QASIM et al v. SPECTRUM BRANDS HOLDINGS, INC. et al

2:21-cv-18744Njd12 gen 2026

Testo completo

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
IBRAHIM QASIM and NOUH QASIM,
Plaintiffs,
v.
SPECTRUM BRANDS HOLDINGS, INC.,
et al.,
Defendants.
Civil Action No. 21-18744 (JXN)(JRA)
OPINION
NEALS, District Judge
Before the Court is Defendants Spectrum Brands Holdings, Inc. (“Spectrum”), United
Industries Corporation (“United”), Liquid Fence Company, and The Home Depot, Inc.’s (“Home
Depot”) (collectively, “Defendants”) motion to exclude the opinions and testimony of Dr. James
Pugh, Ph.D., P.E. (“Dr. Pugh”) pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and Daubert v. Merrell
Dow Pharmaceuticals., Inc., 509 U.S. 579, 589–95 (1993). (ECF No. 42.) Plaintiffs Ibrahim Qasim
(“Ibrahim”1) and Nouh Qasim (“Nouh”) (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) opposed (ECF No. 45), and
Defendants replied (ECF No. 46). The Court held a Daubert hearing (ECF No. 110), and the parties
submitted supplemental briefs (ECF Nos. 109, 111). For the reasons set forth below, Defendants’
motion to exclude Dr. Pugh’s testimony is GRANTED.
I. 	BACKGROUND
A. 	Statement of Facts
The parties are familiar with the facts, so the Court recounts them briefly. Ibrahim bought
a sixty-four-ounce container of EcoLogic Bed Bug Killer 2 (“Product”) from Home Depot on
1 Because Plaintiffs share the same last name, the Court refers to them individually by their first names.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 1 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
2
August 26, 2019.2 (Defs.’ Statement of Undisputed Material Facts (“SUMF”) ¶ 1, ECF No. 42-
12.) On September 2, 2019, at 9:00 a.m., Ibrahim sprayed all sixty-four ounces of the Product into
the living room of the apartment he and Nouh shared. (Id. ¶¶ 16–18.) At 5:00 p.m., as Nouh turned
on the gas stove in the kitchen to make coffee, a fireball erupted, severely burning both Plaintiffs.3
(Id. ¶ 19.) The Newark Fire Department found sodium azide in the bathtub drain, a highly toxic
chemical compound “used to make explosives and methamphetamine.”4 (Id. ¶ 24.) First
responders also found a gasoline can in the apartment.5 (Id. ¶ 25.)
B. 	Procedural History
In August 2021, Plaintiffs sued Defendants in New Jersey Superior Court for (i) Strict
Products Liability: Design Defect (Count One), (ii) Strict Products Liability: Failure to Warn
(Count Two), (3) Negligence (Count Three), and (4) Violations of the Consumer Fraud Act
(“CFA”) (Count Four). (See Compl, ECF No. 1-1.) Defendants timely removed to this Court.6 (See
Notice of Removal, ECF No. 1.)
2 United designed, labeled, and packaged the Product.2 (Id. ¶ 10.) Spectrum, a holding company, indirectly owns
United. (See Defs.’ SUMF at 1 n.1.)
3 As explained in its summary judgment Opinion, the Court accepted this fact as unrebutted because Plaintiffs failed
to cite any record evidence to the contrary. Qasim v. Spectrum Brands Holdings, Inc., No. 21-18744, 2024 WL
4345153, at *1 n.4 (D.N.J. Sept. 30, 2024).
4 In Plaintiffs’ statement of undisputed material facts, Plaintiffs assert the Newark Fire Department’s statement is
inadmissible hearsay. (See Pls.’ Statement of Undisputed Material Facts (“SUMF”) ¶ 24, ECF No. 45-2.) To be sure,
a party “may object that the material cited to support or dispute a fact cannot be presented in a form that would be
admissible in evidence.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c)(2). But “this must be done in a brief. The statement of material facts is
not the vehicle for conveying these points.” Teubert v. SRA Int’l, Inc., 192 F. Supp. 3d 569, 576 (D.N.J. 2016). Because
Plaintiffs do not make this argument in their brief, the Court considers the Newark Fire Department’s statement
undisputed for purposes of this motion. Id.
