Dunsmore v. State of California et al

3:20-cv-00406Casd19 dic 2025

Testo completo

1
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
DARRYL DUNSMORE, et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
SAN DIEGO COUNTY SHERIFF’S
DEPARTMENT, et al.,
Defendants.
Case No.: 20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
ORDER GRANTING IN PART
DEFENDANT COUNTY OF SAN
DIEGO’S MOTION FOR
RECONSIDERATION
[Dkt. No. 886]
I.
INTRODUCTION
The County of San Diego (“County”) seeks reconsideration of an order
compelling 	the 	production 	of 	reports 	generated 	by 	the 	San 	Diego 	Sheriff’s
Department’s Critical Incident Review Board (“CIRB”) pertaining to in-custody
deaths. In light of the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Greer v. Cnty. of San Diego, 127
F.4th 	1216 	(9th 	Cir. 	2025), 	the 	Court 	grants 	the 	County’s 	motion 	for
reconsideration as to the CIRB Reports but denies the motion without prejudice as
to the additional relief sought.
/ / /
/ / /
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 1 of 7
2
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
II.
BACKGROUND
On December 13, 2023, the Court granted Plaintiffs’ motion to compel the
production of 	25 CIRB Reports 	pertaining to inmates 	who died in Sheriff’s
Department custody. Dkt. No. 468 (the “CIRB Order”). In relevant part, the Court
found the County had not carried its burden to show the Reports were subject to
the attorney-client privilege in their entirety. 	After providing the County an
opportunity to demonstrate that specific portions of the CIRB Reports should be
redacted, the Court ordered the production of the CIRB Reports with redactions
that were “limited to communications between Chief Legal Advisor Michael Faigin
and other CIRB members.” 	Dkt. No. 507 at 2. 	Thereafter, the County identified
nine additional CIRB Reports within the scope of the CIRB Order, resulting in a
total of 34 CIRB Reports produced by the County.
On February 10, 2025, the Ninth Circuit issued its opinion in Greer, holding
the attorney-client privilege applied to certain CIRB Reports concerning in-custody
deaths. 	Greer, 127 F.4th at 1227. 	The Ninth Circuit remanded “with instructions
to require the return and/or destruction of the disputed documents, which are
privileged.” 	Id.
III.
DISCUSSION
A. 	The CIRB Order
The County has consistently maintained that the attorney-client privilege
applies to the CIRB Reports in their entirety. 	In ordering the County to produce
the CIRB Reports to Plaintiffs, this Court concluded the County had not met its
burden to “show that the primary purpose of the communications in each Report
was to seek or give legal advice.” CIRB Order at 9. After considering the Sheriff’s
Department Policy and Procedure Manual, the CIRB Reports at issue and the
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 2 of 7
3
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
testimony of Chief Legal Advisor Michael Baranic1, the undersigned found “the
CIRB could fulfill its duties under [the Policy and Procedure Manual] to vote on
policy violations and address training or policy issues absent any legal advice from
the Chief Legal Advisor.” 	Id. at 11. 	Moreover, although the CIRB Reports need
not contain legal advice for the attorney-client privilege to apply, the CIRB Reports
at issue did not contain any readily identifiable legal advice provided by the Chief.
B. 	Greer
In Greer, the district court ordered the County to produce in discovery
redacted CIRB Reports pertaining to 12 in-custody deaths. 	Greer, 127 F.4th at
1221. The plaintiff filed portions of the CIRB Reports “conditionally under seal” in
opposition to the County’s motion for summary judgment. 	Id. 	After the case
settled, the district court granted a motion by news organizations to “unseal the
CIRB documents for ‘public inspection.’” 	Id. at 1222.
