KNOX v. NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS et al

2:25-cv-01293Njd3 feb 2026

Testo completo

UNITED 	STATES 	DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
TRISMA KNOX,
Plaintiff,
v.
NEW 	JERSEY 	DEPARTMENT 	OF
CORRECTIONS 	and 	NICHOLAS
CALICCHIO,
Defendants.
No. 	25-cv-12 93 	(MEF) (MAH)
OPINION and ORDER
* 	* 	*
For 	the 	purposes 	of 	this 	brief 	Opinion 	and 	Order, 	the 	Court
largely 	assumes 	familiarity 	with 	the 	procedural 	history 	and
allegations 	of 	this 	case.
* 	* 	*
A woman 1 	("the 	Plaintiff") 	sued her 	Employer 2 	and 	her
Supervisor, 3 	alleging 	"discrimination, 	harassment, 	and
retaliation." 	Complaint 	and 	Jury 	Demand 	("Complaint") 	(ECF 	1)
<JI<JI 	9-11, 	15.
The 	Employer 	and 	the 	Supervisor 	now move 	to 	dismiss 	some 	of 	the
Plaintiff's 	claims 	under 	Federal 	Rules 	of 	Civil 	Procedure
12 (b) ( 1) 	and 	12 (b) ( 6) . 	See 	Brief 	in 	Support 	of 	Defendants'
Partial 	Motion 	to 	Dismiss 	the 	Complaint 	Pursuant 	to 	Rule 	Fed. 	R.
Civ. 	P. 	12 (b) (1), 	and 	12 (b) (6) 	("Defendants' 	Brief") 	(ECF 	7-1)
at 	1.
1
2
3
Trisma 	Knox.
New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections.
Nicholas 	Calicchio.
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 1 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
The 	motion 	is 	mainly 	granted.
* 	* 	*
First, 	consider 	the 	Plaintiff's 	claims 	for 	breach 	of 	the 	implied
covenant 	of 	good 	faith 	and 	fair 	dealing. 	See 	Complaint 	11 	79-
82.
The 	Employer, 	the 	New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections, 	argues
that 	this 	claim 	cannot 	go 	forward 	because 	it 	is 	protected by
sovereign 	immunity. 	See 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at 	8-9.
This 	has 	it 	right.
Under 	the 	Constitution, 	"states 	[are] 	generally 	immune 	from 	suit
by private 	parties 	in 	federal 	court." 	MCI 	Telecomm. 	Corp. 	v.
Bell 	Atl. 	Pa., 	271 	F.3d 	491, 	503 	(3d 	Cir. 	2001). 	"This 	immunity
extends 	to 	state 	. 	. 	departments." 	Id. 	And 	that 	includes 	the
New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections. 	See 	Fox 	v. 	Bayside 	State
Prison, 	726 	F. 	App'x 	865, 	867-68 	(3d 	Cir. 	2018) 	(so 	holding) . 4
As 	to 	the 	Supervisor, 	who 	also 	works 	for 	the 	New 	Jersey
Department 	of 	Corrections 5 --- 	he 	argues 	that 	because 	the
Department 	gets 	immunity, 	he 	(the 	Supervisor) 	is 	shielded by
immunity, 	too. 	See 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at 	5-6, 	8-9.
This 	argument 	works. 	The 	Supervisor 	is 	taken 	as 	having 	been
sued here 	in 	his 	official 	capacity. 6 	And 	"[i]ndividual 	state
employees 	sued 	in 	their 	official 	capacity 	are 	. 	. 	entitled 	to
[sovereign] 	immunity because 	official-capacity 	suits
generally 	represent 	only 	another 	way 	of 	pleading 	an 	action
4 	Accord, 	e.g., 	Jones 	v. 	DiBenedetto, 	2025 	WL 	1040387, 	at 	*2
(D.N.J. 	Apr. 	8, 	2025); 	Graham v. 	New 	Jersey, 	2022 	WL 	4010856, 	at
*5 	(D.N.J. 	Sept. 	2, 	2022); 	Tellus 	v. 	Murphy, 	2025 	WL 	3707430, 	at
*3 	(D.N.J. 	Dec. 	22, 	2025)
5 	See 	Complaint 	1 	3.
6 	The 	complaint 	does 	not 	explicitly 	indicate 	whether 	the
Supervisor 	is 	sued 	in 	his 	official 	or 	personal 	capacity. 	But 	in
their 	brief, 	the 	Defendants 	said 	that 	the 	Supervisor 	is 	sued 	in
"his 	official 	capacity," 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at 	5-6, 	and 	the
Plaintiff 	did 	not 	challenge 	this 	characterization 	in 	her 	reply.
