SCOTT v. THE COOPER HEALTH SYSTEM

1:22-cv-04123Njd4 feb 2026

Testo completo

[ECF No. 125]
THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
CAMDEN VICINAGE
NORMAN L. SCOTT, SR.,
Plaintiff,
v.
THE COOPER HEALTH SYSTEM,
Defendant.
Civil No. 22-4123 (KMW/SAK)
OPINION AND ORDER
This matter is before the Court on the Motion for Recusal of Magistrate Judge [ECF No.
125] filed by pro se Plaintiff Norman L. Scott, Sr. 1 	The Court received the opposition of
Defendant The Cooper Health System [ECF No. 131]. The Court exercises its discretion to decide
the motion without oral argument. See FED. R. C IV. P. 78; L. C IV. R. 78.1. For the reasons to be
discussed, Plaintiff’s motion is DENIED.
I. 	BACKGROUND
Since the parties are familiar with the factual background and procedural history of the
case, only the most salient points will be set forth herein. In brief, Plaintiff filed this action against
Defendant asserting claims of employment discrimination based on, inter alia, race, sex, and age
under state and federal law. See Compl., ECF No. 2. Specifically, Plaintiff asserts that he applied
for but did not receive a position at Cooper Health based on the alleged discrimination. He further
asserts that this position was offered to another applicant without experience.
1 Plaintiff’s motion also seeks an order to stay all proceedings pending resolution of his motion
for recusal. See Pl.’s Mot. at 6–7.
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 1 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
2
Plaintiff now moves for an order recusing the undersigned pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 144,
455(a), and 455(b)(1). See Pl.’s Mot. at 1. He alleges that the requested relief is required by law
based upon a perceived “[h]ostility and [d]ismissiveness [t]oward Plaintiff” by the Court. Id. at 2.
He also alleges that the Court engaged in “improper premature fact-finding,” calling into question
its impartiality. Id. at 3–4. Plaintiff entirely relies upon purported excerpts from a single hearing
transcript in support of these arguments. See id. at 2–4 (citing Hr’g Tr., Sept. 22, 2025). Notably,
no party appears to have requested a transcript of this hearing as it’s conspicuously absent from
the docket. However, the record reflects that the Court issued an order thereafter memorializing
its oral rulings on discovery at the hearing and denying a pending motion of Plaintiff’s. See Order,
Sept. 25, 2025, ECF No. 94. Plaintiff then moved for reconsideration of the discovery rulings. See
ECF No. 97. The Court denied the motion alongside a subsequent motion for reconsideration filed
by Plaintiff concerning similar discovery issues. See Op. & Order, Dec. 18, 2025, ECF No. 128.
At bottom, both reconsideration motions and the instant motion for recusal are rooted in a common
and recurring issue only recently raised by Plaintiff—the identity of the unknown “Sandy” witness.
The Court denied Plaintiff’s oral request to compel discovery regarding his or her identity at the
September 22, 2025 hearing as untimely. See id. at 3. Another request which related, in part, was
denied on other grounds. See id. at 3–4; Order ¶ 7, Oct. 7, 2025, ECF No. 101. Plaintiff loosely
likens the Court’s orders denying his Sandy-related discovery requests as conduct demonstrating
bias and prejudgment by the Court. The Court must note that, in the attached affidavit pursuant to
28 U.S.C. § 144, Plaintiff raises additional issues not addressed within his motion.2
2 The Court must also note that Plaintiff’s affidavit includes an improper electronic signature.
See D ISTRICT OF NEW J ERSEY ECF P OLICIES AND P ROCEDURES § 12(b) (as amended Apr. 3, 2014)
(prescribing that a “document requiring the signature of a non-attorney must be filed electronically
by . . . submitting a scanned document containing the necessary signature”).
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 2 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
3
Defendant opposes Plaintiff’s motion, contending “it amounts to nothing more than mere
dissatisfaction with this Court’s Orders.” Def.’s Opp’n at 1. It further contends that the record is
devoid of any evidence demonstrating any personal bias or prejudice by the Court against Plaintiff.
See id. at 1–4. It also asserts Plaintiff has not produced any such evidence. See id. at 4. As such,
Defendant maintains that Plaintiff’s motion must be denied.
II. 	DISCUSSION
A. Legal Standard
Under 28 U.S.C. § 144, a judge must recuse herself if a party files a “timely and sufficient
affidavit” establishing that the judge “has a personal bias or prejudice against him or in favor of
any adverse party.” To succeed on a recusal motion, the movant must make a threefold showing:
“(1) the facts must be material and stated with particularity; (2) the facts must be such that, if true
they would convince a reasonable person that a bias exists; [and] (3) the facts must show the bias
is personal, as opposed to judicial, in nature.” Discover Bank v. Greenwood House Home for the
Jewish Aged, No. 18-16020, 2023 WL 2307091, at *1 (D.N.J. Feb. 28, 2023) (citing United States
v. Thompson, 483 F.2d 527, 528 (3d Cir. 1973)).
Section 455(a) prescribes that any “magistrate judge of the United States shall disqualify
[herself] in any proceeding in which [her] impartiality might reasonably be questioned.” 28 U.S.C.
§ 455(a). The test for recusal under this section is an objective one. In re Kensington Intern. Ltd.,
353 F.3d 211, 220 (3d Cir. 2003) (citation omitted). While Section 455(a) is considered a catchall
disqualification provision, Section 455(b)(1) is narrower “in that it requires a judge to disqualify
[herself] only if ‘[she] has a personal bias or prejudice concerning a party, or personal knowledge
of disputed evidentiary facts concerning the proceeding.’” Id. (quoting 28 U.S.C. § 455(b)(1))
(citing Liteky v. United States, 510 U.S. 540, 548 (1994)).
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 3 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
4
Under either statute, the movant must generally rely on extrajudicial conduct in order to
demonstrate bias or prejudice. See Liteky, 510 U.S. at 551. Thus, “opinions formed by the judge
