejudice, or futility."
Alston v. Parker, 363 F.3d 229, 236 (3d Cir 2004).
By way of relevant background, Wagner was incorporated under New
Jersey law 	on 	April 	3, 1989. 	(Doc. 	30-1 ). 	Wagner was engaged 	in 	the
business of designing and manufacturing industrial machines.
Fast forward to March 19 , 2024. On that day, the plaintiff's left arm was
pulled into a shear/slitter machine made for flooring material when he was
attempting to unjam the rollers of the machine at his workplace. The incident
resu lted in the plaintiff suffering a degloving injury to his arm . The machine
involved in the incident was designed and manufactured by Wagner.
On August 5, 2024, the plaintiff filed a writ in the Court of Common
Pleas of Ph iladelphia County 	against Forbo Floori ng, 	Inc. , and Wagner
related to the March 19 , 2024, incident. (Doc. 43-4 ). The writ was served on
Wagner on September 3, 2024. (Id.).
Three 	weeks 	later, 	on 	September 	24, 	2024, 	Wagner 	voluntari ly
initiated its dissolution and began formally winding up its affairs. On that date,
the Treasurer of the 	State of New Jersey certified 	that Wagner fi led 	a
Certificate of Pending Dissolution under N.J.S. 14A:12-3. (Doc. 30-2). The
Certificate reflects that Wagner would cease doing business as of that date
and did not intend to recommence business.
- 3 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 3 of 17
On January 27, 2025, the Treasurer of the State of New Jersey certified
Wagner was dissolved in accordance with the laws of the State. (Doc. 30-3).
Shortly thereafter, by 	stipulation dated 	February 27, 2025, 	the plaintiff's
action in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County was dismissed
without prejudice. (Doc. 46-1 ).
On May 23, 2025, the plaintiff filed the instant personal injury action
pursuant to 28 	U.S.C . §1332 against a number of companies, including:
Wagner Industries, Inc ., Forbo America, Inc. , Forbo America Services, Inc.,
Forbo Floor Coverings, Inc., Forbo Flooring , Inc., Forbo Siegling, LLC , Forbo
Group, Forbo Management SA, and Forbo Holdings, Ltd. 	(Doc. 1). As to
Wagner, the plaintiff brings claims for negligence and strict liability.
On August 4, 2025, Wagner filed the pending motion to dismiss the
plaintiff's complaint. (Doc. 30). In its motion , Wagner argues that, since its
dissolution was completed January 27 , 2025, 	it became a defunct entity
incapable of being sued. Given that this action was commenced on May 23,
2025, approximately four months after its dissolution, Wagner argues that
the plaintiff's claims against it are legally futile and warrant dismissal with
prejudice as a matter of law. The plaintiff has filed a brief in opposition to
Wagner's motion (Doc. 43-1) to which Wagner filed a reply brief (Doc. 47).
- 4 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 4 of 17
As indicated , Wagner was incorporated in the State of New Jersey.
Therefore, its capacity to be sued is governed by the laws of that state.
Fed.R.Civ.P. 	17(b)(2). 	The 	New 	Jersey 	Business 	Corporation 	Act
("NJBCA"), N.J.S.A. §14A:1 -1, et seq., governs the methods by which New
Jersey corporations 	can 	be 	dissolved 	and 	the 	requirements to 	achieve
dissolution . 	See 	N.J.S.A. 	§14A12-1(a)-(h). 	Under 	the 	NJBCA, 	a
corporation's completed dissolution is effective upon the filing of a Certificate
of Dissolution , N.J.S.A. §14A: 12-8(c), which in this case was filed on January
27, 2025.
While Wagner concedes that it remained subject to suit in between the
filing of its Certificates Pending Dissolution and Dissolution, citing to Global
Landfill Agreement Group v. 280 Dev. Corp ., 992 F.Supp. 692 (D.N.J. 1998),
Wagner argues that it ceased being amenable to suit once the Certificate of
Dissolution was filed on January 27, 2025.