5 As before, Plaintiffs’ statement of undisputed material facts asserts the first responders’ statement is inadmissible
hearsay. (Pls.’ SUMF ¶ 25.) And again, the statement of material facts is not the place to make this argument. Teubert,
192 F. Supp. 3d at 576.
6 The Court notes it has jurisdiction. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, a federal court has jurisdiction over an action where (a)
no plaintiff is a citizen of the same state as any defendant, and (b) the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000. Zambelli
Fireworks Mfg. Co. v. Wood, 592 F.3d 412 (3d Cir. 2010). A corporation is a citizen of both its state of incorporation
and where it principally does business. Id. (citing 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)). Plaintiffs are New Jersey residents; Spectrum,
United, and Home Depot are Delaware corporations principally doing business in Wisconsin, Missouri, and Georgia,
respectively; Legal Fence is not a legal entity separate from United. (Notice of Removal at 2–3.) So, the parties are
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 2 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
3
Plaintiffs retained Dr. Pugh as an expert, who summarized his analysis in a two-page report
(“Pugh Report”). (See Defs.’ SUMF ¶ 27; Pugh Report, ECF No. 42-11.) Dr. Pugh bought a
fourteen-ounce aerosol can of the Product as an “exemplar” of the container Ibrahim used. (Pugh
Report at *4.7) To render his conclusions, Dr. Pugh examined: (i) “the photographs of the container
of [the Product] used by . . . [P]laintiffs”; (ii) the exemplar can; (iii) “the Safety Data Sheet for [the
Product]”; (iv) “the specifications for Sodium Azide”; and (v) “the specifications for Sodium
Benzoate, one of the components of the [Product].” (Id.) Dr. Pugh explained:
The Safety Data Sheet for the [Product] indicates that it is flammable and must not
be used in the presence of heat or open flame. The [exemplar] can of [the Product]
lists sodium benzoate as a component, and in very small print, necessitating a
magnifying glass, “Do not use or store near heat or open flame.” There was none
of the three hazard pictograms, nor signal words, nor adequate hazard statements
on the can itself, all of which are mandated by the Safety Data Sheet, and as
mandated by the ANSI Z35 and Z535 series of standards. Further, there was no
information as to how long to wait prior to exposing treated areas to an open flame
such as a cigarette lighter, a match, or a gas-range.
Further, the container of [P]roduct used in the accident has the verbiage “Safe
Around Children & Pets” with an associated pictogram showing a child and a pet
prominently present on the front of the container and as the first and topmost
alerting instruction provided. The presence of wording, and pictogram all are
misleading and necessarily create an illusion of safety in the use of the product, and
is dissuasive of a user proceeding further in the reading of the instructions,
particularly in the absence of additional pictograms such as the open flame
pictogram. . . .
Further, in addition[ ] to the aerosol product being flammable in and of itself,
sodium benzoate, one of the components of the [Product], dries to a white dusty
powder, which is explosive in nature.
(Id. at *4–5.) After recounting Plaintiffs’ telling of the events, Dr. Pugh,
completely diverse. And, while Plaintiffs do not specify the amount of damages sought, the severity of their injuries
indicates such an amount likely exceed $75,000. See Morrison v. Spirit Airlines, Inc., No. 19-18743, 2019 WL
6907481, at *3 (D.N.J. Dec. 17, 2019) (noting amount in controversy appeared to exceed $75,000 where plaintiff
alleged sustaining serious and permanent injuries).
7 Pincites preceded by an asterisk (*) refer to CM/ECF pagination.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 3 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
4
concluded, to a reasonable degree of scientific, engineering, ergonomic, and human
factors certainty, that the defective labeling of the product was the proximate cause
of the accident. Had an open flame pictogram been prominently displayed as the
child and pet pictogram was displayed, the plaintiff would have noticed that the
product was flammable and would not have taken necessary precautions to avoid
ignition of the product.