See 	Melo 	v. 	Hafer, 	912 	F.2d 	628, 	635 	(3d 	Cir. 	1990) 	(noting 	that
courts 	can 	refer 	to 	the 	"course 	of 	[the] 	proceedings" 	to
determine 	the 	capacity 	in 	which 	a 	given 	defendant 	has 	been 	sued)
(cleaned 	up).
2
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 2 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
against 	the 	state." 	Betts 	v. 	New 	Castle 	Youth 	Dev. 	Ctr., 	621
F.3d 	249, 	254 	(3d 	Cir. 	2010) 	(cleaned 	up).
Bottom 	line: 	the 	Employer, 	the 	New 	Jersey 	Department 	of
Corrections, 	gets 	sovereign-immunity protection 	from 	the 	implied
covenant 	claim 	--- 	and 	drafting 	behind, 	so 	does 	the 	Supervisor,
the 	New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections 	employee. 7
* 	* 	*
Come 	now 	to 	the 	Plaintiff's 	claims 	that 	the 	Employer 	violated
the 	Age 	Discrimination 	in 	Employment 	Act 	and 	the 	Americans 	with
Disabilities 	Act, 	two 	federal 	laws. 	See 	Complaint~~ 	56-60, 	67-
72.
As 	to 	these 	claims, 	the 	Employer 	again 	points 	to 	sovereign
immunity, 	see 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at 	4-6, 8 but 	the 	Plaintiff 	has 	a
counterargument: 	sovereign 	immunity 	is 	off 	the 	table 	because 	she
is 	looking 	for 	"injunctive 	relief 	. 	. 	to 	end 	continuing 	or
ongoing 	violations 	of 	federal 	law." 	Plaintiff's 	Memorandum 	of
Law 	in 	Opposition 	to 	Defendants' 	Partial 	Motion 	to 	Dismiss
Pursuant 	to 	Rule 	12 (b) (1) 	and 	12 (b) (6) 	("Plaintiff's 	Brief")
(ECF 	9) 	at 	4.
7 	Against 	this 	conclusion, 	the 	Plaintiff 	argues 	that 	New 	Jersey
has 	given 	up 	its 	immunity 	as 	to 	implied 	covenant 	claims, 	via 	the
New 	Jersey 	Contractual 	Liability Act. 	See 	Plaintiff's
Memorandum 	of 	Law 	in 	Opposition 	to 	Defendants' 	Partial 	Motion 	to
Dismiss 	Pursuant 	to 	Rule 	12 (b) (1) 	and 	12 (b) (6) 	(ECF 	9) 	at 	8-9
(citing 	N.J. 	Stat. 	Ann. 	§ 	59:13-3). 	But 	that 	Act 	only 	applies
to 	lawsuits 	brought 	in 	New 	Jersey 	state 	courts. 	See 	NJSR
Surgical 	Ctr., 	L.L.C. 	v. 	Horizon 	Blue 	Cross 	Blue 	Shield 	of 	N.J.,
Inc., 	979 	F. 	Supp. 	2d 	513, 	518-20 	(D.N.J. 	2013); 	Winfield 	Scott
Tower 	Urb. 	Renewal 	LP 	v. 	Luciani, 	2024 	WL 	4570908, 	at 	*4 	n.5
(D.N.J. 	Oct. 	24, 	2024) 	(following 	NJSR); 	Prelle 	v. 	U.S. 	Mint,
2024 	WL 	4898064, 	at 	*6 	(E.D. 	Pa. 	Nov. 	26, 	2024) 	(same); 	see 	also
Patriot 	Aviation, 	LLC 	v. 	New 	Jersey, 	2007 	WL 	604793, 	at 	*4
( D. N. J. 	Feb. 	2 0, 	2 0 0 7) .
8 	Federal 	statutes 	can 	sometimes 	remove 	a 	state's 	sovereign
immunity. 	But 	for 	the 	sorts 	of 	workplace 	discrimination 	claims
in 	play 	here, 	the ADA 	does 	not 	do 	that. 	See 	Bd. 	of 	Trs. 	of
Univ. 	of Ala. 	v. 	Garrett, 	531 	U.S. 	356, 	360 	(2001). 	And 	neither
does 	the 	ADEA. 	See 	Kimel 	v. 	Fla. 	Bd. 	of 	Regents, 	528 	U.S. 	62,
91 	(2000).