In Global, the Global Landfill Agreement Group was held responsible
for cleaning up hazardous substances at a landfill. Global sought contribution
for the costs of cleanup from a number of other parties. One of those parties
was 280 Development Corporation, a former New Jersey corporation that
had dissolved long before the filing of the contribution action. Because 280
- 5 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 5 of 17
Development Corporation 	had 	been dissolved, 	it sought to 	be dismissed
from the action arguing that it could no longer be subject to suit.
In considering the matter, the District Court in New Jersey provided:
Plaintiff reads the statute to mean that a corporation can
be sued indefinitely after it has dissolved, wound up its affairs,
and distributed al l of its assets. This position is without merit.
Plaintiff has pointed to 	no authority 	in 	New Jersey or in 	this
district to 	support the 	position 	that 	a corporation 	which 	has
wound up and distributed all of its assets is subject to suit.
Section (2) of the statute is governed by Section (1 ), which
refers to 	a dissolved 	corporation 	winding 	up 	its 	affairs 	and
distributing its assets. It is undisputed that a corporation in that
process can sue and be sued. Once the corporation finishes that
process, it ceases to exist. A corporation may not be sued in
perpetuity.
Global, 992 F. Supp. at 695.
In 	so 	finding, 	the 	Global court looked to a comparable New York
statute, N.Y. Bus. Corp. §1006, which has been interpreted to mean that an
action can only be brought against a dissolved corporation until its affairs are
fully adjusted and its assets distributed. Global, 992 F.Supp. at 695 (citations
omitted). Under the New York statute, once the corporation 's affairs are fully
adjusted, the corporation is considered defunct and any suits against the
company are considered futile. Id. Instead , the only remaining remedy is to
maintain an 	action directly against the directors and/or shareholders. 	Id.
(citations omitted).
- 6 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 6 of 17
Based upon the similarities between the New Jersey and New York
statutes, the New Jersey District Court interpreted the NJBCA to mean that
"[a] corporation may indeed be sued while it is winding up its affairs, but that
amenability to suit ends when the corporation's assets have been distributed
and its affairs wound up ." Id. at 695-96. The court noted, however, that th is
would not apply in situations where the corporation was dissolved in order to
avoid creditors or potential su its. Id. at n.2.
In his brief in opposition to Wagner's motion , the plaintiff argues that,
despite Wagner's argument that it is not amenable to suit under the NJBCA,
New Jersey law does not prevent a dissolved corporation from being sued
after dissolution. 1 In doing so, the plaintiff looks to a number of cases decided
both before and after Global.
The earliest of the cases relied upon by the plaintiff is Hould v. John P.
Squire 	& 	Co ., 	79 	A. 	282 	(N .J. 	Sup. 	Ct. 	1911 ), which 	interpreted 	the
predecessor to 	the 	NJBCA as 	allowing 	suits 	against 	corporations 	after
1 In his responsive materials, the plaintiff indicates that he has not yet
had 	the 	opportunity 	to 	conduct 	any 	discovery 	of 	Wagner's 	business,
purported dissolution , the motivation for the initiation of dissolution 21 days
after it learned it was being sued 	by the plaintiff, or Wagner's business
activities after dissolution. (Doc. 43-1 , p. 2).
- 7 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 7 of 17
dissolution. 2 Construing the statute with an indefinite term liberally, the New
Jersey Supreme Court provided that "[t]o hold otherwise would enable a
corporation to defeat valid causes of action for heavy damages by the simple
expedient of dissolution and organization of a new corporation , taking over
the assets of the old one." Id. at 283.3
Subsequently, in Newmarkv. Abee/, 102 F.Supp. 993 (S.D.N .Y. 1952),
an 	antitrust 	action 	was 	brought 	against, 	among 	others, 	L.T.S. 	Cutter
Corporation , a New Jersey Corporation, which had been dissolved in 1948,
prior to the action havi ng been filed . In addressing the capacity of L.T.S.
Cutter Corporation to be sued, the district court provided:
The capacity of a corporation to sue or be sued in a Federal
Court is 'determined by the law under which it was organized.'
Rule 17(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C.A.
Since the defendants are New Jersey corporations, the effect of
dissolution 	is dependent upon 	New Jersey law. Sedgwick v.
