PAPA v. IAT INSURANCE GROUP, INC.

1:25-cv-04049Njd3 mar 2026

Testo completo

1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
ROSEMARIE PAPA,
Plaintiff,
v.
IAT INSURANCE GROUP, INC.,
Defendant.
No. 25-cv-04049
OPINION
APPEARANCES:
Daniel S. Orlow
Andrew J. Sarrol
C ONSOLE M ATTIACCI LAW , LLC
110 Marter Avenue, Suite 502
Moorestown, NJ 08057
On behalf of Plaintiff.
Tricia B. O’Reilly
WALSH P IZZI O’R EILLY F ALANGA LLP
Three Gateway Center
100 Mulberry Street, 15th Floor
Newark, NJ 07102
Brett A. Carpenter (Pro Hac Vice)
David L. Woodward (Pro Hac Vice)
P OYNER S PRUILL LLP
301 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1900
Raleigh, NC 27601
On behalf of Defendant.
O’HEARN, District Judge.
THIS MATTER comes before the Court on Defendant IAT Insurance Group, Inc.’s
(“Defendant” or “IAT”) Motion to Transfer Venue to the Eastern District of North Carolina. (ECF
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 1 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
2
No. 17). The Court did not hear oral argument pursuant to Local Rule 78.1. For the reasons that
follow, Defendant’s Motion is GRANTED.
I. 	BACKGROUND
Plaintiff Rosemarie Papa (“Plaintiff” or “Papa”), a New Jersey resident, was hired by
Defendant in April 2018 for a remote position. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶¶ 1, 16; Papa Decl., ECF
No. 26-2 at ¶ 4). In her role as Senior Instructional Designer, Plaintiff conducted employee
trainings, one-on-one coaching sessions, and individual development plans, primarily via Zoom
while working from her home in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. (Pl.’s Opp., ECF No. 26 at 2; Papa
Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶¶ 11–13, 15). At the outset of her employment, Plaintiff designed and
taught her own classes. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶ 21). Plaintiff’s responsibilities also included
frequently conducting in-person trainings in North Carolina, Florida, Connecticut, Missouri, and
Illinois. (Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶ 14).1
Defendant is a North Carolina corporation with a principal place of business and corporate
headquarters located in Raleigh, North Carolina. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶ 2; Def.’s Mot., ECF No.
17-1 at 5). Plaintiff’s direct supervisor, Jennifer Ratliff (“Ratliff”), IAT’s Vice President of
Learning and Development, worked from Defendant’s Illinois location, and Ratliff reported to
Alisa Miller (“Miller”), IAT’s Chief Human Resources Officer, who worked from Defendant’s
headquarters in North Carolina. (Pl.’s Opp., ECF No. 26 at 2; Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶¶ 6–
9).
1 	“In 2022 and 2023, approximately 25% of [Plaintiff’s] workload consisted of in-person
trainings in States outside of New Jersey, including North Carolina, Florida, Connecticut,
Missouri, and Illinois.” (Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶ 14). Plaintiff traveled to Defendant’s home
office approximately twelve times in the last two years of employment with Defendant. (Def.’s
Mot., ECF No. 17-1 at 11; Miller Decl., ECF No. 17-2 at ¶ 5).
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 2 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
3
During her employment, Plaintiff alleges Defendant subjected her to discriminatory,
retaliatory, and hostile treatment based on her age, disability, requests for and use of medical leave
as an accommodation, and use of FMLA benefits. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶ 71). Plaintiff also
alleges Defendant retaliated against her because she had made a complaint of age discrimination.
(Id. at ¶ 36).2
On September 27, 2023, Plaintiff participated in a Zoom meeting with Ratliff, where
Plaintiff alleges she was “verbally abused.” (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶ 42; Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-
2 at ¶ 16). Plaintiff subsequently met with Miller via Zoom to discuss her concerns. (Compl., ECF
No. 1 at ¶ 44; Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶¶ 17–18). On November 30, 2023, Ratliff issued
Plaintiff a Coaching Conversation. (Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶ 19). On December 15, 2023,
Plaintiff met with Miller and Ratliff via Zoom to discuss Plaintiff’s concerns. (Compl., ECF No.