(Id. at *5.)
In October 2023, Defendants moved for summary judgment and to exclude Dr. Pugh’s
expert report under Federal Rule of Evidence 702. (See Defs.’ Moving Br., ECF No. 42-1.)
Defendants argued Dr. Pugh’s expert report should be excluded because it concluded the warning
label on the Product caused the fire without 	“any mention of scientific methodologies,
mathematical calculations, or independent testing and analysis.” (Id. at 14–15.) Specifically,
Defendants claimed Dr. Pugh did not perform any testing or analysis to determine: (a) the cause
or origin of the fire; (b) “whether chemical components of the Product (e.g., sodium benzoate or
isopropyl alcohol) . . . could have concentrated near the ignition source of the stove to cause a
fire”; or (c) “how any vapor from the Product that was applied in the living room and evaporated
into the air could have migrated toward the kitchen.” (Id. at 15.) Plaintiffs opposed (Pls.’ Opp’n,
ECF No. 45-1) and Defendants replied (Defs.’ Reply, ECF No. 46).
The Court granted Defendants’ motion in part. See Qasim, 2024 WL 4345153, at *1–6.
The Court dismissed Counts One, Three, and Four with prejudice, id. at *3–4, and dismissed all
claims against Home Depot, id. at *5–6. As for Count Two, the Court concluded a Daubert hearing
was necessary before it could resolve the motion. Id. at *4. Accordingly, the Court denied the
summary judgment motion without prejudice as to Plaintiffs’ failure to warn claim. Id.
The Court held a Daubert hearing on October 6, 2025. (See Hearing Tr., ECF No. 110.) At
the hearing, Defendants argued: (1) Dr. Pugh was not qualified to offer an opinion about the cause
and origin of the fire; (2) Dr. Pugh’s opinion about the cause of the fire was not relevant because
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 4 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
5
it did not address how the warning on the Product led to the fire; and (3) Dr. Pugh’s methods were
unreliable because he did not conduct any testing to show how Plaintiffs’ suggested flammability
pictogram would have been more adequate, and failed to rule out other possible causes of the fire.
(Id. at 14:22–17:15.)
Dr. Pugh testified at the Daubert hearing. (See generally id.) Dr. Pugh explained he earned
an undergraduate degree in engineering and a Ph.D. in biomedical engineering from the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (“MIT”). (Id. at 26:1–5.) While a graduate student at MIT,
Dr. Pugh worked at the U.S. Army Materials and Mechanics Research Lab. (Id. at 25:21–23.) After
graduating, Dr. Pugh taught biomechanics, engineering, and materials sciences at several
institutions, including New York University. (Id. at 26:16–27:8.) Dr. Pugh testified he had “been
frequently called on to analyze products, warnings, and instructions, particularly with regard to
motor vehicle vehicles . . . and how the operators manual can be improved significantly to draw
people’s attention to certain aspects of a motor vehicle.” (Id. at 23:19–24:1.) Dr. Pugh stated he
also did “work with the U.S. Postal Service with regard to improving their employee safety with
guidance with signage and the like.” (Id. at 24:2–8.) Dr. Pugh averred he did “a lot of thermal
injuries analysis, particularly electrical with regard to short circuits, electrocutions, arcing of
networks that have caused injuries.” (Id. at 24:20–22.)
Dr. Pugh opined the Product’s 12% isopropyl alcohol content caused the fire, as the blaze
“was totally consistent with an isopropyl alcohol fire.” (Id. at 31:9–11.) Dr. Pugh explained he was
qualified to conclude that isopropyl alcohol caused the fire because:
I have a large amount of experience with alcohol, isopropyl alcohol fires. I am a
sailor. I had a sail boat that had an alcohol stove, isopropyl stove, for a number of
years that I would work with. And I am very aware of certain features of isopropyl
alcohol fires that people aren’t aware of.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 5 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
6
(Id. at 30:16–22.) On cross-examination, however, Dr. Pugh acknowledged he “didn’t do any
experiments” to assess if isopropyl alcohol could cause a fire based on how Plaintiffs used the
product. (Id. at 59:1–3.) Dr. Pugh also noted he did not create any experimental model to analyze
the Product’s flammability. (Id. at 81:20–24.) Moreover, Dr. Pugh conceded he did not conduct
any testing or analysis to determine how long it would take for the Product’s flammable
components to dissipate. (Id. at 77:20–78:5.)