Beasley, 84 U.S.App.D.C. 325, 173 F.2d 918; Beasley v. Fox, 84
U.S.App.D.C. 327, 173 F.2d 	920; Treemond 	Co. 	v. 	Schering
Corporation, 3 Cir ., 122 F.2d 702.
2 The language of the statute then provided : "All corporations, whether
they expire by their own limitation or be annulled by the Legislature or be
otherwise dissolved, shall be continued bodies corporate for the purposes of
prosecuting and defending suits by or against them , and of enabling them to
settle and close their affairs, to dispose of and convey their property and to
divide their capital, but not for the purpose of continuing the business for
which they were established. " Corporation Act of 1896, §53, P. L. p. 295.
3 Hould appears to be the only case from a binding New Jersey court
on the issue. See GC/U-Employer Retirement Fund v. Progress Printing Co,
Inc ., 2021 WL 3912552, *6 (C .D. Cal. May 10, 2021 ).
- 8 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 8 of 17
Section 14:13-4 of the General Corporation Law of New
Jersey, N.J.S.A., provides that all dissolved corporations 'shall
be continued bodies corporate for the purposes of prosecuting
and defending suits by or against them*** .' Under this section,
L.T.S. Cutter Corporation, even though dissolved, is subject for
an indefinite period to all 'suits at law or in equity, in contract or
tort, or of what nature soever, and whether begun before or after
dissolution .' Hould v. John P. Squire & Co. , 81 N.J.L. 103, 79 A.
282, 283.
Newmark v. Abee/, 102 F. Supp. 993,994 n.1 (S.D.N.Y. 1952).
Jumping ahead to 1972, the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Pennsylvania decided Johnson v. Four States Enterprises, Inc.,
355 F.Supp. 1312 (1972). Johnson was a breach of construction contract
action brought against Four States Enterprises, Inc., and its directors. The
action was ultimately dismissed against the directors for lack of diversity.
However, in addressi ng whether service on a New Jersey registered agent
for the corporation which had previously been dissolved was valid and proper
service , citing to Hou/d, the court provided that "under New Jersey Law, a
corporation after dissolution may be sued for a cause of action in tort arising
before such dissolution, and process may be served on the registered agent
of the corporation . This Court sees no reason why an action for breach of
contract should abate because of dissolution ." Johnson , 355 F. 	Supp. at
1319 (citations omitted), aff'd, 495 F.2d 1368 (3d Cir. 1974).
- 9 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 9 of 17
Later, the Supreme Court of New York considered whether a dissolved
New Jersey corporation , Jenkins Bros ., was amenable to suit in an asbestos
personal 	injury action . 	See 	Germain 	v. A. 0 . 	Smith 	Water Products, 41
Misc.3d 1228(A) (N .Y.S. 2013).4 In doing so, the court noted the language
of the applicable New Jersey Statute, which reads in relevant part:
14A:12-9. Effect of dissolution
(1) Except as a court may otherwise direct, a dissolved
corporation shall continue its corporate existence but shall carry
on no business except for the purpose of winding up its affairs by
(a) collecting its assets;
(b) conveying for cash or upon deferred payments, with or
without security, such of its assets as are not to be distributed in
kind to its shareholders;
(c) paying , satisfying and discharging its debts and other
liabi li ties; and
(d) doing all other acts required to liquidate its business and
affairs.
(2) Subject to the provisions of subsection 	14A: 12-9(1 ),
and except as otherwise provided by court order, the corporation,
its officers, directors and shareholders shall continue to function
in 	the 	same 	manner 	as 	if dissolution 	had 	not 	occurred. 	In
particular, and without limiting the generality of the foregoing,
(a) the directors of the corporation shall not be deemed to
be trustees of its assets ... ;
4 The plaintiffs counsel in Germain had also named Jenkins Bros. as
a defendant in a number of other asbestos personal injury actions. Germain,
41 Misc.3d at *1 n. 1.
- 10 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 10 of 17
(b) title to the 	corporation's 	assets 	shall 	remain 	In 	the
corporation until transferred by it in the corporate name;
(c) 	the 	dissolution 	shall 	not 	change 	quorum 	or voting
requirements for the board or shareholders ... ;
(d) shares may be transferred until the record date of the
final liquidating distribution or dividend to shareholders;
(e) the corporation may sue and be sued in its corporate
name and process may issue by and against the corporation in
the same manner as if dissolution had not occurred;
(f) no action brought against any corporation prior to its
dissolution shall abate by reason of such dissolution.
