People v. Kingery CA4/1

CourtListener 9997497Calctapp3 lug 2024

Testo completo

Filed 7/3/24 P. v. Kingery CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D082519, D082706

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v. (Super. Ct. No. SCN415759)

JAMES CHARLES KINGERY,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Michael D. Washington, Judge. Affirmed.
Justin Behravesh, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
No appearance for Plaintiff and Respondent.

INTRODUCTION
In October 1987, the partially nude and lifeless body of 26-year-old
Julia Hernandez Santiago was found under an Acacia tree on an ivy-covered
hillside in Carlsbad. She had been raped and strangled. Her murder
remained unsolved for more than 30 years until a hit in the Combined DNA
Index System (CODIS) matched James Charles Kingery’s DNA to sperm
collected from Santiago’s body. In May 2023, a jury convicted Kingery of the

first degree murder (Pen. Code,1 § 187, subd. (a)) and forcible rape (§ 261,
former subd. (2)) of Santiago. He was sentenced to a prison term of 25 years
to life.
Kingery appeals. His appointed appellate counsel filed an opening
brief raising no arguable issues and requesting that we exercise our
discretion to review the record for potential issues under People v. Wende
(1979) 25 Cal.3d 436 (Wende) and Anders v. California (1967) 386 U.S. 738
(Anders). We issued an order giving Kingery an opportunity to file his own
supplemental brief, but he has not done so. We have independently reviewed
the record and find no arguable issue that would result in a modification or
reversal of the judgment. Accordingly, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
I.
Trial Evidence
At the time of her murder, Santiago worked as a live-in housekeeper at
the home of Nessie and Norton Cooper, off Alga Road in the city of Carlsbad.
She had been introduced to the Coopers by Celine Asano, an acupuncturist
who treated Santiago, free of charge, from time to time for her severe
rheumatoid arthritis. Asano described Santiago as a very personable and
gentle person, “very discreet, very quiet, [and] very private.” Santiago was
also, in Asano’s view, “handicapped.” She had deformities to her hands and
joints because of her significant arthritis, which caused her to walk “very
slowly” and “very deliberately.”

1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
On October 9, 1987, Santiago took the bus to Asano’s office for an
afternoon acupuncture appointment. When she left, Santiago told Asano she
was going to stop into a Longs Drugstore on her way back to the Coopers’
home. Santiago stopped into a Longs Drugstore to drop off film to develop.
At some point later, she returned to the Coopers’ home and then left again
around 6:30 to 7:00 p.m. That was the last time Santiago was seen alive.
Early the next morning, passersby found Santiago’s body in an ivy
embankment, just off Alga Road near El Camino Real. She was “splayed out”
on her back underneath an Acacia tree. With her legs spread “very wide
apart,” she was clad only in a torn blouse and bra, breasts exposed. Her
clothing, purse and shoes were scattered nearby. Her panties were hanging
on a tree branch. Bruising to her collarbone and marks on her throat left
little doubt in the mind of the homicide detective at the scene that she had
been strangled in a violent “rape murder.”
The medical examiner concluded Santiago’s cause of death was
asphyxia due to manual strangulation. Biological evidence was swabbed
from the victim’s mouth, vaginal, and anal cavities. A “large number of
intact and tailless spermatozoa” was present in her vagina, which established
the sperm had been deposited within a “short[ ] period of time” from
discovery, “[u]sually several hours, rather than days.”
At the time, much of this area of Carlsbad was undeveloped. Santiago’s
body was found in a location adjacent to residential areas near open and
vacant lots. The morning she was discovered, police spoke to John
Moderzinsky who was near the crime scene under police control. He told an
officer he was in the area at approximately 9 p.m. on October 9, 1987, getting
water out of a spigot for his van, when he heard a noise in the bushes. He
saw a person lying in the ivy underneath the Acacia tree and asked if they

3
were okay. He could not tell if it was a man or a woman, but they “[s]at up,
put their arms either on their knee or their chest area and didn’t respond to
him.” He thought the person was intoxicated and walked away.
The investigation went cold without any leads. In 2004, a criminalist
developed a DNA profile from the vaginal and rectal slides taken from
Santiago’s body and entered it into CODIS. The criminalist concluded the
spermatozoa from the vaginal and rectal slides were from the same unknown
male contributor.
In March 2020, a “metal pole” and a buccal swab was recovered from

Kingery by the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department.2 A DNA profile of
Kingery was then developed from the buccal swab and uploaded to CODIS.
Two months later, in May 2020, the CODIS system matched Kingery’s DNA
profile to the unknown male DNA profile in Santiago’s murder.
As a result of the CODIS hit, further DNA testing was done. Kingery’s
DNA from the metal pole was compared to the sperm DNA from Santiago’s
vaginal and rectal slides. Kingery was included by random match

probability3 of 1 in 26 trillion as the contributor of the sperm DNA from the
vaginal sample, and 1 in 75 trillion as the contributor of the sperm DNA from

2 Kingery was arrested on March 5, 2020 for possession of a billy club
(§ 22210). The billy club was a metal pole, approximately 22 inches long and
one-half inch in diameter. One end was wrapped in black electrical tape.
The trial court granted the defense motion to exclude testimony of King’s
arrest or reference to the item as a billy club or weapon. The parties entered
a stipulation that a “metal pole” and buccal swab had been recovered from
Kingery.