Dr. Pugh testified he was not a certified fire investigator, a member of the International
Association of Arson Investigators, the National Association of Fire Investigators, or the National
Fire Protection Association. (Id. at 59:18–60:19.) Nor had Dr. Pugh published any articles about
the adequacy of pesticide warnings or isopropyl alcohol fires. (Id. at 65:1–23.) Dr. Pugh
acknowledged he examined a different container of the Product—Ibrahim used a sixty-four-ounce
hand pump bottle of the Product; Dr. Pugh examined a fourteen-ounce aerosolized spray can. (Id.
at 69:16–70:19.)
Dr. Pugh explained he did not conduct any experimental testing to rule out other possible
causes of the fire. Though a can of gasoline was found in the apartment, Dr. Pugh ruled out gasoline
as a cause without any experimental testing. (Id. at 75:4–19, 76:5–12.) Likewise, although the
bathroom had traces of sodium azide, an explosive substance, Dr. Pugh ruled that out as a cause
of the fire because the fire started in the kitchen. (Id. at 34:22–25.)
Dr. Pugh concluded the Product’s warning label “was defective and deficient” because it
was not alerting, sufficiently alerting to a user, that the product, which contains
12[%] isopropyl alcohol, which is highly flammable, and is highly flammable even
when mixed with other ingredients, including water to dilutions as low as one or
two percent. That it does not indicate to a user adequately the flammable nature of
the product and the fact that it should not be used near an ignition source. The
ignition source being such as a Piezo electric ignitor on a stove, a gas stove as an
expert.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 6 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
7
(Id. at 29:24–30:10.) Because the Product contained flammable isopropyl alcohol, Dr. Pugh
concluded the container should have “included an open flame pictogram.” (Id. at 52:12–13.)
However, Dr. Pugh stated he did not test his proposed pictogram on any focus group or consumers.
(Id. at 74:3–19.) And Dr. Pugh acknowledged he could not say “within a level of certainty” that
Ibrahim would have used the Product differently if it had had a pictogram. (Id. at 71:15–16.)
Following the Daubert hearing, the parties submitted supplemental briefs. (Pls.’ Supp. Br.,
ECF No. 109; Defs.’ Supp. Br., ECF No. 111.)
II. 	LEGAL STANDARD
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, a witness qualified as an expert may provide expert
testimony if: (a) “the expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the
trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue”; (b) “the testimony is based
on sufficient facts or data”; (c) “the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods”;
and (d) “the expert’s opinion reflects a reliable application of the principles and methods to the
facts of the case.” Fed. R. Evid. 702. Federal Rule of Evidence 702 thus imposes “three distinct
substantive restrictions on the admission of expert testimony: qualifications, reliability, and fit.”
Cohen v. Cohen, 125 F.4th 454, 460 (3d Cir. 2025) (quoting Elcock v. Kmart Corp., 233 F.3d 734,
741 (3d Cir. 2000)).
“[T]rial courts must perform a gatekeeping function to ensure the relevance and reliability
of expert testimony.” In re Johnson & Johnson Talcum Powder Prods. Mktg., Sales Pracs. &
Prods. Litig., 509 F. Supp. 3d 116, 130 (D.N.J. 2020). “In conducting this analysis, courts are to
consider ‘all aspects of the expert’s testing: the methodology, the facts underlying the expert’s
opinion, [and] the link between the facts and the conclusion.’” Id. at 131 (quoting ZF Meritor, LLC
v. Eaton Corp., 696 F.3d 254, 291–92 (3d Cir. 2012)). “Moreover, courts must ensure that expert
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 7 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
8
testimony reflects accepted standards within the relevant scientific and business communities.” Id.