1 at ¶¶ 49–53; Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶ 20). On January 8, 2024, Plaintiff received a Final
Written Warning, making her ineligible for various benefits. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶¶ 54–55).3
Plaintiff later filed a rebuttal. (Id. at ¶ 59).
“In late January 2024, Plaintiff’s doctor placed her on a leave of absence.” (Id. at ¶ 60). On
May 9, 2024, Defendant notified Plaintiff that she was being replaced and provided “unpaid leave
as an ADA accommodation until July 7, 2024,” following the exhaustion of her FMLA leave,
2 In December 2022, Plaintiff, who was 62 years old at the time, questioned the requirement
that she cross-train facilitators and emailed Ratliff that “you are phasing me out because of my
age.” (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶¶ 17, 22–29). Ratliff subsequently “admonished Plaintiff for putting
a complaint about age discrimination in writing.” (Id. at ¶ 30). Plaintiff suffered from rheumatoid
arthritis and neuropathy, which she had communicated to Ratliff. (Id. at ¶ 32). In September 2023,
Plaintiff underwent bloodwork which showed “abnormalities consistent with multiple myeloma.”
(Id. at ¶ 33). Plaintiff made Ratliff aware of this development and testing related to possible blood
cancer. (Id. at ¶ 35).
3 “Defendant’s Final Written Warning made Plaintiff ineligible for a raise, bonus, or 401K
match for 2023.” (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶ 55).
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 3 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
4
citing “undue hardship on the team.” (Id. at ¶¶ 61–62). Plaintiff’s doctor thereafter advised she
could return to work on July 8, 2024. (Id. at ¶ 67). Defendant then offered Plaintiff the position of
Business Technical Training Strategist, which Plaintiff declined. (Id. at ¶¶ 68–69).
Plaintiff claims she was physically located in New Jersey during “many of the crucial
events surrounding her employment,” including during Zoom calls with Ratliff and Miller, when
Plaintiff was issued a Coaching Conversation and Final Written Warning, when Plaintiff was
notified Defendant was replacing her position, and when Plaintiff subsequently reached out to
IAT’s Human Resources Department. (Pl.’s Opp., ECF No. 26 at 3; Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at
¶¶ 16–25). These events occurred through Zoom, email, or other electronic communications, and
there is no evidence that Ratliff, Miller, or any other IAT personnel traveled to New Jersey in
connection with them. (Papa Decl., ECF No. 26-2 at ¶¶ 16–25; Miller Decl., ECF No. 17-2 at ¶¶ 8–
15). Defendant claims “that the major decisions concerning [Plaintiff’s] employment, which are at
the heart of her dispute with Defendant, were all made outside of New Jersey and primarily in
North Carolina.” (Def.’s Reply, ECF No. 29 at 6). While Ratliff was physically located in Illinois,
Miller and other IAT human resources personnel were in North Carolina when they made decisions
as to Plaintiff’s cross-training responsibilities, complaints of mistreatment, medical leave and
accommodation, issuance of a Final Written Warning, and positions which may be available
following Plaintiff’s FMLA leave. (Id.; Miller Decl., ECF No. 17-2 at ¶¶ 8–15).
II. 	PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On May 9, 2025, Plaintiff brought this action in the District of New Jersey, asserting claims
under the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”), 42 U.S.C. § 12101 et seq.; the Age
Discrimination in Employment Act (“ADEA”), as amended, 29 U.S.C. § 621 et seq.; the
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 4 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
5
New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (“NJLAD”), N.J.S.A. § 10:5-1 et seq.; and the Family
and Medical Leave Act (“FMLA”), 29 U.S.C. § 2601 et seq. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at 2). Defendant
filed an Answer to the Complaint and Affirmative Defenses on July 14, 2025. (ECF No. 4). On
August 14, 2025, Defendant filed the Motion to Transfer Venue now before the Court under 28
U.S.C. § 1404(a), arguing that a substantial part of the events related to Plaintiff’s allegations
occurred in the Eastern District of North Carolina, making it a more convenient forum. (ECF No.
17-1 at 6). Plaintiff then filed a Brief in Opposition, (ECF No. 26), to which Defendant replied,
(ECF No. 29).