3 Random match probability means the probability that a randomly
selected person would have the same DNA profile as that found in the
evidence sample.

4
the rectal sample. DNA from Santiago’s bra was also analyzed. In a mixed
DNA profile, Santiago was determined to be a 70 percent contributor and
Kingery a 20 percent contributor. The probability of this match was 1 in
“four million three hundred thousand,” which is “very strong support for
inclusion.”
Kingery testified in his own defense. He claimed he met Santiago at
the Crazy Burro, a Mexican restaurant he frequented in 1987. The two “hit it
off” and “[s]parks were flying.” It was about 4:30 to 5:30 p.m. They left
together and sat in his car to talk. They ended up having consensual sex.
They talked about seeing each other again and he told her she could find him
at the Crazy Burro. He offered her a ride home but she said she would walk
home. He denied raping or killing her or ever being on the hill where she was
found dead.
The defense had filed a motion in limine to present evidence of third
party culpability, contending the evidence tended to inculpate Moderzinsky.
The trial court granted the motion. At trial, however, the jury heard
testimony that Moderzinsky was excluded as a possible contributor of the
DNA obtained from Santiago’s bra; excluded as a possible contributor of the
sperm DNA from the vaginal and rectal swabs of Santiago; and excluded as a
possible contributor of the non-sperm fraction of the DNA profile obtained
from the vaginal swab. Kingery, on the other hand, was included as a
possible contributor of the non-sperm fraction from the vaginal swab. The
non-sperm fraction from the rectal swab was determined to be a single source
female DNA profile which included the victim.

5
II.
Verdict and Sentencing
The jury convicted Kingery of first degree murder (§ 187, subd. (a);
count 1) and forcible rape (§ 261, former subd. (2); count 2). In July 2023, the
trial court sentenced Kingery to the midterm of six years on count 2 and a
consecutive sentence of 25 years to life on count 1. In August, the People
determined the rape charge was beyond the statute of limitations. At the
People’s request, the trial court recalled the sentence, vacated sentence on
count 2, and ordered the indeterminate sentence on count 2 remain. The
People dismissed count 2.
III.
Pretrial Motion to Suppress Evidence
Before trial, Kingery filed a motion to suppress all evidence seized from
his vehicle during his March 2020 detention and arrest for possession of a
billy club (see fn. 2). The motion was heard concurrently with the
preliminary hearing. Defense counsel clarified Kingery was not contesting
the stop nor seeking to exclude the DNA evidence subsequently obtained.
Rather, he contested only the search of the vehicle. The People presented the
following evidence to support the lawfulness of the vehicle search.
On March 5, 2020, sheriff’s deputies received a radio call of a man,
later determined to be Kingery, driving a truck erratically around the
intersection of Poway and Pomerado. Kingery pulled into a Circle K gas
station and was “screaming and throwing things.” The deputies initiated a
traffic stop. When Kingery came to a stop, one deputy approached him on the
driver’s side and asked for his driver’s license. Kingery was alone. Within
minutes of the stop, the second deputy who had approached on the passenger
side observed in clear view a “sap or a bat protruding from between the

6
driver’s seat and the center console.” Kingery was then removed from the
vehicle and placed in handcuffs for officer safety. A gloved deputy removed
the “baton or bat of some sort” from the vehicle. It was 22 inches long, about
half an inch in diameter and weighed 1 pound and 8.4 ounces. It appeared to
be a deadly or dangerous weapon to the deputies. Kingery was then arrested
and placed in a patrol vehicle. In a search of the vehicle incident to his
arrest, deputies found a silver container with a substance that tested positive
for methamphetamine in the center console.
The trial court denied the defense motion to suppress, finding the billy
club (“a readily usable dangerous weapon”) was seen in plain view during a
lawful traffic stop and justified Kingery’s removal and the weapon’s removal
for officer safety.
DISCUSSION
Appointed appellate counsel filed a brief summarizing the facts and
proceedings below, arguing no specific contentions as grounds for relief, and
asking this court to review the entire record for error as mandated by Wende,
supra, 25 Cal.3d 436. To assist the court in its review, and in compliance
with Anders, supra, 386 U.S. 738, counsel identified the following possible,
but not arguable, issues: (1) Whether the trial court erred by denying
Kingery’s motion to suppress? (2) Whether Kingery’s conviction for first
degree murder was supported by substantial evidence?
We have considered the potential issues identified by Kingery’s
appellate counsel and conducted an independent review of the entire record
for other arguable issues under Wende and Anders. Based on our review, we
conclude there is no arguable issue that would result in a modification or
reversal of the judgment. Kingery is competently represented in this appeal.
Accordingly, we affirm the judgment. (Wende, supra, 25 Cal.3d at pp. 441–

7
442.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

DO, J.

WE CONCUR:

HUFFMAN, Acting P. J.

BUCHANAN, J.

8

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.