“The party proposing the expert testimony must show that each prong is satisfied by a
preponderance of the evidence.” Fabricant v. Intamin Amusement Rides Int. Corp. Est., No. 19-
12900, 2025 WL 1823143, at *11 (D.N.J. July 2, 2025) (quoting Oddi v. Ford Motor Co., 234
F.3d 136, 144 (3d Cir. 2000)).
III. 	DISCUSSION
A. 	Qualification
A witness “must be qualified to testify as an expert.” Ford v. Ford Motor Co., 311 F. Supp.
3d 667, 673 (D.N.J. 2017) (quoting Calhoun v. Yamaha Motor Corp., 350 F.3d 316, 321 (3d Cir.
2003)). This is a low bar. In re Paoli R.R. Yard PCB Litig. (“Paoli II”), 35 F.3d 717, 741 (3d Cir.
1994). An expert need only “possess[] specialized expertise.” In re Hum. Tissue Prods. Liab. Litig.,
582 F. Supp. 2d 644, 655 (D.N.J. 2008) (quoting Pineda v. Ford Motor Co., 520 F.3d 237, 244
(3d Cir. 2008)). Specialized expertise is “skill or knowledge greater than the average layman.”
Aloe Coal Co. v. Clark Equip. Co., 816 F.2d 110, 114 (3d Cir. 1987). “[A] broad range of
knowledge, skills, and training qualify an expert as such,” Paoli II, 35 F.3d at 741, including
“practical experience as well as academic training and credentials.” Daiichi Pharm. Co., Ltd v.
Apotex, Inc., No. 03-937, 2005 WL 7979497, at *2 (D.N.J. Nov. 1, 2005) (quoting Elcock, 233
F.3d at 741). “The criteria required to qualify an expert turn largely upon the subject matter of the
opinion to be offered.” Silipena v. Am. Pulverizer Co., No. 16-711, 2024 WL 3219226, at *10
(D.N.J. June 28, 2024) (quoting Kerrigan v. Maxon Ind., 223 F. Supp. 2d 626, 635 (E.D. Pa.
2002)). “If the expert meets liberal minimum qualifications, then the level of the expert’s expertise
goes to credibility and weight, not admissibility.” Kannankeril v. Terminix Int’l, Inc., 128 F.3d
802, 809 (3d Cir. 1997). “[I]t is an abuse of discretion to exclude testimony simply because the
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 8 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
9
trial court does not deem the proposed expert to be the best qualified or because the proposed
expert does not have the specialization that the court considers most appropriate.” Holbrook v.
Lykes Bros. S.S. Co., 80 F.3d 777, 782 (3d Cir. 1996).
Here, Dr. Pugh opined about the Product’s warning label and the cause of the fire. Dr. Pugh
has extensive experience analyzing “products, warnings, and instructions.” (Hearing Tr. at 23:19–
24:1.) So, he has more knowledge than the average layperson about the adequacy of warnings. Dr.
Pugh, therefore, is qualified to opine about the Product’s warning label.
Dr. Pugh, however, is not qualified to testify about the cause of the fire. To be sure, Dr.
Pugh testified he had “done a lot of thermal injuries analysis” and was “exposed to a large amount
of fire and thermal events” in his work at MIT. (Id. at 24:20–25:14.) But analyzing burns on the
human body or seeing fires in a ballistics laboratory are fundamentally different than investigating
the origin of a fire. Dr. Pugh has never been a fire investigator, been a member of a professional
fire investigation organization, or published an article on the causes of fires. (Id. at 59:18–60:19,
65:1–23. See also Pugh Report at *7–34.) Dr. Pugh has no training in recognizing burn patterns.
