USA v. BUTLER

3:23-cr-00828Njd2 feb 2026

Testo completo

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 1 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 2 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 3 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 4 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 5 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 6 of 6 PageID: <pageID>

OCR transcription for search; preserved printed pages are authoritative

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 1 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

NOT FOR PUBLICATION

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Criminal Action No. 23-828 (MAS)
MEMORANDUM OPINION

DAVID BUTLER.

SHIPP, District Judge

This matter comes before the Court upon Defendant David Butler’s (“Defendant”) Motion
to Withdraw his Guilty Plea, pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(d).! (ECF No. 66.)
The United States of America (the “Government”) opposed (ECF No. 69), and Defendant replied
(ECF No. 72). The Court has carefully considered the parties’ submissions and decides the matter
without oral argument pursuant to Local Criminal Rule 1.1 and Local Civil Rule 78.1(b). For the
reasons stated below, the Court grants Defendant’s Motion to Withdraw his Guilty Plea.

I. BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

On October 16, 2023, Defendant was charged by Indictment with: (1) conspiracy to
distribute methamphetamine, heroin, phencyclidine, and oxycodone contrary to 21 U.S.C.
§§ 841 (a)(1), (b)(1)(A), (b)1)(B), and (b)(1)(C), in violation of 21 U.S.C. § 846 (“Count One”);
(2) distribution and possession with intent to distribute phencyclidine and oxycodone, in violation

of 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1) and (b)(1)(C) (“Count Two”); (3) distribution and possession with intent

! Hereinafter, all references to “Rule” or “Rules” refer to the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.

AUTHENTICATED
U.S. GOVERNMENT
INFORMATION

GPO

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 2 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

to distribute phencyclidine, in violation of 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1) and (b)(1)(C) (“Count Three’’);
and (4) distribution and possession with intent to distribute phencyclidine and oxycodone, in
violation of 21 U.S.C. §§ 841(a)(1) and (b)(1)(C) (“Count Four’). (See generally Indictment, ECF
No. 33.)

Defendant entered into a plea agreement (the “Plea Agreement”) with the Government
pursuant to Rule 11(c)(1)(C) on May 22, 2024, by which the parties stipulated to a sentence “of
imprisonment within the range of 84 months to 108 months and three years of supervised
release[.]” (Plea Agreement 1, ECF No. 55.) The Plea Agreement provided that Defendant would
plead guilty to Counts Two, Three, and Four of the Indictment, and that the Government would
dismiss Count One of the Indictment if Defendant complied with its terms. Ud. at 1.) The Plea
Agreement contained a Schedule A that included several factual stipulations (the “Relevant
Conduct”). (Ud. at Schedule A.)

On June 5, 2024, the Court convened a change of plea hearing. (ECF No. 53; Ex. A to
Def.’s Mot. to Withdraw Plea (“Plea Hr’g Tr.”), ECF No. 66-2.) At the hearing, the Court engaged
Defendant in a colloquy regarding his decision to enter a plea of guilty and thereafter found that
Defendant was: (1) “fully competent and capable of entering an informed plea”; (2) “aware of the
charges and the consequences of the plea”; and (3) entering a guilty plea that was “knowing and
voluntary” and “supported by an independent basis in fact.” (Plea Hr’g Tr. at 4:6-16:19.) The
Court, however, deferred its decision to accept the Plea Agreement pending an opportunity to
review the final Presentence Report (the “PSR”’), which Defendant would have the ability to review
and object to in advance of sentencing. (/d. at 16:20-23, 17:4-7.)

Defendant’s sentencing was scheduled for December 3, 2024. Ud. at 17:10-11.) It was

subsequently adjourned and following a status conference held on April 10, 2025, Defendant was

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 3 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

appointed new counsel. (ECF No. 63; ECF No. 64.) Defendant, thereafter, filed the instant Motion
to Withdraw his Guilty Plea (“Motion to Withdraw”). (Mot. to Withdraw, ECF No. 66.)

Il. LEGAL STANDARD

Rule 11(d)(2)(B) “provides that ‘[a] defendant may withdraw a plea of guilty . . . after the
court accepts the plea, but before it imposes [a] sentence if[] . . . the defendant can show a fair and
just reason for requesting the withdrawal.’” United States v. Wilder, 134 F. App’x 527, 528 (3d Cir.
2005) (first two alterations in original) (quoting Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(d)(2)(B)). In determining

299

whether a defendant has shown a “‘fair and just reason’” for withdrawal, a district court must
consider three factors: (1) “whether the defendant asserts his innocence”; (2) “the strength of the
defendant’s reasons for withdrawing the plea”; and (3) “whether the government would be
prejudiced by the withdrawal.” United States v. Jones, 336 F.3d 245, 252 (3d Cir. 2003). “This
analysis requires that a district court consider each factor, but critically, does not make any one
mandatory such that failure to establish one will necessarily dictate rejection of the motion.”
Wilder, 134 F. App’x at 528 (emphasis in original).

While “[a] defendant ‘bears a substantial burden’ in showing that withdrawal of a guilty
plea is justified,” United States v. Berkowitz, No. 22-1967, 2023 WL 2064510, at *3 (3d Cir. Feb.
17, 2023) (citation omitted), the decision “‘to grant a motion to withdraw a guilty plea lies within
the discretion of the district court[,|’” United States v. Burrell, No. 22-294, 2025 WL 639332, at

*2 (E.D. Pa. Feb. 27, 2025) (quoting United States v. James, 928 F.3d 247, 253 (3d Cir. 2019)).