On 	appeal, 	the 	Ninth 	Circuit 	reversed 	the 	order 	unsealing 	the 	CIRB
documents. The Ninth Circuit noted the CIRB’s stated purpose is “to consult with
department legal counsel when an incident occurs which may give rise to litigation”
and that “the County’s current and former Chief Legal Advisors both averred that
consulting with counsel is the primary purpose of the CIRB.” 	Id. at 1226. 	The
Ninth Circuit concluded:
Here, the CIRB reports contained in the record meet the criteria for
attorney-client privilege. Department Policy required the Chief Legal
Advisor to be part of the CIRB, and there is no contention that the Chief
Legal Advisor was absent from any of the meetings memorialized in
the reports. In each instance, areas of potential liability for the inmate's
1 Baranic testified regarding the CIRB process and functions in another case
involving the production of CIRB Reports. 	See Morton v. Cnty. of San Diego, et
al., 21-cv-1428-MMA-DDL, Dkt. No. 79.
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 3 of 7
4
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
death were discussed. In most instances, counsel participated actively
by asking questions designed to understand and, where appropriate,
by highlighting areas of potential liability.
In short, both the participants in the CIRB and its critics consistently
viewed the primary purpose of the CIRB as assessing legal liability for
a past event and avoiding legal liability for future similar events. The
district court's ruling to the contrary was erroneous.
Id.
Significantly, Greer concluded the attorney-client privilege applied to the 12
CIRB reports in their entirety and directed “the return and/or destruction of the
disputed documents, which are privileged.” Id. at 1227. The majority did not adopt
the dissent’s position that “swaths of the CIRB reports are plainly not privileged,”
id. at 1238, and that “the proper remedy was to redact, not withhold, the reports.”
Id. at 1239.
Subsequent to Greer, District Judge Battaglia directed the undersigned to
determine whether information taken from CIRB Reports and included in expert
reports submitted by four expert witnesses in this case was privileged under Greer.
Dkt. No. 823 at 5-6. Based on an in camera review of those expert reports and the
CIRB Reports from which the information was taken, the undersigned found that
the attorney-client privilege applied to the CIRB Report information contained in all
four reports. Dkt. Nos. 915 at 6 and 920 at 3. Thereafter, Judge Battaglia directed
the Clerk of Court to strike the documents containing privileged CIRB Report
information and directed the parties to file revised versions of the documents with
redactions to privileged information. Dkt. No. 936. The parties complied. Dkt. No.
937.
/ / /
/ / /
/ / /
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 4 of 7
5
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
C. 	Motion for Reconsideration
The County moves for reconsideration of the CIRB Order under Greer.
Specifically, the County requests the Court find that the CIRB Reports are subject
to the attorney-client privilege and order Plaintiffs and their experts to destroy or
return the documents.2 Dkt. No. 886-1 at 5. In addition, the County seeks an order
(1) requiring Plaintiffs’ counsel to provide a sworn declaration stating the CIRB
Reports have been destroyed and identifying all persons provided the CIRB
Reports or information therein, (2) directing that “all filed documents including
privileged information” be “withdrawn from the Court records,” (3) directing that any
privileged CIRB Report information contained in expert reports “be withdrawn from
Court filings,” and (4) directing Plaintiffs’ counsel not publish or share any portion
of the expert reports containing privileged CIRB Report information. 	Id. at 5-6.
Plaintiffs oppose the motion. 	Dkt. No. 894. 	Plaintiffs represent that they
have destroyed all CIRB Reports in their possession and requested that their
experts do the same. Dkt. No. 894-1 at 2.
D. 	CIRB Reports
“A motion for reconsideration should not be granted, absent highly unusual
circumstances, 	unless 	the 	district 	court 	is 	presented 	with 	newly 	discovered
evidence, committed clear error, or if there is an intervening change in the
controlling law.” 	Marlyn Nutraceuticals, Inc. v. Mucos Pharma GmbH & Co., 571
F.3d 873, 880 (9th Cir. 2009) (citation omitted). 	Reconsideration is appropriate
here because the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Greer constitutes a change in the
controlling law subsequent to the CIRB Order.