on the basis of facts introduced or events occurring in the course of the current proceedings, or of
prior proceedings, do not constitute a basis for a bias or partiality motion unless they display a
deep-seated favoritism or antagonism that would make fair judgment impossible.” Id. at 555.
Further, “judicial rulings alone almost never constitute a valid basis for a bias or partiality motion;”
“[a]lmost invariably, they are proper grounds for appeal, not for recusal.” Id. (citation omitted);
see, e.g., Securacomm Consulting, Inc. v. Securacom Inc., 224 F.3d 273, 278 (3d Cir. 2000)
(citations omitted) (“We have repeatedly stated that a party’s displeasure with legal rulings does
not form an adequate basis for recusal.”).
B. Analysis
Here, the Court finds that Plaintiff’s motion and corresponding affidavit consist entirely of
conclusory statements lacking any foundation in fact. In other words, his affidavit is insufficient
and fails to establish any personal bias or prejudice against him. Plaintiff relies on the following
reasons to question the Court’s impartiality: (1) the Court “accus[ing] [him] of ‘playing games’
despite [his] disability and pain,” (2) the Court “adopt[ing] Defendant’s version of disputed facts,
including rejecting [his] eyewitness account of a second interviewer, ‘Sandy,’” (3) the Court’s
“reli[ance] on Defendant’s certification as conclusive truth,” (4) the Court’s “fail[ure] to enforce”
an October 7, 2025 Order “requiring Defendants to supplement discovery,” and (5) the purported
denial of “all motions” at a November 19, 2025 conference without explanation.3 Pl.’s Mot. at 5.
3 The Court notes that it is at a loss as to what Plaintiff is referring to here. Once again, neither
party requested a transcript of the subject conference, which was scheduled as a status conference.
See ECF No. 100. The minute entry for the conference confirms this much and makes no reference
to any motions. See ECF No. 116. The only order the Court issued following the conference is a
November 19, 2025 Text Order reaffirming the deadline for dispositive motions. ECF No. 117.
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 4 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
5
Since Plaintiff relies solely on an unofficial transcript of the September 22, 2025 hearing to support
these arguments, he fails to cite to any official portion of the record in support of his motion.
Consequently, he fails to expound upon items four and five, which stem from subsequent hearings.
As to the first three items, the Court finds Plaintiff misconstrues the Court’s statements and
misapprehends its rulings. Based upon a review of the audio recording of the September 22, 2025
hearing, the Court agrees with Defendant’s contention that Plaintiff quotes the Court grossly out
of context. The Court’s reference to “playing games” was not in response to Plaintiff’s disability
or pain but rather his refusal to answer a question. See Def.’s Opp’n at 2 (“Nothing in the transcript
of the hearing suggests that the Court was accusing Plaintiff of playing games because he was
disabled. 	Plaintiff was asked at the conference if he had an understanding of the race of the
individual hired, to which he responded yes, but yet refused to answer the Court’s question when
asked to identify the race of the individual.”). 	Notably, the Court inquired at the outset of the
hearing if Plaintiff was able to proceed after he advised he was “in a lot of pain at the moment.”
Plaintiff stated that he was able to answer the Court’s questions truthfully despite his condition
and elected to proceed. After roughly forty minutes, Plaintiff indicated he was not able to continue
because of his pain. 	The Court then agreed to end the hearing early and render a ruling on the
remaining issues based on the parties’ submissions. Therefore, the Court finds that Plaintiff fails
to point to any evidence or facts in the record that supports the conclusion that a reasonable person
would doubt the Court’s impartiality with respect to item one.
Plaintiff simply misapprehends the Court’s rulings with his contentions contained in items
two and three. Plaintiff contends that the Court “adopted Defendant’s version of disputed facts”
as to the unknown “Sandy” witness and “relied on Defendant’s certification as conclusive truth.”
Pl.’s Mot. at 5. To be clear, the Court made no such ruling. Instead, the Court found that Plaintiff
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 5 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>
6
had failed to submit any evidence to refute the statements contained in Defendant’s certification.
Plaintiff seemingly conflates the denial of his request for further discovery concerning “Sandy” as
the Court adopting his adversary’s position. Plaintiff’s arguments that the Court acted with bias
or prejudice are based upon nothing more than his mere disagreement or dissatisfaction with the
Court’s decisions and rulings. See In re TMI Litig., 193 F.3d 613, 729 (3d Cir. 1999) (“[A]dverse
rulings do not warrant disqualification.”); Smith v. Vidonish, 210 F. App’x 152, 155 (3d Cir. 2006)
(holding that conclusory statements in a recusal affidavit need not be credited).4 For these reasons,
the Court finds Plaintiff’s assertions of impartiality and bias unavailing and will deny his motion
in its entirety.5
III. 	CONCLUSION
Accordingly, for all the foregoing reasons,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED this 4th day of February, 2026, that Plaintiff’s motion for
recusal [ECF No. 125] is DENIED; and it is further
ORDERED that Plaintiff’s motion to stay [ECF No. 125] is DENIED as moot.
s/ Sharon A. King
SHARON A. KING
United States Magistrate Judge
cc: Hon. Karen M. Williams, U.S.D.J.
4 Because Plaintiff fails to offer any evidence or otherwise articulate any arguments in support
of items four and five, the Court need not address them.
5 In light of the Court’s ruling on Plaintiff’s motion for recusal, the Court will deny his motion
to stay as moot.
Case 1:22-cv-04123-KMW-SAK Document 138 Filed 02/04/26 Page 6 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.