3
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 3 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
It 	is 	true 	that 	sovereign 	immunity 	can 	work 	differently when
forward-looking 	injunctive 	relief 	is 	sought. 	See 	Ex 	parte
Young, 	209 	U.S. 	123, 	159-60 	(1908).
But 	that 	switch 	is 	only 	flipped 	when 	the 	defendant 	in 	question
is 	an 	"individual 	state 	officer[]." 	MCI 	Telecomm. 	Corp., 	271
F.3d 	at 	506.
And 	the 	Employer-defendant, 	the 	New 	Jersey 	Department 	of
Corrections, 	is 	not 	that. 	It 	is 	an 	agency, 	not 	an 	individual.
"[SJ uits 	against 	. 	. 	States 	and 	their 	agencies 	. 	. 	are
barred 	regardless 	of 	the 	relief 	sought." 	P.R. 	Aqueduct 	& Sewer
Auth. 	v. 	Metcalf 	& Eddy, 	Inc., 	506 	U.S. 	139, 	146 	(1993); 	see
also 	Shahin 	v. 	Del. 	Dep't 	of 	Fin., 	344 	F. 	App'x 	765, 	766 	(3d
Cir. 	2009); 	Kreiger 	v. 	Pa. 	Off. 	of Atty. 	Gen., 	44 	F. 	App'x 	537,
537 	(3d 	Cir. 	2002).
That 	is, 	"the 	relief 	sought," 	an
the 	defendant 	is 	an 	individual.
506 	U.S. 	at 	146. 	But 	not 	where,
"State[] 	. 	agenc[y] ." 	Id.
injunction, 	can matter 	where
P.R. 	Aqueduct 	& Sewer Auth.,
as 	here, 	the 	defendant 	is 	a
Accordingly, 	the 	ADA 	and ADEA 	claims 	against 	the 	Employer, 	the
New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections, 	must 	be 	dismissed.
* 	* 	*
Look, 	finally, 	to 	the ADA 	and ADEA 	claims 	against 	the
Supervisor.
As 	to 	these, 	the 	back-and-forth 	starts 	out 	as 	before. 	The
Supervisor 	invokes 	sovereign 	immunity. 	See 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at
4-6. 	And 	the 	Plaintiff 	again 	says 	that 	the 	above-discussed
sovereign-immunity 	exception 	applies 	--- 	the 	one 	for 	suits 	that
seek prospective 	injunctive 	relief 	against 	individual 	state
officials. 	See 	Plaintiff's 	Brief 	at 	4-5.
When 	it 	comes 	to 	the 	Supervisor, 	the 	Plaintiff 	seems 	to 	have 	the
winning 	argument. 	After 	all, 	the 	Supervisor 	is 	an 	individual,
and 	the 	Plaintiff 	is 	seeking 	a 	forward-looking 	injunction
against 	him. 9
9 	An 	injunction 	to 	give 	the 	Plaintiff 	an 	"[a]bility to 	volunteer
for 	overtime," 	to 	change 	her 	everyday workplace
responsibilities, 	and 	some 	other 	things. 	See 	Complaint 	at 	12.
4
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 4 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
But 	the 	counterargument 	from 	the 	defendants 	is 	this: 	the
injunction 	the 	Plaintiff 	seeks 	against 	the 	Supervisor 	is 	really,
in 	substance, 	a 	request 	for 	an 	injunction 	against 	her 	Employer,
the 	New 	Jersey 	Department 	of 	Corrections. 	The 	state, 	the
argument 	goes, 	"is 	the 	real, 	substantial 	party 	in 	interest 	in
this 	matter." 	Reply 	Brief 	in 	Support 	of 	Defendants' 	Partial
Motion 	to 	Dismiss 	the 	Complaint 	Pursuant 	to 	Fed. 	R. 	Civ. 	P.
12(b)(l), 	and12(b)(6) 	("Defendants' 	Reply") 	(ECFl0) 	at 	4. 	And
so, 	it 	is 	said, 	the 	state's 	sovereign 	immunity 	should 	cover 	the
Supervisor.
This 	argument 	is 	not 	persuasive.
It 	cannot 	be 	squared with 	Ex 	parte 	Young, 	which 	allows 	for
certain 	injunctive 	suits 	against 	a 	state 	official, 	even 	though
the 	practical 	impact 	of 	these 	injunctions 	often 	falls 	on 	the
state 	the 	official 	works 	for. 	See 	209 	U.S. 	at 	159-60.
