City and County of Butte-Silver Bow v. 3M Company et al

2:25-cv-00036Mtd12 gen 2026

Testo completo

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
BUTTE DIVISION
CITY AND COUNTY OF BUTTE-
SILVER BOW,
Plaintiff,
v.
3M COMPANY (F/K/A
MINNESOTA MINING AND
MANUFACTURING COMPANY);
DUPONT DE NEMOURS, INC.;
THE CHEMOURS COMPANY;
THE CHEMOURS COMPANY FC,
LLC; CORTEVA, INC., GLOBE
MANUFACTURING COMPANY
LLC; W.L. GORE & ASSOCIATES,
INC.; AND LION GROUP INC,
Defendants.
CV-25-36-BU-BMM
ORDER
on Supplemental Authority
INTRODUCTION
Defendant Dupont De Nemours, Inc., The Chemours Company, The
Chemours Company FC, LLC, and Corteva, Inc. (collectively “Dupont”) filed a
notice of supplemental authority on January 2, 2026. (Doc. 158). Dupont contends
that an order in Ryan v. Newark Grp., Inc., Civ. No. 4:22-cv-40089-MRG, __ F.
Case 2:25-cv-00036-BMM Document 160 Filed 01/12/26 Page 1 of 4
2
Supp. 3d __, 2025 WL 3764916 (D. Mass. Dec. 30, 2025) (“Ryan”), proved
relevant to Dupont’s personal jurisdiction arguments made in Dupont’s motion to
dismiss. (Doc. 106 at 7-12). The Court reviewed Ryan before filing its order
denying Dupont’s motion to dismiss. The Court determined that the court’s
decision and analysis in Ryan did not change the Court’s personal jurisdiction
analysis contained within its order on the matter. (See Doc. 159). A review of Ryan
proves instructive.
In Ryan, the court explained the plaintiff had failed to make a prima facie
showing of personal jurisdiction over the defendant, Dupont, in Massachusetts.
(Doc. 517 at 16.) Ryan reasoned that the evidence provided by plaintiff did not
establish “any connection to how Dupont’s PFAS ended up in Massachusetts.” (Id.
at 15.) The plaintiffs in Ryan did not offer affidavits, testimony, or other evidence
to establish Dupont’s purposeful availment toward Massachusetts. (Id.) Dupont
provided evidence that it had made no connections or sales in Massachusetts. (Id.)
The plaintiffs in Ryan did not contradict these assertions by Dupont. (Id.) As a
result, the court held that the plaintiff had failed to demonstrate the requisite
relatedness, purposeful availment, and reasonableness to allow the District of
Massachusetts to exercise personal jurisdiction over Dupont.
The same does not prove true here. Plaintiff City and County of Butte Silver
Bow (“Plaintiff”) provided the Court with affidavits and other evidence that
Case 2:25-cv-00036-BMM Document 160 Filed 01/12/26 Page 2 of 4
3
Dupont purposefully has directed its conduct toward Montana. The Court found
relevant Dupont’s conduct of awarding Montana fire departments turnout gear sets
in an annual giveaway. (Doc. 129 at 19.) Plaintiff provided declarations that
Dupont, in collaboration with another Defendant, Globe, had shipped similar
turnout gear at issue in this case to Montana fire departments as winners of the
giveaway. (Doc. 132 ¶ 6.) Plaintiff asserted that Defendants had encouraged the
Montana fire departments who received the Dupont/Globe turnout gear sets to
advertise the winnings and charitable acts of Dupont/Globe on social media. (Id.)
Plaintiff further provided an affidavit by Diane Evankovich attesting that she
had been made aware of these Dupont/Globe giveaways in Montana. (Doc. 132.)
The Court also found relevant Plaintiff’s assertion that Evankovich and Zach
Osborne, the Butte Silver Bow Fire Chief, attested that they were contacted about
and marketed directly to purchase turnout gear containing Dupont’s PFAS. (Docs.
129 at 19, 132, 46-1, and 46-2.) Dupont’s action in directing turnout gear to
Montana and seeking to advertise and market such gear to Montana fire
departments differs from the facts of Ryan. Dupont’s actions indicate Dupont’s
encouragement for Montana residents, particularly fire departments, to purchase
and use Dupont products allegedly containing PFAS.
The Court was provided contrary evidence for Dupont’s assertions that it did
not direct sales, marketing, or other activities into Montana. Plaintiff provided the
Case 2:25-cv-00036-BMM Document 160 Filed 01/12/26 Page 3 of 4
4
requisite evidence to establish personal jurisdiction over Dupont in Montana. The
Court found that personal jurisdiction over Dupont comported with due process.
Dupont’s conduct indicates purposeful directed activities to Montana, specifically
about the product at issue, firefighter turnout gear.
The Court’s review of the supplemental authority provided by Dupont does
not alter the Court’s determination that the Court may exercise personal
jurisdiction over Dupont in this action. Dupont’s conduct directed at Montana was
not simply based on the "random, fortuitous, or attenuated" contacts “[Dupont]
ma[de] by interacting with other persons affiliated with the state.” Cataraha v.
Elemental Prism, LLC, 2018 WL 3448283, at *4 (D. Mont. July 17, 2018) (citing
Walden v. Fiore, 571 U.S. 277, 286 (2014)).
DATED this 12th day of January 2026.
Case 2:25-cv-00036-BMM Document 160 Filed 01/12/26 Page 4 of 4

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.