III. 	LEGAL STANDARD
Under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), “[f]or the convenience of the parties and witnesses, in the
interest of justice, a district court may transfer any civil action to any other district or division
where it might have been brought or to any district or division to which all parties have consented.”
The purpose of this section is to “prevent the waste of time, energy and money,” and “protect
litigants, witnesses and the public against unnecessary inconvenience and expense.” Yacovella v.
Apparel Imports, Inc., No. 14-5484, 2015 WL 5098009, at *3 (D.N.J. Aug. 31, 2015) (quoting
Ricoh Co. v. Honeywell, Inc., 817 F. Supp. 473, 479 (D.N.J. 1993)). It thus “provides for the
transfer of a case where both the original and the requested venue are proper.” Jumara v. State
Farm Ins. Co., 55 F.3d 873, 878 (3d Cir. 1995). “The burden of establishing the need to transfer
[] rests with the movant.” Halpern v. Centroid Sys., Inc., No. 24-7037, 2024 WL 4533370, at *9
(D.N.J. Oct. 21, 2024) (quoting Jumara, 55 F.3d at 879). A court may consider affidavits and other
evidence outside the pleadings in deciding a motion to transfer under § 1404(a). E.g., Beaumont v.
Vanguard Logistics Servs. (USA), Inc., 615 F. Supp. 3d 253, 259 (D.N.J. 2022).
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 5 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
6
When considering motions to transfer under § 1404(a), courts in the Third Circuit consider
a series of non-exhaustive public-interest and private-interest factors. Jumara, 55 F.3d at 879–80.
The six private-interest factors are:
[i] plaintiff’s forum preference as manifested in the original choice; [ii] the defendant’s
preference; [iii] whether the claim arose elsewhere; [iv] the convenience of the parties as
indicated by their relative physical and financial condition; [v] the convenience of the
witnesses – but only to the extent that the witnesses may actually be unavailable for trial
in one of the fora; and [vi] the location of books and records (similarly limited to the extent
that the files could not be produced in the alternative forum).
Id. at 879 (citations omitted). The six public-interest factors are:
[(i)] the enforceability of the judgment; [(ii)] practical considerations that could make the
trial easy, expeditious, or inexpensive; [(iii)] the relative administrative difficulty in the
two fora resulting from court congestion; [(iv)] the local interest in deciding local
controversies at home; [(v)] the public policies of the fora; and [(vi)] the familiarity of the
trial judge with the applicable state law in diversity cases.
Id. at 879–80 (citations omitted).
IV. 	DISCUSSION
Considering all the relevant factors and interests under § 1404(a), for the reasons that
follow, the Court finds that the private and public interest factors as a whole favor transfer.
A. The Private-Interest Factors Weigh in Favor of Transfer
First, Plaintiff brought suit in the District of New Jersey, while Defendant is moving for
transfer to the Eastern District of North Carolina. A plaintiff’s preference “is a paramount
consideration,” and will “not be lightly disturbed.” Shutte v. Armco Steel Corp., 431 F.2d 22, 25
(3d Cir. 1970). Nevertheless, “the plaintiff’s choice is not necessarily decisive, particularly where
the central facts of the lawsuit did not occur in the plaintiff’s chosen forum.” Halpern, 2024 WL
4533370, at *9 (citation omitted).
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 6 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
7
The Court next looks to where the claim arose. “[G]enerally, a claim arises in the forum
containing the dispute’s ‘center of gravity,’ that is, where the events and transactions central to the
dispute occurred.” West v. NNIT, Inc., No. 24-38, 2024 WL 3509512, at *8 (D.N.J. July 23, 2024)
(citing Allied Old Eng., Inc. v. Uwajimaya, Inc., No. 11-1239, 2012 WL 3564172, at *4 (D.N.J.
Aug. 16, 2012)). In employment discrimination cases, the Court considers where the alleged
discriminatory decisions were made instead of where the plaintiff felt the effects of the decisions.
See Yacovella, 2015 WL 5098009, at *8 (determining transfer motion based on where the decision
to terminate employee occurred instead of where employee received his termination letter). Thus,
in employment cases like this one involving remote employees, the fact that the employee worked
in the state is not dispositive if the relevant conduct and decisions took place elsewhere.