Moreover, 	the 	argument 	is 	at 	odds 	with 	Board 	of 	Trustees 	of
University 	of Alabama 	v. 	Garrett, 	in 	which 	the 	Supreme 	Court
held 	that 	the 	part 	of 	the 	ADA 	invoked 	here 	by 	the 	Plaintiff 10
"can 	be 	enforced 	. 	in 	actions 	for 	injunctive 	relief" 	against
individual 	state 	officials, 	like 	the 	Supervisor. 	531 	U.S. 	356,
374 	n. 9 	(2001).
And 	finally, 	the 	Supervisor's 	argument 	runs 	aground 	on 	Koslow 	v.
Commonwealth 	of 	Pennsylvania, 	in 	which 	the 	Third 	Circuit 	held
that 	sovereign 	immunity 	did 	not 	prevent 	a 	plaintiff 	from 	seeking
(as 	here) 	prospective 	injunctive 	relief 	under 	the 	ADA 	against 	an
employee 	at 	a 	state 	department 	of 	corrections. 11 	See 	302 	F.3d
161, 	179 	(3d 	Cir. 	2002).
The 	Supervisor's 	motion 	to 	dismiss 	the 	ADA 	claim on 	sovereign
immunity 	grounds 	must 	be 	denied. 12
10 	Title 	I. 	See 	Complaint 	11 	67-72; 	Garrett, 	531 	U.S. 	at 	360.
11 	There, 	the 	state 	was 	Pennsylvania. 	Koslow, 	302 	F.3d 	at 	165.
Here, 	it 	is 	New 	Jersey.
12 	The 	same 	analysis 	applies 	to 	the 	Plaintiff's 	ADEA 	claim. 	It
can 	go 	forward 	to 	the 	extent 	the 	Plaintiff 	seeks 	prospective
injunctive 	relief 	against 	the 	Supervisor. 	See 	Smith 	v. 	Sec'y 	of
Dep't 	of 	Env't 	Prot. 	of 	Pa., 	540 	F. 	App'x 	80, 	82 	(3d 	Cir. 	2013);
Dennison 	v. 	Ind. 	Univ. 	of 	Pa., 	2022 	WL 	3213657, 	at 	*11 	(W.D. 	Pa.
Aug. 	9, 	2022), 	aff'd 	on 	other 	grounds, 	2023 	WL 	8595426 	(3d 	Cir.
Dec. 	12, 	2023); 	Howell 	v. 	Millersville 	Univ. 	of 	Pa., 	2017 	WL
5
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 5 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
* 	* 	*
In 	short:
The 	motion 	to 	dismiss 	at 	ECF 	7 	is 	granted 	as 	to 	(i) 	the 	implied
covenant 	claims 	pressed 	against 	each 	defendant, 	and 	(ii) 	the 	ADA
and ADEA 	claims 	against 	the 	Employer, 	the 	New 	Jersey 	Department
of 	Corrections.
The 	motion 	is 	denied 	as 	to 	the 	ADA 	and ADEA 	claims 	brought
against 	the 	Supervisor, 	to 	the 	extent 	the 	Plaintiff 	seeks
prospective 	injunctive 	relief. 13
IT 	IS 	on 	this 	2nd 	day 	of 	February, 	2026~ 	SO ORDERED.
Michael 	E. 	Farbiarz, 	U.S.D.J.
3189209, 	at 	*3 	(E.D. 	Pa. 	July 	27, 	2017); 	Thelen 	v. 	Pa. 	State
Sys. 	of 	Higher 	Educ., 	2021 	WL 	3370791, 	at 	*10 	(W.D. 	Pa. 	Aug. 	3,
2021).
13 	In 	one 	spot, 	the 	Complaint 	arguably 	seeks 	damages 	under 	the
ADA 	and 	the 	ADEA 	against 	the 	Supervisor. 	See 	Complaint 	at 	12.
The 	Supervisor 	argues 	that 	these 	claims 	are 	barred by 	sovereign
immunity, 	see 	Defendants' 	Brief 	at 	5-6, 	and 	the 	Plaintiff's
push-back 	ignores 	damages 	--- 	focusing 	only 	on 	the 	idea 	that 	she
is 	indeed 	seeking 	injunctive 	relief. 	See 	Plaintiff's 	Brief 	at
4-5. 	If 	the 	Plaintiff 	seeks 	damages 	against 	the 	Supervisor
under 	the 	ADA 	and/or 	the 	ADEA, 	then 	she 	will 	need 	to 	clarify 	her
intentions 	during 	any 	subsequent 	stages 	of 	this 	litigation. 	If
she 	does 	so, 	the 	Supervisor 	will 	then 	be 	afforded 	an 	opportunity
to 	press 	any 	arguments 	in 	response.
6
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 6 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.