(Id. at 49:11–15.) And the record does not reflect he has any practical experience investigating the
origin of a fire. Instead, Dr. Pugh’s sole experience with fire causation comes from owning a
sailboat with an isopropyl alcohol stove, (id. at 30:18–19), and taking courses at MIT covering
isopropyl alcohol fires, (id. at 48:24–49:3.) But the fact that Dr. Pugh knows what an alcohol fire
looks like in a stove on a boat does not qualify him to give an expert opinion that this fire was an
alcohol fire, or the Product caused it. See Yazujian v. PetSmart, 729 F. App’x 213, 216 (3d Cir.
2018) (excluding retail safety expert whose sole experience was “based on his review of over one
hundred retail store manuals, and . . . visits to retail stores where he would walk in and look
around.”); United States v. Keszey, 643 F. App’x 153, 158 (3d Cir. 2016) (excluding snake bite
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 9 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
10
expert who had “had little, if any, training in herpetology and minimal academic exposure to the
subject.”); Aloe Coal Co., 816 F.2d at 114–15 (holding tractor salesman unqualified to testify about
cause of tractor fire); United States v. Nyce, No. 20-063, 2022 WL 1214171, at *4 (E.D. Pa. Apr.
25, 2022) (“And while [defendant’s experts] may have some experience in breeding animals,
nothing in their biographies suggests that they are qualified—or even able, as a veterinarian would
be—to similarly interpret [veterinary medical] records.”); Travelers Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. v. R-Tek
Insulation, Inc., 673 F. Supp. 3d 879, 885 (N.D. Ohio 2023) (“The fact that [an expert] possesses
knowledge of how a fire might theoretically be started by the heat from a non-IC rated canister
light in no way qualifies him to give an expert opinion on the cause or origin of the fire in this
case.”). Accordingly, while Dr. Pugh is qualified to testify about warning labels, he is not qualified
to testify about the cause of the fire.
B. 	Reliability
Expert testimony must be reliable. Daubert, 509 U.S. at 590–91. Reliable testimony is
“based on the methods and procedures of science, not on subjective belief and unsupported
speculation.” Cohen, 125 F.4th at 461–62 (quoting Karlo v. Pittsburgh Glass Works, LLC, 849
F.3d 61, 80–81 (3d Cir. 2017)). “This inquiry ‘applies to all aspects of an expert’s testimony: the
methodology, the facts underlying the expert’s opinion, [and] the link between the facts and the
conclusion.’” Id. at 462 (alteration in original) (quoting ZF Meritor, 696 F.3d at 291). The question
is not “whether a particular scientific opinion has the best foundation, or even whether the opinion
is supported by the best methodology or unassailable research.” Id. (quoting Karlo, 849 F.3d at
81). “Instead, the [C]ourt looks to whether the expert’s testimony is supported by ‘good grounds.’”
Karlo, 849 F.3d at 81 (quoting In re TMI Litig., 193 F.3d 613, 665 (3d Cir. 1999)). Good grounds
include:
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 10 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
11
(1) whether a method consists of a testable hypothesis; (2) whether the method has
been subject to peer review; (3) the known or potential rate of error; (4) the
existence and maintenance of standards controlling the technique’s operation; (5)
whether the method is generally accepted; (6) the relationship of the technique to
methods which have been established to be reliable; (7) the qualifications of the
expert witness testifying based on the methodology; and (8) the non-judicial uses
to which the method has been put.
Id. (quoting UGI Sunbury LLC v. A Permanent Easement for 1.7575 Acres, 949 F.3d 825, 834 (3d
Cir. 2020)). But “these factors are neither exhaustive nor applicable in every case.” Kannankeril,
128 F.3d at 806–07. Though no single factor “is dispositive, some analysis of these factors is
necessary.” UGI Sunbury LLC, 949 F.3d at 834. And the Court has “‘broad latitude’ in determining
how to assess the reliability of an expert opinion.” Tyger v. Precision Drilling Corp., 832 F. App’x
108, 112 (3d Cir. 2020) (quoting Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael, 526 U.S. 137, 141–42 (1999)).
