O'Toole v. Ravalli County Sheriff's Office

9:21-cv-00089Mtd12 feb 2026

Testo completo

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
MISSOULA DIVISION
DANIEL O’TOOLE, RICHARD
CHURCHILL, and KEITH
LEONARD, individually and on
behalf of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
RAVALLI COUNTY,
Defendant.
CV 21–89–M–DLC
ORDER
The Parties’ final pretrial materials are due February 16, 2026. (Doc. 133 at
2.) Last night, Plaintiffs filed a Motion to Clarify, seeking guidance from the Court
as to which theories Plaintiffs may advance at trial. (Doc. 144.)
Apparently, there is a dispute between the Parties regarding the scope of the
trial scheduled to commence on March 9, 2026. Plaintiffs assert that they are not
under “any legal obligation to identify their legal theories in their complaint, nor
do they believe that caselaw limits Plaintiffs’ legal theories to any particular
theories advanced in a complaint.” (Doc. 145 at 2.) Plaintiffs double down on this
statement by further asserting that “they may advance any legal theories at trial
supported by evidence in the record, and neither Plaintiffs’ voluntary outline of
Case 9:21-cv-00089-DLC Document 147 Filed 02/12/26 Page 1 of 4
2
legal theories in their [Second Amended Complaint (“SAC”)] nor F&R 78’s
parsing of legal theories affects Plaintiffs’ ability to argue additional or different
theories at trial if the evidence supports such arguments.”1 (Id. at 4.)
These are bold statements untethered to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
and suggest that the trial in this case is going to be some sort of a “free for all” in
which the Plaintiff class will be allowed to advance new legal theories that were
not pled in the SAC.
That is not going to happen. As explained below, the Plaintiff class claims
are limited to Counts One, Two, Four, Five, and Eight of the SAC.
The Court previously certified the following class as to Counts Three
through Eight of Plaintiffs’ SAC: “All indigent persons who are or will be: accused
of a crime in Ravalli County, Montana, arrested, incarcerated, placed on the Jail
Diversion Program, and charged pretrial fees without having been convicted for
the crime for which the Jail Diversion Program was ordered.” (Doc. 79 at 4.) The
Court denied without prejudice this same class as to Counts One, Two, and Nine,
subject to renewal following summary judgment. (Id. at 3–4.) Plaintiffs seek
damages, declaratory, and injunctive relief.2
1 Judge DeSoto’s F&R (Doc. 78) was not an exercise in “parsing.” It was a ruling
on motions for summary judgment.
2 The Court previously declined to issue a preliminary injunction. (Doc. 79 at 3.)
Case 9:21-cv-00089-DLC Document 147 Filed 02/12/26 Page 2 of 4
3
On June 2, 2025, the Court ruled on the Parties’ respective Motions for
Summary Judgment, allowing Counts One, Two, Four, Five, and Eight to advance
to trial. (Doc. 127.) To the extent the Court needed to clarify that Counts One and
Two, having survived summary judgment, are proceeding with Counts Four, Five,
and Eight as a class, the Court takes the opportunity to do so now. On March 9,
2026, the Parties will try the following Counts from the SAC as a class as defined
above:
Count 1: Violation of Procedural Due Process Regarding Deprivation of
Property Interest in Fee Amount. Plaintiffs claim that Defendant Ravalli County
deprived them of their property without due process as guaranteed under the
Fourteenth Amendment by charging them for pretrial fees without any finding of
guilt. (Doc. 34 ¶¶ 192–93.)
Count 2: Violation of Procedural Due Process for Arbitrary Bail. Plaintiffs
claim that Ravalli County charges fees associated with the conditions of pretrial
release for however long the case remains in pretrial status, and in doing so
imposes the fees as quasi-bail, without the attendant due process protections. (Id. ¶
195.)
Count 4: Violation of Procedural Due Process Regarding Ability to Pay.
Plaintiffs claim that Ravalli County’s practice of assessing pretrial fees without
Case 9:21-cv-00089-DLC Document 147 Filed 02/12/26 Page 3 of 4
4
considering ability to pay violates the Procedural Due Process Clause of the
Fourteenth Amendment. (Id. ¶¶ 200–01.)
Count 5: Violation of Procedural Due Process for Incarceration for Non-
Payment of Fees. Plaintiffs claim that by permitting the revocation of bail based on
failure to pay pretrial fees without considering ability to pay, Ravalli County is
effectively criminalizing poverty in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s
Procedural Due Process Clause. (Id. ¶¶ 203–06.)
Count 8: False Imprisonment. Plaintiffs claim that Ravalli County
unlawfully detains pretrial arrestees beyond their release date by conditioning
release on payment of arbitrary pretrial fees and that such “unlawful and
involuntary restraint” constitutes false imprisonment. (Id. ¶¶ 216–17.)
These are the only legal claims that remain in this case. They are all class
claims. Evidentiary proof at trial will be strictly limited to these five counts of the
SAC.
DATED this 12th day of February, 2026.
Case 9:21-cv-00089-DLC Document 147 Filed 02/12/26 Page 4 of 4

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.