N.J. Rev . Stat. §14A:12-9.
In its motion to dismiss the action in Germain , Liberty Mutual, on behalf
of Jenkins, maintained that, once the winding up of a dissolved corporation
is completed, there is no longer a corporation against which suits may be
commenced . 	This 	is 	the 	same 	contention 	made 	by 	Wagner 	here.
Disagreeing with Liberty Mutual, the court in Germain reasoned:
Liberty Mutual contends that once the winding up process
of a dissolved New Jersey corporation is completed there is no
longer a corporation against which suits may be commenced. In
this regard, 	section 	(1) 	of 	N.J . Stat. 	§14A: 12-9, 	upon which
Liberty Mutual relies, establishes a finite post-dissolution list of
activities that a dissolved corporation is permitted to undertake
for 	the 	purpose 	of 	winding 	up 	its 	business. 	The 	activities
identified in section (2) of N.J . Stat. § 14A: 12-9, which include the
ability to sue and be sued as if dissolution had not occurred, are
subject to no such limitation because they do not constitute the
carrying on of business of the dissolved corporation . If Liberty
- 11 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 11 of 17
Mutual's interpretation of New Jersey law is that a dissolved
corporation is only amenable to suit until it is finished winding up
its affairs were correct, the ability to sue and be sued would be
included under N.J. Stat.§ 14A:12-9(1), not N.J. Stat.§ 14A:12-
9(2). Similarly, if all of the activities listed in N.J. Stat.§ 14A:12-
9(2) were intended to be limited to the winding up process, the
New Jersey Legislature would have had no reason to draft two
subsections to address this issue.
Germain v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co., 41 Misc. 3d 1228(A), 981 N.Y.S.2d
635 (Sup. Ct. 2013), aff'd sub nom. In re New York City Asbestos Litig. , 116
A.D.3d 571, 984 N.Y.S.2d 335 (2014).
. 	Setting 	its reasoning 	apart from that 	in 	Global, wherein 	the court
pointed 	to 	the 	lack 	of 	authority 	to 	support 	a 	finding 	that 	a 	dissolved
corporation remains amenable to suit even after the winding up of affairs, the
court in Germain first looked to the holding in Hou/d, supra. In doing so, the
Germain court pointed out that Hou/d was cited with approval in Int'/ Union
of Operating Engineers, Local 68, AFL-C/O v. RAC Atlantic City Holdings,
LLC, 2013 WL 353211 	(D .N.J. Jan. 29 , 2013), decided years after Global,
wherein the court found that the New Jersey Legislature did not place any
limitation on suits against dissolved corporations. Id. at *34. The court further
looked to Johnson, supra, 	a decision affirmed by the Third Circuit, which
found that the NJBCA allows legal actions against a dissolved corporation in
the same manner as if dissolution had not occurred. 	In fact, the Germain
court provided:
- 12 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 12 of 17
The majority of courts that have ruled on this issue have agreed
that a New Jersey corporation is amenable to suit even after the
winding up process has been completed. See In re Krafft-Murphy
Co. , 62 A3d 94, 103 (Del. 	Ch . 2013) (New Jersey "statutorily
provide[s] 	for 	the 	endless 	continuation 	of 	a 	dissolved
corporation .") ; Gilliam v Hi Temp Prods. , et al., 260 Mich App 98,
123 	(2003) 	("Unlike 	Michigan, 	California, 	New 	Jersey, 	and
Alaska have not followed the Model Business Corporation Act
(1984) by establishing time limits for claims against a dissolved
corporation. "); Johnson v Four States Enterprises, Inc ., 355 F.