But while Daubert does not require “a paradigm of scientific inquiry,” it demands “more than [a]
haphazard, intuitive inquiry.” Oddi, 234 F.3d at 156. “[A]n expert opinion overly reliant on
assumptions absent ‘sufficient factual predicates’ is a ‘castle made of sand.’” Tyger, 832 F. App’x
at 113 (quoting Elcock, 233 F.3d at 755).
i. 	Fire Causation
Dr. Pugh’s opinion about the cause of the fire lacks good grounds because it is based
entirely on comparing pictures of the apartment to his experience using an alcohol stove on a boat.
“Although there may be some circumstances where one’s training and experience will provide an
adequate foundation to admit an opinion and furnish the necessary reliability to allow a jury to
consider it, this is not such a case.” Oddi, 234 F.3d at 158. Dr. Pugh did not test the Product or
account for the distance between where Ibrahim sprayed the Product and the site of the fire, the
time between when Ibrahim sprayed the Product and the fire, or the presence of other flammable
substances in the apartment. He “used little, if any, methodology beyond his own intuition.” Id.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 11 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
12
“There is nothing here to submit to peer review, and it is impossible to ascertain any rate of error
for [Dr. Pugh’s] assumptions about the [cause of the fire].” Id. “Similarly, no standards control his
analysis, and no ‘gatekeeper’ can assess the relationship of [Dr. Pugh’s] method to other methods
known to be reliable and the non-judicial uses to which it has been put.” Id. In short, Dr. Pugh had
no reliable basis to conclude the Product’s isopropyl alcohol content caused the fire. See, e.g.,
Fabricant, 2025 WL 1823143, at *15 (excluding roller coaster design expert who “simply
compared photographs of rollercoasters he found on the internet to the Kingda Ka photograph
taken by Plaintiffs in this case.”); Furlan v. Schindler Elevator Corp., 516 F. App’x 201, 206 (3d
Cir. 2013) (excluding liability expert whose opinion was based solely on amateur photograph and
fact that accident occurred).
ii. 	Failure to Warn
Courts in this District “look to the following non-exclusive indicia of reliability” in product
liability cases:
whether the expert considered (1) federal design and performance standards, (2)
standards 	established 	by 	independent 	standards 	organizations, 	(3) 	relevant
literature, (4) evidence of industry practice, (5) product design and accident history,
(6) illustrative charts and diagrams, (7) data from scientific testing, (8) the
feasibility of any suggested modification, and (9) the risk-utility of any suggested
modification.
Ebenhoech v. Koppers Indus., Inc., 239 F. Supp. 2d 455, 467 (D.N.J. 2002) (quoting Milanowicz
v. Raymond Corp., 148 F. Supp. 2d 525, 533–34 (D.N.J. 2001)).
Dr. Pugh’s conclusions about the Product’s warning label lack signs of reliability. Here,
the Product had a flammability warning. (See Pugh Report at *4.) Examining a fourteen-ounce
spray can of the Product, Dr. Pugh concluded the text was too small. However, it does not appear
he examined the warning on the much larger sixty-four-ounce container of the Product Ibrahim
used on the day of the accident. (Id. at *4–5; Hearing Tr. 70:1–13.) “[E]xpert testimony which
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 12 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
13
concludes that warnings are ‘deficient in placement, design, orientation, and content’ is unreliable
if the expert . . . has not read the warnings which were present on the product . . . .” Ebenhoech,
239 F. Supp. 2d at 468 (quoting Jaurequi v. Carter Mfg. Co., 173 F.3d 1076, 1084 (8th Cir.1999)).
In any event, Dr. Pugh did not consider federal pesticide labeling standards, industry
practice, the Product’s accident history, scientific testing, whether his proposed open flame
pictogram was feasible, or whether it would have prevented the accident. (See Pugh Report.) Nor
did he provide any visual aids to explain his conclusion that the Product had an inadequate warning
and that his proposed warning was adequate. (Id.) At most, Dr. Pugh asserts the Product’s warning
did not comply with two standards from the American National Standards Institute (“ANSI”) and
a warning handbook from 2006. (Id.) “However, [Dr. Pugh] does not discuss what these sources
say nor how they informed his analysis. Nor does he attach the relevant excerpts as exhibits.”