/ / /
2 Each CIRB Report provided to the Court for in camera review consists of a
cover page signed by the “Board Chair” and a memorandum captioned “Inter-
Departmental Correspondence.”
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 5 of 7
6
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Greer held that the CIRB Reports at issue in that case “meet the criteria for
attorney-client privilege” because “areas of potential liability for the inmate’s death
were discussed” at each CIRB meeting and “both the participants in the CIRB and
its critics consistently viewed the primary purpose of the CIRB as assessing legal
liability for a past event and avoiding legal liability for future similar events.” Greer,
127 F.4th at 1226. 	And as noted above, Greer held the attorney-client privilege
applied to the CIRB Reports in their entirety. 	Id. at 1227.
The Ninth Circuit’s analysis applies with equal force to this case and compels
the conclusion that the attorney-client privilege applies to the 34 CIRB Reports at
issue here. 	Although Greer dealt with different CIRB Reports, “[t]he decision
addressed the CIRB process itself, and concluded that the primary purpose of the
CIRB is to assess legal liability and avoid future liability.” 	Est. of Arroyo by &
through Wilson v. Cnty. of San Diego, No. 21CV1956-RBM-SBC, 2025 WL
1532873, at *4 (S.D. Cal. May 29, 2025). 	Thus, “the analysis in Greer logically
extends to other CIRB reports and related documents prepared under the same
framework.” 	Id. 	(granting 	motion 	for 	reconsideration 	of 	order 	compelling
production of CIRB reports and directing plaintiff to return and destroy CIRB
Reports at issue). 	See also Rupard v. Cnty. of San Diego, No. 23CV1357 CAB
(BLM), 2025 WL 1082795, at *3 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 10, 2025) (same). 	Although it is
not clear from the face of each CIRB Report whether the County’s Chief Legal
Advisor attended each CIRB meeting, a declaration submitted by Mr. Baranic
describes that the Chief Legal Advisor or a designee attended the CIRB meetings
and that Mr. Baranic is “unaware of a CIRB meeting ever taking place without an
attorney from the Sheriff’s Legal Affairs Unit present . . . .” Dkt. No. 998 at 4.
The 34 CIRB Reports at issue here are privileged under Greer. As such, the
Court grants the motion for reconsideration of the CIRB Order as to these
documents. 	With respect to the specific 	relief the County seeks, 	Plaintiffs
represent that counsel and their experts have destroyed the CIRB Reports
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 6 of 7
7
20-cv-406-AJB-DDL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
produced in this litigation, and Plaintiffs’ counsel has confirmed that only those
experts received the CIRB Reports. Moreover, the parties have redacted the CIRB
Report information contained in expert reports filed in this matter. Dkt. No. 937. As
such, the Court understands there is no privileged CIRB Report information in the
possession of Plaintiffs’ counsel or Plaintiffs’ experts and that the public docket
contains no privileged CIRB Report information. The County does not explain with
specificity why the additional relief it seeks, e.g., declarations from Plaintiffs’
counsel is warranted.
IV.
CONCLUSION
For all the foregoing reasons, the Court concludes the CIRB Reports
produced in this case are privileged under Greer and GRANTS the County’s
motion for reconsideration of the CIRB Order. Given the steps taken by Plaintiffs’
counsel and their experts to destroy the CIRB Reports and redact all CIRB Report
information on the public docket, the Court DENIES WITHOUT PREJUDICE the
County’s motion insofar as it seeks additional remedial actions. 	If the County
concludes that such additional relief remains necessary, it shall first meet and
confer with Plaintiffs’ counsel as to the specific additional relief it seeks and the
basis for that relief. 	Prior to filing any further motion, the parties shall seek a
discovery conference with the Court to address any issues the parties are unable
to resolve on their own.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated: December 18, 2025
Hon. David D. Leshner
United States Magistrate Judge
Case 3:20-cv-00406-AJB-DDL Doc 1013 Filed 12/19/25 PgID.<pageID> Pg 7 of 7

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.