For example, in Wayne v. Fuji Photo Film USA, Inc., the court granted transfer to New
Jersey where the plaintiff, though generally working remotely from Pennsylvania, was based out
of and spent significant time in the employer’s New Jersey office, the alleged adverse employment
action occurred there, and the decision was made at the employer’s headquarters in New York.
No. 07-5536, 2008 WL 3832406, at *2, *4 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 14, 2008). Similarly, in Khartchenko v.
American Oncologic Hospital, Inc., a court in this District transferred a remote employee’s case
from New Jersey to the employer’s home forum of Pennsylvania, finding that the employee’s
remote work from New Jersey—which began approximately six years into her employment—and
the employee’s communications from New Jersey were insufficient to anchor venue when the
relevant employment decisions took place in Pennsylvania and the records and witnesses were
located there. No. 23-23043, 2025 WL 3140604, at *2–3 (D.N.J. Nov. 10, 2025).
By contrast, in Halpern, the court decided against transferring a remote worker case from
New Jersey to Michigan, finding that a substantial part of the events occurred in both forums
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 7 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
8
simultaneously. 2024 WL 4533370, at *1, *10. In that case, the plaintiff’s employment was
explicitly tied to developing the New Jersey market and involved extensive work in the state. Id.
Although Dilmore v. Alion Sci. and Tech. Corp. suggested that termination may occur
where the notice is directed and received, No. 11-72, 2011 WL 1576021, at *5–7 (W.D. Pa. Apr.
21, 2011), more recent cases decided since the proliferation of remote work have instead
emphasized the location where the decisions were made, rather than the situs of their effects. See,
e.g., Grieco v. Alacrity Adjusting Sols., LLC, No. 24-3023, 2025 WL 2712211, at *2 (E.D. Pa.
Sept. 23, 2025) (finding that alleged unlawful employment practices did not occur in Pennsylvania
merely because employee communicated with potential employer from his Pennsylvania home,
when potential employer did not make decisions in Pennsylvania); see also Wilson v. JPMorgan
Chase, No. 18-13789, 2020 WL 3168539, at *4 (D.N.J. June 15, 2020) (finding “Plaintiff’s
communications from New Jersey do not form a substantial amount of the alleged wrongful acts,”
when conduct and employment decisions occurred in New York).
Here, Plaintiff primarily performed remote work from New Jersey and was present in New
Jersey during many of the alleged discriminatory actions. (Pl.’s Opp., ECF No. 26 at 3; Papa Decl.,
ECF No. 26-2 at ¶¶ 16–25). However, the decisions underlying her claims were made by IAT
personnel located outside of New Jersey, primarily in North Carolina, making the facts of this case
closer to that of Wayne or Khartchenko than Halpern. (Def.’s Reply, ECF No. 29 at 6; Miller Decl.,
ECF No. 17-2 at ¶¶ 8–15). In addition, Plaintiff’s role required travel outside of New Jersey to
various states, along with regular visits to Defendant’s North Carolina headquarters. (Papa Decl.,
ECF No. 26-2 at ¶ 14; Def.’s Mot., ECF No. 17-1 at 11; Miller Decl., ECF No. 17-2 at ¶ 5). Unlike
in Halpern, there is no evidence that Plaintiff’s employment was directed toward developing the
New Jersey market or otherwise involved extensive work focused on the state. Consistent with
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 8 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
9
Wayne and Khartchenko, here the conduct giving rise to Plaintiff’s claims centers on where
Defendant’s employment decisions were made rather than where Plaintiff resided. Accordingly,
this 	factor 	weighs 	heavily 	in 	favor 	of 	transfer.