Supp. 1312, 1319 (E.D. Pa. Dec. 13, 1972), aff'd 495 F2d 1368
(3d 	Ci r. 	1974) 	("under New Jersey 	Law, a corporation 	after
dissolution may 	be 	sued for a cause of action 	in tort arising
before such dissolution .. .. ); Dr. Hess & Clark, Inc. v Meta/salts
Corp ., 119 F.Supp. 427, 429 (D.N.J. Mar. 4, 1954) (noti ng that
"New Jersey has, by statute, preserved the right of suit" against
dissolved corporations); Newmark v Abee/, 102 F. Supp. 993 n.1
(S .D.N.Y. Mar. 3, 1952) (dissolved New Jersey corporations are
subject to suit "for an indefinite period" ).
Germain, 41 Misc. 3d 1228(A) at *5. Given the line of authority and the plain
meaning of the statute, Germain found that New Jersey Law permitted the
suit against Jenkins, a dissolved corporation. See a/so In re New York City
Asbestos Litigation, 116 A.D.3d 571 (N .Y.S. 2014) ("The plain language of
the New Jersey dissolution statute, 	which governs here, provides for a
corporation that has been dissolved to 'sue and be sued in its corporation
name' (N.J. Stat. Ann . §14A:12-9 [2] [e]), and the statute places no restriction
on how long a dissolved corporation maintains its capacity to be sued for its
tortious conduct committed pre-dissoluti on (see Hou/d v John P. 	Squire &
Co ., 81 N.J. L. 103, 79 A 282 [1911] ; International Union of Operating Engrs .,
- 13 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 13 of 17
Local 68, AFL-CIO v RAC Atlantic City Holdings, LLC, 2013 WL 353211 , *10,
2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 11413, *34 [D .N.J. 2013]").
More recently, the issue was addressed by the court in GCIU-Employer
Retirement Fund v. Progress Printing Co, Inc., 2021 WL 3912552 (C . D. Cal.
May 10, 2021 ). This was an ERISA action brought by the GCIU-Employer
Retirement Fund and its Board of Trustees against, among others, Progress
Printing Co ., Inc. , which was required to make contributions to the retirement
fund as a signatory to a collective bargaining agreement. Progress was a
New Jersey corporation which 	had ceased 	operations 	in 	2011 	and was
officially dissolved under New Jersey law in 2012 prior to the ERISA action
being filed .
Relying on Global, supra , Progress sought dismissal of the complaint
on the basis that it had been fully dissolved and lacked the capacity to be
sued. On the other side, the plaintiffs relied upon Germain, supra, to argue
that the NJBCA provides no limitation on the capacity of a dissolved New
Jersey corporation to be sued.
Noting that neither Global nor Germain was binding on the court in the
interpretation of New Jersey law, the court looked to the language of the
statute to determine the motion:
The 	plain 	language 	of sub-section 	(2)(e) 	allows 	a dissolved
corporation to sue and be sued as if dissolution had not occurred,
- 14 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 14 of 17
with 	no 	limitations 	other than 	those 	set forth 	in 	section 	(1 ).
Section (1) states that a dissolved corporation shall continue its
existence, with no temporal limitation. The only restriction is a
specific prohibition-the dissolved corporation shall carry on no
"business" other than for the purpose of winding up. Suing and
being sued is not "business." See Germain, 2013 WL 6065986,
at *4 ("The activities identified in section (2) of N.J. Stat. §14A: 12-
9, which include the ability to sue and be sued as if dissolution
had not occurred, are subject to no such limitation because they
do not constitute the carrying on of business of the dissolved
corporation."); see a/so Business, Black's Law Dictionary (11th
ed. 2019) (defining the term as "[a] commercial enterprise carried
on for profit"). Section (1) does not say that corporate existence
shall continue until it has wound up, or only for the purpose of
winding up. The corporation may not carry on business, except
insofar as it is winding up, but otherwise its legal status exists
even after dissolution-including to sue and be sued. The Global
Landfill court's conclusion that the corporation "ceases to exist"
once it finishes winding up contradicts the plain language of the
statute. 992 F. Supp. at 695.
GCIU-Emp. Ret. Fund, 2021 WL 3912552, at *4.
Continuing to read subsection (2)(e) in context, the court observed:
Section (2) lists ways in which corporations "shall continue to
function in the same manner as if dissolution had not occurred."