Iii. DISCUSSION

Defendant argues that this Court should grant his Motion to Withdraw for the following
reasons: (1) he was not apprised of the legal effect of the Relevant Conduct included in Schedule

A of the Plea Agreement; (2) his original attorney provided ineffective assistance of counsel which

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 4 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

resulted in Defendant’s guilty plea to offenses he did not commit—specifically, to the Relevant
Conduct from the conspiracy count; (3) his guilty plea was neither intelligent nor voluntary; and
(4) he would not have pled guilty if he understood the full weight of his guilty plea. (Def.’s Moving
Br. 4-7, ECF No. 66-1.)

The Government argues that Defendant has failed to meet his burden because: (1) he has
not asserted his innocence to the charges to which he pled guilty; (2) he has not adequately
demonstrated that his former counsel’s conduct amounts to a viable claim of ineffective assistance
of counsel; and (3) the Government would be prejudiced by the withdrawal of Defendant’s guilty
plea. (Gov’t’s Opp’n Br.1-2, ECF No. 69.)

First, the Court must consider whether Defendant has credibly asserted his innocence.
Jones, 336 F.3d at 252-53. Here, Defendant has not asserted his actual innocence of the charges to
which he pleaded guilty. (See Def.’s Cert. (“Cert.”) § 4, ECF No. 66-2 (explaining that “Counts
[Two], [Three,| and [Four] charge me with possession of CDS on those defined dates with intent
to distribute same[,]” and that “[t]hose charges I still wish to enter a guilty plea”).) Defendant has,
however, asserted his innocence to Count One of the Indictment, the conspiracy charge. Ud. § 3.)
Defendant contends that the Relevant Conduct included in Schedule A of the Plea Agreement
amounted to, “in essence[, him] pleading guilty to the conspiracy count.” (/d. § 7.) He submits that
the original plea agreement that he rejected—which included a guilty plea to Count One—and the
Plea Agreement that he accepted—in which the Government dropped Count One, were not actually
different because, according to Schedule A of the Plea Agreement, he “was to be sentenced on the
drug weight” included in Count One. (/d. J 8.) Defendant, additionally, asserts his actual innocence
on Count One of the Indictment (the conspiracy count), and contends that “I have always

maintained my innocence on that Count.” (/d. 3.) Because Defendant asserts his actual innocence

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 5 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

to Count One and appears to have a fundamental misunderstanding of how the Relevant Conduct
will impact his ultimate sentence, the Court finds that this factor weighs in favor of permitting
Defendant to withdraw his guilty plea.

Second, the Court must weigh Defendant’s reasons for withdrawal. James, 928 F.3d at 253.
Here, Defendant maintains that had he “known the full consequences[,|” he would “have never
pled guilty to the ‘[R]elevant [C]onduct’[.]” (Def.’s Moving Br. 1, 6.) Defendant contends that he
would have gone to trial instead. Ud. at 7.) Again, because there appears to be a fundamental
misunderstanding of how the Relevant Conduct will affect Defendant’s sentencing, the Court finds
that this factor weighs in favor of permitting Defendant to withdraw his guilty plea.

Third, the Court must weigh the prejudice to the Government of permitting Defendant to
withdraw his guilty plea. Jones, 336 F.3d at 255. The Government contends that it would be
prejudiced by the withdrawal of Defendant’s plea because its witnesses and attorneys were already
preparing to proceed to trial in May 2024 when Defendant signed the Plea Agreement. (Gov’t’s
Opp’n Br. 12.) It submits that preparing for trial all over again would be prejudicial. (/d.) The
Court agrees with the Government and finds that this factor weighs against permitting Defendant
to withdraw his guilty plea.

In sum, however, the Court places significant weight on the fact that it has not yet accepted
the Plea Agreement. (Plea Hr’g Tr. 16:20-23.) Based on Defendant’s fundamental
misunderstanding of how the Relevant Conduct included in Schedule A of the Plea Agreement will
affect his sentencing, the Court finds that there are fair and just reasons for permitting Defendant
to withdraw his guilty plea. United States v. Stewart, 51 F. Supp. 2d 1147, 1161 (D. Kan. 1999)
(explaining that “[t]he existence of a fundamental misunderstanding of the requirements and

operation of the plea agreement is a fair and just reason for permitting [a] defendant to withdraw

Case 3:23-cr-00828-MAS Document 78 Filed 02/02/26 Page 6 of 6 PagelD: <pagelD>

his plea” (citation omitted)), aff’d, 215 F.3d 1338 (10th Cir. 2000); United States v. Long,
No. 23-635, 2025 WL 1079061, at *2 (N.D. Ohio Apr. 8, 2025) (“Withdrawal of a plea is
appropriate where there is a real confusion or misunderstanding of the terms of the agreement.”).

IV. CONCLUSION

For the reasons set forth herein, Defendant’s Motion to Withdraw is granted. The Court

will issue an Order consistent with this Memorandum Opinion.

NM Eb pl

MICHAEL A. Suipp / /
2D / UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
/ , 2026

DATED: = /

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.