Turning to the convenience factors, the Court considers parties’ physical and financial
conditions. Halpern, 2024 WL 4533370, at *9 (citing Jumara, 55 F.3d at 879–80). Here,
Defendant and many of its key witnesses reside in the Eastern District of North Carolina and
Plaintiff resides in New Jersey. (Def.’s Mot., ECF No. 17-1 at 5, 11). While the Court
acknowledges Plaintiff’s argument that Defendant is in a better position to travel, (Pl.’s Opp., ECF
No. 26 at 6–7), Plaintiff has not provided any reason for why she cannot travel, outside of Plaintiff
not having North Carolina counsel. (Id. at 7; Def.’s Reply, ECF No. 29 at 9–10). Plaintiff does not
allege, however, that she would not be able to obtain counsel in North Carolina, either as primary
counsel or as local counsel to move for admission of her current counsel pro hac vice. Moreover,
both parties have agreed to remote depositions, and if trial were to occur, the cost and burden of
transporting multiple defense witnesses to New Jersey would considerably outweigh the cost and
burden of Plaintiff and, if needed, Plaintiff’s current counsel traveling to North Carolina. (Def.’s
Reply, ECF No. 29 at 8). These factors weigh slightly toward transfer.
In assessing the location of books and records, Defendant reports that the relevant records
are located in North Carolina, but neither party makes any representation that any document could
not be made available at trial in either forum. (Pl.’s Opp., ECF No. 26 at 7–8; Def.’s Mot., ECF
No. 17-1 at 12; Def.’s Reply, ECF No. 29 at 10). This factor is thus neutral.
Overall, the private interest factors weigh toward transfer.
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 9 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
10
B. The Public-Interest Factors Are Neutral or Weigh in Favor of Transfer
The Court now turns to the public-interest factors. First, a judgment rendered in either the
District of New Jersey or the Eastern District of North Carolina could be registered in either
district. See SI Power LLC v. Pathway Holdings Mgmt. V, LLC, No. 15-6101, 2016 WL 7130920,
at *9 (D.N.J. Dec. 7, 2016). This factor is neutral.
Ease, expeditiousness, and expense of proceedings, as discussed in greater detail above, all
favor transfer. Relative court congestion strongly supports transfer as well. As Defendant
underscores, the Eastern District of North Carolina faces significantly less overall congestion than
this Court.4
Further, this case is not merely a local dispute. Plaintiff brings her claims not only under
New Jersey but also federal law, and the dispute concerns employment actions between a New
Jersey employee and a North Carolina corporation. (Compl., ECF No. 1 at ¶¶ 1, 2). New Jersey
has an interest in protecting its citizens from harassment and retaliation, but so too does North
Carolina in adjudicating claims arising from employment decisions made by corporations within
its borders. And while this Court may generally have greater familiarity with the NJLAD, there is
nothing novel about its provisions; indeed, it essentially mirrors federal law in most respects, see
Schurr v. Resorts Int’l Hotel, Inc., 196 F.3d 486, 498 (3d Cir. 1999). The Court has full faith in
the judges of the Eastern District of North Carolina to properly apply the NJLAD. Defendant
identifies multiple cases in which courts in this District have entrusted the federal courts of other
states to adjudicate NJLAD claims. See West, 2024 WL 3509512, at *8 (transferring a case
4 See Table C-1—U.S. District Courts–Civil Federal Judicial Caseload Statistics, U.S. Cts.
(Mar. 	31, 	2025), 	https://www.uscourts.gov/data-news/data-tables/2025/03/31/federal-judicial-
caseload-statistics/c-1 (logging significantly more pending civil cases in the District of New Jersey
than in the Eastern District of North Carolina).
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 10 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>
11
involving NJLAD claims to the Southern District of Georgia); see also Booth v. Citizens Bank,
N.A., No. 22-5276, 2023 WL 3916275, at *6 (D.N.J. June 9, 2023) (transferring a case involving
NJLAD claims to the District of Rhode Island).
In sum, considering the relevant public and private interest factors, the Court finds this
action should be transferred to the Eastern District of North Carolina pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
§ 1404(a).
V. 	CONCLUSION
For the reasons expressed above, it is ordered that Defendant’s Motion to Transfer, (ECF
No. 17), is GRANTED. The Clerk of the Court shall transfer this action to the U.S. District Court
for the Eastern District of North Carolina. An appropriate Order accompanies this Opinion.
CHRISTINE P. O’HEARN
UNITED S TATES DISTRICT JUDGE
Case 1:25-cv-04049-CPO-EAP Document 38 Filed 03/03/26 Page 11 of 11 PageID:
<pageID>

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.