Milanowicz, 148 F. Supp. 2d at 541. Dr. Pugh’s “unexplained citations to design and performance
standards do not show that his opinion is reliable.” Ebenhoech, 239 F. Supp. 2d at 46. So, neither
Dr. Pugh’s opinion that the Product caused the fire, nor his opinion that the flammability warning
on the Product was inadequate, are reliable.
C. 	Fit
“An expert’s testimony ‘fits’ the proceedings, if it ‘will help the trier of fact to understand
the evidence or to determine a fact in issue.’” Cohen, 125 F.4th at 464 (quoting Fed. R. Evid.
702(a)). Fit “goes primarily to relevance.” Id. (quoting Karlo, 849 F.3d at 81). An expert’s “bare
conclusions are not admissible under [the fit requirement] of Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of
Evidence.” Snead v. Casino, 700 F. Supp. 3d 203, 216 (D.N.J. 2023) (alteration in original)
(quoting H.M. ex rel. B.M. v. Haddon Heights Bd. of Educ., 822 F. Supp. 2d 439, 448 (D.N.J.
2011)). Such an opinion is “of no assistance to the trier of fact.” Silipena, 2024 WL 3219226, at
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 13 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
14
*14 (D.N.J. June 28, 2024) (quoting Tannock v. N.J. Bell, 223 N.J. Super. 1, 7 (N.J. Super. App.
Div. 1988)). Rather, an expert must give the “‘why and wherefore” underlying their opinion.
Snead, 700 F. Supp. 3d at 216 (quoting Iudici v. Camisa, No. 12-3466, 2022 WL 3998295 (D.N.J.
Sept. 1, 2022)).
Dr. Pugh’s analysis is bereft of a why or wherefore. For instance, Ibrahim stated he used
the Product around 9:00 A.M., and the fire occurred around 5:00 P.M. (Hearing Tr. 76:25–77:6.)
At the Daubert hearing, Dr. Pugh testified it was “unlikely” the Product caused the fire if Ibrahim’s
timeline 	were 	true. 	(Hearing 	Tr. 	77:7–14.) 	Dr. 	Pugh 	added 	he 	“disagree[d] 	with 	the
characterization of the time that Ibrahim applied it in view of what [Nouh] said.” (Id. at 77:14–
16.) But Dr. Pugh did not explain why he disagreed with Ibrahim’s account and believed Nouh’s.
(See generally id.) Nor did he address the issue in his report. (See Pugh Report.) Instead, he simply
concluded the fire started when Nouh said it did. (Id.) That is of no assistance to the factfinder.
See Faragalla v. Otundo, 626 F. Supp. 3d 783, 788 (D.N.J. 2022) (holding expert’s opinion lacked
“sufficient factual foundation” where it was “solely derived from [plaintiff’s] representations.”).
Likewise, although Ibrahim testified “he never read the warnings or instructions on the [P]roduct”
before using it (Hearing Tr. 68:15–18), Dr. Pugh concluded an open flame pictogram would have
prevented the fire (see Pugh Report). Dr. Pugh entirely failed to explain why a plaintiff who did
not read any of the warnings on the Product would nonetheless read a different warning on the
Product. Here, too, the lack of a why or wherefore does not assist the factfinder. Dr. Pugh’s
opinions, accordingly, do not fit the proceedings.
Because Dr. Pugh is not qualified to render expert opinions on fire causation, his
conclusions on fire causation and adequate warnings are unreliable, and his analysis does not fit
the proceedings, his testimony must be excluded.
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 14 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>
15
IV. 	CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, Defendants’ motion to exclude Dr. Pugh’s testimony (ECF No.
42) is GRANTED. An appropriate Order accompanies this Opinion.
DATED: 1/12/2026 	_______________________
JULIEN XAVIER NEALS
United States District Judge
Case 2:21-cv-18744-JXN-JRA Document 117 Filed 01/12/26 Page 15 of 15 PageID:
<pageID>

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.