It does not list activities that the corporation may undertake as
part of the winding 	up process and 	only until that process 	is
complete-it provides certain principles of the corporate form that
endure beyond dissolution. One of these principles is that the
corporation can sue and be sued. It would not make sense for
sub-section 2(c), which maintains the corporation's quorum and
voting requirements, to last only so long as the corporation is in
the process is winding up. There also would be no need for sub-
sections 2(b) and (d) to specify their own termination conditions
if the entire section was conditioned on the corporation being in
the 	process 	of winding 	up. 	The fact that these 	sub-sections
include time limitations and sub-section (2)(e) does not is telling.
- 15 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 15 of 17
If suing and being sued were part of the winding up process, it
would 	have 	been 	listed 	in 	section 	(1 ), 	not 	section 	(2). 	See
Germain, 	2013 	WL 	6065986, 	at 	*4 	("If 	Liberty 	Mutual's
interpretation of New Jersey law is that a dissolved corporation
is only amenable to suit until it is finished winding up its affairs
were correct, the ability to sue and be sued would be included
under N.J. Stat.§ 14A:12-9(1), not N.J. Stat.§ 14A:12-9(2).")
Id. at *5.
Although case law on the issue is sparse, the court went on to outline
the case law which more widely accepts the view set forth in Germain, rather
than Global, and noted that the fact that other states' statutes specify a time
limit for claims against dissolved corporations, while New Jersey's does not,
further reinforces that amenability to suit is perpetual in New Jersey. Id.
Finally, the court discussed 	another reason 	why 	it found 	Globa/'s
reasoning to be unpersuasive. In this regard the court provided:
It relies heavily on a case from the Southern District of New York
which it claims interpreted an analogous New York statute. See
992 F. Supp. at 695 (citing Flute v. Rubel, 682 F. Supp. 184, 187
(S.D.N.Y. 1988)). But the New York statute discussed in Flute,
while sim ilar, states that a dissolved corporation "may continue
to function 	for the 	purpose 	of winding 	up 	the 	affairs 	of the
corporation 	in the same manner as if the dissolution 	had 	not
taken place ." N.Y. Bus. Corp. Law §1006(a) (emphasis added).
Section 	14A: 12-9(2), 	by 	contrast, 	states 	that 	the 	dissolved
corporation "shall continue to function in the same manner as if
dissolution 	had 	not 	occurred"-omitting 	the 	phrase, 	"for 	the
purpose of winding 	up the 	affairs of the corporation." 	In 	the
former statute, the corporation continues to exist solely for the
purpose of winding 	up its affairs. The latter contains no such
conditional clause. The New York law also uses the permissive
"may ," 	suggesting 	the 	corporation 	may 	choose 	to 	end 	its
- 16 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 16 of 17
existence, while the New Jersey statute uses the mandatory
"shall. "
Id. (emphasis in original).5
Considering 	the 	positions 	of 	the 	parties, 	with 	Wagner's 	reliance
primarily 	on 	Global and the plaintiff's on 	Germain, 	and the case law as
discussed above interpreting the NJBCA, the court finds the position of the
plaintiff better supported. As a result, Wagner's motion to dismiss will be
denied. An appropriate order shall issue.
E. MANNION
tes District Judge
DATE: 	J/~/<r,,
25- 91 3-01
5 In 	its 	reply 	brief, 	Wagner argues that the 	rationale 	applied 	and
decision reached in Global continue to be followed. (Doc. 47). In doing so,
Wagner cites to Next Millennium Realty, LLC v. 	Adchem Corp., 	2016 WL
1178957 (E.D.N .Y. Mar. 23, 2016), wherein the court addressed whether a
dissolved 	New York 	corporation 	was 	subject to 	suit 	under New York's
Business Corporation Law. While Wagner argues this law is substantively
identical to the NJBCA at issue in this case, this is the same New York law
which was distinguished in GCIU-Employer Retirement Fund, supra.
- 17 -
Case 3:25-cv-00913-MEM Document 53 Filed 03/20/26 Page 17 of 17

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.